Administrative United Kingdom
Farah Hassan Gelle v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors
NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01507 (GRC)
Case Reference: FT/D/2026/0150/FCT
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL
GENERAL REGULATORY CHAMBER
(TRANSPORT)
Heard remotely by CVP on: 7 October 2026
Decision given on: 02 November 2026
Before
JUDGE MCMAHON
Between
FARAH HASSAN GELLE
Appellant
-and-
REGISTRAR OF APPROVED DRIVING INSTRUCTORS
Respondent
Representation:
The Appellant was represented by Mr. OS Shoker, solicitor of H & McLaws, Solicitors
The Respondent was represented by Mr. A. Raja, Deputy Registrar of the Respondent.
Decision: The appeal is Allowed. The Decision of the Respondent made on 15 January 2026 is set aside.
REASONS
Mode of Hearing
1. The proceedings were listed for oral hearing, remotely, by CVP and proceeded in that mode.
Background
2. The Appellant failed the Standards Check test, required by the Respondent to be undertaken by the Appellant, on two occasions, namely, 31 January 2025 and 1 August 2025, pursuant to the provisions of the Motor Cars (Driving Instruction) Regulations 2005. The Respondent also submitted that the Appellant had failed to attend test appointments on 31 January 2025, 19 March 2025, 6 May 2025 and 10 November 2025. This was refined in the Respondent’s Response document dated 28 May 2026 to submit that the Appellant had failed to attend the 10 November 2025 test on time and that he had cancelled three tests on 3 November 2022, 19 March 2025 and 6 May 2025, respectively. Consequently, the Respondent, in a decision dated 15 January 2026, removed the Appellant’s name from the Approved Driving Instructors Register (‘the Register’), pursuant to section 128(2)(d) of the Road Traffic Act 1988, as amended (‘the Act’), taking into account representations made by the Appellant on 24 November 2025.
3. In his said representations the Appellant maintained he had attended a test date, but did not identify that date, that did not proceed as an engine warning light had illuminated on his vehicle; that his name should not be removed from the Register as he was now better prepared, having attended the last instructors conference this year and had taken on-line and face to face coaching lessons in order to do better.
6. Neither the Respondent, nor the Tribunal, in determining an appeal, could alter the result of a Standards Check test, nor order a re-test, a challenge that could only be taken to the Magistrates’ Court. The Appellant did not make any such application to the Magistrates’ Court in respect of the outcome of either of his two failed Standards Check test.
Notice of Appeal
7. The Appellant submitted a Notice of Appeal dated 23 February 2026 stating –
– he had submitted an appeal, albeit incomplete, on time, being, at that time, unrepresented and unfamiliar with Tribunal procedural requirements, but had, subsequently, been completed in full and re-submitted within the extended period permitted by the Tribunal;
– that no prejudice would be suffered by the Respondent if the appeal was admitted [and it was admitted], but refusal to admit it would cause him significant prejudice given the impact on his ability to practice his profession and that it was, therefore just and proportionate to allow the appeal to proceed;
– the Respondent [and, now, the Tribunal on appeal, standing in the shoes of the Respondent] should reconsider its decision ‘in accordance with law’ and afford him a further opportunity to undertake another Standards Check test;
– he had been an Approved Driving Instructor (‘ADI’) since 2018, having successfully trained a substantial number of learner drivers to pass their driving test;
– the first time he had been required to undertake a Standards Check test was in 2024;
– he accepted he had failed a Standards Check test on 31 January 2025 and on 1 August 2025, but challenged the assertion of the Respondent that he had failed to attend for a Standards Check test on four occasions –
• he had been involved in a road traffic accident n 19 March 2025 [corrected in oral evidence to 19 April 2025];
• he had notified the Respondent that he was unable to attend the Standards Check test arranged for 19 April 2025 and this had been accepted by the Respondent, attending the rescheduled appointment on 1 August 2025;
• on 1 November 2025, the examiner refused to proceed with the Standards Check test as an engine warning light was illuminated on the Appellant’s vehicle;
.
– it was incorrect and procedurally unfair that the Respondent should characterise these as ‘failures to attend’ by the Appellant;
– the Respondent failed to consider whether the Appellant had a reasonable excuse for any alleged non-attendance or aborted Standards Check tests and failed to exercise his discretion lawfully before imposing the most severe regulatory sanction available;
– the grounds advanced by the Respondent disclosed material errors of fact; failure to take account of relevant considerations and misapplication of the statutory framework in the case of the Appellant’s road traffic accident;
– the consequences of the decision were severe, the Appellant being the sole earner in his household, that included two young children, the decision depriving the Appellant of his livelihood ad risked unnecessary reliance on state benefits.
