Civil United Kingdom
Raj Pal Senna v Sam Carter
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWHC 2875 (KB)
Case No: KB-2026-000988
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
KING'S BENCH DIVISION
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Date: 6 November 2026
Before :
Her Honour Judge Melissa Clarke sitting as a Judge of the High Court
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Between :
| MR RAJ PAL SENNA | Claimant/ Respondent | |
| – and – | ||
| MR SAM CARTER | Defendant/ Applicant |
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
The Claimant /Respondent appeared in person
Mr Matthew Psycharis (instructed by Clyde & Co) for the Defendant /Applicant
Hearing date: 6 November 2026
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
JUDGMENT
HHJ Melissa Clarke:
1. This is judgment in an application by the Applicant, Mr Sam Carter, for the Court to make a general civil restraint order (“GCRO”) against the Respondent, Mr Raj Pal Senna.
2. Mr Psycharis represents Mr Carter. Mr Senna appeared in person, accompanied by his carer who assists him. He asked for reasonable adjustments because of his mental and physical health issues, and I agreed that he could take time to find documents and have regular breaks when he asked for them. He had several such breaks. I concluded submissions just before the short adjournment and said I would return to give judgment at 2pm. Mr Senna informed Mr Psycharis and my clerk that he did not intend to return for the judgment and so it was delivered in his absence. I am releasing these judgment notes so that Mr Senna has a record of my reasons without being put to the expense of a transcript.
Law and Procedure
3. Pursuant to PD3C, paragraph 4.1, a GCRO may be made by, inter alia, a Judge of the High Court where the party against whom the order is made persists in issuing claims or making applications which are totally without merit, in circumstances where an extended civil restraint order would not be sufficient or appropriate. It restrains that person from issuing any claim or making any application in the High Court or the County Court (if the order has been made by a judge of the High Court) without first obtaining the permission of a judge identified in the order. Pursuant to PD3C paragraph 4.3(1), if such a claim or application is brought without complying with the provisions of the order, it stands automatically struck out or dismissed.
4. A GCRO is, therefore, wider than an extended civil restraint order (“ECRO”) which restrains only the making of claims and applications “concerning any matter involving or relating to or touching upon or leading to the proceedings in which the order is made”, without first obtaining such permission. A GCRO restrains the issue of all claims and applications in the court(s) identified in the order whether or not they are linked to the proceedings in which the order was made.
5. Per Chief Constable of Avon & Somerset v Gray [2019] EWCA Civ 1675, the question for the Court is whether a GCRO is necessary in order (a) to protect litigants from vexatious proceedings against them, and/or (b) to protect the finite resources of the Court from vexatious waste, and this question is to be answered having full regard to the impact of any proposed order upon the party to be restrained.
6. Proof of three totally without merit or ‘TWM’ claims or applications has been described as the bare minimum to constitute persistence, but:
i) there is no reason why, if both a claim and an application in that claim are certified as totally without merit, both should not be counted for the purpose of considering ‘persistence’ (Sartipy v Tigris Industries Inc [2019] 1 WLR 5892);
ii) although three TWMs are the minimum, the question remains whether the party concerned is acting ‘persistently’, which requires an evaluation of the party’s overall conduct. As Lewis J (as he then was) stated in Society of Lloyd’s v Noel [2015] 1 WLR 4393 at [40] – [41], “In exercising the discretion, the court will have to assess the risk of the individual making further applications which are totally unmeritorious. Past conduct is relevant to that assessment… Indeed, it would, in my judgment, be illogical to leave earlier totally without merit claims and applications out of account.”;
iii) The TWM findings which may be taken into account include those made before a relevant ECRO (Caine v Facebook Ireland Limited [2021] EWHC 2264 (QB), Kerr J at [37]).
Is Mr Senna a litigant who has persistently issued claims or made applications which are totally without merit?
7. Mr Senna has an involved history as a litigant which has resulted in three ECROs being made against him previously: by Nicol J (as he then was) on 19 December 2011, see R (Dhanota) v Parole Board [2011] EWHC 3731 (Dhanota being a previous name of Mr Senna); by Newey J (as he then was) on 20 July 2017, see Birdi & Senna v Price & Pettit [2017] EWHC 1859; and by Julian Knowles J on 9 March 2021, see Senna v Henderson & Ors [2020] EWHC 3345 (QB) for background and Senna v Henderson & Ors (No 2) [2021] EWHC 453 (QB) for the ECRO decision. Accordingly, three judges have already been satisfied that he is a litigant who has persistently issued claims or made applications which are totally without merit.
