Administrative United Kingdom

AH v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Official source

First-tier Tribunal

(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: PA/50295/2025

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Heard at Birmingham (Priory Court)

On 3November 2026

By Cloud Video Platform

Before

first-tier tribunal JUDGE cj williams

Between

AH

(anonymity direction Made)

Appellant

and

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: Mr O Sobowale of Counsel, instructed by Halliday Reeves

For the Respondent: Ms S Edwards, Home Office Presenting Officer

DECISION AND REASONS

1. The appellant, a citizen of Somalia, appeals under the provisions of the Nationality, Immigration, and Asylum Act 2002 against the respondent’s decision dated 23 December 2024 to refuse his protection claim made on 17 August 2023. As such ss30-39 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 (‘the 2022 Act’) apply.

Anonymity Direction

2. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because the importance of facilitating the discharge of the obligations of the United Kingdom (‘UK’) under the Refugee Convention outweighs the principle of open justice.

BACKGROUND

3. The background to this appeal is set out in the documentation contained on myHMCTS. I was provided with a stitched bundle (SB) of 279 pages, which comprised evidence relied on by both parties. The appellant also provided a copy of an email sent to the respondent on 6 June 2024 containing amendments to his screening interview.

4. The appellant asserts that they would be at risk on return due to his imputed political opinion and his ethnicity, or alternatively that he is entitled to humanitarian protection.

HEARING

5. The hearing was recorded and that recording shall stand as the record of proceedings. I joined the hearing remotely from another hearing centre, and all other attendees were in person at Birmingham. There were no issues with connection during the hearing.

Issues in dispute

6. The parties agree that the following issues are in dispute:

(i) Is the appellant credible in his claim to be at risk upon return to Somalia?

(ii) If so, would internal relocation to Mogadishu be unduly harsh?

7. Ms Edwards confirmed the respondent accepted, in light of what is said in her CPIN, that there would be no sufficiency of protection available to the appellant if his claim was made out. Mr Sobowale confirmed the appellant’s claim on Article 8 ECHR grounds was parasitic upon the protection claim and did not need to be considered discretely.

Evidence and submissions

8. The appellant gave evidence in Somali with the assistance of an interpreter, Ms Ahmed. At no time during the hearing did I observe any difficulties in communication between the appellant and the interpreter, nor were any issues raised by the parties. The appellant adopted his witness statement and was cross-examined by Ms Edwards. I heard submissions from both representatives, and at the end of the hearing I reserved my decision which I now give with reasons.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

9. To succeed in an appeal on asylum grounds, the appellant must show a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason (race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, political opinion). The burden of proof rests on the appellant. As the asylum claim was made on or after 28 June 2022, pursuant to s32 of the 2022 Act, in considering whether the appellant qualifies as a refugee, I must apply a two-stage test. I must first determine the following matters on the balance of probabilities:

(a) whether the appellant has a characteristic which could cause them to fear persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion (or has such a characteristic attributed to them by an actor of persecution), and

(b) whether the appellant does in fact fear such persecution in their country of nationality as a result of that characteristic.

10. If I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the appellant does have such a characteristic, and fears persecution as a result of that characteristic, I must go on to determine whether, applying the lower standard of proof, there is a reasonable likelihood that:

(a) the appellant would be persecuted for a Convention reason on return;

(b) that there would be insufficient protection; and

(c) they could not internally relocate.

11. To succeed on an appeal on humanitarian protection grounds the appellant must not be a refugee; they must show substantial grounds for believing that they would face a real risk of suffering serious harm in their country of origin. The burden of proof rests on the appellant.

FINDINGS

Is the appellant credible in his claim to be at risk upon return to Somalia?

12. The appellant’s claim is that he is at risk from the Islamic Courts Union (‘the ICU’). The appellant claims that his father was a religious teacher, who in 2006 was approached by the ICU who demanded he stop his teaching. The appellant further claims his father and brother were killed by the ICU in January 2007. The appellant subsequently left Somalia in 2007 but claims the group has continued to search for him and would kill him should he return to Somalia.

