Miscellaneous United Kingdom
NHS South West London ICB v RFA & Ors
| Judgment Approved by the court for handing down |
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWCOP 59 (T3)
Case No: COP1384909T
COURT OF PROTECTION
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Date: 06/11/2026
Before:
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE MCKENDRICK
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Between:
| NHS SOUTH WEST LONDON ICB | Applicant | |
| – and – | ||
| (1) RFA (by her litigation friend the Official Solicitor) (2) THE ROYAL HOSPITAL FOR NEURO-DISABILITY (3) CZ |
Respondents |
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Ms Ariana Kelly (instructed by Hill Dickinson LLP) for the Applicant
Ms Nicola Kohn (instructed by the Official Solicitor) for the First Respondent
Ms Katie Scott (instructed by Bevan Brittan LLP) for the Second Respondent
Mr Ian Brownhill (instructed by Scott-Moncrieff & Associates Ltd for the Third Respondent
Hearing date: 4 November 2026
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Approved Judgment
This judgment was handed down remotely at 14.00 on 6 November 2026 by circulation to the parties or their representatives by e-mail and by release to the National Archives.
………………………..
This judgment was delivered in public, but a transparency order is in force. The judge has given leave for this version of the judgment to be published on condition that (irrespective of what is contained in the judgment) in any published version of the judgment the anonymity of the first respondent and members of her family must be strictly preserved. All persons, including representatives of the media and legal bloggers, must ensure that this condition is strictly complied with. Failure to do so may be a contempt of court.
McKendrick J:
Introduction
1. This judgment is concerned with whether Clinically Assisted Nutrition and Hydration (hereafter “CANH”) is in the best interests of a profoundly disabled sixty year old woman. She is anonymised in this judgment as ‘RFA’ to protect her private and confidential information. The Applicant is the statutory body responsible for funding her care and treatment. The applicant does not prescribe CANH. RFA lives in a specialist nursing facility managed by the Second Respondent (“the RHN”). CZ is her husband. RFA’s CANH is prescribed by her GP, who is not a party to this application.
2. I heard this matter for a pre-trial review on 19 October 2026. Up until that hearing RFA’s sister, BL, was a party to these proceedings as the Fourth Respondent. BL is of the opinion that it is in RFA’s best interests that CANH should be withdrawn and her sister should receive end-of-life palliative care. BL has filed two witness statements in these proceedings setting out her views on her sister’s best interests. BL filed a form COP9 dated 15 October 2026 in which she sought a direction to be discharged as a party because party status has negatively impacted her mental health. No party opposed her application. I discharged her as a party. Her COP9 form stated: “I do not intend to file and further evidence or make further submissions and therefore respectfully seek an order discharging me as a party. I ask that the evidence already filed on my behalf remains before the Court for consideration”
3. At the pre-trial review there was some discussion as to whether I should make a final order there and then or have some form of further hearing or provide a written judgment without a further hearing. A written judgment was encouraged given concerns about future developments and likely reviews. Given the limited time available to read the 730-page bundle for the pre-trial review and in the light of both the gravity of the decision and the different opinions of RFA’s close family members, I was not prepared to simply agree with the remaining parties and make a final order without proper consideration of the evidence. However, noting that there was no longer a party advocating for the withdrawal of CANH, I reduced the time estimate for the hearing, listed by order of the Vice President, Theis J, from three days to half a day.
4. At the final hearing the positions of the parties were as follows. The applicant ICB takes a neutral position on whether it is in RFA’s best interests to continue to receive CANH. The Official Solicitor, as litigation friend to RFA, considers that CANH should continue. The RHN takes a neutral position on whether it is in RFA’s best interests to continue to receive CANH. CZ, RFA’s husband, considers that CANH should continue.
5. I note and repeat that RFA’s sister, BL, no longer a party, has asked that the court take her evidence into consideration in making the decision. BL considers that RFA would not have wished for CANH to continue.
6. Given this background, I heard short submissions from the parties on 4 November 2026. I formed the view it was disproportionate and unnecessary to hear any oral evidence. I have concluded that it is in RFA’s best interests to continue to receive CANH. In the light of the position between the parties to this application, my reasons, set out below, are more succinct than they would have been in the context of a contested application. Nonetheless, given the importance of these life and death issues; the importance of transparency; and the public interest in these issues, this judgment explains the court’s conclusions, made on behalf of RFA.
Background
7. The applicant ICB issued its COP 1 application on 5 June 2026. The application form noted RFA’s husband and sister disagreed as to whether or not continued CANH was in RFA’s best interests and “the clinical teams consider the issue is finely balanced and seek the court’s determination of the same.” Theis J made directions for further evidence from Professor Derick Wade to be filed by the Applicant ICB on 7 July 2026. She further directed that an expert witness be appointed and report on RFA’s best interests. Dr Ajoy Nair was instructed by the Official Solicitor.
8. RFA is 60. Before her illness she worked in the music industry. She is a Grade 8 pianist for whom music is a lifelong passion. RFA’s friends and family describe her as a creative, intelligent, kind and thoughtful person. They note she is devoted to her family. The written evidence of RFA’s sister, BL tells me that RFA enjoyed ‘eating and cooking food, going to galleries to look at art, going swimming, singing and playing the piano, seeing musical theatre, browsing in shops, going for walks in nature, being by the sea, visiting European cities and experiencing different languages and cultures, watching thrillers/crime drama on TV, chatting and laughing with friends and family, eating chocolate and drinking endless cups of Earl Grey tea.’
