Miscellaneous United Kingdom

Loyal Support Limited v Care Quality Commission

Official source

First-tier Tribunal Care Standards

The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care) Rules 2008

2025-01719.EA

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKFTT 01445 (HESC)

Hearing held remotely on 16 October 2026

Before

Ms Jenny Appleton (Tribunal Judge)

Ms Elizabeth Bainbridge (Specialist Member)

Miss Michele Tynan (Specialist Member)

Loyal Support Limited

Appellant

-v-

Care Quality Commission

Respondent

DECISION

The Appeal

1. This is Loyal Support Limited’s (‘the Appellant’) appeal against a decision of the Care Quality Commission (‘CQC’ and ‘the Respondent’) to cancel its registration as a service provider in respect of the regulated activity of ‘personal care’, as carried on from Loyal Support Limited, 9 Shaftesbury Centre, Percy Street, Swindon, SN2 2AZ.

2. The appeal was brought by Mr Jacob Frimpong, director of Loyal Support Limited. Mr Frimpong appealed to the First-tier Tribunal against the Respondent’s decision of 14 November 2025, pursuant to section 32 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (the Act).

The hearing

3. The hearing took place on 16 October 2026 as a video hearing, which was agreed by the parties. The tribunal, parties, and all witnesses attended remotely.

4. The documents the Tribunal was referred to were in the electronic hearing bundle provided in advance of the hearing (570 pages). In addition, there was:

a. A Scott Schedule, dated 26 August 2026;

b. CQC position statement dated 14 September 2026;

c. Application notice with draft order submitted by the Appellant dated 17 September 2026 and the position statement of the Respondent in response;

d. Application notice with draft order submitted by the Respondent dated 13 October 2026 and the Appellant’s written submissions in response; and

e. Skeleton arguments submitted separately by the Appellant and Respondent, both dated 09 October 2026.

Attendance

5. Mr Frimpong attended and represented himself. Mr Frimpong also gave oral evidence at the hearing and called one witness, Mrs Gifty Frimpong.

6. The Respondent was represented by Mr Jon Okunpolor Junior for CQC Legal Services. The Respondent called one witness, Jennifer Shoemark, CQC Operations Manager.

Preliminary issues

7. The tribunal considered an application for strike out made by Mr Okunpolor Junior on behalf of the CQC pursuant to Rule 8(4)(c) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care Chamber) rules 2008. This was opposed by the Appellant.

8. Rule 8(4)(c) allows the tribunal the discretion to strike out the whole or part of the proceedings if the tribunal considers there is no reasonable prospect of the applicant’s case, or part of it, succeeding.

9. The thrust of Mr Okunpolor Junior’s submission was that there was no evidence advanced by the Appellant to show that they were carrying on the regulated activity, or that they were in a position to imminently do so. He suggested that the appeal should therefore be struck out with no reasonable prospect of success.

10. Mr Frimpong conceded that the regulated activity of personal care had not been carried out and was not imminently likely, however, he argued in response that the decision to cancel registration was discretionary not mandatory, and that the tribunal should consider the whole picture including operational readiness, business development activities, and adverse health issues affecting Mr Frimpong’s ability to work when deciding if the decision to cancel was reasonable and proportionate.

11. The tribunal considered that the statutory provision to cancel registration is discretionary not mandatory and that consideration of an appeal of this sort involves not only establishing the facts, namely that the regulated activity has not been carried on, but also a determination on the reasonableness and proportionality of the decision taken to cancel registration. The tribunal was mindful that a preliminary decision to strike the case out under rule 8(4)(c) would involve an evaluation of the evidence before hearing it, and deprive the Appellant of his right to challenge the reasonableness and proportionality of the Respondent’s decision. The tribunal therefore declined to strike the case out and determined instead that the appropriate course was to hear evidence in order to determine its prospect of success.

12. The tribunal next addressed an application by the Appellant for the first and second witness statements of Ali Butt, and the first witness statement of Gaurav Vashisht to be read. Mr Butt was abroad and unavailable to attend the hearing. Mr Vashisht had not responded to attempts to contact him to secure his attendance at the hearing.

13. Mr Frimpong acknowledged potential unfairness to the Respondent but submitted it was a matter for the tribunal to determine what, if any, weight should be attached to those statements. Mr Okunpolor Junior identified parts of the evidence he wished to challenge through cross-examination and submitted it would be unfair to admit those statements.