13. The parties agree that the ICU is a group which now forms part of Al Shabaab. This point is specifically accepted at [9b] of the respondent’s refusal decision. The respondent accepts the appellant’s identity and his Somali nationality but does not accept the credibility of the claim for a number of reasons given in the refusal decision and elucidated by Ms Edwards before me.

14. First, it is said the appellant was inconsistent about who it is he fears upon return. In his screening interview, (SI 4.1), the appellant said he feared Al-Shabaab. In his substantive interview (AIR 42-43, 50-52), the appellant said that ‘I was not even in the country when Al Shabaab started to exist’, and that he ‘did not experience Al Shabaab’. When this inconsistency was put to the appellant in interview (AIR 44), and he was asked why he had given the incorrect name at screening interview, he said ‘I was confused, I spent 2 nights in Calais and I already had too many problems and I was really cold because of the water that was banging me and I could not remember anything at that time’.

15. I pause to remind myself of the circumstances in which the screening interview is conducted, and, as highlighted at [19] of YL (Rely on SEF) China [2004] UKIAT 00145,

‘It has to be remembered that a screening interview is not done to establish in detail the reasons a person gives to support her claim for asylum. It would not normally be appropriate for the Secretary of State to ask supplementary questions or to entertain elaborate answers and an inaccurate summary by an interviewing officer at that stage would be excusable. Further the screening interview may well be conducted when the asylum seeker is tired after a long journey. These things have to be considered when any inconsistencies between the screening interview and the later case are evaluated’.

16. Having said that however, the appellant’s screening interview was conducted two days after his arrival in the UK, and not immediately after. The appellant confirmed at the start of his interview that he was ready to be interviewed, and at the end of the interview he confirmed he did not want to add or change any of his responses. I also bear in mind the fact the appellant, through his representatives, made amendments to his screening interview, and did not make any amendment to the name of the group he feared.

17. I also bear in mind the amendment which was made appears to shift the basis of the claim. The appellant states there was a land dispute between his tribe and ‘Haber Gadier’ clan and that his father and brother were killed because ‘they wanted our land’. This is a different account to the one given in his screening interview, i.e. that his father was killed by Al Shabab because of religious teachings. There is no explanation for the difference in account, and I note it was only when prompted and asked about Al Shabaab in his substantive interview that the appellant mentioned any issues his father faced because of religion.

18. I do not accept the appellant’s claim in his witness statement (p.139, SB), that he referred to Al Shabaab simply as the ‘current name of the group’. The appellant himself differentiated between the ICU and Al Shabaab during his substantive interview, even saying he had no issues with Al Shabaab and that they didn’t exist when he left Somalia. If the appellant’s position was simply that it was the same group, he could have said that in his substantive interview but did not. I find the inconsistency tells against the credibility of the account.

19. Turning to the issue of the death of his father and brother, the appellant’s evidence on this incident was also inconsistent. First, the appellant said in his first substantive interview (AIR 31) that his ‘father and brother were killed right in front of [him]’. In oral evidence however, the appellant said he was ‘not far from them’. He also provided a different account of who it was who hid him after the deaths. In his interview (AIR 31), the appellant said he was taken away and hidden by a distant uncle.

20. In oral evidence however, the appellant said it was a member of the public who had hidden him, and that he did not remember referring in the interview to anyone ‘walking by’ and hiding him. In my assessment, the incident of the appellant’s father and brother being killed is part of the core of his claim, and yet his inconsistent evidence about where he was, and what happened immediately after is indicative of a lack of credibility.

21. The appellant further claims there has been contact from Al Shabaab with his mother, looking for the appellant. The appellant’s first substantive interview took place on 4 October 2024. In that interview, he confirmed he had contact with his mother a week before (AIR 11). Whilst he answered questions about those he claimed to fear, the appellant did not disclose any ongoing search for him, even when asked what he thought would happen to him on return (AIR 27).