9. Neither her friends nor her family consider that RFA had religious beliefs which would have been likely to influence her views on treatment.
10. RFA married CZ in 2003, and her family life centred on their daughter, who is grown up and attends university. RFA continues in addition to have contact with her mother, sister and brother.
11. RFA was diagnosed with ‘relapsing and remitting multiple sclerosis’. Medical records suggest it was asymptomatic. In April 2021, RFA received a Covid-19 vaccination, subsequent to which she developed Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis. This is a rare autoimmune demyelinating disorder of the central nervous system, which led to RFA suffering a severe brain injury. RFA has since been in a prolonged disorder of consciousness, with a permanent tracheostomy and all nutrition and hydration by gastrostomy ever since.
12. Following a period as an inpatient at an acute hospital, RFA was discharged and, in August 2021, admitted to the RHN’s hospital. In November 2021, RFA was discharged from the RHN’s Brain Injury Service and transferred to a specialist nursing home, which is managed by them. RFA was unable to return home due to her complex care needs. RFA receives NHS Continuing Healthcare in line with the Applicant’s statutory duties. It emerged at the final hearing – it not being clear in the written evidence – that CANH is prescribed to RFA by her General Practitioner. I queried why he is not a party. I was informed the GP will be bound by my decision and follow it. I will briefly return to this issue below.
13. The tests of RFA’s awareness are summarised in the first witness statement of Ms A, who is the clinical lead for speech and language therapy at the Second Respondent. RFA has had some responses to stimuli, and has been noted to track people with her eyes (showing a preference for faces, seeking out and maintaining eye contact for periods). RFA’s family have reported additional behaviours (including appropriate but inconsistent laughing and crying) but these have not been observed during formal testing; ward staff have indicated that they have seen RFA smiling appropriately occasionally. Ms A notes that there has been some variation in RFA’s presentation during different tests, including some higher-level behaviours (including bringing a spoon to her mouth, tapping a switch, opening a lid or smiling appropriately). However, Ms A writes that that these behaviours were not considered to be consistent or reproducible. Assessments in June 2026 recorded that RFA was in a Minimally Conscious (“MCS”) Plus state.
RFA’s Current Situation
14. RFA lives in a specialist nursing home where her husband, CZ, visits her almost daily and regularly takes her off the ward to go to concerts, church services, cafés and the garden. RFA’s daughter visits regularly, and other family (including RFA’s sister, mother and brother) visit on occasion.
15. RFA is diagnosed with suspected multiple sclerosis, tracheomalacia (a floppy airway), fibrous ankylosis and changes in her temporomandibular joint in her jaw (which leads to restricted jaw movements)
16. RFA’s GP describes RFA as clinically stable, “by this I mean that she does not experience a great degree of variability in her health. For instance, she is not frequently unwell with infections. She is, however, medically complex and her relative stability is due to highly skilled care from very experienced staff providing continuous care to RFA. Her presentation is complex and her care needs are high…”.
17. In August 2026, RFA was admitted to an acute hospital following seizures. It is anticipated that this was associated with a reduction in Levetiracetam – an anti-epileptic medication.
18. Ms A describes RFA’s physical presentation in her evidence. RFA ‘presents with severe physical disability. She does not have any sitting balance and postural control is limited to some ability to lift and lower her head. She presents with significantly increased muscle tone and global rigidity, and this has contributed to severe stiffness in her neck, upper and lower limbs, and positioning difficulties.’ RFA uses a tilt-in-space wheelchair, and has support with positioning at all times, which is necessary for managing pressure relief, movement of her limbs, respiratory function and digestion. RFA requires full assistance with all transfers and repositioning. RFA has an inconsistent ability to move her left hand, which Ms A considers has deteriorated over time due to stiffness and a loss of range of movement of her fingers.
19. A summary of RFA’s needs was given at the December 2025 best interests meeting:
[RFA] has global stiffness despite current medication and a DNAR escalation plan is in place.
[RFA] has chronic respiratory issues but is generally currently clinically stable.
[RFA] has a long-term tracheostomy in situ. [RFA]’s tracheostomy is likely permanent due to tracheomalacia; she has significant dynamic airway collapse and bulging of the trachea.
[RFA] has a speaking valve in situ but has not spoken since 2021. [RFA] is given nebulizers and suctioning from the mouth and tracheostomy. [RFA]’s tracheostomy is changed every 28 days.
[RFA] requires ongoing CANH. [RFA] has a PEG is situ which requires replacement soon. [RFA] cannot her open mouth and will therefore require surgery at an acute hospital for the PEG change which may not be successful, putting her under strain and stress….
[RFA] receives personal care between 4-6 times per day and receives medication 4 times per day. [RFA] sits in a wheelchair for up to 6 hours per day. [RFA] has cogwheel rigidity of the limbs. [RFA] has bilateral fabricated hand splints at nighttime.
[RFA] is doubly incontinent, and incontinence pads are used, requiring two staff to change.
[RFA] has a Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) 9 out of 15.
Prognostically, [RFA] is currently very stable however her tracheostomy and secretions, despite medications, means she is at an increased risk of aspiration or pneumonia. Prognosis is considered in years.
