Administrative United Kingdom

Haxhi Deva v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Official source

First-tier Tribunal

(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Numbers: HU/56719/2026

& EU/60775/2026

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Heard at Hendon Magistrates Court

On 28 October 2026

Before

first-tier tribunal JUDGE MOON

Between

HAXHI DEVA

(anonymity direction NOT Made)

Appellant

and

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: Mr Z. Reza, Counsel

For the Respondent: Miss S. Khawaja, Home Office Presenting Officer

DECISION AND REASONS

1. The appellant is a citizen of Albania who was born on 3 June 1999 and so is aged 27 at the date of the appeal. He first entered the United Kingdom in March 2021 having been issued leave to enter as the spouse of an EU national on 4 December 2020. He was granted a residence permit on 6 March 2021 and had valid leave until 2 September 2021. The appellant made an in-time application under the EU Exit Settlement Scheme as the dependant of a non-EU national on 23 May 2021 which was granted on 1 November 2021 with leave valid until 2 November 2026.

2. The appellant separated from his wife and a divorce was finalised on 20 February 2025. On 13 March 2025 the appellant made a fresh application under the EU settlement scheme (‘EUSS’) on 13 March 2025. That application was refused on suitability grounds in a decision dated 6 May 2026. This is one of the decisions which is the subject of this appeal. The application was refused because on 6 August 2025 the appellant was convicted of possessing a Class A drug (cocaine) with intent to supply. He was sentenced to 31 months imprisonment which was subsequently varied on appeal to 27 months (2 years and 3 months). An appeal against a refusal to grant EUSS leave may be made on the basis that the decision is not in accordance with Appendix EU to the Immigration Rules or that the decision breaches rights that the appellant has under the Withdrawal Agreement.

3. On 16 September 2025 the respondent issued the appellant with a Stage 1 notice of a decision to deport him. The notice confirmed that the decision would be made in accordance with domestic legislation. Human rights submissions were made on behalf of the appellant in response on 11 March 2026; these were centred on his private life namely, his length of lawful residence and the fact he had worked and paid taxes. Copies of tax returns were provided. On 6 May 2026 the respondent issued a Stage 2 decision to deport the appellant and refused his human rights claim. The appellant appeals against the respondent’s decision under the provisions of the Nationality, Immigration, and Asylum Act 2002.

Publication

4. At the hearing I confirmed that the Tribunal may publish this decision. There was no application for anonymity and I see no reason for an anonymity direction, none having been made in the criminal proceedings.

The Legal Framework

5. The structured approach to be taken in these decisions is set out in Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 (Sections 117A – D). Section 117C makes it clear that the deportation of a foreign criminal is in the public interest. This appellant falls within the definition of foreign criminal because he has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment which exceeds 12 months.

6. In a case such as this where the appellant has been sentenced to a period of imprisonment of more than 12 months, but less than four years (a ‘medium offender’), Section 117C(3) confirms that the public interest requires deportation unless Exception 1 (Private Life) or Exception 2 (Family Life) applies. If neither of the Exceptions apply to this appellant, the appeal should be allowed if there are “very compelling circumstances” over and above those described in Exceptions 1 and 2.

7. There are three limbs to Exception 1, in order to meet this Exception all three must be satisfied: the appellant must have

• Been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life, and

• Be socially and culturally integrated into the United Kingdom, and

• There must be very significant obstacles to his reintegration into Albania

8. At the hearing, Mr Reza conceded that the appellant could not meet Exception 1 because he has not been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life. Whilst all of his stay has been lawful, he has lived here for five years and he is aged 27. It was submitted that the remaining two limbs are met.

9. The main thrust of this appeal is Exception 2 which, in accordance with Section 117C(5) of the 2002 Act may apply where an appellant has a genuine and subsisting relationship with a qualifying partner and the effect of deportation on that partner is unduly harsh. (The alternative basis for meeting Exception 2 is the presence of a qualifying child, the appellant does not have a child.) The appellant’s evidence was filed on 15 July 2026. The bundle included an appellant’s skeleton argument in which it was asserted that he is in a genuine and subsisting relationship with Ms Nicole Harrison who is a British Citizen. This bundle contains a witness statement prepared by Ms Harrison who states that the relationship began in December 2024.

