Property United Kingdom

Lucilla Monaco v Giovanni Orlando

Official source

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKUT 411 (LC)

Case Nos: LC-2026-254

IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL (LANDS CHAMBER)

AN APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE FIRST-TIER PROPERTY CHAMBER

Ref: LON/00AC/MNR/2025/1008

23 October 2026

TRIBUNALS, COURTS AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 2007

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RENT DETERMINATION – validity of landlord’s notice – FTT failed to consider tenant’s arguments, evidence, and comparables

BETWEEN:

LUCILLA MONACO

Appellant

-and-

MR GIOVANNI ORLANDO

Respondent

36 Leeside,

Barnet,

EN5 2PG

Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke

Determination by written representations

© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2026

The following cases were referred to in this decision:

A1 Properties (Sunderland) Limited v Tudor Studios RTM Company Limited [2024] UKSC 27

Delta Vale Properties Limited v Mills [1990] 1 WLR 445

MannaiInvestment Co Ltd v Eagle Star Life Assurance Co Ltd [19971 AC 749

Mooney v Whiteland [2023] EWCA Civ

Perotti v Amboh Properties Limited [2025] UKUT 421 (LC).

Introduction

1. This is an appeal by a tenant, Ms Lucille Monaco, against the First-tier Tribunal’s determination of a market rent for her property following the service of a notice of increase of rent by her landlord, Mr Giovanni Orlando. She appeals because, she says, the FTT ignored arguments she made and evidence she relied on. The appeal has been decided under the Tribunal’s written representations procedure; neither party has had legal representation.

2. The notice of increase was served by the landlord on 27 August 2025 and so this appeal is concerned with the law as it stood at that date and not with the law as amended on 1 May 2026.

The legal background

3. The FTT has jurisdiction to determine a market rent for property, under section 14 of the Housing Act 1988, following service of a notice of increase of rent by a landlord under an assured tenancy under which there is no contractual provision for the increase of the rent. The requirements for such a notice are set out in section 13 of the 1988 Act, including the requirements for the date on which the notice may require the new rent to take effect. A form is prescribed for the landlord’s use, by the Assured Tenancies and Agricultural Occupancies (Forms) (England) Regulations 2015 (the 2015 Regulations); the landlord must use form 4 in the Schedule or (by regulation 2) a form "substantially to the same effect" as form 4. It requires the landlord to set out the proposed new rent, the existing rent, the date on which the rent was first increased under the statutory notice procedure, and the date on which it is proposed that the new rent shall take effect.

4. The new rent will take effect on the date stated in the notice unless before that date the tenant applies to the FTT for a determination of the market rent. Once such an application is made both parties have the opportunity to make representations and provide evidence, for example of the condition of the property or about the rent payable for comparable properties.

5. Section 14 of the 1988 Act provided (prior to 1 May 2026) that the rent determined by the FTT would take effect on (and was therefore backdated to) the date specified in the landlord’s notice, unless the FTT found that that would cause “undue hardship” to the tenant, in which case the start date could be postponed up to, but not later than, the date of the determination of the new rent.

The facts, and the decision of the FTT

6. The appellant holds a tenancy of 36 Leeside, Barnet, which the FTT said was granted on 7 June 2024 for a period of 12 months; that seems to have been the latest in a series of one-year tenancies. The property is a three-bedroom semi-detached house. On 27 August 2025 the Landlord served a notice of increase, on the prescribed form, which proposed a new rent of £2,350 per month in place of the existing rent of £1,825 per month to take effect from 7 October 2025. On 30 September 2025 the appellant referred the notice to the FTT for the determination of a market rent.

7. In her statement of case she said:

“I believe the notice is not legally valid due to a material error contained in line 3

of the form. Specifically, where the form requires the first rent increase "date"

after 11th February 2003, my landlord has instead entered a monetary value

(“£1,700.00 per month”). This constitutes an error of substance, as the Housing

Act 1988 (as amended) and the prescribed Form 4 require the entry of a date, not

a rent amount.”