20. There is an agreed PEG Management and Emergency Failure Plan dated 1 September 2026 in place, as it is recognised that replacement of RFA’s PEG may be problematic. Any replacement of RFA’s PEG will require admission to the acute hospital.
21. Dr X, Consultant in Neuro-rehabilitation at the RHN, and Dr Y, GP, are in agreement about a medication review plan for RFA. RFA’s prescription for Baclofen has recently been stopped. She is currently being weaned off Sertraline. Dr X has confirmed that if, following a completed reduction of Sertraline and completion of a review period following cessation of Baclofen, her spasticity has not become worse, Dr X will attempt to reduce the next suitable medication, dependent on her clinical presentation at the time. In Ms A’s second witness statement dated 16 October 2026, she sets out a plan to undertake ongoing monitoring of RFA’s level of consciousness approximately monthly whilst RFA’s medications are being reviewed and amended, through completing 2-3 assessments in the course of a week.
The Reviews of CANH
22. The continuation of RFA’s receiving CANH has been considered on several occasions as is required by Royal College of Physicians PDOC National Clinical Guidelines dated April 2020. These reviews are as follows:
a. June 2024: There was a consensus that it was in RFA’s best interests to continue to receive CANH, as it was felt that RFA would not want to disrupt her daughter’s studies by losing her mother.
b. February 2025: RFA’s sister, BL, approached RHN to state her view that she did not consider that RFA would want to continue to receive CANH. A best interests meeting was convened in March 2025, but a consensus could not be reached due to differing views on the part of RFA’s family about her wishes and feelings.
c. December 2025: The ICB convened a further best interests meeting, which considered the options of discontinuing CANH or continuing the status quo of providing this to RFA. There was no consensus from those in attendance at the meeting as to RFA’s best interests, which focused on the views of RFA’s sister BL, and was not attended by other family members.
d. March 2026: A further meeting was held (which was attended by Dr Y and Ms D as well as representatives of the ICB and RHN). RFA’s husband and daughter were in attendance, and the meeting focused on the views of RFA’s husband and daughter, and was not attended by BL
A Summary of the Clinical and Expert Evidence
23. Evidence has been filed from three consultants in neurorehabilitation: Dr X, who is a consultant at the RHN; Professor Derick Wade, consultant in neurological rehabilitation, who was instructed by the ICB to provide a second opinion report on RFA; and Dr Ajoy Nair, consultant in rehabilitation medicine who was instructed by the Official Solicitor to offer an expert opinion on RFA’s condition and presentation.
Impact of Medication on Consciousness
24. Professor Wade filed a report on 6 August 2026. Professor Wade reserved his final opinion, as he ‘observed that [RFA] was on five drugs that might affect her level of responsiveness and consciousness, and that there were no evident benefits to be had from any of them and that they had not been reviewed or optimised. I concluded that at present she is at the lower end of the spectrum of responsiveness and consciousness. On reducing and withdrawing her medication, she might become more responsive, but she will remain without autonomy, consistent functional activities, the ability to communicate specific information, and the ability to live outside an institutional setting for the rest of her life. She may gain better social interaction. My recommendations are to hold a meeting urgently to discuss the management of the gastrostomy and to start reducing her medication.’
25. Professor Wade filed a letter dated 27 September 2026 following a review of further documents on gastrostomy management and drug reduction. Professor Wade maintained his position that the drugs were causing sedation, and that a concerted effort should be made to withdraw the drugs to determine whether they are benefitting RFA. Professor Wade did not prepare a final report, as I discharged the direction to do so at the PTR on 19 October 2026.
26. Dr Ajoy Nair’s report was filed on 25 September 2026. Dr Nair aligned himself with the views of Professor Wade, and expressed his views that RFA’s medications may be leading to sedation which is not offering clinical benefit to her.
27. Dr X has filed a witness statement addressing the issues raised by Professor Wade and Dr Nair regarding RFA’s medication and the possibility of sedation. Dr X disagrees that RFA is sedated, but has agreed that he always seeks to reduce medications where possible, whilst monitoring for rebound effects of the symptoms that the medications were prescribed for. Following consideration of Dr X’s witness statement on medications, and Dr Y’s view on medications, Dr Nair concluded that it is the clinicians at the RHN who must decide what medications to reduce and at what rate, recognising that it is not unusual for clinicians to have differing views on such issues. Dr Nair agreed that it is perfectly reasonable for Dr X and Dr Y to alter medications in a manner and at a rate that they see appropriate.
Diagnosis In Respect of Consciousness
28. Dr Nair considered RFA’s presentation and concludes that RFA is in a ‘Minimally Conscious – Plus’ state, notwithstanding that objective assessments may suggest she has only displayed behaviours consistent with MCS Minus state. Dr X agrees with this diagnosis. I note this is consistent with other specialist PDOC assessors. A speech and language therapist has filed detailed evidence of the ten CRS-R assessment completed with scores ranging from 8-13. Ten WHIM assessments were also completed showing a range of responses. Further tests with CZ were carried out in April to June 2026 which demonstrated MCS Plus was the likely diagnosis. This witness said that RFA does smile to her family on occasion. She also stated that she normally appeared settled, calm and did not present with behaviours associated with pain. It was noted that very little pain relief has been administered to RFA (Ibuprofen twice in 2026 and paracetamol not since August 2025).