10. This new matter of the relationship was addressed at a Case Management Review Hearing which took place on 21 July 2026. In a respondent’s review dated 27 July 2026, the respondent gave consent for the Tribunal to consider the new matter the same document confirmed that it is accepted that Ms Harrison is a British Citizen however, the respondent’s position is that it is not accepted that the relationship is genuine and subsisting. The respondent also takes the view that the effect of deportation on Ms Harrison would not be unduly harsh.

11. Section 117C(6) of the 2002 Act states “In the case of a foreign criminal who has been sentenced to a period of imprisonment of at least four years, the public interest requires deportation unless there are very compelling circumstances, over and above those described in Exceptions 1 and 2.” In NA (Pakistan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department[2016] EWCA Civ 662; [2017] 1 WLR 207, the Court of Appeal held that a medium offender such as the appellant who has been sentenced to more than 12 months but less than four years who cannot satisfy the unduly harsh test can nevertheless seek to show that the very compelling circumstances test is met. On behalf of the appellant it is submitted that there are very compelling circumstances in this case which is based upon a combination of factors which apply to the appellant. One of these factors in the relationship between the appellant and his brother which, it is submitted, is very close.

The Hearing

12. The following documents were available;

a) An appellant’s bundle containing 699 pages which includes an appellant’s skeleton argument at AB 3 – 8 which is dated 15 July 2026.

b) An appellant’s second bundle containing 123 pages

c) An appellant’s third bundle containing 11 pages.

d) Separate respondent’s bundles in relation to each of the appeal references.

e) A respondent’s review dated 27 July 2026.

f) An OASys risk assessment completed on 1 September 2026.

13. The hearing took place in-person and the appellant was assisted by an Albanian interpreter. During the hearing I heard evidence from the appellant, Ms Harrison, the appellant’s brother, Mr Jurden Deva and the partner of the appellant’s brother, Ms Aiesha Alushi.

The Evidence

Background

14. The appellant was born in Albania in 1999. His mother, father and four sisters still live in Albania (OASys risk assessment page 18). He completed secondary school while in Albania and worked in the Construction industry there, sometimes with his father in Albania and he also travelled to Greece for this work (OASys report p15). He was married to a citizen of Italy in Albania on 6 November 2020. It is likely that he obtained leave to enter the United Kingdom on the basis of that marriage. He arrived in the United Kingdom in March 2021 (paragraph 1 of his witness statement). At the hearing he confirmed that he separated from his wife in August 2024, divorce proceedings were concluded on 20 February 2025.

15. The evidence of all four witnesses is that the appellant began his relationship with Ms Harrison in December 2024 having met at a restaurant where she worked in September 2024. One subject of cross examination was why this relationship was not relied on when human rights submissions were made in March 2026.

16. In their witness statements, the appellant and Ms Harrison state that they lived together, no dates are provided. In paragraph 6 of her witness statement Ms Harrison says that she moved into his apartment after approximately one year. In the respondent’s review it is highlighted that there is no evidence of cohabitation or shared finances or communication, or any other evidence of the existence and nature of the relationship aside from a small number of photographs. Under cross examination the evidence of Ms Harrison was that she did not officially move in with the appellant but she was spending a lot of time at his flat.

17. Ms Harrison has obtained a degree and a Masters in Psychology. At the hearing, she confirmed she started her studies in 2022 and completed her Masters in the summer of 2026, she is waiting for her results. She said her area of specialism is the medical applications of psychology. She is currently looking for work in her chosen area. She said that in 2022 she lived in accommodation provided by the university but then lived with her parents from year two of her studies.

