Administrative United Kingdom

Al Amira Beauty Salon v The Pensions Regulator

Official source

NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01474 (GRC)

Case Reference: FT/PEN/2026/0056

First-tier Tribunal

(General Regulatory Chamber)

Pensions

Decided without a hearing

Heard on: 16 October 2026

Decision given on: 27 October 2026

Before

JUDGE SIMON BIRD KC

Between

al amira beauty salon

Appellant

and

THE PENSIONS REGULATOR

Respondent

Decision: The reference is ALLOWED and the matter is remitted to the Respondent. The fixed penalty notice is revoked and no further directions are required.

REASONS

1. This is the Appellant’s appeal by way of reference and its grounds relate to (a) a fixed penalty notice (FPN) with reference 16070325527 issued on 2 December 2025 under section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 (PA 2008) and (b) an Escalating Penalty Notice (“EPN”) with reference 231002340066 issued on 5 January 2026 under section 41 of the PA 2008. The Notices were issued because the Respondent was of the opinion that the Appellant had failed to comply with a Compliance Notice (CN) issued under section 35 of the PA 2008 on 29 September 2025 which required compliance by 14 November 2025.

The Legal Framework

2. The Pensions Act 2008 and the Employer’s Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 impose a number of legal obligations on employers in relation to the automatic enrolment of certain employees into occupational or workplace personal pension schemes. The Respondent has statutory responsibility for securing compliance with these obligations and may exercise certain enforcement powers.

3. One of the duties on an employer is to pay relevant contributions to an occupational or personal pension scheme in respect of enrolled employees. Where the Respondent is of the opinion that relevant contributions have not been paid, it has power under section 37 of the PA 2008 to issue an Unpaid Contributions Notice (“UCN”) requiring an employer to pay unpaid contributions into a pension scheme and to provide evidence that it has done so.

4. If there is a failure to comply with an unpaid UCN, the Regulator may issue a fixed penalty notice (section 40) and, in the event of continuing non-compliance, an EPN under section 41 of the PA 2008. Section 43 provides for the Regulator to review notices, including an UCN, a FPN and an EPN. The penalty prescribed in the present case is £400 in respect of the FPN and a daily rate of £50 in respect of the EPN.

5. The Tribunal’s jurisdiction is derived from section 44 of the PA 2008. Where a person to whom a notice has been issued under section 40 has first made an application for review of the FPN, they may then make a reference to the Tribunal. The role of the Tribunal is to make its own decision on the appropriate action for the Regulator to take, considering all the evidence before it. The Tribunal may confirm, vary or revoke a Notice and when it reaches a decision, it must remit the matter to the Regulator with such directions (if any) required to give effect to the decision.

6. The main issue in this appeal is whether the UCN was issued and then received by the Appellant. The Appellant also argues that all its employees had opted out of enrolment during the relevant period so no contributions were owed. It also argues that NEST had made an error by creating duplicate accounts with the same e-mail address which had resulted in the claim that it had not paid its relevant cotnributions.

7. In relation to the main issue, section 303 of the Pensions Act 2004, applied by section 144A of the PA 2008 to notices issued under its provisions, provides that:

“…

(2) The notification of document may be given to the person in question –

(a) by delivering it to him;

(b) by leaving it at his proper address, or

(c) by sending it by post to at that address.

….

(6) For the purposes of this section and section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 (c.30)(service of documents by post) in its application to this section, the proper address of a person is –

(a) in the case of a body corporate, the address of the registered or principal office of the body,

….”

8. The Appellant is a body corporate and, therefore, section 303(6)(a) of the 2004 Act applies to the instant reference.

9. Section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978, referred to in section 303(6), provides that:

“Where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post (whether the expression “serve” or the expression “give” or “send” or any other expression is used) the, unless the contrary intention appears, the service is deemed effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing the document and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post”.

10. Section 7 therefore provides for a rebuttable presumption that a notice which is contained in a letter which is properly addressed, pre-paid and posted is to be deemed served at the time the letter would be delivered in the ordinary post.

