Administrative United Kingdom

IS v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Official source

First-tier Tribunal

(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: PA/74885/2025

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Heard at Taylor House Decision & Reasons Promulgated
On 6 November 2026 9 November 2026

Before

JUDGE OF THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL J K SWANEY

Between

IS

(anonymity direction MADE)

Appellant

and

the secretary of state for the home department

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: Mr Riok, legal representative

For the Respondent: Ms Barry, presenting officer

Direction pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014

Unless and until this appeal is finally determined or the court/tribunal directs otherwise the appellant is granted anonymity.

No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.

DECISION AND REASONS

Anonymity

1. I have decided to maintain the anonymity direction in this case because the need for the United Kingdom to discharge its obligations under the Refugee Convention outweighs the public interest in open justice.

Background

2. The appellant is a citizen of Kazakhstan. He appeals the decision made on 17 June 2025 to refuse his international protection and human rights claims.

3. The appellant first arrived in the United Kingdom on 26 May 2024. He had entry clearance as a temporary work (seasonal worker) migrant, valid until 25 November 2024. He claimed asylum on 14 October 2024. He now appeals that decision.

The appellant’s claim

4. The appellant claims to have a well-founded fear of persecution for reason of his imputed political opinion. He fears the police having been arrested and detained in January 2022 after being caught up in protests in which he was not participating. He claims that the police visited his home in Kazakhstan in early October 2024, looking for him. He claims that they are interested in him because they suspect him of having been involved in the protests and taking part in anti-government activities aimed at bringing down the government. He relies on a summons, which he states was left with his mother. He fears that he will be arrested, detained, and possibly killed on return.

The respondent’s decision

5. In her letter dated 17 June 2025 the respondent gave the following reasons for her decision:

(i) The appellant’s nationality and identity are accepted.

(ii) It is not accepted that the appellant was arrested or detained in January 2022 or that he received a police summons related to his detention in January 2022.

(iii) The appellant is not credible because his account is lacking in detail and inconsistencies in that account have not been adequately explained. His account is inconsistent with background information.

(iv) It is accepted that if the material facts of the appellant’s claim are accepted, there would not be sufficiency of protection, and he could not internally relocate.

(v) The appellant’s claim for humanitarian protection fails for the same reasons as his asylum claim.

(vi) It is not accepted that the appellant would face very significant obstacles to his integration in Kazakhstan and he does not satisfy paragraph PL5.1(b) of Appendix Private Life of the Immigration Rules.

(vii) It is not accepted that the appellant’s removal would give rise to unjustifiably harsh consequences for him or a member of his family and the decision is therefore proportionate and lawful pursuant to section 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998.

The appeal hearing

6. The appellant attended the hearing and gave evidence in Russian through an independent interpreter. I have considered the oral evidence and submissions together with the following documents in reaching my decision:

(i) Appellant’s notice of appeal and skeleton argument.

(ii) Appellant’s bundle.

(iii) Respondent’s bundle.

(iv) Respondent’s review.

7. Ms Barry made an application to rely on documents not contained in the respondent’s bundle. They consisted of photographs and three videos which were provided to the Home Office by the appellant by email after his substantive interview and before the respondent’s decision. She explained that there were formatting issues, which is why they had not been included in the respondent’s bundle and because they were stored separately to the rest of the appellant’s file. She also made an application to admit documents from the respondent’s file including copies of pages of the appellant’s passport and file notes relating to the appellant’s visa for the United Kingdom.

8. Mr Riok confirmed that he had seen the documents, but that the appellant had not. I noted that it was the appellant who had provided the photographs and videos and that he had seen them albeit possibly not recently. I gave Mr Riok an opportunity to take instructions and indicated that he could ask the appellant questions about the documents in evidence in chief if necessary. Mr Riok took instructions and confirmed that he had no objection to the admission of the documents and the videos. I admitted all of the evidence.

The law and burden and standard of proof

9. The appellant claimed asylum on 14 October 2024, and sections 30 to 39 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 apply to his case.

10. Paragraph 334 of the Immigration Rules provides that an applicant will be granted refugee status if the respondent is satisfied that the criteria of that provision are met. The applicant must be in the United Kingdom or have arrived at a port of entry; demonstrate that he falls within the definition of a refugee in article 1 of the Refugee Convention; is not excluded from the protection of the Refugee Convention pursuant to article 33(2); and that refusing his claim would require him to go in breach of the Refugee Convention to a country in which he would be persecuted on account of his race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership of a particular social group.

