Administrative United Kingdom

Northgate Healthcare Holdings Limited v The Environment Agency

Official source

NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01493 (GRC)

Case Reference: FT/EV/2025/0078

First-tier Tribunal

General Regulatory Chamber

Environment

Heard remotely by video conference

Heard on: 21 September 2026

Decision given on: 29 October 2026

Before

TRIBUNAL JUDGE WILSON

TRIBUNAL MEMBER PENDRY

Between

NORTHGATE HEALTHCARE HOLDINGS LIMITED

Appellant

and

THE ENVIRONMENT AGENCY

Respondent

Decision: The appeal is allowed.

Substituted Decision Notice: The Civil Penalty Notice is varied, and a substituted Civil Penalty Notice is to be issued against the appellant in the amount of £4,000, payable within 6 weeks of the date of issue of the revised Civil Penalty Notice.

REASONS

Representation

1. The appellant represented itself through Mr Hartles. The Respondent was represented by Mr Dale-Harris (Counsel).

Background

2. The appellant appeals against the notice of a civil penalty, reference ESOS-ENF-3-2444 dated 28 April 2025 issued pursuant to regulation 39 of the Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme Regulations 2014 ("the ESOS Regulations"). The civil penalty was imposed in the amount of £10,260 in respect of the appellant's failure to undertake an ESOS assessment and report the ESOS assessment in accordance with Part 4 and Part 5 of the ESOS Regulations by 17 January 2025.

3. The ESOS Regulations were promulgated to transpose Articles 8(4)-(6) of the EU Energy Efficiency Directive (2012/27/EU) which required Member States to introduce mandatory energy efficiency audits for all "large enterprises". As set out in the Explanatory Memorandum to the ESOS Regulations, the aim is to drive improvements in energy efficiency in Member States, to meet the EU’s (then extant) targets of a 20% reduction in primary energy consumption by 2020 as against a 2007 business as usual projection baseline.

4. The appellant is a parent company which holds subsidiary companies. The group provides residential and care homes.

5. The following is a chronology of events according to the respondent. We note at this stage that some of these matters are not accepted by the appellant, and we return to them below.

6. The respondent asserts that it sent an initial letter (an awareness letter) to the appellant on 14 December 2023 to make it aware of the Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme ("ESOS") and the actions required to ensure compliance. The letter gave a date for compliance of 5 June 2024. The respondent asserts that a second awareness letter was sent on 29 May 2024 this gave a date for compliance of 6 August 2024. A third awareness letter was sent on 26 July 2024.

7. The deadline for compliance passed on 6 August 2024 and it is accepted that the appellant did not comply. The respondent asserts that on 11 September 2024 it sent a Compliance Notice to the appellant giving a deadline for compliance of 25 September 2024.

8. On 17 September 2024 Mr Hartles wrote to the EA confirming that the appellant qualifies as a large business for the purposes of the ESOS Regulations due to its employee numbers, but indicating it had not been contacted previously about the scheme. He asked for a portal, but indicated the deadline of 25 September 2024 “might be unrealistic”

9. On 27 September 2024 the EA’s enforcement, team, wrote to Mr Hartles confirming that letters had been sent on 14 December 2023 and 02 August 2024, providing a link to the ESOS Guidance and asking for him to register the organisation on the ESOS reporting system MESOS “early next week if possible”. The correspondence warned that Enforcement Notices would be sent out in due course “which will allow you 3 months to conduct ESOS activity and submit a compliance notification”.

10. On 14 October the ESOS Enforcement team wrote to Mr Hartles providing a link to Section 4 of the ESOS Guidance, and asking that an organisation account in the ESOS Reporting System, MESOS, be created by 18 October. Mr Hartles emailed the following day to confirm that he had set up the portal and had “been in contact with” a lead assessor.

11. The respondent asserts that an enforcement notice was issued to the appellant on 17 October 2024 with a deadline for compliance of 17 January 2025. The appellant accepts receipt of the enforcement notice and accepts that it did not complyby 17 January 2025.

12. On 24 January 2025 a Regulatory Compliance Officer wrote to the appellant regarding the notice provided in October 2024 referred to a deadline of 30 January 2025 and requested a response if there were any difficulties in meeting the 30 January 2025 deadline.

13. The appellant responded on 31 January confirming that no further progress had been made. The quote from the lead assessor received in November was “too expensive at a cost of over £9000”, the appellant was awaiting two further quotes and that the notice of intent was expected.

14. On 13 February 2025 the respondent issued a Notice of Intent to Impose a Civil Penalty under regs. 45-46 of the ESOS Regulations. The respondent accepts that this notice erroneously referred to an energy audit deadline of 6 August 2025 rather than 6 August 2024. The Notice of Intent included links to the Enforcement and Sanctions Policy and asked that any further information that the appellant considered relevant should be submitted by 13 March 2025.

15. On 21 February 2025 the appellant informed the respondent that a lead assessor had been appointed and that work was being undertaken to secure compliance.