8. That history was comprehensively summarised by Julian Knowles J at [24] – [29] of Henderson & Ors, and is further updated in Henderson & Ors (No 2).
9. All three of those judges, and others, have commented on Mr Senna’s characteristics as a litigant in critical terms, going back to 2002 when Gibbs J in a case of Dhanota v Birdi described his conduct as having “the hallmarks of that of a vexatious litigant. The pattern of these applications indicates an attempt to use the court’s process not for proper and legitimate reasons, but rather for the purpose of abuse of the process in order to pursue numerous and repetitive allegations and arguments most, if not all, of which are wholly lacking in any arguable merit”. Newey J in Birdi & Senna v Price & Pettit after setting out a raft of claims and applications made by Mr Senna and dismissed as totally without merit in [40] and [41] of his judgment described him as “someone who, as regards matters relating to Mr Birdi’s bankruptcy, refuses “to take ‘no’ for an answer”.”. Julian Knowles J noted in Senna v Henderson (No 2) at [10], “I am told by Mr Pillai that since the Claimant commenced these actions in April and May 2020 there have been no fewer than 27 applications by the Claimant which have been certified as TWM.”. He described him in Senna v Henderson at [221] as “a serial nuisance litigator” since “at least 2002”. He went on to say, “The present claims are merely the latest sorry chapter of failed litigation that has disproportionately utilised precious court resources and caused distress, expense and inconvenience to others”.
10. A new chapter of litigation was instigated by Mr Senna in 2026. It arose out of a decision in 2023 when a company of which he was a director sought to register a trade mark in the UK that resembled a mark that had long been used by the Hoya Corporation and its predecessors in title. Hoya Corporation instructed Lewis Silkin solicitors and Mr Sam Carter, who is a barrister specialising in intellectual property rights, to act in trade mark opposition proceedings in the United Kingdom Intellectual Property Office (“UKIPO Proceedings). Following a contested hearing the hearing officer, Mr Mark Bryant, found that it had been filed in bad faith and refused the registration to Mr Senna’s company.
11. Mr Senna was unhappy with this result but the company of which he was a director did not seek to appeal it. Of greater concern to him is that evidence of a spent conviction had been disclosed during the course of the proceedings contrary to section 4(1) Rehabilitation of Offenders Act. In 2026 he issued this claim against Mr Carter, and separate claims against his instructing solicitors Lewis Silkin (KB-2026-001124) and against the Comptroller General of Patents Designs and Trade Marks and Mr Mark Bryant and two others (KB-2026-002166).
12. In relation to these proceedings against Mr Carter, Master Byass made an order of his own motion pursuant to CPR 3.4(2) on 5 June 2026. He stayed the claim, providing that unless Mr Senna applied by 19 June 2026 to make an application to lift the stay accompanied by revised particulars of claim which complied with the pleading rules in CPR 16 and PD16, the claim would be struck out. Mr Senna did not comply with Master Byass’s order, and so the claim was struck out.
13. Mr Senna applied to set aside the order of Master Byass and for permission to rely on an amended particulars of claim enclosed with the application notice, which was listed before Master Armstrong at a hearing on 8 July 2026. Both parties attended. Mr Carter was represented by Mr Theo Barclay of counsel and Mr Senna was in person. Master Armstrong dismissed the application and certified it as totally without merit, ordering Mr Senna to pay Mr Carter’s costs on the indemnity basis. That is the first recent TWM certification.
14. Mr Senna sought permission to appeal at that hearing, which was refused by the Master. He has since filed a notice of appeal of Master Armstrong’s decision, based on an allegation that he was somehow misled by Mr Carter’s legal representatives in the course of the hearing before him. Mr Senna in his skeleton argument seeks to argue that Master Armstrong’s decision was wrong, relying on a finding of Mr Justice Eardley in Senna v Lewis Silkin but it is not for me to look behind an order which certifies a claim or application as totally without merit. That certification stands unless and until it is set aside on appeal.