11. The Respondent is also able to rely on a second set of rebuttable presumptions as to the issue and service of notices under the PA 2008 contained in regulation 15 of the Employer’s Duties (Registration and Compliance” Regulations 2010 (the 2010 Regs). Regulation 15 provides:

“(3) The presumptions in paragraph (4) apply where notices to which section 43 applies are issued…..

(4) For the purposes of this regulation, it is presumed that –

(a) where a notice is given a date by the Regulator, it was posted or otherwise sent on that day;

(b) if a notice is posted or otherwise sent to a person’s last known or notified address, it was issued on the day on which that notice was posted or otherwise sent; and

(c) a notice was received by the person to whom it was addressed.”

12. In essence, once the Respondent has discharged the evidential burden of establishing that the relevant notice was issued and properly addressed, if an Appellant claims not to have received the relevant notice, they bear the onus of rebutting the regulation 15(4)(c) presumption that it was received by them. The presumptions have been described as strong statutory presumptions (Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Limited v The Pensions Regulator PEN 2020 0203).

Relevant Case Law

(i) Evidence of issue of the notice as a matter of fact

13. In J M Kamau Limited v The Pensions Regulator [2025] UKFTT 00435 (GRC) the Chamber President held that in subsequent cases the Pensions Regulator was entitled to rely on the evidence given in that case as to the system it operates for the issuing of notices such as FPNs with no further requirement to produce a witness statement detailing the processes, unless a direction is made to that effect in a given reference. No such direction was given in the current reference. However, the Chamber President added the following caveats:

(a) The ruling was predicated on the evidence given in that case continuing accurately to reflect the processes in place and it continuing to be the case that there have not been any adverse issues with the system that could cause doubt as to the reliability of the information it produces

(b) Where the Pensions Regulator intends to rely upon the evidence given in the Kamau case, this must be clearly identified in the Rule 23 response to the reference;

(c) To discharge the burden of demonstrating that the relevant was issued as a matter of fact, the Pensions Regulator can be expected to provide to the Appellant and the Tribunal screenshots from the relevant tabs from its IT system relating to the particular Appellant; and

(d) Whilst this is likely to be sufficient for the Pensions Regulator to satisfy the burden placed upon it, it is not inevitable and each case will need to be determined on its own facts.

(ii) Rebuttal of the statutory presumption of service

14. In London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar [2017] UKUT 150 (LC) the Tribunal explained the effect of the presumption of receipt in the following terms:

“82. A legal presumption like the one in s.7 has the effect of reversing the burden of proof. Once the landlord has proved that the notice was properly addressed, pre-[aid and posted, it has nothing further to do – unless the contrary is proved. If the contrary is provide, then the landlord must, as it were, go the long way round and actually prove service without the help of the presumption and must therefore convince the tribunal on the balance of probabilities that the notice was actually received. But it is only required to do that if the contrary is proved and not if the contrary is merely asserted”.

15. In Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Limited the Tribunal further emphasised that a bare denial or receipt of the relevant notice was insufficient to discharge the presumption of service.

(iii) Service requires no collaboration of reciprocal act from the intended recipient

16. In Kamau, the Chamber President found at [122] that the fact that a notice had not come into the hands of the Appellant was not sufficient to rebut the presumption that the notices were as a matter of law received. There was nothing in section 303 of the PA 2004 or 15(4) of the 2010 Regs which supported a conclusion that service is only effected once there is some collaboration or some reciprocal action on the part of the intended recipient. He added that:

“121. As a matter of practical reality, if this were not the case it is difficult to see how the system could sensibly function. An intended recipient could deliberately choose not to pick up mail on the assumption that some of the mail would be the bearer of bad news. In doing so, they could legitimately rebut the presumption of service”.

The Appellant’s Case

17. In summary, the Appellant argues that the decision to issue the EPN and FPN should be revoked because it did not receive the Unpaid Contributions Notice dated 29 September 2025 and it was not therefore not given a fair opportunity to respond before a Fixed Penalty was issued.

