Constitutional European Court of Human Rights
EDWARDS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
EUROPEAN COMMISSION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
against the United Kingdom
The European Commission of Human Rights sitting in private on
July 1985, the following members being present:
5
MM-
C- A. N(>RGAARD, President
G. SPERDUTI
J. A. FROWEIN
G. JCfRUNDSSON
G. TENEKIDES
S. TRECHSEL
B. KIERNAN
.
J. A. CARRILLO
A. S- GCrZUBUYUK
H. G. SCHERMERS
H. DANELIUS
G. BATLINER
H. VANDENBERGiE
Mrs G. H. THUNE
Sir Basil HALL
Mr. H. C- KRUQ2R, Secretary to the Commission
Having regard to Art. 25 of the Convention for the Protection
of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms;
Having regard to the application introduced on 25 June 1984
by Ms. Christing Y. EDWARDS against the United Kingdom and registered
on
4
February 1985 under file No- 11377/85;
Having regard to the report provided for in Rule 40 of the
Rules of Procedure of the Commission;
Ha
V
ing deliberated
;
Decides as follows:
E 85.109
06.2
–
2 –
11377/85
THE FACTS
The facts as they have been submittted on behalf of the
applicant, British citizen born in 1946 and living in London, by her
representative Mr. Peter D. Quick, solicitor of Heywood, near
a
a
Manchester, and County Legal Officer to the Greater Manchester
Council, may be summarised as follows:
The London Government Act 1963 established
of local government for the Greater London area which came into force
on April 1965. Local administration was thereafter to be exercised
a two-tier system
1
by the Greater London Council (the *’GLC ») and by borough councils.
Tlie London borough councils were responsible for providing the more
localised services while the GLC would administer those services the
nature of which required
a unified policy over the whole of the
Greater London area. These services include the provision of fire
services arid fire prevention, the disposal of waste and refuse,
strategic planning, and certain aspects of housing and major highways
The GLC also exercises functions in the fields of industry and
employment, recreation and the arts, civil defence and flood
prevention as well as a wide variety of other matters. The GLC is
.
also responsible, through
a special committee known as the Inner
London Education Authority, for the provision of education in central
London
.
Under this system an individual has the right to vote in the
periodic elections for the GLC and also for his local London borough
council. Elections to the GLC have been held in 1967, 1970, 1973,
1977 and 1981
Together with the individual*
councillors to the GLC for his area, he has
–
on each occasion for a four year term of office.
right to take part in electing
corresponding right to
s
a
require his local councillor to represent his interests on the Greater
London Council on any matter which may be of.concern to him and for
the proper administration of which the GLC is directly responsible to
the local electorate.
The applicant is a resident of the Greater
London area and is consequently entitled to participate in any
elections to the GLC.
On
1 February 1985, by means of an order of the Secretary of
State, certain provisions contained in tte Lpc^ Government (Interim
Provisions) Act 1984 (« the 1984 Act ») came into force. The effect of
these provisions is to revoke the individual
elections to the GLC. The 1984 Act achieves this by (a) putting an
end to elected membership to the GLC, b) cancelling aH future
’s right to vote in
(
elections, including those due to take place in 1985, and (c)
extending the terms of office of the existing GLC councillors to
1
April 1986.
cease to hold office and the 1984 Act makes no provision for the
future of the GLC or for the administration of its functions.
After that date, the present councillors will simply
It
therefore appears from the fonn of the 1984 ^t as drafted that the
right of an Individual resident in the Greater London area to
participate in elections to the GLC is abolished.
The 1985 elections
will not take place, and draft legislation is currently pending before
the United Kingdom Parliament to abolish the GLC.
3
11377/85
The applicant argues that the GLC forms part of the
legislature of the United Kingdom, since it enjoys the power to
legislate in ways which affect the individuals, living in its area. The
GLC may make byelaws for various purposes which in effect amount to
local legislation. It may make various orders affecting the
individual*
s liberty, Including a very comprehensive control over the
roads and the traffic flow system in Greater London, it has extensive
powers compulsorny to purchase private land for its many functions,
and it may even promote local legislation in Parliament which
specifically affects the people of the Greater London area.
CaULPLAlKTS
The applicant contends that the GLC constitutes part of the
« legislature » of the United Kingdom, and that the removal of free
elections to that council is
a violation of the guarantees contained
in Art.
3 of Protocol No. 1.