8. She included extensive information about the condition of the property, and expressed concerns about electrical gas safety. Once the FTT had given directions she provided a schedule of comparable properties.

9. The FTT inspected the property on 13 March 2026 and described it room-by-room in its decision of 16 March 2026; it also recorded, very briefly indeed, the tenant’s evidence that there were broken windows at the property and that the loft showed signs of significant disrepair and might be a source of water ingress. The FTT said that “In terms of rental evidence, the Tenant did not provide any documentation or submissions”.

10. The FTT went on to record the landlord’s evidence about work he had done at the property, and the comparable properties he had put forward with rents of £2,500 and £1,900 per month, and his assertion that he had had a professional valuation of the property which put its market rent at between £2,600 and £2,800.

11. The FTT said that the landlord’s comparable properties were of limited usefulness and concluded:

“Relying on its own expert, general knowledge of rental values in the area, and applying the limited value of the comparables provided by the Landlord, the Tribunal considers that the market rental of the subject Property modernised and in good order would be in the order of £2,800 pcm.”

12. It then deducted £840 per month for the condition of the property and lack of white goods, taking the market rent to £1,960. It stated “the Tenant made no submissions or provide any evidence of hardship” and determined that the rent would take effect on the date on the notice, from 7 October 2025.

The appeal

13. The appellant sought permission to appeal the decision on a number of grounds: she said that the FTT had not addressed her argument that the notice was invalid, nor her evidence about gas and electrical safety at the property, nor her comparables, nor her evidence of hardship.

14. The FTT’s refusal of permission to appeal stated the claimed invalidity of the notice “was a point that the Tribunal had already considered and in correspondence dated 3 December 2025, the Tribunal confirmed to the Tenant that it had jurisdiction and that the case could proceed.”

15. The appellant has permission from this Tribunal to appeal the FTT’s decision on the following grounds:

“First on the ground that the FTT did not address the applicant’s argument that the landlord’s notice was invalid and therefore failed to decide an issue before it.

Second on the ground that the FTT failed to take relevant evidence into account because:

a. The FTT did not address the applicant’s evidence of a gas leak and electrical hazards;

b. The FTT did not explain why it rejected the applicant’s evidence of comparable properties; and

c. The FTT did not take into consideration the applicant’s evidence of undue hardship.”

Ground 1

16. It is disappointing that this ground was not properly addressed in the FTT’s refusal of permission to appeal. The FTT’s email of 3 December attached a standard form letter and directions which said nothing about the validity of the notice. I take it that the FTT regarded the notice as valid and simply went on to give directions; but the appellant was convinced that it was not and it would have been appropriate for the FTT to answer her concerns. It is well-established that whilst under the law as it stood before 1 May 2026 the FTT did not have jurisdiction to give a definitive answer about the validity of a notice of increase of rent, that being a matter for the county court, it should address arguments about validity and of course will not proceed on the basis of an obviously invalid notice.

17. The appellant suggests that I set aside the FTT’s decision because it did not address her argument, and remit the matter to the FTT for it to decide on validity. I am not going to do that; the notice was plainly valid and it would be disproportionate to set aside the FTT’s decision purely because it failed to deal with the point. I say that for the following reasons.

18. The form correctly stated the existing rent and the proposed rent. The error that the appellant has pointed out was that in line 3 of the prescribed form the landlord is required to state “The first rent increase dated after 11 February 2003.” That date, at first sight mystifying in the context of a tenancy that began in 2024, is required in order to ensure that the next date on the form, the start date for the new rent, is calculated correctly, because it cannot be less than 52 weeks after the last occasion on which the rent was increased.

19. The correct answer, if the tenancy began in June 2024, was “n/a”, or “the rent has not been increased”. Instead the landlord put “£1,700”.

20. However, the next line of the form required the start date for the new rent; the landlord put “7 October 2025” and there is no suggestion that that was not a date on which the new rent could start.