18. It argues that the alleged unpaid contributions relate to May to July 2025 and during this period, all employees had opted out of the Appellant’s pension scheme, so no contributions were due.

19. It also contends that NEST made an error by creating duplicate accounts under the same email which prevented the Appellant accessing the correct account. The NEST portal showed no arrears or outstanding actions, and despite contacting NEST on three occasions, no representative was able to confirm that contributions were owed.

20. The Appellant maintains that the £400 penalty was paid only to prevent further escalation and was not an admission of liability and that it had not received a copy of the Compliance Notice from the Respondent and that, had it done so, it would have taken immediate steps to comply.

The Respondent’s Response

21. The Respondent says that on 14 September 2025, it had emailed the Appellant at the address provided by it on completing its Declaration of Complianc,e saying that it had received a report from NEST, the Appellant’s pension provider, that there were unpaid contributions for the period 1 May 2025 to 31 July 2025. The email warned of the risk of enforcement action in the event that the contributions remained unpaid.

22. Having received no response to its email the Respondent issued an UCN to the Appellant at its registered office 18 Belmont Circle, Kenton Lane, Stanmore, Harrow HA38RF on 29 September 2025 with a deadline of 10 November 2025. The Appellant submitted a review request to the Respondent in respect of the UCN on 5 October 2025 arguing that it had no relevant employees for which contributions needed to be paid for the relevant period. On 10 October 2025, the Respondent confirmed the UCN, it having concluded that there was no evidence to support the Appellant’s claim and NEST had not closed the report.

23. The Respondent says that the Appellant was then sent a reminder of the need to comply with the UCN on 19 October 2025, but as there was no evidence of compliance by the deadline, a FPN was issued on 2 December 2025 requiring it to comply with the UCN. No review of the FPN was requested by the Appellant and it is not the notice appealed in the Appellant’s grounds of appeal. Had the Appellant sought to appeal against it, the Respondent would have asked for the appeal to be struck out on the conditions set out in section 44(2) of the PA were not met and the Tribunal would not have had jurisdiction (relying on Mosaic Community Care Limited v The Pensions Regulator PEN/2015/0004.

24. On 11 December 2025, the Appellant telephoned the Respondent and it was explained to it why the FPN had been issued and what would be required by way of evidence to address the non-compliance.

25. Whilst the Appellant paid the FPN penalty on 3 January 2026, no evidence of compliance with the UCN was received and the Respondent therefore issued the EPN on 5 January 2026 with a deadline of 1 February 2026. The penalty which has accrued under the EPN is £250. A review request was made by the Appellant in respect of the FPN on 29 January 2026 on substantially the same grounds as relied upon in this appeal. The Respondent confirmed the EPN on 10 February 2026 but with a varied date for compliance of 15 March 2026. The Respondent advised the Appellant that it had still not provided acceptable evidence of compliance in respect of the correct NEST scheme.

26. On 30 March 2026, the Respondent received notice of the Appellant’s appeal.

27. On 10 April 2026, the respondent received a DR770 NEST report which showed that, for the relevant scheme, there were unpaid contributions due of £177.81. There then followed an exchange of correspondence as the Respondent sought to establish which of the Appellant’s employees had opted out of the NEST scheme for the months of May to July 2025.

28. The Respondent relies on the presumptions of service arising under s 303(6)(a) Pensions Act 2004, s 7 Interpretation Act 1978 and regulation 15(4) of the Employers' Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010.

29. Both the Compliance Notice and FPN were sent to the Appellant’s registered office as recorded at Companies House. The Respondent argues that the Appellant has merely asserted that it did not receive the UCN, but that was insufficient to rebut the statutory presumption of service relying on the Upper Tribunal decision in Akhter and the Tribunal decision n Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Ltd v The Pensions Regulator PEN.2020.0203.

