Administrative United Kingdom
Zacarias Trinidad Polanco v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: HU/54399/2026
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Harmondsworth IAC
On 22 October 2026
Before
first-tier tribunal JUDGE MOON
Between
ZACARIAS TRINIDAD POLANCO
(anonymity direction NOT Made)
Appellant
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr S. Slater, Legal Representative
For the Respondent: Mr H. Waseem, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
1. The appellant is a citizen of the Dominican Republic who was born on 15 March 1983 and so is aged 43 at the date of the appeal. He first entered the United Kingdom on 6 July 2015 having been issued a EEA Family Permit Visa, he would have been aged 32 when he first arrived. The appellant applied for an EEA residence Card as a Non EEA National on 1 November 2015, this was initially refused but an appeal against the refusal was allowed and he was issued an EEA Residence card on 5 December 2017. It seems likely that the appellant’s legal status in the United Kingdom was as a result of his marriage in February 2015.
2. On 9 June 2021 the appellant applied for leave in accordance with the European Union Settlement Scheme (EUSS), he was granted indefinite leave to remain on 25 August 2021. In summary, the appellant lived in the Dominican Republic until the age of 32 when he arrived in the United Kingdom. He has lived here ever since and all of his stay has been lawful.
3. On 17 September 2025 the appellant was convicted of attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child, attempting to cause a female to engage in sexual activity without consent and attempting to facilitate the commission of an offence of sexual activity in the presence of a child/attempting to cause a child to watch a sex act. He was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment and made subject to a sexual harm prevention order for ten years.
4. On 1 October 2025 the respondent issued the appellant with a Stage 1 notice of a decision to deport him. The appellant did not respond to the notice but the respondent decided that implied human rights submissions had been made; the appellant claimed to have a private life here in the United Kingdom and submitted evidence of lawful employment in 2016 and between 2021 to 2025. On 10 February 2026 the respondent issued a Stage 2 decision to deport the appellant and refused his human rights claim. The appellant appeals against the respondent’s decision under the provisions of the Nationality, Immigration, and Asylum Act 2002.
Publication
5. At the hearing I confirmed that the Tribunal may publish this decision. There was no application for anonymity and I see no reason for an anonymity direction, none having been made in the criminal proceedings.
The Legal Framework
6. The structured approach to be taken in these decisions is set out in Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 (Sections 117A – D). Section 117C makes it clear that the deportation of a foreign criminal is in the public interest. This appellant falls within the definition of foreign criminal because he has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment which exceeds 12 months.
7. In a case such as this where the appellant has been sentenced to a period of imprisonment of more than 12 months, but less than four years, Section 117C(3) confirms that the public interest requires deportation unless Exception 1 (Private Life) or Exception 2 (Family Life) applies. If neither of the Exceptions apply to this appellant, the appeal should be allowed if there are “very compelling circumstances” over and above those described in Exceptions 1 and 2.
8. There are three limbs to Exception 1, in order to meet this Exception all three must be satisfied: the appellant must have
• Been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life, and
• Be socially and culturally integrated into the United Kingdom, and
• There must be very significant obstacles to his reintegration into the Dominican Republic
9. At the hearing, Mr Slater conceded that the appellant could not meet Exception 2 because he does not have a partner or a child. Mr Slater also conceded that the appellant cannot meet Exception 1 because he has not been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life. Whilst all of his stay has been lawful, he is now aged 43 and arrived aged 32 and so he has spent less than half of his life living here.
10. Although the appellant cannot succeed in this appeal solely through reliance on the exceptions to deportation set out in sections 117C(4)-(5), it is well-settled that the exceptions “may provide a helpful basis on which an assessment can be made whether there are "very compelling circumstances, over and above those described in Exceptions 1 and 2" as is required under section 117C(6)” (paragraph 37, NA (Pakistan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department & Ors [2016] EWCA Civ 662). This means that it is still relevant to make a finding on limbs two and three of Exception one.
The Hearing
11. The following documents were available;
a) The appellant’s first witness statement dated 15 October 2026.
b) An appellant’s bundle containing 134 pages (AB). The appellant’s skeleton argument is at AB 156 – 164) of the bundle.
c) A respondent’s bundle containing 82 pages (RB) which includes the Judges Sentencing Remarks and an OASys Risk Assessment dated 19 August 2026.
12. Prior to the hearing, the appellant’s representatives applied for an adjournment in order to obtain medical records and expert evidence relating to possible side effects of medication taken by the appellant at the time of the offending behaviour, the purpose was not to challenge the conviction but to challenge the length of his sentence in the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), that application was refused by a different Judge on 6 October 2026 on the basis that the function of the Immigration Tribunal is to decide the appeal on the basis of the facts as they currently stand and the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to relitigate the appellant’s guilt. In the decision the Judge also stated that no timetable had been provided. A further application for reconsideration of this decision was made but refused.