THE LàSB
The applicant is resident in the Greater London area and
complains that the cancellation of the elections to the Greater London
Council (« the GLC »), in which she was entitled to participate, fails
to respect her rights as guaranteed by Art.
states:
3 of Protocol No. 1, which
« The High Contracting Parties undertake to hold free
elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot, under
conditions which will ensure the free expression of the
opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature. »
The Commission notes that section
2
(1 ) of the I^ocal
Government (Interim Provisions) Act 1984 (« the 1984 Act ») provides
that « No ordinary elections of councilors of the Greater London
Council … shall be held after the coming into force of this Act »
and that the term of office of any councillor due to expire on
,
7
May 1985 (the end of the period for which they had been elected
pursuant to the previous elections) would be extended to
1 April 1986.
These proyisips came ito force on
1 February 1985 pursuant to the
Local Government (Interim Provisions) Act 1984 (^pointed Day) Order
1985. It is therefore apparent that the elections of councillors to
the GLC have been cancelled by the 1984 Act.
The Conmision recalls its constant case-law in which it has
established that, although the wording of Art.
provides expresiy only fpr an institutional guarantee of free
elections, it implies recognition of the principle of imiversal
3
of Protocol No.
1
a
,
suffrage and, in this context the right to vote and the right to stand
for election to the legislature. However, this right is neither
absolute nor without limitations, but subject to such restrictions
imposed by the Contracting States as are not arbitrary and do not
11377/85
interfere with the free expression of the people’s opinion (see Dec.
No. 6573/74 v. the Netherlands, 19.12.74, D.R.
6745/76 and 6746/76 v. Belgium, 30.5.75, D.R.
1
p, 87; and Dec- Nos.
p. 110, at p. 116).
2
Art.
3
of Protocol No.
1 protects the right of the people by
means of free elections to choose the « legislature »
.
The Commission
must therefore consider whether the GLC can be considered as
constituting part of the legislature of the United Kingdom.
In this
respect the Commission recalls its decision in Dec. No. 5155/71, X. v.
the United Kingdom, 12.7.76, D.R. p. 13, which concerned the
6
suspension of local government elections in Northern Ireland. The
Commission held that:
»
… in considering the status of local authorities in
Northern Ireland the Commission takes note of the statement
of the respondent Government that insofar as these local
authorities have
a legislative function it is confined to
the making of bye-laws applicable within their areas and
these powers are rigidly limited by Statute and they have no
powers to make rules other than in accordance with the
powers conferred by Parliament. »
The Commission concluded that the local authority in question was not
therefore part of the legislature.
The constitutional arrangements of the United Kingdom do not
authorise the exercise of legislative powers by subordinate bodies.
As
a matter of British constitutional law, Parliament, as the elected
representative of the British people, may therefore vote to abolish
the GLC if this course of action recommends itself. The absolute
constitutional authority which the British Parliament is able to
exercise is indicative of the subordinate and subsidiary nature of the
GLC.
In addition, the Commission must review the specific powers
enjoyed by the GLC, the main sources of which are the London
…..
Government Act 1963 and the Local Government Act 1972. The GLC is
a
body corporate created by statute and as such may only do such things
as are expressly or impliedly authorised by statute or by subordinate
legislation. It is, however, specifically authorised to do anything
which is calculated to facilitate the discharge of any of its
statutory functions.
I
I
It is clear that the GLC is
a
repository of extensive powers
j
}
of a predominantly administrative nature concerning the organisation
and provision of local services. Most of these powers are granted by
statute or other subordinate legislation which defines closely and
restrictively their field of application. Other powers require the
i
|
i
approval and consent of
be exercised. Still others may be exercised by the GLC but such
a
superior executive authority before they may
j
1
exercise will not become effective until approved by
authority.
a
confirming
j
‘
.
\
I
i
i
t
I
t
I
•
-•
\
K
____________________
_________________________…•
V-..
■
f
–
5
11377/85
Having regard to the powers exercised by the GLC, its
relationship to the United Kingdom Parliament, the Commission’s
previous case-law, and the facts of the case, the Commsision is of
the opinion that, despite the significant scope of its functions, the
GLC cannot properly be said to form part of the « legislature » of the
United Kingdom. It does not possess an inherent primary rulemaking
power and those powers which have been delegated to it by the
Parliament of the United Kingdom are exercised subject to that
Parliament’s ultimate control.
The GLC not forming part of the legislature of the United
Kingdom, the cancellation of elections to it cannot raise an issue
under Art.
3 of Protocol No. 1.
It follows that this application is incompatible
ratione materiae with the provisions of the Convention within the
meaning of Art. 27 (2).
For these reasons, the Commission
DECLARES THE APPLICATION INADMISSIBLE
Secretary to the Commission
President of the Conmission
(H. C. KRUGER)
/
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.