16. On 4 March 2025 the appellant provided written representations in mitigation in response to the Notice of Intent.

17. An ESOS report was completed on 25 March 2025. This was submitted to the respondent on 1 April 2025.

18. The civil penalty notice which is the subject of this appeal was issued on 28 April 2025.

The Respondent's Decision

19. The Civil Penalty Notice imposed a penalty of £10,260 because the appellant had failed to carry out an ESOS assessment and report the ESOS assessment in accordance with Part 4 and Part 5 of the ESOS Regulations by 17 January 2025. The notice recorded that under regulation 45 of the ESOS Regulation the following financial penalties may be imposed for failing to undertake an energy audit:

• An initial penalty of up to £50,000; and

• A further penalty of up to £40,000 comprising £500 for each working day starting on the day after the service of the compliance notice, subject to a maximum of 80 working days.

20. It was noted that the appellant had failed to comply with the extended compliance deadline of 6 August 2024 and had failed to comply with the Enforcement Notice requiring compliance by 17 January 2025. The respondent recorded that it had applied the approach set out in its Enforcement and sanctions policy (ESP) The respondent produced a table that summarised the four-step approach that it adopted to set the penalty. That table is set out below.

Step 1 Check or determine statutory maximum for the breach Statutory maximum – £90,000
A notification of compliance was not submitted. The maximum penalty that the organisation is liable to is £90,000 (£50,000 + £40,000 [£500 x over 80 days after service of Compliance Notice])
Step 2 Decide whether to waive the penalty or set the initial penalty amount by assessing the nature of the breach and other enforcement positions in line with Section D Initial penalty amount – £45,000
(£5000 – reduction due to your new entrant status, plus the daily penalty £40,000, totalling £45,000)
Step 3 Work out penalty starting point and penalty range Culpability category – Negligent
This means failure by the organisation as a whole to take reasonable care to put in place and enforce proper systems for avoiding commission of the offence.
Size of the organisation – Medium
Latest registered accounts from October 2024 state Turnover of £11,651,744
Penalty starting point – £5,400
Penalty range – £2,475 – £13,500
Step 4 Set final penalty amount by assessing the aggravating and mitigating factors Final penalty amount – £10,260

21. In giving reasons for its decision, the respondent stated as follows:

The most relevant factors in reaching this decision are as follows:

We have assessed the ‘nature of the breach’ in line with Section D2.3 of the Enforcement and Sanctions Policy. Failure to undertake an energy audit undermines the integrity of the scheme as it is a key requirement of the ESOS Regulations. We do not think it is appropriate to waive the penalty.

We consider you to be a new entrant to the scheme. We have therefore reduced the financial penalty set out in regulation 45(2)(a)(i) to £5000

We consider that a penalty, including the daily penalty, is necessary to mark the breach and encourage future timely compliance.

In assessing the size of your organisation, you are a medium organisation, based on the turnover of £11,651,744 in your annual report and financial statements for year ended December 2023.

In assessing the culpability category, we consider that your culpability category is Negligent, due to the failure by the organisation as a whole to take reasonable care to put in place and enforce proper systems for avoiding commission of the breach. The statutory compliance deadline was 05 June 2024.

22. The respondent then listed aggravating and mitigating factors which we consider in further detail below. Having considered the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors, the respondent set the financial penalty at £10,260.

The law

23. Part 4 of the ESOS Regulations creates an obligation on responsible undertakings to carry out ESOS assessments (regulation 20) for which at least one lead assessor must be appointed (regulation 21(1)(a)). Part 4 sets out what is required of an ESOS assessment and provides that a responsible undertaking must produce an ESOS report.

24. Part 5 of the ESOS Regulations sets out notification and confirmation requirements for ESOS assessments. Regulation 29 provides that a responsible undertaking must notify the scheme administrator using the Notification System whether the participant has complied with Part 4 by providing certain information. Regulation 30 provides that a participant must appoint one or more responsible officers in relation to an ESOS assessment and gives a definition of "responsible officer". Regulation 31 sets out what the responsible officer must confirm in the notification required by regulation 29.

25. Part 7 makes provisions relating to compliance and enforcement. Regulation 35 provides that the respondent may issue a compliance notice where it requires information to monitor compliance and makes provision about compliance notices. Regulation 37 provides that a responsible undertaking must notify the scheme administrator if it becomes aware that it is in breach of any requirement of the ESOS Regulations. Regulation 38 provides that the respondent may serve an enforcement notice on any responsible undertaking it reasonably believes has failed to comply with a requirement of the ESOS Regulations. It also makes provision for the content, format and service of an enforcement notice.

26. Part 8 makes provision relating to civil penalties and breaches. Regulation 39 provides that where the respondent is satisfied that the responsible undertaking is liable to a civil penalty, it may serve a penalty notice imposing the penalties and other requirements set out in Part 8. Regulation 39 makes provision for the content, format and service of the penalty notice. Chapter 2 of Part 8 sets out the breaches of the Regulations in respect of which liability to a civil penalty arises and the amounts of the penalties. Pursuant to regulation 42, the respondent has discretion to waive a civil penalty, impose a lower financial penalty, or modify the application of a publication penalty.