14. Rule 15(2) allows the tribunal broad discretion to admit evidence whether or not this would be admissible in a civil trial in England and Wales; or the evidence was available to a previous decision maker. It also allows the tribunal to exclude evidence that would otherwise be admissible in various circumstances, most relevant here is whether it would be otherwise unfair to admit the evidence.

15. The tribunal considered the Appellant and his witnesses had been given ample notification of the date of hearing. The Case Management Order of Judge Appleton dated 25 September 2026 set out a clear expectation that any witnesses in dispute relied upon by parties should attend the hearing and the consequences of their evidence potentially being excluded if they did not. Notably, Mr Vashisht was not responsive to attempts to contact him and Mr Butt had prioritised family commitments abroad. The tribunal was mindful that admission of their statements would result in unfairness to the Respondent because there would be no opportunity for the Respondent to cross-examine those witnesses or to challenge the evidence given. The tribunal therefore concluded that it would then be unfair to admit this evidence and so directed that their statements should be excluded.

16. The tribunal clarified the approach to fact finding in the appeal and the timetable for the hearing, noting that Mr Frimpong was appearing as an appellant in person. The tribunal confirmed that the evidential burden rested with the Respondent, to be discharged to the standard of ‘more likely than not’. The tribunal also confirmed that its powers included a decision to confirm the cancellation or to direct that it ceases to have effect, or to direct that it ceases to have effect and to impose discretionary conditions on registration.

Background

17. The Appellant has been registered with the CQC since 16 May 2024 to provide the regulated activity of ‘personal care’. It was confirmed during the hearing that since registration, Loyal Support Limited has never carried on the regulated activity of personal care.

18. On 14 August 2025, the Respondent requested confirmation from the Appellant of the status of the regulated activity of personal care at the location since 16 May 2024. On 20 August 2024, 20 November 2024, 20 February 2025, and 07 August 2025, the Respondent emailed the Appellant requesting confirmation on the status of regulated activity being carried out from the location since 20 May 2024. On 22 August 2024, 20 November 2024, 26 February 2025 and 11 August 2025 respectively, the Appellant responded to confirm they had not carried out the Regulated Activity from the location. On 19 September 2025, the Respondent sent to the Appellant a Notice of Proposal to cancel the Appellant’s registration. Upon consideration of the Appellant’s representations dated 14 October 2025, the Notice of Proposal was adopted into a Notice of decision dated 14 November 2025.

19. On 22 December 2025, the Appellant applied to the tribunal to appeal against the Respondent’s decision.

Legal framework

20. Section 2 of the Act invests in the Respondent registration, review, and investigation functions. By virtue of Section 3(1), the Respondent’s main objective is to protect and promote the health, safety and welfare of the people who use health and social care services. Section 3(2) empowers the Respondent to fulfil its functions for the general purpose of improving health and social care services, the provision of health and social care services in a way that focuses on the needs and experiences of people who use those services, and the efficient and effective use of resources in the provision of health and social care services.

21. Section 4 of the Act sets out the matters to which the Respondent must have regard in performing its functions, including: the views expressed by or on behalf of members of the public about health and social care services; experiences of people who use those services, and their families and friends; views expressed by organisations and contractors about the provision of those services; and the need to protect and promote the rights of people using them. Any action taken by the Respondent should be proportionate to the risks against which it would afford safeguards, and targeted only where it is needed.

22. Section 20 of the Act empowers the Secretary of State to make regulations in relation to regulated activities. The relevant regulations in this case are the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, SI 2014/2936 (‘the 2014 Regulations’) and the CQC (Registration) Regulations 2009 (‘the 2009 Regulations’).

23. Sections 26, 27 and 28 of the Act set out the procedural requirements in relation to notification of the Respondent’s decision.

24. Section 32 of the Act provides a right of appeal to this tribunal against a decision to cancel the registration of a service provider in relation to a regulated activity. The tribunal may confirm the decision or direct that it is not to have effect. Under section 32(6), the tribunal also has power to vary any discretionary condition for the time being in force in respect of the regulated activity to which the appeal relates; to direct that any such discretionary condition is to cease to have effect; to direct that any such discretionary condition as the tribunal thinks fit shall have effect in respect of the regulated activity; or to vary the period of any suspension. Section 32(7) provides that a ‘discretionary condition’ for this purpose means any condition other than a registered manager condition required by section 13(1).