15. Meanwhile, in the case of Senna v Lewis Silkin, Lewis Silkin applied to strike out the claim and for a GCRO to be made against Mr Senna. Mr Senna made an application to amend his particulars of claim. Both came before Mr Justice Eardley who reserved judgment on the strike out and application and adjourned consideration of the GCRO application pending his judgment. He handed down his judgment on 3 November 2026 ([2026] EWHC 2806 (KB)), which I have read, in which he held that statements in evidence and submissions during the IPO Proceedings were protected by immunity from suit, and section 4 of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 did not expressly or by implication remove that immunity. He held that he would strike out the claim as totally without merit, and dismiss Mr Senna’s application as totally without merit. I do not believe the order making that certification has been sealed yet but when it has, they will be the second and third recent TWM certification.
16. These claims arising out of the IPO Proceedings are not the only litigation in which Mr Senna has recently been involved.
17. On 28 April 2026, Mr Senna brought a claim against Lady Justice Dame Victoria Sharpe, at that time the President of the King’s Bench Division, and Master Byass (KB-2026-001511). I have not seen any of the pleadings in the claim but I have seen two orders of Master Sullivan at least one of which is not in the bundle but which I have obtained from the court. The first is an order of 1 May 2026 which recites that it is made of the court’s own motion. She struck out the claim as totally without merit for reasons which included that judges cannot be sued personally for judicial acts. That is the fourth recent TWM certification. The other is an order of 6 July 2026 following an application by Mr Senna inter alia to declare the order of 1 May 2026 void ab initio or to set it aside. She struck out that application without listing it, as totally without merit. That is the fifth recent TWM certification.
18. As is usual when matters relating to civil restraint orders come before me, as they often do in my capacity as Designated Civil Judge of Oxford and Thames Valley, I consult the court systems to see what other claims the litigant has brought, and whether any other TWM certifications have been made in respect of the litigant’s claims or applications on the various lists which are kept of TWM orders. There appear to be a few other claims currently proceeding in which Mr Senna is the Claimant of which Mr Carter was not aware. In two of those the register shows that orders have been made dismissing his applications as TWM. One is Senna v Scottish Daily Record and Sunday Mail Ltd KB-2026-001121, in which Collins-Rice J made an order on 19 August 2026 dismissing part of the Claimant’s application dated 29 July 2026 as totally without merit. That is the sixth recent TWM certification. The other is Senna v Haven-Wright and Ors KB-2026-001792 in which Master Byass made an order yesterday, 5 November 2026, dismissing the Claimant’s application dated 8 October 2026 as totally without merit. That is the seventh recent TWM certification.
19. In relation to the order of Collins-Rice J Mr Senna told me that he took issue with the sealing date applied to the order and has applied to set it aside on that basis. I asked him what relevance the sealing date had to the merits of the application he had made and he simply responded that the court should not backdate a seal. He did not engage with the question of whether the Master was right to certify it as totally without merit.
20. Considering that history of countless TWM certifications before the latest ECRO, and the extensive recent history of 5 TWM certifications since April 2026 with two more of Eardley J which will be made as soon as the order in Senna v Lewis Silkin is sealed, I have no doubt on the evidence before me that Mr Senna has persistently issued claims and made applications which are totally without merit, and continues to do so. I would reach that decision even if I had excluded from my consideration the order of Master Armstrong the subject of an as-yet undetermined appeal.
Is there a risk of Mr Senna bringing further claims and making further applications which are totally without merit, if left unrestrained?
21. Mr Carter draws my attention to various statements made by Mr Senna made in the course of the UKIPO hearing which he submits show that Mr Senna’s attitude is that people do not have the right to try and stop him from doing what he was, and that if they do, he will “attack them… like they have attacked me” Mr Senna submits that this is not fair, that those statements were made in the course of a very stressful hearing which he says he was legitimately aggrieved about. He points instead to Mr Justice Eardley’s recent judgment in Senna v Lewis Silkin in which it was accepted that he was genuinely distressed in that hearing, that he had a genuine desire to vindicate his rights, and noted that in the hearing before him Mr Senna conducted himself with “the utmost courtesy throughout” and that he had no reason to doubt that he had taken account of judicial criticisms and had learned to control himself in court. In the hearing before me Mr Senna did get upset at times, in particular shortly before a break, but after the break he apologised for raising his voice, which I was grateful to receive. I accept Mr Senna’s submission and do not take those statements into account against him.