Life Expectancy
29. Professor Wade considers RFA has an estimated actuarial life expectancy of about 9 years – but recognised that she could die in the near future from an overwhelming infection, or live for 15 years. Dr X considers RFA’s life expectancy is likely to be just under 10 years, because she has good medical stability and care. Dr Nair considers that RFA likely has a life expectancy of less than 5 years.
Recovery?
30. Professor Wade, Dr Nair and Dr X all opine that five years following the index event, there is not any prospect of RFA making a meaningful recovery.
Best Interests?
31. Dr Nair considered that RFA’s circumstances present finely balanced arguments for both continuation and withdrawal of CANH, but ultimately took the view that it was in her best interests for CANH to continue for the following reasons set out in his report:
Establishing Best Interest. In [RFA]’s circumstances this has been the toughest challenge. As noted in the opening statement of section 4.6 of the RCP 20205 guidance on PDOC, best interests are not restricted to medical considerations, nor do they necessarily mean the prolongation of life. It is evident from the testimony of [EK], [CZ], [AD] and [FP], that [RFA] had very strong beliefs around being present for her child. Even [BL], [RFA]’s sister, who advocates for CANH to be withdrawn, does not deny that [RFA] is able to recognise people she knows well. As I clarified to [BL], it is not the number of opinions provided for and against CANH withdrawal but the strength and clarity of their arguments that the court must put weightage on. [RFA] is aware of the presence of her daughter/husband/brother and seems to enjoy being near them.
• Positive experiences. While I accept that [RFA] has lost autonomy, that is not a strong enough reason to withdraw CANH when she has positive experiences. Lots of disabled people lose autonomy. Examples of positive experiences noted by [Ms A], other expert PDOC assessors and nurses include:
-seeing, recognising and being with her daughter, husband, brother and family.
-having an emotional response to familiar music.
-track photos of her daughter more than that of others.
-smiling appropriately (even if inconsistent) to jokes.
• Absence of Pain: Staff and family agree that [RFA] is calm and comfortable most of the time. There are observations that she does grimace and breathes faster when her hands are stretched, and splints are applied twice a day, but she settles very quickly.
• Impact of medications: In my opinion there is some uncertainty around the impact of Ropinirole, Levodopa, Sertraline and Piracetam on her awareness and ability to communicate. Even if these medications are gradually withdrawn, I do not expect a dramatic improvement in her level of awareness and interaction given the severity of brain damage evident on her scans. However, when the decision of CANH withdrawal is so irreversible, any uncertainty must be highlighted.
32. Dr Nair reflected that whilst RFA does have some positive experiences at present, that could well change over the next few months to years. ‘As her contractures get worse, positioning in bed/wheelchair and skin care become more challenging, it is possible that pain could worsen and negate any positive life experiences that [RFA] currently has, then at the [sic] point the CANH decision must be reviewed.’
33. On the ultimate question before the court, Dr Nair concludes that: “In my opinion, at present, we should continue with [RFA]’s clinically assisted nutrition and hydration for the time being. When the decision around CANH is finely balanced, the sanctity of life must be allowed to prevail.”
Evidence and Views from RFA’s Family and Friends
34. CZ and RFA’s daughter consider that it is in RFA’s best interests to continue CANH and preserve the status quo. They consider that this is in line with what RFA’s wishes would have been if she had capacity. CZ considers that she would wish to continue living, and considers that there is no evidence that RFA would wish for her life to end. He considers that she would wish to remain involved in their family life, and particularly would wish to remain a part of their daughter’s life. He does not consider that she had any particular fear or unease around medical procedures where they served a purpose (noting that RFA chose to go through IVF to have their daughter). CZ states that in the context of her suspected multiple sclerosis, ‘In 2018 [RFA] confided to me during MS meetings at [X] Hospital which I attended with her in 2018 that if the MS outcome progressed and developed further she would want to continue living life and being there for [their daughter].’
35. CZ has filed a witness statement which summarises his position:
“Since the beginning of [RFA]’s condition, I have remained closely involved in her care and welfare. I have visited her as much as I physically and practically can. My involvement has not been remote or occasional. I have been present with her over time, watched her closely, spoken to her, cared for her and observed her responses.
Over time, I have seen signs that [RFA] is aware, responsive and emotionally engaged. These signs include smiling, reacting to humour, responding to music, showing interest when I speak to her about our daughter, and demonstrating movements of her mouth and facial expression. I have also observed what I believe to be developments in her physical responses.
[RFA] has always been a determined person. She has never been someone who simply gives up. She is stubborn in the positive sense: resilient, independent and strong. She has always had a fighting spirit. That was part of the person I married and loved, and I believe that part of her remains.
[RFA]’s role as a mother has always been central to her identity. Becoming a mother was one of her lifelong dreams. She loved our daughter deeply and wanted to see her flourish through education, university and adult life. In my view, it would be contrary to [RFA]’s wishes and values to deprive her of the opportunity to continue being part of our daughter’s life.
…I do not accept that [RFA]’s current condition means that she has no meaningful awareness or quality of life. From the time I spend with her, I believe that she has comprehension and understanding. I accept that she cannot communicate in the way she once did, but I have learned to understand her new ways of communicating.
