Administrative United Kingdom
Rehana Anjum v The Entry Clearance Officer
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)
Appeal Number: EU/54411/2024
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Birmingham
On 13 October 2026
Before
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL JUDGE Elliott
Between
REHANA ANJUM
Appellant
and
THE ENTRY CLEARANCE OFFICER
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr M. Azmi, Counsel
For the Respondent: Mr R. Lack, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
1. This is the decision of the Tribunal in the appeal of the Appellant against the decision of the Respondent made on 3 May 2024.
Background
2. The appellant is an Indian citizen, born in 1952, and so 73 years of age. She sought entry clearance to the UK as the dependent parent of the spouse of a relevant EEA citizen, namely her son-in-law, Zakir Mohammed Begum (’the sponsor’), who is a Spanish national residing in the UK and with indefinite leave to remain. He is married to the appellant’s daughter.
3. The sole issue in issue in this appeal is whether, at the date of her application for entry clearance on 24th February 2024, the appellant was dependent on her sponsor for the purposes of Appendix EU (Family Permit), meaning that she could not meet her essential living needs without the sponsor’s material support.
4. The respondent does not dispute the family relationship. She accepted that the sponsor had sent money to the appellant, but was not satisfied that the evidence demonstrated genuine dependency as opposed to financial assistance. The refusal letter focussed on the absence of clear evidence of the appellant’s own financial circumstances in in India, and lack of evidence of her income, expenditure, housing arrangements and medical needs.
The Hearing
5. The hearing took place face to face. It was recorded and that recording is the record of proceedings and should be consulted in the event of any dispute about what was said at the hearing.
Issues
6. The parties agreed that sole issue in dispute is whether the appellant is in fact dependent upon her sponsor for the purposes of Appendix EU (Family Permit).
Evidence
7. I have before me a 483 page stitched bundle of documents, which appears on the myHMCTS portal. I also had an additional appellant’s bundle consisting of 23 pages and containing, mainly, additional money transfer receipts. Mr Azmi acknowledged that the additional bundle had been served late and applied to admit it, as evidencing ongoing support and the collection of money in India. Mr Lack did not object. I decided that it was in the interest of fairness to admit it.
8. I heard oral evidence from the sponsor, assisted by a Hindi-speaking interpreter. I was satisfied that there were no apparent difficulties with the process of interpretation. The sponsor adopted the contents of his witness statement dated 10th March 2025 as his evidence in chief, attesting to the truth of its contents. He was then cross-examined by Mr Lack. There was no re-examination, but I asked the sponsor some questions by way of clarification.
9. I then heard submissions from both representatives, following which I reserved my decision. I have considered all of the written and oral evidence and the submissions in arriving at my decision.
Legal Framework
10. The grounds of appeal open to the appellant are that the respondent's decision either does not comply with the Residence Scheme Immigration Rules or does not comply with the Withdrawal Agreement between the UK and the EU. The Residence Scheme Immigration Rules are in Appendix EU and Appendix EU (Family Permit) of the Immigration Rules.
11. The relevant question is whether, at the date of the application, the appellant was dependent upon the sponsor within the meaning of Annex A to Appendix EU (Family Permit). The burden of proof rests on the appellant and the standard of proof is the balance of probabilities.
12. In Reyes v Migrationsverket (Case C423/12) the Court of Justice confirmed that dependency is a question of fact. It is sufficient that material support is in fact provided and that the family member is unable to support themselves without it. The issue is whether the family member receives material support from the sponsor because that support is necessary in order to meet their essential living needs. There is no need to investigate the reasons for the dependency or why the person has become dependent.
13. The domestic authorities emphasise that the Tribunal must focus on the practical reality of the family member’s circumstances. In Lim v ECO Manila (2015) EWCA Civ 1383, the Court of Appeal held that the question is whether the claimed dependent is in fact dependent on the sponsor to meet their essential living needs. The mere receipt of money from a family member is not sufficient. Equally, the fact that money is regularly provided may constitute strong evidence of dependency where that support is used to meet ordinary living needs.
14. Dependency does not require total dependency or destitution. A person may have some resources of their own and yet still be dependent if those resources are insufficient to meet their essential living needs without the sponsor’s support. That assessment is fact sensitive and must be conducted in the round, taking account of all the evidence.
FINDINGS OF FACT
15. I found the sponsor to be a reliable and credible witness. He gave his evidence in a straightforward way and his answers were consistent with the case that has been advanced throughout the proceedings. Whilst he was unable to give precise details of every aspect of the appellant’s finances, I found that unsurprising given he lives in the United Kingdom and the appellant lives in India. I did not form the impression that the sponsor was tailoring his evidence or trying to mislead the Tribunal. I found him to be an honest witness doing his best to explain the appellant’s circumstances as he understands them to be.
16. I accept the sponsor’s evidence that the appellant is an elderly widow who lives alone in India. I accept that she inherited her home from her late husband and therefore does not have to meet any rental costs. I also accept that the appellant has never had any significant employment and that she has no meaningful independent source of income to meet her day to day needs.