11. The appellant must show that his claim engages a Convention reason and that he has a subjective fear of persecution on the balance of probabilities. If he establishes that, he must demonstrate to the lower standard, i.e. that there is a reasonable degree of likelihood, that he would be persecuted for a Convention reason; that there would be insufficient protection; and that he could not internally relocate.

12. Paragraph 339C of the Immigration Rules provides that an applicant who does not qualify as a refugee will be granted humanitarian protection if the criteria of that provision are met. The appellant must show that there are substantial grounds for believing that he would face a real risk of suffering serious harm and that owing to such risk he is unable or unwilling to avail himself of the protection of the country of return, i.e. Kazakhstan.

13. In relation to an alleged breach of article 3 of the ECHR, the appellant must show that there are substantial grounds for believing that he will be exposed to a real risk of torture, or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Article 3 is absolute and does not permit any justification or exclusion.

14. Appendix Private Life of the Immigration Rules governs applications made on private life grounds. It is for the appellant to establish that he satisfies any relevant provisions of the Rules on the balance of probabilities.

15. In so far as he relies on article 8 of the ECHR the appellant must demonstrate that he has a private and/or family life in the United Kingdom which will be subject to interference by the decision under appeal. If that is shown, it is for the respondent to establish that any interference is lawful, in pursuance of a legitimate aim and is necessary and proportionate in a democratic society. Sections 117A to 117D of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 (the 2002 Act) are relevant to any consideration of article 8 of the ECHR outside the Immigration Rules.

Findings and reasons

16. It is not disputed that the appellant’s claim engages a Convention reason, and I find that it does – his imputed political opinion. The respondent also accepted that if the appellant’s protection claim is well-founded, then there would not be sufficiency of protection, and he could not internally relocate. Mr Riok confirmed that the appellant’s claims under paragraph PL5.1(b) of Appendix Private Life, and under article 8 of the ECHR stand or fall with his asylum claim. No separate arguments were advanced. The issues for determination in this appeal are:

(i) Is the appellant credible?

(ii) Does the appellant have a subjective fear of persecution or serious harm?

(iii) If so, is that fear well-founded?

Is the appellant credible?

17. The respondent raised 8 points regarding the appellant’s credibility in her reasons for refusing the claim set out at paragraph 10 (not numbered but falls between paragraphs 9 and 11).

18. Points 10(a) to (c) are essentially all the same and assert that the appellant’s account of the events of 4 January 2022 during the protest lacked detail and specificity. The appellant’s evidence is that he was not involved in the protests at all and was simply on his way home and got caught up in them. It is unsurprising that he was therefore unable to provide much detail. The respondent does not dispute that there were widespread protests in Kazakhstan in January 2022, which was confirmed by Ms Barry at the hearing. I place little weight on the lack of detail about the appellant’s movements and events on 4 January 2022.

19. Point 10(d) asserts that aspects of the appellant’s claim are inconsistent. In particular she considered that his evidence that there were patrols everywhere was inconsistent with being unable to explain where the security services who arrested him materialised from. The respondent relies on the appellant’s answers to questions 23, 32 and 34 of his interview. Question 23 is not a question at all; it is a reminder to the appellant to wait for the interpreter to finish interpreting and has no relevance to this point. Question 22 was a general question asking the appellant to explain what happened to him in January 2022 and was not specifically related to patrols or their whereabouts. Question 32 was ‘what happened to you when you were thrown into the bus? Was anything said to you?’ This does not relate to the whereabouts of patrols. Question 34 was ‘When you were walking through the city can you describe the scene to me. What were the protestors doing? Were they violent or peaceful? Were they chanting? Did they have banners?’ Again, this has nothing to do with the whereabouts of patrols. I place no weight on point 10(d), as it is not an inconsistency.

20. Point 10(e) asserts that the appellant failed to give a sufficiently detailed account of his arrest and detention because he was unable to recall any details about the person who interrogated him or the questions that he was asked. When asked at question 38 who was interrogating him and whether the appellant was told his name, rank or position, the appellant stated that he could not remember and that he forgot. When asked what kind of questions he was asked, the appellant replied: ‘why were you there’ (question 39). When asked ‘did they ask you any other questions?’ (question 42), he replied most of the questions were concerning where I lived, where I worked, and why I was there’. When asked what type of questions he was asked about why he was there, he replied: ‘nothing special, just common questions’ (question 43). The appellant’s evidence is that he was detained with a number of other individuals in a gym. He does not claim to have been interrogated in any depth or for a significant period. The appellant has provided a reasonable level of detail in my view. His responses show that the questions asked of him were to establish who he was and why he was in the area at the time. I do not attach any significant weight to this point.