I have seen [RFA] experience joy. She smiles regularly. She greets [EK] and me with what I experience as a warm smile of recognition and love. She reacts to humour and has giggled at my jokes and impressions. These reactions are meaningful to me because I know [RFA] and I know how she used to respond.
[RFA] continues to respond to music and performance. Music has always been important to her. She still appears to enjoy listening to her favourite music and watching performances. When we play music or involve her in activities she enjoys, I see emotional responses and engagement. Particularly music that she remembers from the past can trigger reactions.
I discuss our daughter with [RFA]. When I talk to her about [EK], [RFA] listens and engages with interest. She reacts with movements of her mouth and smiles. This is particularly important because [EK] has always been central to [RFA]’s life.
[RFA] appears happy when she sees family members and can recognise and
differentiate between faces of friends and family. I have observed happiness in her eyes when she sees [EK], her brother [FP], her mother [AD] and me. I believe these responses are genuine and significant.
[RFA]’s life at RHN includes social and therapeutic activities. She attends concerts, visits home, attends church on Sundays, participates in CODA therapy classes, art lessons and private physiotherapy sessions. She is able to meet people, be present in conversations and feel included. These matters are not insignificant. They show that her life still contains human contact, stimulation, enjoyment and dignity.”
36. CZ has filed a witness statement from RFA’s daughter, who supports her father’s position. She discusses her very close relationship with her mother, and RFA’s very active role in her upbringing and education. She notes that RFA was committed to promoting her wellbeing, and that her mother was a ‘fighter.’ She does not consider that RFA had any particular opposition to medical intervention, and notes that she had many medical interventions before her brain injury that she took in her stride. She states that RFA smiles when she comes to see her, and discusses how she brings her mother photos of everything she does to keep her involved in her life. She writes that RFA is still very much a part of her life, and would wish to continue in her role as her mother.
37. BL considers that it is in RFA’s best interests to discontinue CANH and that this is what she would have wanted if she had capacity. BL prepared two witness statements. BL submitted witness statements from her daughters and RFA’s nieces which support BL’s position. BL’s evidence is that:
[RFA’s] life is entirely passive – everything is done to her and she has no capacity to do, say or choose anything. We never had direct conversations about whether we would want to be kept alive in a profoundly brain injured state – I don’t think we knew that this was something that happened to people. But as a sister who has known her all her life, I am certain that she would not want to be kept alive in the state she is in. [RFA] hated medical procedures and people looking at her body. She did not look after her own health very well and often missed appointments for smear tests, mammograms and even brain scans for her MS. For the last few years of her conscious life, she was not even registered with a local GP. She never wore clothes that showed her legs and she didn’t wear sandals in summer because she didn’t like people seeing her feet. Now her days are made up of nurses and carers doing things to her body. She would be appalled at the lack of privacy and the total loss of dignity.
When I sit in front of [RFA], I am looking for my sister but I can’t find her in the care home. I find her in my memories, in our old messages, in my journal writing, in the natural world and in my conversations with other people who knew and loved her. The day-to-day care she receives on the ward is very good. But in order to treat her with respect and dignity, and to ensure her human rights are being properly considered, there must be discussions and decisions about the quality of the life she is left with. To have [RFA] kept alive with no agency or communication is unbearable for me. But I would be able to bear it if I believed that [RFA] was having a quality of life that she would value. I don’t believe she is.
38. BL’s second witness statement emphasises BL’s experiences with RFA throughout her life, noting that RFA’s focus changed after marrying and becoming a mother. BL considers that communication and experiences were very important to RFA, and that RFA experienced being confined to her home during the pandemic as feeling ‘trapped’ and being a ‘nightmare’ – BL considers that RFA’s life is now far more restricted. BL also states that in conversations about a relative who experienced severe illness and disability at the end of their lives, she and RFA both felt that they would not wish to live in that manner, and that living in a manner which involved continuous, high levels of care and loss of autonomy would significantly compromise her dignity. BL states that while she was desperate to see improvement in RFA, she does not agree with the views of CZ that RFA is consciously moving and considers that the medical evidence does not indicate any improvement. BL disagrees with CZ’s characterisations of her relationship with RFA, and states that while they may have argued and had ups and downs, they had a lifelong bond as sisters and remained in each other’s lives. BL’s evidence is that:
“I love my sister very much and would give anything to have her back. But I know she will never come back and to keep her body alive in this way feels like an avoidance of the inevitable ending, and a prolonging of her burden. My position is not based upon what I would choose for myself, nor upon a wish to bring about [RFA]’s death. I dread her death and the grief that will follow. But my understanding is that the legal question to be asked is whether the continuation of CANH remains in [RFA]’s best interests, based on her perspective and taking into account her wishes, feelings, beliefs and values, her personality, the prognosis and her likely attitude to the burdens and benefits of treatment. I recognise the strong presumption in favour of preserving life, and the seriousness and finality of withdrawal. I have been considering all of this for most of the last five years, day and night. I have read and researched widely on the topic. My evidence, as outlined above, is that, knowing [RFA] like I do, she would not have regarded continued treatment as providing a life or outcome that she would consider worthwhile. This conclusion is based not merely on my own opinion, but on all the evidence gathered over a lifetime of knowing [RFA], observing [RFA], loving [RFA] and talking to [RFA].”
