Family Etats-Unis
BERNICE RUTLAND v. TODD C. STEWART, INDIVIDUALLY; TODD C. STEWART D.D.S., P.A.; AND ROCK DENTAL ARKANSAS, PLLC, D/B/A HELENA FAMILY DENTAL
Cite as
2026 Ark. 161
SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
No. CV-25-36
Opinion Delivered: October 29, 2026
BERNICE RUTLAND
APPELLANT
V.
TODD C. STEWART, DISSENTING OPINION FROM THE
INDIVIDUALLY; TODD C. DENIAL OF PETITION FOR
STEWART, D.D.S., P.A.; AND ROCK REVIEW.
DENTAL ARKANSAS, PLLC, D/B/A
HELENA FAMILY DENTAL
APPELLEE
NICHOLAS J. BRONNI, Associate Justice
Citing its own precedent, the court of appeals departs from ours. Compare Rutland v.
Stewart,
(citing Jackson-Rice v. Rice,
) (dismissing an appeal under Arkansas Rule of Appellate Procedure—Civil 3(e) without analyzing prejudice), with Mann v. Pierce,
,
(requiring a prejudice analysis before dismissal under Rule 3(e)). As Judge Wendy Wood correctly points out, this court’s precedent allows less than perfect compliance with Ark. R. App. P.—Civil 3(e), unless the appellee can show prejudice from the appellant’s failure to strictly comply with the rule. Rutland,
(Wood, J., concurring) (citing Rogers v. Tudor Ins. Co.,
Ark. 226, 231
,
). It’s a fundamental principle of law that the court of
appeals cannot overrule or ignore our precedent. But by denying this petition, the majority
allows just that. Therefore, I respectfully dissent.
Special Justice CORY COX joins.
Official sources: view the source page