21. Point 10(f) relates to the appellant’s belief that the authorities were subjecting people detained on 4 January 2022 to a second interrogation. It is asserted that this lacks specificity and credibility. The appellant states that his belief is based on what he has heard in the community rather than any direct knowledge. This was put to the appellant in cross-examination, and he stated that he had heard people talking about it, saying that people who had participated had disappeared and that some had been interrogated. He confirmed that he did not personally know anyone who had disappeared or been interrogated. The appellant’s account does lack detail and although I accept that it may be what he believes was happening, my attention was not drawn to any relevant background evidence which would support that belief. This is not really a matter going to the appellant’s credibility; it is an evidential issue.

22. Point 10(g) relates to the appellant’s ability to leave Kazakhstan using his own passport, which was issued to him in November 2022, without difficulty. The respondent asserts that his ability to travel freely is not consistent with the authorities having any interest in him. The appellant was asked about his travel in cross-examination. He confirmed that he had travelled to Albania and Morocco after he was arrested and before he travelled to the United Kingdom. He stated that he received no adverse attention from the authorities either on exit from or entry to Kazakhstan. That the appellant was apparently able to obtain a passport and travel freely in and out of Kazakhstan after his arrest is potentially a matter that damages his credibility and carries weight in my assessment of credibility.

23. Point 10(f) is about the summons relied on by the appellant. The respondent declined to place any weight on this document because it was not translated by a certified translator in the United Kingdom. Ms Barry accepted that a translation made in the United Kingdom has now been provided. In cross-examination Ms Barry put an apparent inconsistency in the document to the appellant. She noted that the document appears to have been signed and dated on 11 October 2024, whereas the appellant’s evidence is that it was delivered to his mother on 10 October 2024 when the police visited her home. The appellant did not attempt to explain this and maintained that the document was given to his mother on 10 October 2024. This is a material discrepancy, for which the appellant did not provide an explanation. There was no evidence from the appellant’s mother to confirm how or when she obtained the document. This is evidence that ought reasonably to have been available, as the appellant is in contact with his mother.

24. Matters that were not raised in the decision under appeal but which arise from the appellant’s interview and witness statement were put to him in cross-examination. Ms Barry asked the appellant what the police said to his mother when they visited her. He stated that they told her that he was a witness to some crime during the protests. He stated that they did not mention what crime. Ms Barry referred the appellant to paragraph 11 of his witness statement in which he states that the police went to his house and accused him of taking part in anti-government activities to take down the government.

25. Ms Barry asked if they did not say that to his mother, referring to her earlier question, and it was not stated in the summons, how did he know that. The appellant stated that ‘they said it to her’. I put it to the appellant that he had given two different answers about what the authorities said to his mother and asked him if he could explain why. The appellant stated that his answer to the second question was what his mother told him in her own words. I pointed out that the questions were the same, i.e. what did the authorities tell his mother? He reiterated his answer that when the police came, they told his mother that he was a witness to a crime and that they left the summons and that when she sent him the summons, she told him that the police were accusing him of being involved in the protests. I find that the appellant’s answers to the same question are discrepant. While he attempted to say in his oral evidence that it was his mother who told him that the police were accusing him of being involved in the protests; his witness statement and his initial answer in cross examination are that the police told his mother this. This is inconsistent and the appellant has failed to provide a satisfactory explanation. This is a matter that carries weight in my assessment of credibility.

26. Ms Barry asked the appellant about paragraph 14 of his witness statement in which he states that the security forces have fabricated a false allegation against him. She asked him: ‘what exactly is the false allegation?’. The appellant stated that ‘once you turn up there, they can claim whatever allegations against you’. Ms Barry put it to the appellant that in his statement he appeared to say that a false allegation had already been made, but his oral evidence suggested that he was afraid that this would happen in the future. The appellant confirmed that: ‘if I turn up there, I will be detained and they will label me with whatever they want’. The appellant’s evidence on this point is inconsistent, and he has failed to provide a satisfactory explanation. This is a matter that carries weight in my assessment of credibility.

27. The appellant provided several photographs and three videos to the respondent. Although they were not initially included in the respondent’s bundle, the appellant did not provide them to the tribunal himself, and it was not clear as to the extent to which he continues to rely on them.

