Administrative United Kingdom

DA v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Official source

First-tier Tribunal

(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)

Appeal Number: PA/51436/2025

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Heard at Columbus House

On 29 October 2026

Before

first-tier tribunal JUDGE Webb

Between

DA

(Anonymity ORDER made)

Appellant

and

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: Mr F Yaqoob (Solicitor)

For the Respondent: Mr J Williams (Presenting Officer)

DECISION AND REASONS

NOTICE OF DECISION

1. The appeal is allowed on asylum grounds.

2. The appeal is dismissed on humanitarian protection grounds.

3. The appeal is allowed on human rights grounds (Article 3).

REASONS

4. The appellant, who claims to be a citizen of Eritrea, has appealed on protection and human rights grounds against the respondent’s decision dated 03 December 2024 refusing their application for leave to remain dated 11 August 2024.

ANONYMITY ORDER

5. I have decided to make an anonymity order because the importance of discharging the obligations of the United Kingdom under the refugee and human rights conventions outweighs the principle of open justice. This case raises issues about the appellant’s potential risk on return to their country of nationality and it is appropriate that the appellant’s identity be protected until the final outcome of this appeal.

BACKGROUND

6. The background to this appeal is set out in the information contained on MyHMCTS.

7. The appellant asserts a right to remain on protection grounds. He claims to fear return to Eritrea as he will be treated as having a political opinion adverse to the current regime as he will be identified as a person who has exited Eritrea unlawfully and avoided conscription.

HEARING

Format

8. The hearing was held by video. There were no issues with any of the participants being able to see or hear each other and I was satisfied that the format enabled a fair hearing.

Issues in dispute

9. This is a case to which the provisions of the Nationality, Asylum and Borders Act 2022 apply and as a result the dual standard of proof applies to the issues I am required to decide under the Refugee Convention.

10. The parties agreed that the issues for me to decide are as follows:

Matters to be decided on the balance of probabilities

(a) Does the appellant have a characteristic that could cause them to fear persecution for one of the five reasons set out in the Refugee Convention.

Matters to be decided on the lower standard

(b) In the alternative would the appellant qualify for humanitarian protection?

(c) Does the decision breach the appellant’s rights under Article 3 ECHR.

11. The parties agreed that the appeal rests on one key factual finding: if I find the appellant is an Eritrean citizen, the respondent concedes that he would be at risk of harm.

12. The respondent has identified the appellant’s failure to claim asylum in France as engaging section 8 of the 2004 Act.

13. The respondent has conceded that there is no protection or internal relocation option if his account is accepted.

14. Mr Yaqoob confirmed the appellant was not pursuing any Article 3 medical grounds or Article 8 private and family life grounds.

Evidence and submissions

15. The appellant and his witness, AA, gave evidence and followed the proceedings with the assistance of an Amharic interpreter. Neither they nor the interpreter indicated any difficulty in understanding each other.

16. The appellant and AA gave evidence; they confirmed their witness statements and were cross-examined by Mr Williams.

17. After I heard evidence, Mr Williams and Mr Yaqoob both made submissions.

18. I recorded the oral evidence and submissions in my record of proceedings and have taken it all into account, along with the documentary evidence downloaded from MyHMCTS. Page references will be to the stitched bundle (SB) unless otherwise stated.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

19. To succeed in an appeal on asylum grounds, the appellant must show a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason (race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, political opinion).

20. The burden of proof rests on the appellant. As the asylum claim was made after 28 June 2022, following s32 of the 2022 Act, I must apply a two-stage test. As per the guidance from JCK (s.32 NABA 2022) Botswana [2024] UKUT 00100, as amended by DS (NBAB s.32(2)(a); JCK amended) Afghanistan [2026] UKUT 00413 (IAC), I must first determine the following matters on the balance of probabilities:

(a) Whether the appellant has a characteristic that could cause them to fear persecution for one of the five reasons set out in the Refugee Convention.

(b) Whether the appellant does in fact fear persecution for that Convention reason?

21. If so, I must go on to determine whether it is reasonably likely that:

(c) The appellant would be persecuted for that Convention reason,

(d) There would not be sufficient protection available, and

(e) The appellant could not internally relocate.