39. RFA’s mother, AD, is not a party, but has filed a witness statement. AD supports CZ’s position and considers that RFA would wish for CANH to continue; AD considers that RFA has made improvements and is showing greater engagement and emotion. AD states that RFA and BL were not close, and she does not consider that RFA would have wanted BL to be influential in this decision.
40. RFA’s brother, FP, is not a party, but has filed a witness statement. FP supports CZ’s position and considers that RFA would wish for CANH to continue; like AD, FP considers that RFA has made improvements and is showing greater engagement and emotion. FP emphasises that he does not consider that RFA would want to do anything to disrupt her daughter’s life, and considers that RFA would wish for her husband and daughter to be the central voices in making decisions in her best interests. FP has previously expressed the view in April 2025 that RFA’s current circumstances “would not be acceptable to her for long term” while acknowledging that, at the time, she would be likely to agree to continue CANH “for the sake of her daughter and rest of family”.
41. Additional views have been provided from a number of friends and family. Several of them support CANH, several oppose CANH. Each has endeavoured to give evidence of what they believe RFA would have wanted.
The Law
42. A summary of the law in this area is set out in NHS North East ICB v FHR And Others [2026] EWCOP 43 (T3) at paragraphs 25 to 43. Those are the principles I apply. In addition, the parties filed a most helpful, agreed summary of the law. I have considered that and note there were no disputes between the parties as the applicable legal context nor any dispute with the summary in FHR.
Capacity
43. There is no dispute (and no doubt) that RFA lacks capacity to make decision in respect of her medical treatment and in particular lacks capacity to consent to receive CANH. The court therefore has jurisdiction to make a best interests decision on her behalf.
CANH – Best Interests Analysis
44. I accept the evidence of the clinicians that RFA is in an MCS Plus state. She at times can express emotional responses to her family. She plainly responds to adults and tracks visiting family with her eyes. Dr Nair noted when he visited RFA with her husband and daughter, as they entered the common room where RFA was sat in her wheelchair “[RFA] immediately identified her daughter and husband and tracked them from across the room.” There is some evidence she has responded to instructions and demonstrates communicable intent, even if not always consistently. I also accept the evidence of Dr Nair and Professor Wade that careful reduction of some medication may result in greater awareness. However, I also accept the evidence that five years post index event, recovery is less likely than likely. I accept RFA appears calm and appears to enjoy being taken outdoors, and she responds to music. Dr Nair specifically noted in his report that he saw her respond to the music of Robbie Williams, which he was told was one of her favourite artists. She is aware of the presence of her husband and daughter. Importantly I also accept she is not in pain. She is very well cared for and those caring for her have administered very little pain relief over the last twelve months in circumstances where they would note behaviour associated with pain and respond to ameliorate this.
45. However, I also note that RFA is hugely dependent on others for all her needs. She is unable to talk. She requires a tracheostomy, although it is not cuffed and she has some ability to swallow and therefore whilst she requires some suctioning this is not at a more intense level. Dr Nair reported the nurse on duty when he visited RFA reported she did not require frequent suctioning. She is doubly incontinent and cannot communicate her needs in this area. She has limited physical movement but can move and use her left arm and hand. She needs to be handled for nearly all movements. She is highly dependent and very vulnerable.
46. I accept Dr Nair’s helpful summary of the benefits and burdens of CANH. He reports on the burdens:
• Total irreversible loss of autonomy as highlighted by Prof Wade.
• Episodes of skin breakdown and pressure sores.
• Progressive development of contractures in neck and limbs despite multiple medications.
• Difficulties with a PEG that is nearing its end of life.
• She is reliant on a tracheostomy that is permanent.
• There is no consistent trajectory towards improving awareness. This may be disputed by [CZ].
• She does not have a means of communicating yes or no.
47. And Dr Nair summarises the benefits as:
• [RFA] is able to discern and recognise close relatives. She has shown a clear preference to the photo of her daughter.
• Does not appear to be in pain.
• Has some positive life experiences-enjoys music, has irrefutable ability to track people, enjoys the fresh air of outdoors.
• Episodes of appropriate smiling, laughing and crying.
• Concerns that [RFA] may be on some medications that she may not really need, the removal of which may lead to changes in presentation
• PDOC category is MCS Plus and not Vegetative State or MCS Minus, though the category of PDOC in itself is not a reason to continue CANH.
• Irrefutable evidence that she would do anything for her daughter, who she conceived through IVF.
48. I accept the clear evidence that RFA’s past feelings, beliefs and values were very much focused on her family and that she delighted in the birth of her daughter after fertility issues. RFA has been blessed, and continues to be blessed at the age of sixty, to enjoy the company of her mother, her brother, her sister, her daughter and her husband and many other family members and friends. It is clear she was an active, artistic thoughtful person. I also accept furthering the welfare of her daughter was a central desire and value in her life.
49. What is more difficult to resolve is the issue of RFA’s past wishes on the subject of being kept alive in her current condition. As other judges (see Lieven J (as she then was) in NHS West and North London ICB v MP [2026] EWCOP 36) and I (NHS North East ICB v FHR [2026] EWCOP 43 (T3) at paragraph 146) have commented it is difficult to conclude on the balance of probabilities, on the basis of the evidence of family and friends, that what was historically communicated about wishing to continue to live in circumstances where P could not have reasonably contemplated their “massively diminished state.” Furthermore, the weight to be placed on such a view, even if securely identified in the evidence, may be limited. There is a huge difference between a family remembering their loved one with their full capacity being a “fighter” with being content to endure the reality of an inability to communicate yes or no whilst every need is met by paid professionals and carers.