28. I understand the appellant’s evidence to be that one video is of the protest, which he did not take himself and which he obtained from YouTube. He stated that he provided it to give an indication of what was happening during the protests. This was untranslated. The other two videos are ones that the appellant took himself at some point after the protest. He stated that the photographs are stills taken from those videos and that the point of them is that they show the gym where he was taken after he was arrested.

29. Given that it is not disputed that the protests occurred, the YouTube video adds little and given that it is not translated, I place no weight on it. The videos and stills taken by the appellant were not taken on the day of the protests; show the outside of a building without giving any information as to its location; and add nothing to his claim because it is not possible to identify where or when they were taken. Even were I to find that they did depict the gym where the appellant claims he was detained, they would add no weight, as they were not taken at the time of detention and do not assist in demonstrating that the appellant was in fact detained.

30. I have considered the lack of evidence about the provenance of the summons and the apparent discrepancy on its face identified by Ms Barry. The appellant maintained that the summons was given to his mother on 10 October 2024 and could not explain why it was apparently signed and dated on 11 October 2024. Had the appellant wished to, he could have quite easily stated that he was simply mistaken about the date it was given to his mother when the discrepancy was pointed out to him. That he did not do so suggests that the discrepancy may be a simple error.

31. In his witness statement the appellant claims that he was physically abused when he was detained. The appellant does not allege any physical abuse in either his screening interview or his substantive interview. He provides no detail of the physical abuse he claims to have suffered in his witness statement other than he was forced to stand for a long time and that his feet started aching. The appellant has had the opportunity to provide detail about any ill-treatment he experienced but has not done so.

32. Having considered all of the above in the round, together with the videos, photographs, and summons relied on by the appellant, I find that the core of his claim is consistent and credible but that he has embellished his claim and that those embellishments are not consistent with the core of his claim and are not credible. The inconsistencies have not been adequately explained for the reasons given above.

33. I make the following findings of fact:

(i) The appellant did not participate in the protests in Kazakhstan in January 2022 and has not articulated any political beliefs.

(ii) The appellant was in the vicinity of the protests as claimed.

(iii) The appellant was arrested and detained as claimed simply because he was in the vicinity of the protests.

(iv) While detained, the appellant was asked questions about who he is, what he did and why he was in the area. He was fingerprinted and released, suggesting that the authorities were satisfied with his explanations. He was not abused or ill-treated during his detention.

(v) The police visited the appellant’s home and served a summons relating to the appellant on his mother.

(vi) The reason the appellant was asked to attend the police station was as a witness and there is no evidence to support his assertion that he has been accused of anything, genuine or fabricated. That he has or might be accused of something is a fabrication designed to bolster his claim.

(vii) The fact that the appellant was able to obtain a passport in November 2022 and travel outside Kazakhstan on two occasions to Albania and Morocco and return to Kazakhstan without issue is an indication that the authorities have no adverse interest in him.

(viii) On being informed that the appellant was not in the country, the police left his mother’s house and there has been no further attempt to contact or locate him. This is a further indication that the authorities have no adverse interest in the appellant.

Does the appellant have a subjective fear of persecution?

34. Applying my findings in relation to credibility and my findings of fact, I find on the balance of probabilities that the appellant does not in fact fear persecution.

Does the appellant face a real risk of persecution or serious harm?

35. I have had regard to the guidance given in the recent case of DS (NABA s.32(2)(a), JCK [2026] UKUT 413 (IAC) and considered whether having found that the appellant does not have a subjective fear of persecution, I should nevertheless go on and consider whether he would face a real risk of serious harm; the sufficiency of protection; and whether internal relocation would be available to him.

36. I find that it is not necessary to do so and rely on my findings of fact which clearly demonstrate that the appellant does not face a real risk of serious harm. The questions of sufficiency of protection and internal relocation therefore do not arise.

37. As already noted, Mr Riok confirmed that the appellant’s claims stand or fall with his asylum claim. Based on my findings above, I find that the appellant would not face very significant obstacles to his integration in Kazakhstan and that his removal would be proportionate and therefore lawful.

Notice of Decision

The appeal is dismissed on asylum grounds.

The appeal is dismissed on humanitarian protection grounds.

The appeal is dismissed on human rights grounds.

I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award.

Signed J K Swaney Date 9 November 2026

Judge J K Swaney

Judge of the First-tier Tribunal

Our immigration lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.