Response of Respondent
8. In his Response, dated 28 May 2026, the Respondent confirmed that –
– in fact, the legislation only required an Appellant to attend one Standards Check test, but it was the Respondent’s practice to allow an Appellant three attempts to pass a Standards Check test;
– the Appellant’s name was first entered onto the ADI Register in 2018 and he had, in fact, failed a Standards Check test on three previous occasions, namely 13 June 2019, 20 September 2019 and 24 March 2022;
– before removal proceedings commenced, the Appellant allowed his ADI registration to lapse on 3 Apri 202 but re-registered in September 2022;
– since then –
• the Appellant had failed a Standards Check test on 31 January 2025 and 1 August 2025;
• the Appellant had cancelled three booked Standards Check tests, namely, 30 November 2022, 19 March 2025 and 6 May 2025;
• one test, on 30 January 2025 was recorded as ‘non-completed;
• one test, on 10 November 2025 was recorded as a ‘failure to attend’;
– on 30 November 2022, at the Appellant’s request, a Standards Check test was re-booked for 31 January 2023;
– the 19 March 2025 test was re-booked, at the Appellant’s request, for 6 May 2025;
– on 22 January 2025, the Appellant requested that the test booked for 30 January 2025 be re-booked as he ‘had to travel due to a family emergency’ but did not reply to a request from the Respondent for supporting evidence: the scheduled test as not, therefore, re-booked but the Appellant did attend in any event but the test did not proceed as an engine warning light illuminated on the Appellant’s vehicle;
– the test scheduled for 10 November 2025 was recorded as ‘failed to attend as when the Appellant did attend, 10 minutes late, he had no pupil with him and, again, an engine warning light was illuminated on his vehicle.
10. The reasons offered by the Respondent for his decision, the decision under appeal, were –
– the Appellant had failed a Standards Check test on two occasions, namely, 31 January 2025 and 1 August 2025;
– he failed to attend the Standards Check test on time on 10 November 2025;
– he was given a reasonable number of opportunities to demonstrate his ability give driving instruction of a satisfactory standard;
– that he had cancelled booked tests on three occasions, namely, 3 November 2022, 1 March 2025 and 6 May 2025 and had failed to attend a scheduled test booked for 10 November 2025;
– there was no evidence that the Appellant had undertaken further professional development to address his weaknesses following his two failed Standards Check tests;
– the Respondent felt obliged to remove the Appellant’s name from the ADI Register as he was unable to satisfy the Respondent of his to give driving instruction to a satisfactory standard.
11. The Appellant, in response to questions from his solicitor at the hearing, reiterated, in greater detail, the grounds of his appeal, emphasising how crucial his role was as a driving instructor was for him and his family being the sole earner in his family; that he understood he was required to take a Standards Check test; that he had never missed a booked test save where events beyond his control intervened, including his road traffic accident and an engine warning light illuminating, it never being his intention to avoid taking a test; that he would undertake another Standards Check test if one were offered; that he had undertaken further professional training following his failing a Standards Check test twice; that he sought one further chance to pass a Standards Check test, would never seek to change the booking and would ensure he had a spare vehicle available.
12. In response to questions from the Respondent’s representative, the Appellant agreed that a Standards Check test was not overly difficult but that he had failed a Standards Check test on five occasions in total. He maintained that he did not refuse to take a Standards Check test, despite numerous bookings being made. He agreed that when required in writing to undertake a Standards Check test, he had been advised of the need to attend with a pupil and a roadworthy vehicle. He clarified that the ‘family emergency’ he had referred to concern that his wife was in hospital but turned up for the test as the Respondent ‘did not accept’ that fact. He concluded by maintaining he was entitled to three attempts to pass a Standards Check test.
13. Th Respondent’s representative confirmed to the Tribunal that he did, ordinarily, in practise, allow three attempts to pass a Standards Check test but the Appellant had been given a reasonable opportunity to undertake a third attempt to do so and that he could not have indefinite opportunities to do so.
24. In closing, the Respondent’s representative referred to page 38 of the bundle in respect of the scheduled Standards Check test booked for 30 January 2025 and submitted that contrary evidence had now been given. He further submitted that the Respondent was obliged to ensure that an ADI was a fit and proper person to have his name retained
on the Register, that a Standards Check test was to ensure that an ADI was adhering to minimum standards to give driving instruction, whereas, in this case, the Appellant had failed to pass a Standards Check test on five occasions in total and had received multiple opportunities to successfully pass the test noting, in particular, that an ADI could not attend for a Standards Check test in a vehicle that was not roadworthy. He also relied on the authority in Bolton, submitting that the system requiring an ADI to undertake Standards Check was, properly, designed to protect public confidence in the Register and that, here, the Respondent had given the Appellant a reasonable and proportionate opportunity to pass the Standards Check test. He submitted that the question of proportionality had to weigh the interests of the Appellant and his family against the matter of public confidence in the Register, road safety and so on.
25. The Appellant’s representative, in closing, submitted that the appeal should be allowed; that the Appellant did not minimise the importance of a Standards Check test and the matter of public confidence in the Register but, he submitted, the real issue was whether the Appellant had been afforded sufficient opportunity to pass a Standards Check test. He submitted that the history recorded in the decision letter was not accurate regarding alleged failure to attend scheduled Standards Check tests (apart from the last of the listed dates). He also submitted that it was the Respondent’s practice to allow an ADI three attempts to pass a Standards Check test and that it was not the case here of the Appellant being allowed ‘endless opportunities’ to pass a Standards Check test. He submitted that it would be reasonable and proportionate to allow the Appellant one final attempt to pass a Standards Check test, referring, in particular, to the Appellant being the sole breadwinner in his household, requiring, he submitted, account to be taken of the seriousness of the consequences of his name being removed from the Register. He maintained that the Appellant had not been asked by the Respondent about professional development before the decision under appeal was made. He invited the Tribunal to find the Appellant was truthful and submitted that all he wanted was one further opportunity to take a Standards Check test; that circumstances had occurred that were outside his control and that removal of his name from the Register was permanent and disproportionate.