21. Whatever the reasons for the mistake in line 3 of the form, it did not mislead the appellant. The error falls squarely within the discussion in MannaiInvestment Co Ltd v Eagle Star Life Assurance Co Ltd [19971 AC 749, where Lord Steyn referred with approval to the test in Delta Vale Properties Limited v Mills [1990] 1 WLR 445 and said:

“Even if such notices under contractual rights reserved contain errors they may be valid if they are "sufficiently clear and unambiguous to leave a reasonable recipient in no reasonable doubt as to how and when they are intended to operate": the Delta case, at p. 454E-G, … That test postulates that the reasonable recipient is left in no doubt that the right reserved is being exercised. It acknowledges the importance of such notices. The application of that test is principled and cannot cause any injustice to a recipient of the notice.

22. The decision in Mannai was about contractual notices, but in Mooney v Whiteland [2023] EWCA Civ 67 the Court of Appeal confirmed that the same reasoning is applicable to a statutory notice such as a notice of increase in rent (and see Perotti v Amboh Properties Limited [2025] UKUT 421 (LC)). And that is consistent with the Supreme Court’s reasoning in A1 Properties (Sunderland) Limited v Tudor Studios RTM Company Limited [2024] UKSC 27; the correct approach is to look at the purpose of the requirement and consider what ought to be the consequences of error. In the present case the information the tenant needed was clearly provided and there was no reason why the error in line 3 should have invalidated the form.

23. Therefore I decline to set aside the FTT’s determination of the market rent on this ground; the notice was valid, and whilst the FTT ought to have dealt with the point it would have made no difference to its decision about rent.

Ground 2

24. Ground 2 is about the FTT’s failure to deal with points argued by the appellant.

25. In considering the appeal bundle I note that the appellant has helpfully acknowledged that she raised personal hardship, in particular her reliance on universal credit, in her application for permission to appeal and not earlier. As a result the appeal cannot succeed so far as her evidence of hardship is concerned; what the FTT said was correct, she did not produce evidence of hardship with her application, and it is not permissible to produce it afresh on appeal.

26. There remain the FTT’s failure to address the appellant’s concerns about gas and electrical safety, and its failure to notice that she had produced comparable properties.

27. As the respondent says, the FTT is not required to deal with every item of evidence. There is an element of judgment as to what needs to be said and what does not. In my judgment a failure to mention something so important as gas and electrical safety concerns, and a statement that the tenant had provided no evidence of comparable properties when in fact she had, are both significant omissions. However, it would not be proportionate to set aside the decision and remit the matter to the FTT for re-determination, with all that that entails for both parties in terms of delay and stress, if those omissions did not make a material difference to the outcome.

Gas and electrical safety

28. In her grounds of appeal the tenant said: “I provided evidence of active hazards at the property, including: a persistent leak into kitchen electrical light fittings confirmed by a moisture meter reading of 400+; a faulty gas hob lacking a Flame Failure Device (FFD); and a reported smell of gas noted by the Tribunal's own assessor. I also highlighted an 11-year breach of statutory duty regarding gas safety certification.”

29. One of the components of the FTT’s reduction in the market rent for the condition of the property was an 8% reduction for the presence of damp and mould. I take it from that that the moisture problem was taken into account. But there was no mention of gas or electrical safety concerns.

30. The respondent in his statement of case in the appeal points out that the appellant’s evidence was disputed and that he relied on annual gas safety certificates from 2019 to 2025; he did not accept that they had not been provided to the tenant. Some of the electrical problems were caused by the tenant’s own appliances. In any event the FTT was concerned, not with regulatory failings but with the effect of the condition of the property upon the market rent. He observes that the appellant has not said what difference the safety concerns would make to the rent.

31. In its refusal of permission to appeal the FTT dismissed the tenant’s concerns about gas and electricity as relating to “historic issues that have been rectified”. In light of what is said in the respondent’s statement of case I think it likely that the FTT accepted his evidence that gas safety certification was up to date and that there were no current problems with the gas or the electricity that could have a bearing on the rent. It would have been helpful for the FTT to spell that out rather than leaving the parties and the appeal tribunal to infer it, but that would appear to be what has happened. Moreover, as the respondent says, the FTT inspected the property and was looking at it from the point of view of the rental market; it made a deduction of nearly one third of the market rent (£840 from £2,800) for the condition of the property, which is a very substantial deduction. For those reasons I think that even if the FTT did overlook any of what the appellant said about the gas or the electricity it is most unlikely that even if the case were remitted any further deduction would be made.