22. Of more relevance, I think, is Mr Psycharis’ submission for Mr Carter that Mr Senna has a history of accusing judges of bias and making totally unmeritorious applications for them to recuse themselves. I accept this submission – see, for example, the judgment of Julian Knowles J in Senna v Henderson at [48], and an application for Master Byass to recuse himself in these proceedings, which he did not pursue. However his recent action in bringing a totally unmeritorious claim against judges, namely Master Byass and the then-President of the King’s Bench Division, is in my judgment a concerning escalation of his vexatious tendencies.
23. Mr Psycharis also points to Mr Senna’s tendency to litigate against legal professionals who oppose him, such as Mr Carter, Lewis Silkin and Mr Mark Bryant hearing officer, in relation to the IPO proceedings, and he draws my attention to emails from Mr Senna in which he complains about the actions of Clyde & Co who represent Mr Carter, and of Mr Theo Berkeley, counsel, who represented Mr Carter before Master Armstrong which resulted in his dismissal of an application as totally without merit. I agree that these show at least the potential for further unmeritorious applications unless restrained.
24. I also accept as relevant Mr Senna’s habit of bringing separate, parallel proceedings against individuals in relation to the same factual matrix. This was the case in all of the matters which resulted in the previous ECROs being made, and it is continued in the claims brought in respect of those involved in the IPO Proceedings. Bringing separate parallel proceedings causes significantly greater use of the court’s finite resources than bringing a single case with multiple defendants.
25. Mr Senna submits that he was injured in a motorcycle accident in 2016 after which he was confined to a wheelchair until 2023 and suffered from PTSD, chronic depression and chronic anxiety. I have not seen any medical evidence of Mr Senna. Nonetheless he acknowledges that his litigation conduct during that period fell below the standard the court is entitled to expect of a litigant. He says that he has since received and continues to receive considerable treatment for his mental health, and no longer uses a wheelchair, but a mobility scooter. That chronology does not explain either his litigation conduct which caused the 2011 ECRO to be made or the recent litigation conduct which has caused 7 orders since April this year to be certified as totally without merit.
26. Mr Senna submits that at the time that each of the previous ECROs made against him was in force, he complied with it and was never found in breach. Again, I do not have any evidence to support or undermine those statements but, if true, they show that they were effective to control his litigation conduct. Whether an ECRO would now be sufficient or appropriate is a separate question, which I address below.
27. Mr Senna submits that Mr Carter brings this application seeking punishment against him, but I accept Mr Psycharis’ submissions that the purpose is protective, both to ensure that no further unmeritorious claims or applications are brought against him personally, and in the public interest to protect others from unmeritorious claims or applications and to protect the precious resources of the court. There is or should be no element of punishment in a civil restraint order and whether Mr Senna should be “punished” is not a factor in the exercise of my discretion..
28. Before me today Mr Senna has indicated that he will wish to appeal the judgment of Mr Justice Eardley and the most recent TWM order made by Master Byass yesterday. That is despite Eardley J’s findings that “some aspects of the proposed amended claim involve abusive relitigation” and his conclusion that “Despite the energy devoted by the Claimant to finding a viable formulation, this claim was always bound to fail and there were no reasonable arguments available to him to persuade the court that it should proceed.”
29. In my judgment, the past evidence pre ECRO and more importantly the recent evidence in 2026 leads me to conclude that there is a very high risk that Mr Senna will bring further claims and make further applications which are totally without merit, if left unrestrained.
What is the appropriate order to be made?
30. Mr Carter seeks a GCRO and submits that an ECRO would be neither sufficient nor appropriate to restrain Mr Senna given the breadth of the subject matter that he has litigated about. Mr Psycharis for Mr Carter has set out an incomplete list at para 57 of his skeleton argument of grievances which have caused him to bring claims later found to be meritorious. This was compiled before he knew about Senna v Scottish Daily Record, Senna v Haven-Williams and the claim against Dame Victoria Sharp.