18. In her witness statement Ms Harrison says that she introduced the appellant to her family at an early stage in their relationship and that they developed a close bond with him (paragraph 5). Her evidence is that he provided her with support when a close relation passed away. At the hearing, her oral evidence was that she had told her mother of the appellant’s conviction but not her father. I asked where her father thought the appellant was when he was in custody, Ms Harrison said that she explained his absence by telling her father that he worked a lot.

19. Having begun their relationship in December 2024, the appellant was arrested on suspicion of dealing Class A drugs in May 2025, he was released on bail until his trial. He pleaded guilty at a Pre-trial review hearing and was sentenced on 5 September 2025. He began his custodial sentence on the same date. He was released in August 2026. The evidence is that Ms Harrison did not visit him in prison because of the distance involved and Ms Harrison’s commitment to her studies.

20. The evidence of Ms Harrison was that she has planned her life with the appellant and that she has worked hard to obtain her qualifications, she would not be able to fulfil her dream to work in her preferred area if she moved to Albania partly because of the language barrier. She also said that if she remains here, this would mean a separation from the appellant and they would not be able to live together as a couple and start a family as they had planned.

21. As stated above, the appellant also relies on his relationship with his brother, Mr Jugen Deva. The brother attended the hearing in order to have his evidence tested in cross examination as did his partner. Mr Jurgen Deva confirmed that he entered the United Kingdom in 2018 and has supported his brother. Documents confirm that the appellant has lived with his brother since arriving in the United Kingdom in March 2021. When the appellant was married, his wife also lived there. The appellant’s brother confirmed that he visited the appellant in prison often and also spoke to him on the phone, sometimes every day and sometimes 3 or 4 times a week. He confirmed that he visits Albania and most recently he went in August 2026 for a period of two weeks. He confirmed that he may be able to provide some support to the appellant in the event of his deportation. He said that he could not commit to providing financial support as this would depend upon him being in a position to meet his own living costs.

The offending behaviour

22. Details are contained within the Judges Sentencing Remarks and also in the OASys risk assessment. On 12 May 2025 the appellant was stopped driving a motor vehicle registered in his name. He was found to be in possession of 12 wraps of cocaine totalling about 5.92 grams with a value between £480 and £600, there was also a larger rock of cocaine (3.49 grams), some Albanian currency and £695.00 in GBP. He pleaded guilty to being in possession of class A drugs with intent to supply and has acknowledged that he was dealing these drugs. In sentencing, the judge found he was performing an operational, rather than a more significant role, but that did have some awareness of the size of the operation due to the number of instructions to deliver drugs. In sentencing, the judge took into account the appellant’s previous good character and the fact that this behaviour was out of character for those who knew him.

Remorse and rehabilitation

23. The judges sentencing remarks confirm that the appellant has not been in trouble before which is also set out at page 12 of the OASys risk assessment and highlighted by Mr Reza. In his witness statement, the appellant confirms that at the time of the offending behaviour, he was going through a difficult time in his life because he was left with some debt following his divorce. He says that initially, he was not aware that parcels he was told to deliver contained illegal drugs but acknowledges that once he became aware, he continued.

24. The appellant has been assessed as posing a medium risk of harm to the public. Whilst the author of the OASys report acknowledges that with the right support and continued positive factors, such as his family and stable accommodation, he would be at low risk of reoffending, should he find himself in a poor financial situation, his risk would be heightened.

25. The appellant’s bundles do not contain any evidence of courses that he has completed to address his offending behaviour but at the hearing he confirmed that he had successfully completed the Stoic course which requires attendance at a number of sessions. The OASys risk assessment states that he spent some of his time in prison usefully as he completed Entry 1 and 2 in English reading and writing (page 15).

Findings

Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002

Exception 1

26. The first limb to Exception 1 is that the appellant must have been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life. Whilst all of his residence has been lawful, the appellant has lived here for a relatively short period and so he has not spent most of his life here. He cannot meet Exception 1 but the unchallenged fact that all of his residence here has been lawful should be carried forward to the overall Article 8 assessment.