17. The respondent placed reliance on the absence of detailed documentary evidence concerning the appellant’s expenditure, whether she has any other income or pension. I have taken those matters into account, but I do not consider they significantly undermine the appellant’s case.
18. The documents contained in the bundles before me demonstrate a lengthy pattern of remittances from the sponsor to the appellant. The respondent accepted that some seventeen transfers had been made between 2021 and 2024. The stitched bundle contains 31 such transfers between April 2021 and March 2025. The additional transfer evidence provided by the appellant demonstrates continuing support throughout 2025 and 2026. Taken together, the evidence demonstrates financial support over a period exceeding five years.
19. I attach weight not just to the existence of those transfers, but to their regularity and consistency. They are not isolated payments made shortly before the application or for the purpose of supporting an immigration application. Rather, they demonstrate an established and continuing pattern of financial support extending both before and after the date of application. I find that continuity materially strengthens the appellant's case that the support reflects a genuine state of dependency rather than occasional assistance.
20. The appellant has provided evidence of medical bills, utility bills, receipts of clothes, groceries and furniture. Although not providing a continuous financial paper trail, they cover a similar period from 2021 to 2025. I accept the sponsor’s evidence that the money he transfers to the appellant are used for her ordinary living expenses, reflected in the receipts before me. Whilst the receipts do not establish that every item was purchased using funds transferred by the sponsor, they are nevertheless consistent with the sponsor's evidence that the appellant's expenditure is concentrated upon ordinary living costs such as food, clothing, household expenses and medical needs. They provide objective support for his account of the appellant's financial circumstances.
21. I also note that the evidence now includes records demonstrating not only that funds were sent by the sponsor but that they were collected by the appellant in India. I regard that as corroborative evidence that the funds transferred were in fact received and available for her use
22. I accept that the appellant is an elderly widow living in India. Although not completely comprehensive, I have taken account of the financial information that she has provided and the oral evidence of the sponsor. Whilst the respondent is entitled to point to the absence of detailed evidence concerning pension entitlement, savings and precise monthly expenditure, I am satisfied that I am nevertheless in a position to reach reliable findings on dependency. The evidence before me includes a substantial body of remittance evidence covering several years, documentary evidence of household expenditure and credible oral evidence from the sponsor.
23. I have also taken into account the affidavit provided by the appellant and the statement from the head of her village. Whilst neither witness was available for cross-examination and I therefore approach that evidence with appropriate caution, I note that both documents are broadly consistent with the sponsor's account of the appellant's circumstances, including her status as an elderly widow living alone and her reliance upon financial support from family members overseas. I regard those documents as providing limited but supportive corroboration of the sponsor's evidence.
24. The respondent submitted that, in effect, the documentary evidence only established financial assistance was provided by the sponsor, not that the appellant was dependent on it. However, I find that the significance of the money transfer evidence lies in the explanation the sponsor gave for them. I accept his evidence that he sends money to the appellant because she has no other meaningful independent means of maintaining herself and that the funds he sends are used for food, clothing and other daily necessities of life. I accept the sponsor’s evidence that the appellant lacks sufficient means to support herself. I find that the money transfers provide financial support that does not simply maintain a certain standard of living, but represents funds required to meet the appellant’s ordinary and essential daily needs.
25. Neither Jia nor Reyes requires dependency to be established by any particular category of evidence, and so I am entitled to make findings based upon credible oral testimony in addition to any supporting documentary evidence. Having accepted the sponsor’s evidence as truthful and reliable, I find that the appellant has established, on the balance of probabilities, that the support she receives is required to meet her essential needs.
26. I do not reach my conclusion on the basis of the sponsor's oral evidence alone. Rather, I find that his evidence is supported by a substantial body of documentary evidence demonstrating regular remittances over many years and by documentary evidence broadly consistent with the expenditure one would expect an elderly widow living alone to incur. Considered cumulatively, that evidence satisfies me that the support provided is necessary.
27. Whilst the respondent’s concerns regarding the adequacy of the documentary evidence are understandable, having heard the sponsor’s oral evidence, and having considered the not insignificant documentary evidence demonstrating the provision of significant financial support over a lengthy period of time, I am satisfied that the appellant has discharged the burden of proof and has demonstrated that, at the time of her application, she was dependent on her sponsor within the meaning of Appendix EU (Family Permit).
Notice of Decision
28. The appellant meets the requirements of the Immigration Rules contained in Appendix EU (Family Permit). The respondent’s decision is therefore not in accordance with the Residence Scheme Immigration Rules and her appeal under the Immigration (Citizens’ Rights Appeals)(EU Exit) Regulations 2020 is therefore allowed.
To the Respondent – Fee Award
29. As I have allowed the appeal I have considered whether or not to make a fee award. I have decided to make no fee award because I have more evidence before me than was before the original decision maker, and I am satisfied that a hearing was necessary to test the evidence of the sponsor.
Signature
Signed Date 4th November 2026
D.J.R Elliott
First-tier Tribunal Judge Elliott
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our immigration lawyer.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).