27. Part 9 makes provision for an appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. Regulation 48(1) provides that there are three grounds of appeal: (i) that the enforcement or penalty notice was based on an error of fact; (ii) that it was wrong in law; or (iii) that it was unreasonable. Regulation 49 provides that the effect of the enforcement notice or penalty notice is suspended pending the determination of an appeal. Regulation 50 sets out what the First-tier Tribunal may do when determining an appeal. It may cancel the penalty notice; affirm the penalty notice, either in its original form or subject to modification; or instruct the respondent to do anything that is within the respondent's power to do.

28. In addition to the ESOS Regulations, the Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme Guidance ("the ESOS Guidance"); the Comply with the Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme Phase 3 Guidance ("the Phase 3 Guidance"); and the respondent's Enforcement and Sanctions Policy ("the ESP") are relevant. The ESP is particularly relevant, as it sets out the stepped approach the respondent takes when deciding whether to impose a civil penalty and in assessing the amount. Annex 2 to the ESP gives guidance on how to set the penalty (Section A) and gives guidance in relation to ESOS specifically (Section D).

29. Regulation 51 of the ESOS Regulations makes provision regarding the service of documents. It provides that any determination or notice required to be served on a responsible undertaking may be served by delivering or sending it to or leaving it at the responsible undertaking's registered office.

30. Section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 applies to notices served pursuant to the ESOS Regulations and provides that where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post, then, unless the contrary intention appears, service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing the document and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would have been delivered in the ordinary course of post.

The Appellant's Case

31. The appellant contends that the respondent's decision to impose a Civil Penalty Notice was inconsistent with the ESP. Essentially the argument is that the Civil Penalty Notice was wrong in law as the Respondent had failed to apply the ESP when issuing the Civil Penalty Notice. The Appellant submits that the rationale for enforcement action was to preserve the integrity of the scheme which is not listed as a consideration under the ESP. The appellant submits that this was not a case involving factors identified in the ESP such as environmental harm, unlawful activity, deliberate avoidance of regulatory obligations or any deliberate attempt to obtain financial advantage through non-compliance. The appellant relies upon the fact that it achieved compliance voluntarily, it undertook the required assessment, submitted a notification of compliance and incurred the costs associated with compliance before the Civil Penalty Notice was issued. The appellant submits that, in those circumstances, the objectives of the ESOS regime had effectively been achieved and that the imposition of a substantial financial penalty was inconsistent with the principles which underpin the ESP. For the same reasons, in the alternative, the appellant asserts that amount of the penalty is unreasonable and should be reduced.

32. The appellant accepts that it did not comply with the ESOS Regulations by the extended compliance deadline of 6 August 2024 and accepts that it did not comply with the Enforcement Notice requiring compliance by 17 January 2025. The appellant disputes receipt of the awareness letters and certain earlier correspondence relied upon by the respondent. The appellant's case is that in addition to the factors identified above there are a number of additional mitigating factors that should result in a reduction of the penalty. The appellant asserts that it did not become aware of its ESOS obligations until August/September 2024 and that thereafter it took steps to secure compliance. The appellant relies upon difficulties in securing the services of a lead assessor, the acquisition of an additional care home in October 2024, pressures associated with operating care homes for vulnerable residents and the limited administrative resources available within the business. The appellant contends that once aware of its obligations it acted in good faith, maintained communication with the respondent and undertook reasonable steps to comply. The appellant relies upon the fact that a lead assessor was eventually appointed, an ESOS assessment was completed and a notification of compliance was submitted before the Civil Penalty Notice was issued.

33. The appellant submits that the respondent's assessment of the organisation as a large undertaking did not properly reflect the nature of its business. Whilst the appellant employed in excess of 250 employees, it submits that the overwhelming majority of those employees were engaged in frontline care roles and that approximately 3 members of staff were employed at head office with an administrative function. The appellant contends that employee numbers therefore overstated the administrative resources available to identify and manage compliance obligations.

34. The appellant relies upon the errors within the respondent's correspondence and notices regarding compliance dates, for example 6 August 2025 rather than 6 August 2024. The appellant submits that regulated entities are entitled to rely upon dates contained in formal enforcement documentation. In addition, a financial penalty cannot be enforced for a deadline that had not yet passed as at the date of the Civil Penalty Notice. The discrepancy in the compliance dates amounts to an error of fact such that Civil Penalty Notice should be set aside. In the alternative, the appellant contends that the inclusion of an incorrect date within formal enforcement documentation was capable of causing confusion and should have been treated as a mitigating factor. The appellant further submits that the existence of those errors demonstrates shortcomings within the respondent's administration of the enforcement process and supports its contention that the final penalty was inconsistent with the principles of fairness and proportionality reflected in the ESP.

35. Accordingly, the appellant asserts that the Civil Penalty Notice is set aside or that the financial penalty is reduced.

The Respondent's Case

36. The respondent's written and oral submissions are summarised below.

37. It was open to the respondent to have pursued additional breaches, including failure to comply with statutory notices. However, it chose to limit its enforcement action to the appellant's failure to undertake the required assessment and failure to submit a notification of compliance. This demonstrates a proportionate approach to enforcement.