32. Accordingly the appeal fails on this point.

The appellant’s evidence of comparable properties

33. The appellant says that on 9 January 2026 she sent to the FTT a long schedule of links to over 30 property listings. In her grounds of appeal she said: “I submitted a list of comparable properties on 9 January 2026, demonstrating that the most similar properties in the area were priced between £1,800 and £2,200 — not £2,800. The £2,800 starting figure is higher than any comparable property submitted by either party.”

34. The material supplied by the appellant is not easy to navigate and so it is not clear to me that she made any written argument to the FTT about those properties.

35. However, the respondent has helpfully explained that he addressed in his evidence the appellant’s schedule of properties and explained that many were four-bedroom properties, properties offered at rents materially above £2,350 per month, or properties outside the immediate neighbourhood. He says that the appellant’s schedule did not establish completed lettings, did not make reliable adjustments for size, condition, location or terms, and that it did not identify a lower rental figure for the property in question. On the contrary, it showed properties with similar or greater accommodation being marketed at or above 2,350 per month. The respondent points out that the rent the FTT arrived at was £1,960, only £60 above the appellant’s two- bedroom end-of-terrace comparable at £l,900 per month, and substantially below her three-bedroom comparable at £2,500 per month. He submits that the FTT’s failure to address the appellant’s comparables was immaterial because the schedule, taken at its highest, did not provide a reasoned evidential basis for a rent below the figure determined.

36. The FTT said: “In terms of rental evidence, the Tenant did not provide any documentation or submissions.” Unfortunately that was not accurate. It may be that the appellant’s schedule was overlooked. Certainly as a long list of internet links it was not in a helpful format. I have opened some of the links and it seems to me that some of them were certainly relevant to the FTT’s determination, although some were not. I do not accept the respondent’s point that in any event the FTT’s figure was only just above the rental for a smaller property and that therefore the consideration of the tenant’s comparables would have made no difference; what the appellant has provided is a collection of properties with their asking prices, most of which appear to be in very good condition. Many will have eventually let for lower prices as a result of some offering and bargaining. And the relevant figure is not the FTT’s eventual determined rent but its good condition value of £2,800 which, in light of its rejection of the respondent’s comparables, had to be arrived at without real comparable evidence. The appellant says that it is higher than any comparable property submitted by either party which is troubling. The appellant did provide useful material and it was not taken into consideration.

37. For that reason I set aside the FTT’s decision that the market rent in good condition was £2,800 and remit the matter to the FTT for re-consideration of that element only of its determination. Its deductions from the market rent will stand.

38. A difficulty with this course of action is that some of the appellant’s comparables will no longer be on the market and so information in the form of links will either not work or will show different properties from those the appellant wanted to rely on. I suggest that the FTT gives directions for her to provide a limited number of comparables from her original list and to say briefly what she wants the FTT to conclude from them, and for the respondent (whose own comparables have already been considered by the FTT) to have the opportunity to reply.

Conclusion

39. To summarise, the appeal succeeds on one point only and is remitted to the FTT for re-consideration only of the market rental value of the property in good condition on the relevant date.

Judge Elizabeth Cooke

23 October 2026

Right of appeal

Any party has a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal on any point of law arising from this decision. The right of appeal may be exercised only with permission. An application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal must be sent or delivered to the Tribunal so that it is received within 1 month after the date on which this decision is sent to the parties (unless an application for costs is made within 14 days of the decision being sent to the parties, in which case an application for permission to appeal must be made within 1 month of the date on which the Tribunal’s decision on costs is sent to the parties). An application for permission to appeal must identify the decision of the Tribunal to which it relates, identify the alleged error or errors of law in the decision, and state the result the party making the application is seeking. If the Tribunal refuses permission to appeal a further application may then be made to the Court of Appeal for permission.

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our real estate lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.