22. To succeed on an appeal on humanitarian protection grounds an appellant must show a real risk of serious harm at the date of the hearing. The burden of proof rests on an appellant. The standard of proof is a reasonable degree of likelihood, which can also be expressed as a reasonable chance or a serious possibility.

23. In relation to Article 3 the appellant must establish that there are substantial grounds for believing there is a real risk of them being subjected to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment on return.

24. Where an appellant has provided documents, it will be for them to show they can be relied upon and they will be considered along with all the other evidence, Tanveer Ahmed [2002] UKIAT 00439.

FINDINGS

Facts in dispute

25. I have not set out every point or piece of evidence, only those that are most important to my decision. In making my findings I have considered all the evidence that I was given.

26. In undertaking my assessment of all the evidence, I have in mind the structured approach set out in KB & AH (credibility-structured approach) Pakistan [2017] UKUT 00491 (IAC).

27. In assessing credibility, I remind myself that an individual may tell lies about some aspects of their case but may be telling the truth about others.

28. Section 8 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants etc) Act 2004 requires that I take certain matters as potentially damaging to the appellant’s credibility. The respondent relies on the appellant’s failure to claim asylum in France.

29. When the appellant was asked in his screening interview why he did not claim asylum in France, he explained he has been advised that he could claim asylum there by the agent, but he did not. In evidence before me the appellant’s explanation was that he was following the instructions of the agent.

30. When this inconsistency was put to him, the appellant denied saying that the agent advised him to claim in France during his screening interview.

31. I reject that. Following his screening interview, but before his main interview, the appellant wrote a letter that corrected some of the information contained in the screening interview (SB 198). That letter does not correct the answer about the agent advising him. Although I take into account the appellant was not represented at that time, I find that if he has not said this at his screening interview it would have been corrected in the letter.

32. I find the appellant has not given a consistent explanation for his failure to claim asylum in France and that undermines his claim to have been under the influence of the agent, as he claimed before me. I find the appellant has not provided a clear explanation for his failure to claim asylum in France and that this undermines his general credibility. I remind myself this is only one factor in my overall assessment.

Whether the appellant has a characteristic that engages the Refugee Convention?

33. This is assessed on the balance of probabilities.

34. The respondent does not accept that the appellant is an Eritrean national. It is accepted that if he is an Eritrean national, he would be imputed with a political opinion on return to Eritrea.

35. The appellant states that he left Eritrea with his mother at the age of four years old. During his interview he gave accurate information about Eritrea and the area where he lived, including details of the coffee ceremony. The respondent argues that this the knowledge of Eritrea could be learned from external sources and so does not add to his credibility.

36. However, the appellant is clear throughout the interview that the information he is providing is information he learned from his mother or found out from others. As Mr Yaqoob put it, he does not embellish his knowledge. Contrary to the respondent’s submissions I find the appellant’s knowledge and the context he says he learned it are a factor that adds to the credibility of his account.

37. The respondent argues that the appellant’s inability to speak Tigrinya is a factor that undermines his account of being an Eritrean citizen.

38. The appellant has not said that he does not know any Tigrinya but accepts that he has very limited knowledge. This is consistent with him being brought up in Ethiopia. I also note the appellant provided an explanation for his mother’s ability to speak both Amharic and Tigrinya as she came from Assab: that is consistent with the country information Mr Yaqoob referred me to (SB 161). The same country information confirms that Eritreans living in Ethiopia may speak some Tigrinya, but not all will, depending on their particular circumstances. I find that appellant’s inability to speak Tigrinya fluently is consistent with the country information. I find this is not a factor that undermines the appellant’s credibility.

39. In his submission Mr Willams put particular emphasis on the appellant’s ability to live in Ethiopia for almost 30 years, get married and have children with no need to regularise his status. It is argued that this is not plausible and undermines the appellant’s credibility.

40. I remind myself that I should not reject the plausibility of an account lightly, and certainly not on the basis that it would not seem reasonable if it happened in the UK, Y [2006] EWCA 1223.

41. The appellant’s account is that after his mother passed away when he was 10, he was taken in by a priest from the church and provided subsistence and accommodation. His evidence was that his marriage, to an Ethiopian citizen, was a religious ceremony only and not registered. When he did begin to live independently his employment was limited to odd jobs as a carpenter, in his interview he described not always being paid for the work he carried out, and the lack of hospital treatment available to his mother that resulted in her passing away.