50. I have concluded on the evidence that, at this stage, given RFA’s calm and pain free demeanour and in circumstances where she plainly responds to her family and stimuli like music and trips outdoors, it is possible to answer the essential question: “whether P could ever recover a quality of life that P personally would value.” By a fine margin, RFA still holds on to the family and art that she cherished before her disastrous reaction to the inoculation. I accept the evidence of Dr Nair. CANH is not currently futile or unduly burdensome. I agree with her husband and daughter and the powerful submission of the Official Solicitor as her litigation friend. I also reach this conclusion in circumstances where no health body has argued for the withdrawal of CANH.
51. It is also the case in a finely balanced case of this nature that ‘the sanctity of life’ emerges powerfully to fill any residual evidential doubts and uncertainties. Coming forth from this disarmingly simple phrase is the inviolable gift of life that is precious and fulfils a sacred purpose. Our awareness of life and knowledge of its inevitable end profoundly shapes our humanity. Respecting life and recognising this is not absolute is a part of what makes us human. RFA’s catastrophic brain injury was caused by her body’s reaction to the COVID-19 vaccination, a measure she took, with capacity, to protect and safeguard her life.
52. I have not fully resolved the dispute between CZ and BL. It is very difficult to do so. It is not currently necessary to do so. I am satisfied that I could not make, on the evidence available to me, a finding that RFA’s past wish would have been to actively end her life because she would have found her current condition undignified. That is not supported by the majority of the written evidence.
53. Having regard to the all the section 4 Mental Capacity Act 2005 factors I reach the conclusion that it is currently in RFA’s best interests to receive CANH.
Ancillary Issues
54. In the course of helpful exchanges with counsel a number of ancillary issues emerged in submissions.
55. The agreed order presented to me sought the following relief:
“IT IS DECLARED AND ORDERED PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 15 AND 16 MENTAL CAPACITY ACT 2005 THAT
RFA lacks capacity to:
a) conduct these proceedings; and
b) make decisions as to her medical care and treatment, including CANH.
The following are lawful, because they are in RFA’s best interests, and the court consents to them on RFA’s behalf:
a. continuing CANH;
b. the TEP;
c. the DNACPR;
d. the PEG Plan; and
e. the Agreed Review Process.”
56. There was no dispute as to the two section 15 MCA declarations in respect of capacity. I took the view that it was only appropriate to make a section 16 MCA best interests order on RFA’s behalf in respect of the continuation of CANH. The TEP is a reference to a ‘treatment escalation plan’. The PEG plan is a plan to resolve what should happen if RFA’s current PEG line (by which she receives CANH) needs to be replaced, which would involve transfer to an acute hospital for a procedure which would not involve a general anaesthetic. The DNACPR is a reference to a form setting out a decision “Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation”.
57. I can understand why it was thought helpful for the court to make best interests orders in respect of these issues, however they were not matters identified for determination in the original application and nor were they matters the subject of initial case management directions. It seemed to me I was being asked to determine the details of clinical decisions which are likely to vary depending on the circumstances. I remind myself of what was said by Peter Jackson LJ in Re A (Covert Medication) [2024] EWCA Civ 572 at paragraph 90: “….the Court of Protection exists to make decisions about whether a particular decision or action is in the best interests of the individual. It is not a supervisory court…”
58. Furthermore, the DNACPR is a clinical matter for doctors in respect of which patients and in some circumstances their families should be consulted. It is not a best interests matter for the court and I do not understand the decision in Townsend v Epson and St Helier University Hospital NHS Trust [2026] EWCA Civ 195 to change that, notwithstanding the fact that placing of a DNACPR in a patient’s medical records is a clinical decision. A DNACPR can be made by a doctor without the agreement of a capacitous patient. Lady Hale held at paragraph 18 of Aintree University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v James [2013] UKSC 67; [2014] 1 AC 591that: “On an application under this Act, therefore, the court has no greater powers than the patient would have if he were of full capacity.” The making of a DNACPR does not require the patient’s consent, although they must be told and a patient who is in disagreement can seek a review and a second opinion. The fact that a DNACPR has been made for a patient who lacks capacity does not mean that such a clinical decision becomes a best interests matter for the Court of Protection. It is a clinical decision of a very different complexion from the CANH decision this court was required to make for RFA.
59. For these reasons I declined to make any section 16 MCA orders in respect of treatment escalation, PEG line replacement or DNACPR. The role of the Court of Protection is not to supervise the healthcare of a patient who happens to be the subject of an application for specific relief. I have determined the particular decision which led to these proceedings being issued. It is not my role to go further.
60. Furthermore, I do not agree with the submissions of Ms Scott and Mr Brownhill that the content of the “Agreed Review Process” and issues in respect of when any further review of whether or not CANH is in RFA’s best interests, is a best interests matter for this court, and can therefore be the subject of a section 16 MCA order determining RFA’s best interests and thereby providing this court’s consent to the review taking place.