13. At the hearing Mr Slater made an oral application for this decision to be reconsidered. I heard submissions from Mr Slater and from Mr Wassem who opposed the requested adjournment. Mr Slater submitted that attempts to obtain medical records from the Immigration Detention Centre had not been successful and he explained that he was now able to present a workable short timetable. Having considered detailed submissions it transpired that the appellant’s representatives wish to consider the medical records in order to establish whether the appellant might have been suffering from side effects of anti-depressant medication that he was prescribed at the time of the offending behaviour. Mr Slater also stated that he wished to consider the medical records to consider whether it would be necessary to instruct a psychologist or a psychiatrist but a decision on the instruction of an expert could not be made until the appellant’s medical records had been obtained.
14. I refused the application largely for the same reasons as the Judge who decided the application on 6 October 2026. I also took note of the wording of Mr Slater’s submissions which was that the appellant describes a history of mental health including depression and panic attacks and that his prescription history may provide independent corroboration of that account and may establish whether the symptoms, treatment and medication are consistent with contemporaneous medical records. Mr Slater also said that the medical records may also provide information necessary for an appropriately qualified expert to consider the relevant questions regarding the risk of offending (my emphasis). Mr Slater also submitted that he did not invite the Tribunal to assume the medical records will support the account, or suggest a diagnosis or favourable expert opinion that would automatically reduce the public interest in deportation. I refused the application, applying the overriding objective which requires consideration of using the resources of the Tribunal in a way that is proportionate to the issues involved in the case. I was not prepared to adjourn a hearing that the Tribunal had allocated one day to in order to allow the appellant’s representatives to read medical records which they may, or may not decide require expert evidence. Relevant factors in assessing the public interest in deportation is the length of the sentence, preventing further offending behaviour and deterrence to others.
15. I also agreed with submissions made by Mr Waseem which were that the appellant is entitled to pursue an appeal in the criminal courts but the mere fact that he wishes to obtain evidence to seek permission to appeal against the sentence does not provide a basis for delaying the progress of these immigration proceedings. The appellant has not demonstrated that any application for permission to appeal has been granted, nor that the convictions have been set aside. The fact the appellant is planning in the future to pursue criminal appeal proceedings is an insufficiently firm basis upon which an indefinite or open-ended adjournment of this appeal can be justified.
16. The appellant does not dispute his guilt, his representatives are trying to establish whether there is any basis upon which the length of the sentence can be appealed. Unless and until the Court of Appeal allow an appeal against the length of sentence, which is very far from certain, the Tribunal must proceed on the basis of the sentence of 18 months imprisonment. I did not hear details of the suggested timetable for an adjournment from Mr Slater because I refused to adjourn the hearing at all and so it was not relevant to hear details of how long and adjournment was being sought. I explained that I was happy for Mr Slater to ask a small number of questions related to the appellant’s mental health in examination in chief. Mr Slater requested that I record his submission that my decision to proceed with the substantive hearing was unfair which I have now done.
17. The hearing took place in-person. The appellant’s representatives had requested a Portuguese Interpreter but at the beginning of the appellant’s evidence, the interpreter informed me that the appellant was speaking mainly in Spanish and she was not happy to proceed. The appellant confirmed that Spanish is his first language and so I adjourned the hearing so that a Spanish interpreter could be sourced. A Spanish interpreter was able to attend the hearing remotely. Initially there were some difficulties with sound but these were resolved when I asked everybody to speak close to the microphones. No objections to the hearing proceeding with a remote interpreter were raised.
18. The appellant answered a small number of questions in examination in chief, at the start of his cross examination I suspected that he was finding some of the complex language difficult to understand. I had noted that paragraph 28 of the ASA indicated that sight of the appellant’s medical notes may mean that the appellant should be considered a vulnerable witness. I did not consider there was a serious problem with the his ability to participate and that the situation could be managed by directions in relation to questioning. I decided it was appropriate to apply the Joint Presidential Guidance Note No 2 of 2010: Child, Vulnerable Adult and Sensitive Witnesses. I directed that questions should be clear and in straightforward language. I also intervened when he was being asked about the details of the offending behaviour; I did not consider these questions would add anything to the respondent’s position because the appellant accepts the details which are clearly set out in the Judges Sentencing Remarks and in the Pre-Sentence Report.
The Evidence
Background
19. The appellant was born in the Dominican Republic in 1983. His pre-sentence report states that he is one of 16 siblings (AB 99). At the hearing he confirmed that he had a large quantity of family and estimated that approximately half remain in the Dominican Republic. He said that one of his brothers lives in America, another lives in Spain and one brother lives here. He worked as a pastry chef in the Dominican Republic. He said that he was diagnosed with diabetes when he lived there but was not prescribed medication for this condition until he came to the United Kingdom. A copy of his diabetes care plan is at AB 91 – 92.