38. The appellant's submissions in relation to the application of the ESP focus upon general statements within the main body of the ESP and fail to properly engage with Annex 2. Annex 2 contains the specific provisions applicable to ESOS enforcement. Annex 2 has been correctly applied throughout. Addressing the appellant’s specific arguments:

a. the integrity of the ESOS regime is an important and legitimate enforcement objective. The integrity of the ESOS scheme is listed as an enforcement objective at Annex 2. Delayed or partial compliance undermines the effectiveness of the scheme and regulated entities must be aware that breaches will be enforced so as to avoid widespread non-compliance;

b. the absence of direct environmental harm does not undermine the validity of the Civil Penalty Notice. The purpose of the ESOS regime is preventative and that harm arises from the lost or delayed opportunity to identify and implement energy efficiency measures;

c. the breach was serious as compliance was not achieved within the prescribed time limits. The appellant was afforded repeated opportunities to comply. Parliament’s intention was for delayed compliance to be treated seriously as evidence by the daily breach penalty;

d. delayed compliance conferred a competitive advantage on those who postpone compliance. The cost of engaging a lead assessor is likely to be less when demand is lower, Timely compliance is therefore important to maintaining a level regulatory environment;

e. the appellant’s failure to comply with deadlines impacts the operation of the ESOS regime. The regulator is required to compile and publish compliance data and that delayed compliance affects the completeness of that data and the assessment of the scheme's effectiveness; and

f. eventual compliance should not be characterised as voluntary corrective action. Compliance was achieved after formal enforcement action had been. Belated compliance is not a substantial reason to refrain from enforcement.

39. The respondent rejects the appellant's assertion that compliance was achieved within time. There was never any extension of the compliance period until 6 August 2025 and that the references to that date in the Notice of Intent and Civil Penalty Notice were obvious typographical errors. The respondent notes that the appellant's own written representations submitted after receipt of the Notice of Intent did not contend that any such extension had been granted.

40. The appellant's conduct following the Enforcement Notice demonstrated that the appellant did not take its obligations under ESOS regime and related regulatory breaches seriously. In particular, the respondent relies upon the delay between the issue of the Enforcement Notice and the appellant's later attempts to secure compliance. The respondent also relies upon the delay in appointing a lead assessor. The respondent submits that the reason advanced by the appellant, namely the cost of obtaining professional assistance, was not a legitimate justification for delaying compliance with a statutory regime. The respondent notes that the appellant's accounts demonstrated sufficient financial resources to fund compliance.

41. In relation to Step 2 of the ESP methodology, the respondent’s position is that it was entitled to conclude that the penalty should not be waived. The respondent relies upon the provisions of Annex 2 of the ESP which identify compliance with the ESOS regime as fundamental to the operation and integrity of the scheme. The respondent further notes that the appellant benefited from a substantial reduction because it was treated as a new entrant to the regime, reducing the initial penalty from £50,000 to £5,000.

42. In relation to culpability, the respondent submits that its assessment of the appellant's conduct as negligent was entirely justified. The appellant is a substantial organisation with significant financial resources and had the ability to put in place systems to identify and comply with regulatory obligations. The respondent submits that the acquisition of an additional care home, difficulties engaging a lead assessor and the limited head office resource do not excuse a failure to comply with statutory obligations. The appellant had access to publicly available guidance and that awareness letters, reminders and enforcement correspondence had been issued over a prolonged period.

43. The respondent’s assessment of the appellant as a large undertaking size was reasonable because it was based upon the criteria prescribed by the ESOS Regulations and the ESP. The respondent contends that the appellant was correctly categorised and that the appellant’s size carries with it corresponding regulatory responsibilities.

44. In relation to aggravating factors, the respondent submits that the appellant failed to comply with a succession of deadlines. The original compliance deadline of June 2024 was extended to August 2024 and the appellant was subsequently afforded a further opportunity to comply through the Enforcement Notice which required compliance by 17 January 2025. The respondent submits that this history of extended non-compliance was properly treated as an aggravating factor.

45. The respondent accepts that mitigating factors were present and submits that these were taken into account. In particular, the respondent accepted that the appellant had responded to the Compliance Notice, had sought to engage a lead assessor and had ultimately submitted a notification of compliance. The respondent submits that those matters were reflected in the final penalty assessment.

46. The respondent relies upon Marshell Oil LLP v EA [2023] UKFTT 948 (GRC) in which the Tribunal accepted that the stepped approach contained in Annex 2, “provided it is correctly followed, provides a sound and therefore reasonable basis for determining the appropriate civil penalty in a given case”.

47. The respondent relies upon Marlborough Sterling Investment Group Ltd v EA [2023] UKFTT 681 in which the Tribunal directed itself that “On an appeal against a penalty notice, the role of the Tribunal is not to place itself in the position of the Respondent and to ask itself what penalty it would have decided to impose, but rather to consider whether the penalty was erroneous either because of a factual or legal error or because it was unreasonable. Unreasonable in this context bears its ordinary meaning i.e. one which having regard to the circumstances is unfair, unsound or excessive. The respondent asserts this is the correct approach but must be read within the context of SSHD v Rehman [2003] 1 AC 153 such that in matters of judgment and evaluation of evidence proper deference should be shown to the primary decision maker.