31. Mr Psycharis submits that by intimating claims against Mr Berkeley and his instructing solicitors, this could be seen as “an increasingly scattergun approach” of the type that Stacey J in London Underground Limited v Mighton said would mean that an ECRO was not appropriate. That is because, he submits, an ECRO would require sign policing to determine whether claims and applications brought by Mr Senna without permission under the ECRO were indeed those which he was entitled to bring or “concerned any matter involving or relating to or touching upon or leading to the proceedings in which the order is made” and so were caught by the ECRO. He submits that would inevitably require additional court resources and time and expense of the relevant parties to determine. He prays in aid of this submission Mr Senna’s assertion in the hearing today that the claim against Dame Victoria Sharp and Master Byass were connected with the subject matter of these proceedings but when I asked him to explain exactly how, he was unable to do so despite speaking for some 10 minutes on the point.
32. Mr Psycharis submits that Mrs Justice Stacey’s comment in London Underground Limited v Mighton at [70] that “An ECRO might encourage [the litigant] to develop his spaghetti strategy of throwing everything at the wall to see what might stick.” applies equally in this case.
33. Mr Senna submits that I should make no order, but if I am to make an order then he will comply with an ECRO as he has his previous ECROs. He submits that a GCRO would be disproportionate and punitive. He asks me to consider his health, the fact that, he says, he continues to have long-term severe depression and anxiety with suicidal ideation which is sufficiently concerning to his medical advisors that he only goes out with a carer present to stop himself from acting on such ideation, and he informs me that he has tried to take his own life a number of times in the past, including after the ECRO made by Knowles J. He said that if a civil restraint order is made today he will kill himself. He became very emotional in submitting that he has been given a right by Parliament under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act not to have his spent conviction referred to, and that everyone is trying to lock him down from enforcing that rights. He said if a civil restraint order is made “I fear I won’t be able to vindicate my rights”.
34. I have listened to Mr Senna, who is an intelligent and articulate man, carefully. Nonetheless I will make a civil restraint order. In my judgment an extended civil restraint order would not be sufficient or appropriate. It will restrain only claims and applications which involve, relate to, touch upon or lead to these proceedings, being those against Mr Carter arising out of allegations made about the IPO Proceedings. It would not have prevented the unmeritorious claim and application made in the Sharpe/Byass proceedings, for example. It arguably would not have prevented the unmeritorious applications in Senna v Haven-Wright and others and Senna v Scottish Daily Record and Sunday Mail Ltd KB-2026-001121 which do not have any direct connection these proceedings, but rather relate to separate allegations that his spent conviction was wrongly published and/or disclosed by those defendants.
35. I will make a general civil restraint order which I consider is necessary in order to protect litigants from vexatious or abusive proceedings against them, and to protect the resources of the Court from vexatious waste. It does not bar Mr Senna from bringing claims or applications, it just puts an additional process in place so that there is judicial scrutiny of the merit of those proposed claims and applications before those which have sufficient merit are permitted to proceed. It does not prevent him from vindicating or enforcing his rights provided that he does so by bringing meritorious claims and applications and complies with the terms of the GCRO. I understand that he will not be happy with my decision and that additional threshold being put in place. I hope he understands that to some extent, as Mr Psycharis submits, it is in his interests, not least because it will protect Mr Senna from the costs consequences and wasted time, effort and stress that he suffers when his unmeritorious claims and applications are struck out or dismissed. I hope it will enable him to focus on claims and applications that have merit and in doing so provide some respite for his mental health rather than cause it to deteriorate.
36. I consider it appropriate to make that GCRO for the longest possible term of three years given the long history of Mr Senna’s making unmeritorious claims and applications stretching over decades and his flurry of recent activity. I do not consider that there is any good reason to make it for a shorter period. It will expire at the end of three years from the date of sealing of the order, at which point consideration could be given to extending it for a further 3 year period, if appropriate.
37. It seems to me that the most appropriate judges to name within it, to whom any application for permission to bring claims or applications should be made, are Master Sullivan and in her absence Mr Justice Eardley.
38. Following my judgment I heard submissions on costs. I have ordered that Mr Senna pay Mr Carter’s costs of this application summarily assessed in the sum of £9751.20, by 4pm on 20 November 2026.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).