20. He met his ex-wife in the Dominican Republic in 2014, she lived in the United Kingdom. They married in 2015 in the Dominican Republic, a copy of the marriage certificate is contained within the respondent’s bundle. The appellant’s ex-wife has prepared a witness statement in support of his appeal which is contained within the appellant’s bundle. At the time of preparing her statement, the ex-wife had a son who was aged 40 and two grandchildren. The witness statement describes how the appellant started to drink heavily from 2017, he told his ex-wife that he did not love her anymore and they separated in June 2022. Her evidence is that she was worried about him after the separation and continued to help with cooking and washing until August 2024. Her evidence is that when the appellant was arrested, she went with him to the police station. She did not attend the hearing in order to have her evidence tested in cross examination.
21. At the time of the decision was made, the appellant provided evidence of his lawful employment in the United Kingdom in 2017 and from 2019 to 2022 and the respondent accepted that he had proven residency in the United Kingdom in 2016 and from 2021 to 2025. The appellant’s bundle contains further evidence which supports continuous residence from 2015 which includes payslips darted November and December 2015 (AB 69 and 70), payslips dated January– May 2016 (AB 71 – 79). A residence card issued on 5 December 2017 (AB 80 -81). The immigration history set out in the decision letter confirms that the appellant was involved in an appeal process in late 2017 and whilst there is a gap in the evidence between June 2016 and 9 June 2021, I have noted that his application for indefinite leave to remain was granted on 25 August 2021 and that application requires five years continuous residence and so the respondent must have been satisfied with the evidence provided within that application.
The offending behaviour
22. Details are contained within the Judges Sentencing Remarks and also in the pre-sentence report. A vigilante group known as the Fleetwood Enforcers had set up a fictional profile of a 14 year old girl. The appellant made contact with the fictional child from 7 November 2022 and sent her messages, photographs and videos of a sexually explicit nature despite being aware of her age. The appellant was arrested on 7 January 2023 after attending an interview at a police station. He fully admitted the facts of the offences. At the time of his pre-sentence report, he said that he was going through a difficult time and described suffering with marital difficulties and implied that he felt under immense pressure at work. He said that these issues contributed to depression, anxiety and panic attacks.
The appellant’s mental health
23. The state of mind of the appellant at the time of the offending behaviour is supported by what is set out in the witness statement of his ex-wife and a witness statement provided by his brother. These statements indicate that the appellant was struggling with his mental health at the time of the Covid-19 pandemic and that he started to experience panic attacks, anxiety and depression. The evidence is that he was diagnosed with anxiety disorder and depression and was prescribed medication in order to manage the symptoms.
24. At the hearing the appellant was asked his opinion on whether the medication was a contributing factor. His evidence was that he became aware of this possibility after his solicitors told him about this but that there was no excuse for committing the offence. He said he was sorry for the offence but that he could not comment on the remainder of the question. Mr Slater rightly objected to this line of questioning on the basis that the appellant was not qualified to give an expert opinion.
25. In his evidence in chief the appellant confirmed that he first sought help for his mental health from his GP in 2021 and was prescribed Sertraline and Propranolol, he also received counselling and therapy at the Camden and Islington Mental Health Centre. He said that he stopped taking his medication in 2023. He was asked if counselling was available in the detention centre. He confirmed that he had been to assessment two weeks ago and was waiting for the outcome of this assessment.
Remorse and rehabilitation
26. The OASys risk assessment indicates that the appellant has attempted to minimise and justify his conduct, at page 9 of the report, the following is said
“Mr Zacariasin interview could offer no clear plausible explanation for his unacceptable behaviours. He indicated that he was in a low mood, however in my opinion, his bouts of depression, anxiety and marital discord in no way explain his sexualized objectification of a child he believed to be a 14 year old child. His expression of regret, although in my opinion genuine, were superficial in nature and the appellant's focus was on the impact that his offending would have on his life. The defendant's behaviours were motivated by his pursuit for sexual gratification and in doing so he had no regard for the possible impact of his behaviours on his victim.
Even today he continues to minimise his actions and demonstrates little insight into the possible impact of his offending.
Mr Zacariasstrenuously denied any sexual attraction to children. Despite the appellant's denial of a sexual attraction to children, the nature of his convictions to contradict what appears to be his sexualized view of children. He admitted in my interview with him that he was aware that his victim had informed him that she was aged 14 and yet he continued with his inappropriate sexualized behaviours. This is a man who, in my view, harbours an unhealthy sexual interest in teenage girls and despite his guilty pleas he has made no attempt to fully account for his behaviours.”