48. Accordingly, the Civil Penalty Notice was lawfully issued and that the penalty of £10,260 was reasonable, proportionate and consistent with the ESP. Accordingly, none of the statutory grounds of appeal are made out.

The Hearing

49. The hearing was conducted by video and there was no objection to that being a suitable method of hearing. We heard oral evidence from Mr Hartles and Mr Belcher. We heard oral submissions from Mr Hartles on behalf of the appellant and Mr Dale-Harris on behalf of the respondent. We have considered the oral evidence and the oral submissions made together with the following documents in reaching our decision:

(i) Hearing bundle (317 PDF pages)

(ii) Authorities bundle (202 PDF pages)

(iii) Skeleton argument on behalf of the respondent.

The Issues

50. The appellant argues that the respondent's issue of the Civil Penalty Notice and the setting of the final penalty is based on an error of fact, is wrong in law and is unreasonable. The issues in the appeal are therefore:

(i) Is the Civil Penalty Notice based on an error of fact;

(ii) Is the Civil Penalty Notice wrong in law; and

(iii) Is the Civil Penalty Notice unreasonable.

Findings, Discussion and Conclusions

Is the civil penalty notice based on an error of fact

51. The appellant’s case is that there are two errors of fact. Firstly, the respondent proceeded on the basis that earlier awareness correspondence had been received when it had not. The implication was that the appellant had less warning of the regulatory requirements than the respondent believed.

52. Secondly, the appellant proceeded on the understanding that the reference to 6 August 2025 was an extension of the compliance deadline. The appellant's position was that this arose as a result of an error by the respondent but the appellant had genuinely proceeded in good faith on the basis that compliance by 6 August 2025 would satisfy the statutory deadline.

53. Turning to the first claimed error of fact, the appellant disputes receipt of the awareness letters dated 14 December 2023, 29 May 2024 and 26 July 2024. In oral evidence Mr Hartles accepted that the address used by the respondent for service of the awareness letters was the appellant's correct address for service. The awareness letters are not notices served pursuant to the ESOS Regulations. Accordingly, we accept, as submitted by the respondent, that the common law principles of service apply, such that a letter posted to the correct address is rebuttably presumed to have been received by the recipient. The appellant does not dispute that the letters were sent. The appellant accepts that the address is the correct address for service. No rebuttal evidence has been produced by the appellant, for example in relation to postal disruption.

54. We have considered the witness statement and oral evidence of Mr Belcher. We found Mr Belcher to be a credible witness. He was clear where the matters to which he spoke were from his own knowledge and where they were from information gleaned from the respondent's contractor. His evidence is that the first awareness letter was sent to the appellant on 20 December 2023 at its registered address. This information was obtained by checking the respondent’s records, including a mailing list. Mr Belcher described how, for subsequent awareness letters, HH Global was contracted to send the letters on the respondent’s behalf. In relation to the second awareness letter, sent in May 2024, the contractor accepted that 0.03% of the letters were unaccounted for and it cannot be certain that the appellant was not one of those 0.03%. In relation to the third awareness letter, dated 26 July 2024, Mr Belcher indicated that the contractor had confirmed that 100% of the relevant letters were sent to Royal Mail for posting. We do have some concerns that, to an extent, the evidence of service from Mr Belcher relies upon what he had been told by a third party, and we have little information as to the methodology and level of certainty that the third party had in relation to the information being provided. Nonetheless, on the balance of probabilities, and on the evidence before us, and perhaps more importantly on the basis that the appellant does not dispute that the letters were sent we find that the letters were posted to the appellant’s correct address for service. There is insufficient evidence before us to rebut the presumption that they were therefore received by the appellant. We are satisfied that the respondent has demonstrated that the awareness letters were served. Accordingly, there is no error of fact in this regard.

55. Turning to the references to 6 August 2025 as the compliance deadline. The error appears in the Notice of Intent and was subsequently repeated in the Civil Penalty Notice. The respondent's evidence, which we accept, was that the reference arose through an administrative error and was not intended to amend or extend any of the compliance dates established by the ESOS regime. The correct compliance dates had previously been identified in the awareness correspondence and enforcement documentation, namely the extended compliance deadline of 6 August 2024 and the deadline of 17 January 2025 imposed by the Enforcement Notice.

56. The factual issue in dispute is whether the appellant genuinely believed that the date for compliance had been extended to 6 August 2025. We are not persuaded that the appellant understood the references to 6 August 2025 to constitute a substantive extension of time for compliance. When the Notice of Intent was issued on 13 February 2025, the appellant had already failed to comply with both the extended compliance deadline of 6 August 2024 and the Enforcement Notice requiring compliance by 17 January 2025. The appellant accepted during the hearing that it was aware of the 17 January 2025 deadline and accepted that the deadline had not been met. We also place weight upon the contemporaneous correspondence exchanged after the expiry of the Enforcement Notice. In correspondence dated 30 January 2025, the appellant explained that it was seeking to engage a lead assessor and was experiencing difficulties obtaining appropriate quotations. That correspondence proceeded on the basis that compliance had not been achieved and that enforcement action was progressing. There is no suggestion within that correspondence that the appellant considered the compliance deadline to have been extended to August 2025.