42. The appellant’s account is consistently of someone without identity documents living on the margins of society. I find this is not an implausible account as argued by Mr Williams and the appellant’s credibility is not undermined.

43. Although, the appellant’s evidence before me was initially that he started living with the priest at age 4, this was corrected by him at the earliest opportunity and explained as a mistake. Contrary to Mr Williams’ submissions, I find the appellant’s credibility is not undermined by such a minor inconsistency in the context of the rest of the appellant’s account being internally consistent.

44. In support of his claim to be Eritrean the appellant has provided photographs of him in Eritrean colours carrying the flag, a letter from an Eritrean orthodox church confirming his attendance and a receipt for payment of membership fees to the Eritrean Community in the UK. I place little weight on the document in my overall assessment as they are of little evidential value. They only show that the appellant has joined organisations which Eritreans join, and that he has held a flag. There is nothing to show that the church or the ECIU undertake any nationality testing or will only allow those who they believe are Eritreans to join.

45. AA also gave evidence in support of the appellant’s account. There was a significant discrepancy in their evidence, with the appellant saying he last saw the witness in 2023 and the witness saying it was in 2021.

46. When this discrepancy was put to AA, by Mr Williams, he confirmed that the last time he had a clear memory of meeting the appellant was in 2021, but that there was significant confusion because of the armed conflict after that date.

47. In his submission Mr Yaqoob argued that there was not an inconsistency, but two witnesses having different recollections, and it did not fundamentally undermine the credibility of the overall account.

48. There is an inconsistency in the evidence, but I found AA’s explanation clear and consistent with the country information. I find that it is possible for individuals to have recollections that differ, in particular where there is an armed conflict. Different recollections do not mean that the events did not take place. I also found it of particular note that although the priest’s name was not in his witness statement, when questioned by Mr William, he was able to provide the priest’s name that was consistent with the appellant’s own evidence.

49. I find, although I treat AA’s evidence with caution, it is not fundamentally undermined by the inconsistency identified. I do give it weight in my overall assessment and that weight goes to the credibility of the appellant’s account.

50. Taking all my findings above, although I find the appellant’s credibility is undermined by his failure to claim asylum in France, that is only one factor in my overall assessment. The appellant’s account is generally consistent, sufficiently detailed, plausible, and supported by country information. It is supported by the core evidence provided by AA. I find those factors that weigh in favour of the appellant’s credibility are not outweighed by his failure to claim asylum in France.

51. I find on the balance of probabilities that the appellant is an Eritrean national. I find on the balance of probabilities, that he would be imputed with a political opinion on return to Eritrea, as conceded by the respondent.

Whether the appellant does in fact fear persecution

52. This is assessed on the balance of probabilities.

53. In light of the respondent’s concession that that if the appellant is an Eritrean national, he would face harm on return to Eritrea, and that the appellant has made an application for leave to remain on a protection basis, I find the appellant has shown on the balance of probabilities that he has a subjective fear of persecution on return to Eritrea.

Risk on return, Internal relocation and sufficiency of protection

54. These are assessed on the lower standard of proof.

55. In light of the respondent’s concession, I find the appellant has shown to the lower standard that he would be persecuted on return to Eritrea and that there would be no protection or internal relocation option for him.

Humanitarian protection and Article 3

56. Taking the findings above, I conclude the appellant has shown to the lower standard of proof that there is a real risk he would be subjected to serious harm on return to Eritrea.

57. For those same reasons I also find that there is a real risk of him being subjected to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment on return.

Application of the law to the facts

58. For the reasons set out above I find the appellant does have a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason.

59. As I have found the appellant is a refugee, I find that the appellant does not qualify for humanitarian protection.

60. For the reasons stated above I also find there is a risk the appellant would suffer treatment contrary to Article 3 ECHR.

ANONYMITY ORDER

Pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, until this appeal is finally determined or the Upper Tribunal or a court directs otherwise, the appellant is granted anonymity.

No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.

If there is an onward appeal or challenge, an application to amend or vary the anonymity order must be made to the Upper Tribunal or court concerned.

TO THE RESPONDENT – FEE AWARD

No fee is paid or payable and therefore there can be no fee award.

N Webb

First-tier Tribunal Judge Webb

05 November 2026

At Kohen Avocats, our immigration lawyer in Paris can review your situation.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.