27. The respondent does not accept that the appellant is socially and culturally integrated into the United Kingdom. I find that he is, due to the evidence that he lived most of his married life here at a time when he was working in the construction industry and contributing to society through the payment of taxes which is demonstrated by tax returns for every tax year of his stay here (2021 through to 2026 in the second appellant’s bundle). He also had three witnesses who were prepared to attend the hearing in order to support him. I also accept submissions made by Mr Reza that the appellant gave convincing evidence that he considers the United Kingdom his home.

28. In relation to the question of whether there are very significant obstacles to the appellant’s integration into Albania, Mr Reza acknowledged there were some difficulties with this given the family members present there, the links that his brother, who is close to him have maintained with his family in Albania recently and the appellant’s acceptance that emotional support would be available on return. This is an appellant who speak Albanian, who is now 27 and lived there until he was 21, was educated in Albania and has experience working in the construction industry with his father. I cannot see any reason why his father cannot help him to obtain work in the construction industry on return, the appellant has maintained his skills in this area through his work in the United Kingdom. I find that there are not very significant obstacles to the appellant’s integration into Albania. I find that the appellant will be able to obtain work in Albania and so he will have the means to pay for accommodation.

Exception 2

29. I accept that the appellant is in a relationship with Ms Harrison but I cannot accept that relationship begun in December 2024. The relationship was not mentioned in human rights submissions made on behalf of the appellant in March 2026. Before preparing the human rights submissions it is reasonable to expect the representatives to have asked questions of the appellant to establish whether he met any of the Exceptions and so the existence of a partner would have been highly relevant. I find that this relationship would have been relied on had it been in existence in March 2026.

30. I cannot accept that Ms Harrison would have failed to make a single visit to the appellant while he was in prison between September 2025 and August 2026. I do not consider the distance between HMP Huntercombe and North London to be prohibitive for an individual who has spent time living away from her family while she was studying at university.

31. In addition, had the appellant been introduced to Ms Harrison’s family and formed a close bond with them before the conviction, it is not plausible that Ms Harrison’s father would have accepted his absence for a period of almost a year as being due to him working a lot. I did not accept Ms Harrison’s attempt to explain why she said she lived with the appellant when in fact, she was staying at his flat. Ms Harrison is educated, there is a clear difference between living with and staying with. I find she was not telling the truth in her witness statement and added the explanation in response to the challenge to this point set out in the respondent’s review.

32. As highlighted by Ms Khawaja there is also very little evidence of the relationship, no record of communication and the very few photographs which have been provided are not date stamped. There is no independent evidence of any relationship until the summer of 2026. The appellant had little knowledge of Ms Harrison’s studies which she cited as being of great importance to her. He did not know that she had completed her courses, he thought she was taking a break and was due to return in April 2027 to study in Kingston when in fact Ms Harrison said that she had been considering entering an application process which opens in April 2027.

33. I find any romantic relationship did not begin until the appellant was released in August 2026 and so any relationship is in its early stages. The appellant and Ms Harrison are clearly not reliant on each other for financial support. Ms Harrison has obtained her educational qualifications without the support of the appellant and she is reliant on her family for accommodation.

34. I accept that Ms Harrison has never been to Albania and has no connections there other than the appellant. I also accept that at the moment, there is a language barrier. However, I find that it would not be unduly harsh for Ms Harrison to relocate to Albania with the appellant, she would be supported by the appellant and his family in Albania. I have found that the appellant would be able to find work in the construction industry and so will have the means to pay for accommodation. If the appellant is deported it is a matter for Ms Harrison as to whether she wishes to disrupt her planned career path for this relationship but many adults decide to relocate to support their partners and Ms Harrison has no known vulnerabilities. She is educated and has lived away from her parents before. I find she has the aptitude to learn the language and the motivation to find work that she would find fulfilling.

35. I find that it would also not be unduly harsh for Ms Harrison to remain in the United Kingdom in the event of the appellant’s deportation to Albania, I have found the relationship is not one that she depends upon to meet her needs, her family provide her with support. Ms Harrison is also ambitious and independent. If she remains in the United Kingdom without the appellant there is nothing to prevent her from applying for positions in order to further her career.