57. Further, following the Notice of Intent, the appellant submitted written representations dated 4 March 2025. Those representations explained the appellant's circumstances, including the acquisition of a further care home, resource pressures within the business and difficulties securing a lead assessor. However, the representations did not assert that the compliance deadline had been extended to August 2025 or that the appellant had relied upon the reference to 6 August 2025 as creating additional time for compliance. We consider that, had the appellant genuinely understood the Notice of Intent to contain a substantive extension of time until August 2025, this would have been an obvious and significant point to raise in response to the Notice of Intent.

58. We also note that by 21 February 2025 the appellant had informed the respondent that a lead assessor had been engaged and that work towards compliance was underway. Thereafter an ESOS report was completed in March 2025 and a notification of compliance was submitted on 1 April 2025. Those actions are more consistent with an understanding that the appellant was already in breach and attempting to remedy that position than with a belief that compliance was not required until August 2025.

59. Taking the evidence as a whole, we find it more likely than not that the appellant appreciated that the reference to 6 August 2025 was an error rather than a substantive extension of time. Accordingly, there is no error of fact in this regard.

60. It follows from all we have said above that the appellant has failed to establish that the civil penalty notice is based on an error of fact.

61. We do, however, pause here to note that there are numerous inconsistencies in the compliance dates given to the appellant within the enforcement documentation and correspondence. We consider that this is relevant to the question of whether the civil penalty notice is reasonable which is considered in further detail below.

Is the Civil penalty notice wrong in law (Proper Application of the ESP)

62. The appellant asserts that the respondent has failed properly to apply the ESP. The appellant is unrepresented. Whilst not particularised in this manner, in our judgment this element of the appellant’s case can be properly characterised as the respondent having failed to apply its own policy without justification. In essence this is a submission that the civil penalty notice is wrong in law.

63. The appellant's submissions in relation to the ESP are set out above and are not repeated in full here. However, we note that the appellant asserted that the preservation of the integrity of the scheme was not listed as a consideration under the ESP. In addition no consideration was given to the fact that this was not a case where environmental harm had been caused, unlawful activity had been undertaken, there had been deliberate avoidance of regulatory obligations, or there had been a deliberate attempt to obtain a financial advantage through non-compliance.

64. Again, the respondent's submissions are set out above and are not repeated here.

65. We agree with the respondent's submission that the appellant has focused on the main text of the ESP but has failed to consider Annex 2.

66. Section 9, titled "How the Environment Agency Makes Enforcement Decisions", refers to Annex 2 in relation to how enforcement decisions are made for climate change schemes. Accordingly, it is clear that Annex 2 is incorporated into the ESP and is relevant to the Civil Penalty Notice. Annex 2 confirms that it applies to various climate change schemes, including ESOS. Section D of Annex 2 expressly deals with ESOS.

67. At the outset of the Annex, it states:

"The nature of the breach assessment is the seriousness of the breach based upon the impact it has on the integrity of the scheme. This means the trust in, transparency, reliability and effectiveness of the scheme. It may include the length of time a person has been required to comply with the law."

68. Section D.2.3 states:

"Undertaking an energy audit is a key requirement of ESOS. This breach impacts on the integrity of ESOS and therefore we usually issue a penalty for failure to undertake an energy audit."

69. Accordingly, we accept the respondent's submission that maintaining the integrity of the scheme was a legitimate consideration pursuant to the ESP. We therefore reject the appellant's submission that the respondent acted other than in accordance with its policy.

70. In addition, we agree with the respondent's rationale for rejecting the appellant's submissions concerning environmental harm, unlawful activity, avoidance of regulatory obligations, financial gain and voluntary compliance. For the reasons advanced by the respondent, we are satisfied that the appellant's non-compliance undermined the objectives and integrity of the ESOS regime, delayed the implementation of energy-efficiency measures and any associated environmental benefits, and thereby frustrated the purpose of the scheme. We accept that the absence of any immediate environmental damage does not mean that no harm arose from the breach. The scheme is intended to identify and encourage energy-efficiency improvements and delays in compliance necessarily postpone the opportunity for such measures to be considered and implemented. We also accept the respondent's submission that prolonged non-compliance risks undermining confidence in, and the effectiveness of, the regulatory regime, particularly if other regulated entities were to adopt a similar approach.

71. We further accept that the appellant derived a practical advantage from its failure to comply within the prescribed timescale by avoiding, for a substantial period, the costs, inconvenience and resource commitments associated with compliance. We agree with the respondent that compliance was not voluntary in any meaningful sense but rather the belated discharge of obligations which had existed for a considerable time.

72. For all the reasons set out above, we are satisfied that the respondent's assessment of the breach and its decision to take enforcement action was in accordance with the ESP. Accordingly, in our judgement the Civil Penalty Notice is not wrong in law

Is the civil penalty notice unreasonable?