27. The OASys risk assessment confirms that the appellant is assessed as posing a low risk of harm in all areas except to children in the community where the risk is assessed as being medium. In submissions Mr Slater highlighted positive comments contained within a letter from the Probation Service at PDF page 112 of the appellant’s bundle.
28. The respondent has highlighted comments set out in the sentencing induction record which state “I got 10 years here, friends, family. I made one mistake but not previously commit crime in UK.” On behalf of the respondent it is submitted that describing such serious offending as “one mistake” is an attempt to minimise the behaviour but in my assessment, it is possible that this has been taken out of context or too much emphasis has been placed on this. The interview appears to have been completed in English which is not the appellant’s first language and another interpretation is that the appellant was explaining that he has one conviction (for three offences) rather than a large number of convictions.
29. The appellant was asked about the offending behaviour at the hearing, he said that he is sorry that he committed the offence and he did not try to blame his medication. My impression of his oral evidence is that this regret is genuine.
Findings
Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002
Exception 1
30. The first limb to Exception 1 is that the appellant must have been lawfully resident in the United Kingdom for most of his life. Whilst all of his residence has been lawful, the appellant has lived here for less than half of his life and so he cannot meet Exception 1. The fact that his residence has been lawful should however be carried forward to the overall Article 8 assessment.
31. The respondent does not accept that the appellant is socially and culturally integrated into the United Kingdom. I find that he is, he lived all of his married life here and although he has now separated, the evidence is that his wife continued to support him. There is also evidence of lawful work in the United Kingdom and so he has contributed to society through the payment of taxes. I accepted his evidence that he struggled with his mental health from the time of the global pandemic, and that he engaged with services offered by his GP to try to address this.
32. In relation to the third limb, Mr Slater confirmed that the appellant’s position is that there are very significant obstacles to the appellant’s reintegration into the Dominican Republic but it was not clarified what these obstacles are. In his oral evidence, the appellant said that he had a large family and half of the family members are in the Dominican Republic. His evidence was that they do provide support but may not be able to provide financial support because some of them have their own commitments and family. In evidence the appellant confirmed that he went to the Dominican Republic for just under one year in 2024 and at that time he stayed with his brother during this visit. He confirmed that his mother lives there but she has some disabilities and does not live at home and is cared for by her sister. The appellant has worked as a pastry chef in the Dominican Republic, speaks the language and has a large number of family members there. I find it has not been established that there are very significant obstacles to re-integration.
Very compelling circumstances
33. It is submitted that in this case there are very compelling circumstances over and above those set out in Exceptions 1 and 2. Mr Slater submitted that he has lived here lawfully since 2015, that he has undertaken victim awareness and empathy work, completed educational courses and engaged with his Offender Manager. It was highlighted that this engagement has been recognised and the appellant’s witness statement confirms that he was recommended for enhanced status. Overall, it was also submitted that the appellant relies on the cumulative circumstances of his case, his lengthy residence, private life, relationships, his mental health and evidence of remorse and rehabilitation.
34. In HA (Iraq) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2022] UKSC 22 guidance is given in relation to the high threshold which must be satisfied to establish very compelling circumstances. It is clear that the cases in which circumstances are sufficiently compelling to outweigh the high public interest in deportation will be rare. Relevant factors are set out in paragraph 51 of HA Iraq, some of these factors do not apply to the appellant because he does not have a partner or child in the United Kingdom.
35. As indicated above, I am satisfied that this appellant has been resident in the United Kingdom since 2015 and that he has worked here lawfully and so has contributed to society through the payment of taxes. I am satisfied that he lived his married life here and although he is now divorced, his ex-wife remains supportive, although the extent of this support is limited because she did not attend the hearing. I find it has not been established that there will be any serious difficulties in the appellant returning to the Dominican Republic, I carry forward findings relating to very significant obstacles in that respect. I find that the appellant has maintained ties with his home country, he visited family there in 2024 and stayed with family members, the evidence is that he has a large network of support there.
36. I note what is said in the OASys risk assessment in relation to the minimisation of his offending behaviour but my impression was that the appellant does now regret his actions and he does recognise the serious harm that would have been caused, had he been communicating with a 14 year old child. I accept that he engaged with all of the courses that were possible in prison and that he was given enhanced status. However, in my assessment there are no features that can be described as compelling in this case. The appellant has mental health difficulties, but this is not unusual. He has no children here and no partner. In the Dominican Republic he does have a support network, he has not lived there since 2015 but he grew up there, spent some time as an adult there, was employed and he visited within the last two years. In all of these circumstances I conclude there are not very compelling circumstances that outweigh the strong public interest in deportation.
NOTICE OF DECISION
The appeal is dismissed on human rights grounds.
TO THE RESPONDENT
FEE AWARD
I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award.
Signed: Date 27/10/2026
Judge S. Moon
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal Moon
At Kohen Avocats, our immigration lawyer in Paris can review your situation.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).