Very compelling circumstances

36. Having found that the appellant does not meet the Exceptions set out in Section 117C (4) and (5) it is now relevant to consider whether there are very compelling circumstances, over and above those described in Exceptions 1 and 2 (section 117C (6). The appellant’s case, as I understand it, is that there are factors which when combined, amount to very compelling circumstances. One aspect is the appellant’s relationship with his brother, Mr Jurgen Deva. I accept that the brothers are close and that they have lived together since March 2021. I also accept that Jurgen visited the appellant in prison and maintained regular telephone contact with him, his evidence about this was clear and plausible. However, Jurgen moved to the United Kingdom three years before the appellant and so they have lived separately in the past. There is some form of dependency because Jurgen provides the appellant with accommodation but there is nothing to suggest this is a necessity rather than a choice. The appellant has had his own income since he has lived here, as evidenced by his tax returns. The brothers are adults, evidence of the close relationship does not, in my assessment, go beyond normal family ties that usually exist between adults. I also note that when the appellant was close to being released from detention in August, which can be a disruptive period, it was not considered essential for Jurgen to remain present to support him because this is when Jurgen travelled to Albania.

37. Mr Reza relied on what was said in the OASys risk assessment in relation to the low risk of reoffending and the appellant’s evidence that he has learnt from his mistake. I am not satisfied that there is genuine remorse. I do not consider there can be remorse without acceptance of the offending behaviour. I find it highly unlikely that when the appellant met some individuals in a coffee shop and was asked to deliver packages to various addresses and collect money, he did not realise that he would in fact be dealing drugs; this account is one that he has maintained as recently as last month because this is set out in the recent risk assessment. The appellant may have realised he has made a mistake but I find that is because of the consequences that have followed for him personally rather than any reflection on the harm he has caused to others. Overall, I accept that if the appellant remains financially stable, his risk of reoffending is low and he has paid a high price for his criminal conduct and so he has an incentive to stay out of trouble. However, I am mindful that whilst evidence reducing the risk of reoffending may carry some weight, this is not a case where evidence of rehabilitation carries great weight.

38. The third appellant’s bundle contains a photograph of medication that the appellant was prescribed on 258 September 2026. This has not been referred to elsewhere in the documents and not expanded on at the hearing. This seems to be antihistamine or medication to reduce motion sickness. The reason for the prescription and any relevance to the issues in my decision has not been made clear.

39. In HA (Iraq) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2022] UKSC 22 guidance was given in relation to the high threshold which must be satisfied to establish very compelling circumstances. It is clear that the cases in which circumstances are sufficiently compelling to outweigh the high public interest in deportation will be rare.

40. In my assessment, the particular circumstances of the appellant including his lawful stay and work here, his brother’s support and the effect on Ms Harrison just do not come close to outweighing the strong public interest in deportation. I conclude there are not very compelling circumstances.

41. The respondent has refused the appellant’s application made under the EUSS scheme on 13 September 2025 on grounds of suitability, the basis of this decision is the fact that the appellant is subject to a deportation order. In paragraph 39 of the ASA the Tribunal is invited to determine the linked EUSS appeal consistently with findings in the Human Rights appeal; I agree with this approach. I have dismissed the appeal against the human rights based submissions and decided that the respondent’s decision to deport is proportionate, it follows that I dismiss the appeal against the respondent’s decision to refuse EUSS leave on suitability grounds. It was not submitted that the decision made by the respondent breaches rights that the appellant has under the Withdrawal Agreement.

NOTICE OF DECISION

The appeal is dismissed on human rights grounds.

The refusal to grant EUSS leave is in accordance with residence scheme immigration rules.

The decision of the respondent does not breach rights that the appellant has under the Withdrawal Agreement.

TO THE RESPONDENT

FEE AWARD

I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award.

Signed: Date 29/10/2026

Judge S. Moon

Judge of the First-tier Tribunal Moon

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our immigration lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.