73. We remind ourselves that, when assessing whether the civil penalty notice is unreasonable, the term "unreasonable" bears its ordinary meaning, namely a decision which, having regard to all the circumstances, is unfair, unsound, or excessive. We also accept that, in assessing the reasonableness of the civil penalty notice, we must afford proper deference to the primary decision maker.

74. It is not disputed that the appellant is a responsible undertaking required to participate in ESOS or that it failed to comply with its obligations under the ESOS Regulations. The appellant accepts that it did not achieve compliance by the extended compliance deadline of 6 August 2024 and further accepts that it failed to comply with the Enforcement Notice requiring compliance by 17 January 2025. We have rejected the appellant’s assertion that it held a genuine belief that date of 6 August 2025 amounted to an extension for compliance.

75. The respondent followed the four-step process contained within Annex 2 of the Enforcement and Sanctions Policy ("ESP"). In relation to Step 1, the respondent correctly identified the statutory maximum penalty. In relation to Step 2, the respondent correctly identified the nature of the breach and correctly applied the reductions available under the ESP, including those applicable to a new entrant.

76. Step 3 required the respondent to determine culpability, organisational size, the penalty starting point and the applicable penalty range. The respondent assessed the appellant's culpability as negligent. The penalty assessment records the respondent's calculation of the applicable starting point and range. The appellant did not challenge with any force the respondent's assessment that the appropriate level of culpability was negligent. Mr Hartles gave evidence that the appellant operates within a heavily regulated sector and takes compliance obligations seriously. We accept that evidence. However, on the evidence before us, we are satisfied that the appellant did not have adequate systems in place to identify and respond to its obligations under the ESOS Regulations. In particular, Mr Hartles' evidence was that he was not aware of a formal process for identifying and escalating regulatory correspondence. Having considered the ESP Guidance, negligent conduct includes a failure by an organisation as a whole to take reasonable care to put in place and enforce proper systems for avoiding commission of the breach. Given the lack of processes for regulatory correspondence, and our finding that the awareness letters were appropriately served, we are satisfied that the appellant's conduct was negligent. There is no dispute that the penalty starting point is £5,400 or the penalty range is between £2475 and £13,500.

77. In light of the appellant’s failure to comply by both 6 August 2024 and subsequently by 17 January 2025, we are satisfied that a financial penalty was necessary in relation to the breach.

78. We therefore turn to Step 4. The respondent identified a number of aggravating factors:

a. the appellant failed to comply with the original ESOS requirements by the extended deadline of 6 August 2024 notwithstanding the awareness correspondence sent on 14 December 2023, 29 May 2024 and 26 July 2024. The appellant failed to comply with the Compliance Notice dated 11 September 2024 and subsequently failed to comply with the Enforcement Notice dated 17 October 2024 requiring compliance by 17 January 2025. The Enforcement Notice provided a further three months within which to achieve compliance, that opportunity was not taken. Accordingly, there is a significant history of non-compliance;

b. following the issue of the Enforcement Notice on 17 October 2024, there was no contact from the Appellant until prompted by a reminder email (24 January 2025) in relation to compliance. This demonstrates that the Appellant did not take its regulatory obligations seriously; and

c. despite having advised in October 2024, following receipt of the Compliance Notice, that a Lead Assessor was to be engaged no appointment was made until February 2025. The reason given for the delay was that the quoted fee of £9,000 was too expensive. Given appellant’s net profit in 2023 of over £1.4 million and dividends of over £500,000 this is not an acceptable reason for the delay.

79. The respondent identified a number of mitigating factors:

a. The appellant responded to the Compliance Notice issued on 11 September 2024, by the deadline specified in that notice accepting the Appellant’s qualification and initially communicated with the ESOS Team regarding ESOS requirements; and

b. the appellant submitted its Notification of Compliance on 1 April 2025.

80. We accept that the respondent has correctly identified a number of aggravating and mitigating factors. However, neither the decision nor the respondent’s written submissions attributes any weight to those factors. At the hearing, we asked the respondent's representative to confirm whether there was a process by which the decision was reached and whether any minutes, notes, or other documents existed which recorded the weight afforded to the various factors identified by the respondent. The respondent's representative confirmed that there was such a process. However, there was no documentation before the Tribunal which identified the weight attributed to the aggravating or mitigating factors. As a result, whilst we can see which factors were taken into account, we are unable to discern the extent to which any particular factor influenced the level of penalty ultimately imposed.

81. We accept that the appellant has a history of non-compliance and failed to comply both with the deadline of 6 August 2024 and with the requirements of the Enforcement Notice dated 17 October 2024. We regard this as a weighty aggravating factor. It demonstrates not merely an isolated failure to comply, but a continued failure to meet regulatory obligations despite being afforded further opportunity to do so. As such, this is a factor which attracts significant weight when assessing the appropriate level of any financial penalty.