26. In final remarks, the Appellant, stated that others had been allowed three attempts to pass a Standards Check test and that there had been no misbehaviour on his part nor any accidents (save the no fault accident referred to in the evidence) since 2018.
Reasons and Conclusions
27. The decision by the Respondent to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register pursuant to s.128(2)(d) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (‘the Act’) in that he had failed the continued ability and fitness test (known as a ‘Standards Check test’) on
two separate occasions, was, undoubtedly, correct as a factual proposition. The Tribunal did not accept, however, the Respondent’s rationale, in arriving at his decision.
11. Section 125(5) of the Act requires that a person whose name is held in the Register
must undergo a test of continued ability and fitness to give instruction in the driving
of motor cars. Although the Act permits removal of a name after a single failure of a
check test, it is usual for an ADI to be allowed three attempts before removal is
ordered. By reason of the word “may” in s.128(1) of the Act, removal from the Register is discretionary.
12. Significantly, pursuant to s.133(1) of the Act, an appeal against the outcome f a Standards Check test can only be appealed to a Magistrates’ Court – not to the Tribunal.The Appellant did not make application to the Magistrates’ Court to challenge the outcome, or conduct, of either of his two unsuccessful attempts to pass a Standards Check test.
13. The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to decide whether the Respondent’s decision to exercise his discretion to remove the Appellant’s name from the ADI Register was correct. The principal way that issue is addressed is by requiring that those who give paid instruction havetheir name on the Register undergo a Standards Check test. Parliament has put other provisions in place so the public can have confidence in the Register. For example, there is a pre-condition to registration that anapplicant has passed all three parts of the qualifying examination and there is arequirement that the applicant is and remains a ‘fit and proper person’ to have hisname on the Register (which goes beyond ability as an instructor) and s.125(5)provides that the entry of a person’s name onto the Register shall be subject to thecondition that, so long as his name is on the Register, he will, if at any timerequired to do so by the Registrar, submit himself for such test of continuedability and fitness to give instruction in the driving of motor cars as may be prescribed (that is, a Standards Check test). The importance of this provision is that it ensures, by periodictesting, that driving instructors, ADIs, remain sufficiently competent to charge fordrivinginstruction. It is therefore an important component in maintaining publicconfidence in the Register. It is important to note that the imposition of thecondition is mandatory and that the terms of the condition are that the Approved Driving Instructor (‘ADI’) will,at any time required to do so by the Respondent, submit himself for a Standards Check test, once the Respondent has required an ADI to submithimself for a Standards Check test.
14. The fact that the assertions of the Respondent as to the facts in this case were somewhat confused, indeed, inaccurate in some respects. and different accounts presented, together with the fact that an ADI is, invariably, offered three attempts to pass a Standards Check test by the Respondent (even though legislation does not require such process), whereas the Appellant had only tried, albeit unsuccessfully, for the purposes of this appeal, to pass a Standards Check test on two occasions. The Tribunal was satisfied that the Respondent was not correct to find that the Appellant had been givenadequate opportunity to pass the Standards Check test, even though he failed to do so – on two occasions – and that there were circumstances, revealed in the written and oral evidence of the parties that, on the balance of probabilities, tipped the question of proportionality in favour of the Appellant. The Tribunal decided that the Respondent, on the particular facts of this appeal, should not have exercised his discretion to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register – the greatest sanction available to him – without offering the Appellant one final, and third, attempt to pass a Standards Check test before exercising such onerous sanction.
15. Nevertheless, the Tribunal was somewhat less than impressed by the fact, for the various reasons stated in his written and oral evidence and submissions, that he did not avail of various alternative dates booked for him to take a third Standards Check test. The Appellant is strongly warned that it is highly unlikely that any further latitude will be granted to him and he is strongly advised to ensure that he sits the next Standards Check test booked for him, not least that he presents with a pupil and a vehicle in a roadworthy condition.
16. The Tribunal is a judicial authority entirely independent of both the Appellant and the Respondent. When an appeal comes before a Tribunal, the Tribunal considers the matter the subject of the appeal entirely afresh while having regard to the views expressed by the Respondent as the body entrusted by Parliament in respect of these matters, being particularly conscious of the need for public confidence in the Register and that those ADIs whose names are entered upon it are competent to be entrusted with providing driving instruction to members of the public.
18. The appealis allowed. The Appellant’s name shall, at present, remain entered on the Register and a third and final booking shall be made for him to pass a Standards Check test at the earliest opportunity.
Signed: Judge McMahon, Date: 30 October 2026
At Kohen Avocats, our administrative lawyer in Paris can review your situation.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).