25. Regulation 3 of the 2009 Regulations requires the Respondent to “establish and maintain a register containing such information as appears to the Commission to be necessary to keep the public informed about the identity of registered persons and their carrying on of regulated activities.”

26. Regulation 6(1)(c) of the 2009 Regulations permits the Respondent to cancel a service provider’s registration if that service provider “is not, and has not been for a continuous period of 12 months ending with the date of the decision to cancel registration, carrying on that regulated activity.”

27. The regulated activity of ‘personal care’ is defined at Regulation 2 of the 2014 Regulations.

28. In these proceedings, the Respondent bears the burden of persuading the tribunal that at the time of the hearing, the Respondent is not, and has not been, for a continuous period of 12 months, carrying on the regulated activity, and that it is reasonable and proportionate to cancel registration. The tribunal must be satisfied of any facts on the balance of probabilities. The tribunal is required to determine the matter afresh and make its own decision on the merits and evidence as of the date of hearing. Subject only to relevance and fairness, this can include new information that was not available or presented at the time when the decision under appeal was made. The fresh determination in this appeal includes consideration of the detailed documentary evidence provided by both parties, as well as oral evidence, subject to questioning over the one-day hearing.

29. The tribunal has considered all of the evidence and written submissions before it, even if not every part of it is mentioned in our decision. We refer only to those parts which were of particular importance in reaching our findings.

Issues

30. The key question for the tribunal was whether, as of today, the decision to cancel the Appellant’s registration should be confirmed or directed to cease to have effect. In determining that, it was necessary for the tribunal to consider firstly whether the grounds for cancellation were made out today, namely whether the Appellant had not for a continuous period of 12 months been carrying on the regulated activity of personal care. It was then necessary for the tribunal to consider secondly, whether cancellation of registration was reasonable and proportionate in all the circumstances of the case.

Position of the parties

31. The Appellant’s position was that:

a. Loyal Support Limited had not carried on the regulated activity of ‘personal care’ since registration on 16 May 2024, and that the 12-month condition in Regulation 6(1)(c) of the 2009 Regulations was satisfied.

b. Loyal Support Limited had nonetheless maintained its readiness to commence the regulated activity of ‘personal care’ by retaining a Registered Manager. Also, that it had made concerted efforts to establish and develop the service including:

i. development of governance and care documentation;

ii. recruiting and assessing prospective staff;

iii. seeking commissioning and private client opportunities; and

iv. developing a working arrangement with Majestic Social Housing Limited.

c. Dormancy of a regulated activity should not automatically be equated with abandonment or inactivity of the provider. The Appellant contended that subsequent to the decision to cancel registration, there was further activity including:

i. Contact with First City Nursing Limited and work connected with its subcontractor qualification process;

ii. Recruitment agency enquiries;

iii. Local Authority tendering activity;

iv. Further business enquiries; and

v. An application related to a Birmingham location and supported living.

d. The Appellant accepted that these activities did not amount to an executed contract, the award of any tender, or approval of a new CQC application. Rather, the Appellant suggested they were relevant as evidence of continuing efforts and potential routes towards future work.

e. The Appellant set out significant adverse health issues Mr Frimpong experienced and contended that these significantly impacted the pace at which business and regulatory matters could be managed.

f. The Appellant asked the tribunal to consider the proportionality of the decision to cancel and to direct that the Notice of Decision is not to have effect.

32. Opposing the appeal, the Respondent’s position was that:

a. The Appellant positively confirmed in emails between 20 August 2024 and 19 September 2025, in their evidence and at the Telephone Case Management Hearing that the Regulated Activity was not being carried on from the Location since registering with the Respondent.

b. There was no evidence by the Appellant’s witnesses that the Appellant is or imminently will be carrying on the regulated activity, at or from the Location.

c. The Appellant had been dormant for 879 days, which far exceeds the 12 months specified in Regulation 6 of the 2009 Regulations.

d. If the Appeal is dismissed and the Appellant’s registration is cancelled, the Appellant retains the option of re-applying to be registered for the regulated activity.

e. The Respondent submitted that the Notice of Decision of 01 December 2025 was both reasonable and proportionate and invited the Tribunal to dismiss the appeal.

Evidence

33. The tribunal considered all the evidence presented in the hearing bundle and in oral evidence during the hearing. It is not necessary to recite this here bearing in mind that the hearing was recorded. The evidence is referred to only as required to articulate the tribunal’s reasons.