82. The respondent relies upon a lack of engagement by the appellant. In particular, it points to the period between the Enforcement Notice dated 17 October 2024 and the reminder email of 24 January 2025. The respondent submits that this is indicative of the appellant not taking its regulatory obligations seriously. We do not agree. Whilst the appellant may not have been in contact with the respondent during this period, it is clear from the evidence (email from Mr Hartles dated 31 January 2025) that it had identified a lead assessor but considered the quotation received to be too expensive. The appellant was thereafter investigating quotations from two alternative lead assessors. Accordingly, it is not, in our view, correct to say that the appellant was not taking its regulatory obligations seriously. Rather, the evidence indicates that it was continuing to work towards compliance, albeit without communicating this to the respondent. This reduces the weight that should be attached to this factor.

83. The respondent relies upon the delay between October 2024 and February 2025 in the appellant appointing a lead assessor. The reason given for that delay was that the initial quotation of £9,000 was considered too expensive. The respondent submits that this is not an acceptable justification, particularly given the appellant's reported profits of £1.4 million and dividends in excess of £500,000. However, we reduce the weight attached to this factor for two reasons. Firstly, we accept that the appellant would not necessarily have possessed extensive knowledge of the likely costs associated with appointing a lead assessor to undertake an ESOS assessment. The appellant is a corporate entity and its directors have fiduciary duties. In those circumstances, it was not unreasonable for the appellant to seek alternative quotations in order to satisfy itself that the services were being procured at a competitive rate. Secondly, whilst we accept that this process contributed to delay, that delay is already reflected in the appellant's poor history of compliance, as set out above. To attach substantial additional weight to the delay in appointing a lead assessor would, in our view, involve an element of double counting. Accordingly, less weight should be attached to this factor.

84. Turning to mitigating factors, the appellant did engage with the respondent during the enforcement process. The appellant’s correspondence during September and October 2024 demonstrated that the appellant was seeking to understand the requirements of the scheme and had begun making arrangements to achieve compliance. All correspondence from the appellant throughout the enforcement period indicated that the appellant was working toward compliance. This factor attracts weight.

85. The appellant ultimately achieved compliance almost 28 days before the Civil Penalty Notice was issued. A lead assessor was retained, an ESOS report was completed on 25 March 2025 and a notification of compliance was submitted on 1 April 2025. Whilst the respondent noted that the Appellant submitted its Notification of Compliance on 1 April 2025, it does not take account of the fact this was approximately 28 days prior to the issue of the Civil Penalty Notice. We attach considerable weight to the fact that compliance had been achieved before the Civil Penalty Notice was issued on 28 April 2025.

86. We accept that the appellant has now put arrangements in place for future compliance. Mr Hartles’ evidence was that TEAM Energy had been engaged and that systems existed to assist with future ESOS obligations. Again, this is a weighty factor, it weighs against the need for a substantial penalty to secure future compliance.

87. Finally, we have also considered the errors made by the Respondent in the Notice of Intent and Civil Penalty Notice both of which state a compliance deadline of 6 August 2025. In addition, there are errors in the compliance dates contained in the correspondence sent to the Appellant. An email dated 24 January 2025 from ESOS enforcement refers to an imminent deadline of 30 January 2025. It would seem the intention was that this email would serve as a reminder. However, the deadline was 17 January 2025. The deadline had already passed at the time the email was sent. Whilst we have found that those errors did not cause the appellant's non-compliance and that the appellant did not genuinely believe that the date had been extended to August 2025, we nevertheless regard repeated errors within formal enforcement documentation and correspondence as a factor carrying some limited weight in the overall assessment of the reasonableness of the penalty. A regulated party is entitled to expect accuracy and consistency in formal communications from its regulator. Repeated errors of the kind identified above have the potential to diminish the significance attached to compliance deadlines and to undermine confidence in the administration of the scheme.

88. For completeness, we do not regard the appellant's lack of administrative resource at head office or competing operational demand as mitigating factors. Responsibility for ensuring compliance with the ESOS regime rests with the appellant, and it was incumbent upon it to maintain adequate systems and processes to discharge its regulatory obligations.

89. Drawing these threads together, we accept that the appellant's history of non-compliance attracts significant weight. However, for the reasons set out above, we consider that reduced weight should be attached to certain of the aggravating factors identified by the respondent. Conversely, a number of mitigating factors attract significant weight and certain mitigating matters were not taken into account. Taken cumulatively, we consider that the mitigating factors outweigh the aggravating factors, albeit not by a substantial margin. We note that the respondent's starting point was a penalty of £5,400. Affording appropriate deference to the respondent's regulatory decision making, we nevertheless conclude that, in light of our findings as to the balance between aggravating and mitigating factors, the appropriate penalty should fall below the starting point, though not substantially below it. The penalty of £10,260 is therefore excessive and unreasonable. We conclude that the appropriate penalty is £4,000. That figure properly reflects the seriousness of the appellant's failures whilst giving appropriate weight to the mitigating factors present in this case.

90. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed and the Civil Penalty Notice is varied by reducing the financial penalty from £10,260 to £4,000.

Decision

1. For all the reasons set out above, this appeal is allowed. The Civil Penalty Notice is varied by reducing the financial penalty from £10,260 to £4,000. Our decision is unanimous.

2. Signed: Judge Wilson Date: 24 October 2026

For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our environmental lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.