30. The Respondent further argues that none of the arguments advanced by the Appellant amount to a reasonable excuse for its non-compliance whether individually or cumulatively and nothing suggests that the Respondent has acted unfairly. In particular:

(a) Whilst the Appellant now claims not to have received the UCN, it sought a review of it by the Respondent on 3 October 2025. It had a took an opportunity to respond to the UCN

(b) The Respondent’s review decision of 10 October 2025 explained why the UCN had been confirmed and what the Appellant needed to do to comply with it and the Appellant had a month remaining at this point to comply;

(c) The DR770 NEST Report showed contributions owing of £177.81 , with one active member also reported on 6 May 2026 and other employees requesting to opt out of the scheme in May 2025. This is the suggested source of the unpaid contributions;

(d) The confusion surrounding the duplicate NEST accounts with different e-mails does not amount to a reasonable excuse as one of the accounts was set up by the Appellant and the other was set up by a delegate of the Appellant (an accountant) at the time it was set up. The Appellant remained responsible for the duty to ensure contributions are paid irrespective of any delegation. It has also been invited to be a delegate for the duplicate account but did not accept. Had it done so, it would have been able to access the relevant scheme before any penalties were incurred. The UCN had referred to that scheme by number and therefore the Appellant had been in possession of the correct reference from the commencement of the enforcement process. The Appellant should have ensured that processes were in place to deal with the change in any delegation to enable it either to upload the relevant information or to close it down. The Tribunal has previously held that it is the responsibility of the employer to comply with its relevant obligations and, if it chooses to use agents, to ensure that they are properly monitored (relying on Farmers Arms Swansea Limited v The Pensions Regulator PEN/2018/0385 and Nigel Rose Limited v The Pensions Regulator PEN/2024/0010); and

(e) The amount of the FPN and the EPN daily rate are prescribed by the 2010 Regulations and there is no discretion to vary them and it was, given the circumstances, reasonable and proportionate to issue the notices which allowed generous compliance periods.

Findings and Reasons

31. The Appellant’s claim that it did not receive the UCN has no merit. It sought a review of that notice on 5 October 2025 and therefore must have received it. Whilst the Respondent has not produced the evidence it would need to produce in order to rely on the presumptions of service, that is of no consequence where other evidence shows that it is more likely than not that the Notice has been received by the person to whom it has been sent. There is no contention made by the Appellant that it did not receive the FPN or the EPN and the evidence of contact with the Respondent after the service of the notices, is sufficient to satisfy me that, on the balance of probabilities all the relevant statutory notices were received by the Appellant.

32. As to the Appellant’s claim at all relevant employees had opted out of the relevant pension scheme, as the evidence shows, the relevant pensions scheme was EMP004895721 and the enrolled employees opted out during or at the end of May 2025. I am satisfied that it is more likely than not that it these employees and their opt out dates, which have resulted in the unpaid pension contributions for May 2025 in respect of the relevant pension scheme. Whilst the Appellant’s duplicate account set up on 1 June 2026 might show no unpaid contributions, its other account, set up by its agent in February 2025. As the Respondent points out, the UCN refers to the February 2025 NEST account by reference number and the Appellant should have ensured on the change of agent or cessation of the agent’s contract, that it had adequate arrangements in place to monitor that account so that it complied with its statutory obligations. Whilst an employer is entitled to delegate the discharge of its obligations to an agent, it cannot delegate the ultimate statutory responsibility for non-compliance to an agent. It therefore remained responsible for ensuring that all relevant contributions were paid on time and, on the facts, it is not a reasonable excuse to argue that the confusion caused by the existence of the duplicate NEST account and the way which the Appellant had allowed it to be set up, led to its breach.

33. I therefore conclude that the Appellant has failed to show that it was not served with the UCN or any reasonable excuse for its non-compliance. I am also satisfied that, given, the importance of the obligation which I am satisfied that the Appellant was in breach of, that the service of a FPN and EPN were both reasonable and proportionate actions on the part of the Respondent. I also agree with the Respondent that, in the absence of there being a review requested of the EPN, the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain an appeal against it, however, as is clear from my reasoning, even if I had jurisdiction I would have dismissed any such appeal.

34. I therefore dismiss the reference, confirm the EPN and there is no need for any further directions.

Signed Judge Simon Bird KC Date: 16 October 2026

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our social security lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.