The tribunal’s conclusions and reasons

34. For the reasons set out below, the tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the registration of Loyal Support Solutions Limited pursuant to Regulation 6(1)(c) of the 2009 regulations shall be confirmed.

35. There was no dispute that since initial registration on 16 May 2024, Loyal Support Limited has not carried on the regulated activity of personal care at all. The tribunal understood and was sympathetic to the challenges faced by the Appellant. The tribunal accepted the efforts evidenced by Mr and Mrs Frimpong to show that Loyal Support Limited has actively sought care packages through Swindon Borough Council as well as pursuing private referrals. Regrettably, those efforts have all thus far been unsuccessful in that they have not resulted in the delivery by the Appellant of the regulated activity of personal care, nor is this imminently expected. The tribunal was therefore satisfied that the grounds for cancellation were made out, namely that the Appellant had not for a continuous period of 12 months been carrying on the regulated activity of personal care.

36. The tribunal then proceeded to consider whether cancellation of Loyal Support Limited’s registration was reasonable and proportionate in all the circumstances of the case. The tribunal noted that there were no concerns raised about operational readiness or capability in this case, nor has any personal care been provided to give rise to any concerns about the standard of care given. The issue is limited to dormancy (in the sense of non-delivery of the regulated activity), noting that 879 days (around 29 months) have passed since the Appellant’s initial registration without the provision of the regulated activity of personal care.

37. The tribunal was mindful of the CQC’s main statutory objective to protect and promote the health, safety and welfare of people using health and social care services, and its obligation under the 2009 Regulations to establish and maintain a register containing necessary information to keep the public informed about the identity of registered persons and their carrying on of regulated activities. Further, under Section 17(1)(e) of the Act, and Regulation 6(1)(c) of the 2009 Regulations, that the CQC is entitled to cancel a service provider’s registration where the regulated activity has not been provided for a continuous period of 12 months ending with the date of the decision to cancel registration. The tribunal considered that this conveyed a clear legislative intention that the register should be accurate and up to date to reflect current service providers.

38. The tribunal accepted Mrs Shoemark’s evidence about the importance of keeping an accurate and up-to-date register to protect patients and to enable the public to make informed choices about where to receive care, thereby upholding public confidence in the system and the regulator. This was not challenged by the Appellant.

39. The tribunal further considered Mr Frimpong’s submission that cancellation was disproportionate where the service provider was operationally ready with a registered manager and governance policies in place, staff recruited, and active pursuance of business opportunities. The Appellant produced evidence to show it had entered into a business partnership with Majestic Housing Limited and had applied to become a subcontractor with First City Nursing. However, there was nothing to demonstrate that the regulated activity of personal care would be carried on against a clear and imminent timetable. The tribunal concluded there was no evidence to indicate any real likelihood that the Appellant would be delivering the regulated activity of personal care imminently.

40. The tribunal also considered Mr Frimpong’s submission that cancellation was disproportionate in the light of his health difficulties from April 2025 to now, noting that he received a cancer diagnosis in June 2025. The tribunal was pleased to hear that Mr Frimpong is recovering well after a prolonged period of medical treatment ending in July 2026. The tribunal weighed Mr Frimpong’s submissions against the Respondent’s response that allowance was made for this by staying these proceedings between January and May 2026, effectively allowing the Appellant an additional 5 months during which time Mr Frimpong has been able to undertake some work for the business. The tribunal noted that this has led to the position today in which the Appellant has now not delivered the regulated activity of personal care for around 29 months, well in excess of the 12 months from registration allowed in the legislation.

41. As part of its assessment of proportionality, the tribunal considered whether there were any conditions it could formulate as an alternative to cancellation. The tribunal was unable to formulate conditions which would be an appropriate response to the ongoing issue of a service provider which is not providing the regulated activity.

42. Finally, the tribunal also considered it relevant to proportionality that the service provider can apply again for registration when it is in a position to carry on the regulated activity.

43. In all these circumstances, the tribunal was satisfied on balance that the decision to cancel the Appellant’s registration was both reasonable and proportionate and should therefore be upheld.

Decision

44. The appeal is dismissed.

45. The CQC’s decision of 14 October 2025 is upheld.

Judge J Appleton

Care Standards & Primary Health Lists Tribunal

First-tier Tribunal (Health, Education and Social Care)

21 October 2026

For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our administrative lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.