22. In the appellant’s oral evidence, he said his mother had told him about a visit to their home in 2023. Ms Edwards put to the appellant his failure to mention any incidents between his exit in 2007 and 2023. The appellant said ‘there were loads of incidents. That’s why I left but I was in Europe at the time’. I do not accept the appellant would have been aware of incidents of people searching for him, and yet he did not mention any of these events in the substantive interview, especially when he confirmed he had spoken to his mother in 2023 and she had told him of these putative searches.

23. I have further taken into account in my assessment of the appellant’s credibility his journey to the UK through various safe countries. In his oral evidence, the appellant explained that he was threatened with removal from Norway and Germany because he had initially been fingerprinted in Italy, where he had been told that it would take a long time to process his claim. I accept in those circumstances the threat of removal would be a factor deterring against making a protection claim, and I therefore do not find the appellant’s credibility is significantly damaged by the failure to make a protection claim in the countries through which he passed.

24. In support of his claim, the appellant has provided an expert report of Omer Ahmed (pp.145-179, SB). Whilst Mr Ahmed in his report states the report has been prepared in accordance with the Practice Direction of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal of 1 November 2024, the report falls short in a number of ways. Whilst Annex 1 to the report refers to the ‘expertise/basis for report’, the author’s qualifications are not outlined in the report, the letter of instruction is not provided, and the Statement of Truth does not comply with the Practice Direction.

25. In any event, notwithstanding these deficiencies, I accept Mr Ahmed’s assessment of the plausibility of the appellant’s claim. That a person who does not conform to the ideological alignment of a group such as Al Shabaab would be at risk from them is plausible, and I accept that the family of such a person would be of interest to them. I do not however, for the reasons I have given, accept that the appellant’s claim is credible.

26. I do not find the appellant left Somalia because of any enmity with Al Shabab or with the ICU. I do not find the appellant has ever been of adverse interest to either group, nor do I find there are any ongoing searches for him. The appellant has been inconsistent about the events precipitating his exit from Somalia, who it is he fears, and the putative interest in him from those he claims to fear. I do not find the appellant would be at risk on this basis.

27. In terms of the risk posed to the appellant because of his clan membership, it is asserted that the appellant being a member of a minority clan is a factor which would place him at risk of persecution. The respondent has not challenged the appellant’s claim to belong to the Ashraf clan, nor that this clan is a minority clan. I see no reason to reject this element of the claim. In terms of whether this would be a factor which would be a source of risk, the expert report indicates that returnees to the appellant’s area, which is under the control of Al Shabaab, are at ‘heightened risk of scrutiny’, especially when returning from a Western country.

28. I accept that in circumstances where, irrespective of my finding that the appellant has had any previous issues with Al Shabaab or the ICU, he has been out of Somalia for nearly twenty years, and that he would be returning to an area under the control of Al Shabaab. I accept in view of the evidence provided, that this would place him in direct contact with Al Shabaab. I do not consider the appellant has shown however, despite the evidence of ‘heightened risk of scrutiny’, that he would be at risk of persecution simply because he would be a returnee from the West.

29. Even applying the lower of standard of proof applicable to humanitarian protection claims, I do not consider the appellant has shown there is a reasonable degree of likelihood that he would face serious harm by virtue of return to his home area from the West alone. Whilst the evidence relied on by the appellant indicates Al Shabaab are the de facto authority in the area; there is nothing to suggest that his minority clan status alone would put him at risk when my findings are taken holistically.

30. I therefore do not conclude the appellant would be at risk upon return to Somalia for a Convention reason, nor would he be at risk of serious harm. It follows that the appellant does not need to relocate internally within Somalia. His appeal therefore does not succeed and falls to be dismissed. In view of the appellant’s position that his Article 8 ECHR claim is dependent upon my findings on his protection claim, the appeal is dismissed on all grounds.

NOTICE OF DECISION

The appeal is dismissed on all grounds.

ANONYMITY DIRECTION

Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellant is granted anonymity.

No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including their names or their addresses, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify them. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.

TO THE RESPONDENT

FEE AWARD

I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award.

Signed CJ Williams 5 November 2026

First-tier Tribunal Judge CJ Williams

Our immigration lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.