61. The Royal College of Physicians PDOC National Clinical Guidelines at page 61 notes:
“Formal clinical re-evaluation for the purposes of treatment planning and best interests decision-making, should be undertaken at 6 and 12 months post-injury and annually thereafter until the patient either dies or emerges from PDOC.”
62. This is of course guidance from clinicians for clinicians. It is not a rule. When and how the issue of whether it remains in RFA’s best interests to receive CANH is a matter for her General Practitioner. He is the medical professional who writes the prescription for her. If he considers CANH is no longer in RFA’s best interests then he must make that determination. If a person with interest disagreed, then the matter may return to court. If the GP makes the contrary assessment on a review, and a person with interest disagrees then they may apply to restore the matter to court. The Court will need to grant permission in all likelihood pursuant to section 50 MCA, which states:
“No permission is required for an application to the court for the exercise of any of its powers under this Act—
(a)by a person who lacks, or is alleged to lack, capacity,
(b)if such a person has not reached 18, by anyone with parental responsibility for him,
(c)by the donor or a donee of a lasting power of attorney to which the application relates,
(d)by a deputy appointed by the court for a person to whom the application relates, or
(e)by a person named in an existing order of the court, if the application relates to the order.”
63. Mr Brownhill’s client is fearful that BL will disagree in twelve months time. Should CANH remain in RFA’s best interests as determined by her GP and should BL disagree and wish for the Court of Protection to make a determination on this issue, she will be required to seek permission pursuant to section 50 MCA. I do not consider she can rely on section 50(1)(e) because she was a party and has been named in previous orders in these proceedings. Any such application would not relate in a meaningful sense to earlier orders made in these proceedings in which BL is named. I interpret section 50(1)(e) to essentially be a liberty to apply provision. Any fresh determination of RFA’s best interests would not relate to orders made in these proceedings. The application would relate to RFA’s best interests at the time of the application. If an application is made to court it can be assessed to consider whether there has been a relevant change of circumstances as set out by Poole J in AF [2020] EWCOP 55 at paragraph 22 (c) (a case itself about inserting a fresh PEG some time after another judge had determined CANH was in the patient’s best interests):
“Where there has been no material change of circumstances subsequent to a previous judgment, no new evidence that calls for a re-opening of the earlier findings, and the earlier evaluation of best interests clearly covers the decision that the new court is being asked to consider, appropriate case management might involve the court summarily determining the new application.”
64. This may lead to the court refusing permission pursuant to section 50 MCA. It may lead to the court granting permission and adopting a summary process to determine any relevant change of circumstances. Unreasonable actions may incur costs consequences.
65. Mr Brownhill sought to argue that RFA would not want her daughter’s university education disrupted. He submitted this court should make a best interests order pursuant to section 16 MCA that the next review of whether CANH is or is not in RFA’s best interests should not take place earlier than the summer of 2029, when RFA’s daughter finishes her university studies. It was said this was a belief or value RFA held in the past.
66. First, I do not accept timing of any such review is itself a best interests matter. It is an administrative matter for RF’s GP having regard to her best interests. RFA, if she had capacity, could not dictate when medical reviews would take place. The timing, for example, of an NHS continuing healthcare assessment is not a best interests matter. Nor is it a decision appropriate to be dictated by reference to the section 4 MCA factors. P does not make the decision about the review and its timing. It cannot be said to be a decision “on P’s behalf in relation to the matter” (to borrow the language of section 16 (2)) notwithstanding the fact it is a decision about P’s best interests. To further illustrate the point, a deputy could not be appointed to make the decision about the timing of the CANH review or P’s behalf – see s. 16(2)(b), which is a useful manner of checking whether the decision is one that can be the subject of a section 16 order.
67. Furthermore, and in any event, I could not accede to Mr Brownhill’s submissions and order that the next review would be in 2029 to accommodate RFA’s daughter’s university studies in RFA’s best interests. Plainly section 4(1)(c) can accommodate altruistic gesture or beliefs by P, see Re G (TJ) [2010] EWHC 3002 (COP) at paragraph 56. I do not accept RFA held a past belief so specific when she had capacity prior to 2021. Nor am I able to infer from her past deeply held family values and evident love and joy for her daughter, that what is proposed is a concrete past wish or value or belief. Even if this could be properly evidenced, it would be difficult to subvert P’s autonomy and dignity to require CANH to be continued to permit her daughter uninterrupted studies. Past wishes and feelings are relevant but the court cannot lose sight of its role to focus on P and their wider best interests.
68. I also disagree that I can make a case management decision within these proceedings in respect of when a future CANH review takes place for RFA. A case management decision is directed at the parties and must relate to the fair determination of the issues in these proceedings. The GP is not a party and nor should case management decision determine future administrative decisions out with these proceedings.
69. I note the Applicant and the RHN adopted neutral positions on the issue of whether CANH was in RFA’s best interests. As I have said, the GP prescribes CANH. He must form a view. I have not heard full argument on the subject but it strikes me that this court will be more assisted by receiving submissions from a medical person/body who requires to face and take the (often difficult) decision (see for example the decision of Mostyn J in A CCG v AF And Others [2020] EWCOP 16 where the GP took a clear position on the role of CANH). That would focus the evidence and arguments. It also strikes me that having two public bodies as parties when they are both neutral is not a good use of public money.
70. I wish RFA and her family well.
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our medical negligence lawyer.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).