Administrative United Kingdom
Homes for Students Limited v Environment Agency
NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01510 (GRC)
Case Reference: FT/EV/2026/0010
First-tier Tribunal
(General Regulatory Chamber)
Environment
Heard by Cloud Video Platform
Heard on: 19 October 2026
Decision given on: 04 November 2026
Before
JUDGE SAWARD
TRIBUNAL MEMBER DR. CATCHPOLE
Between
homes for students LIMITED
Appellant
and
ENVIRONMENT AGENCY
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Toby Fisher, Counsel
For the Respondent: William McBarnet, Counsel
Decision: The appeal is allowed in part.
The Civil Penalty Notice dated 21 January 2026 is affirmed with modification to reduce the amount of financial penalty to £1,500.
REASONS
Background
1. This is an appeal by Homes For Students Limited (“HFS”) against a civil penalty notice (“CPN”) issued by the Environment Agency (“EA”) dated 21 January 2026. The CPN imposes a civil penalty on the Appellant of £25,650 for failure to carry out an energy audit contrary to Chapter 3 of Part 4 of The Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme Regulations 2014, as amended (“ESOS Regulations”) by the statutory compliance date of 5 June 2024.
2. By virtue of regulation 49, the effect of the appeal is to suspend the CPN pending the determination of this appeal.
The Appeal
3. In its Notice of Appeal dated 10 February 2026, HFS appealed against the CPN pursuant to regulation 48(1)(c) of the ESOS Regulation on the ground that it was unreasonable. HFS seeks cancellation of the CPN.
4. In summary, HFS states that it had no awareness of the ESOS Regulations or its obligations thereunder until receipt by post on 17 July 2025 of a Notice of Intent to Impose a Civil Penalty (“NOI”) dated 7 July 2025. HFS claims not to have received any prior correspondence from the EA concerning the Regulations or any alleged breach. This includes the Compliance Notice dated 11 September 2024 (“CN”) and the Enforcement Notice dated 27 November 2024 (“EN”) referenced within the NOI.
5. HFS says it cannot comprehend how all previous correspondence allegedly sent by the EA could have been missed by its office. It maintains that it has robust arrangements in place to ensure that post is properly sorted and disseminated.
6. Immediately upon receipt of the NOI, HFS sought to engage with the EA. The Appellant was surprised by conflicting deadlines given by the EA. By email on 22 July 2025, the EA required HFS to set out how it intended to comply with the ESOS Regulations by 28 July 2025 whereas the NOI gave until 4 August 2025.
7. Had previous correspondence been posted and delivered, HFS believes the EN, at a minimum, would have been promptly brought to the attention of the appropriate individual.
8. HFS relies on a re-determined decision of the First-tier Tribunal (“FTT”) in Elizabeth Arden (UK) Ltd v TheEnvironment Agency[2024] UKFTT 112 (GRC). This decision followed remittal back to the FTT by the Upper Tribunal in Environment Agency v Elizabeth Arden (UK) Ltd[2023] UKUT 180 (AAC). Upon redetermination, the FTT noted that an Enforcement Notice had not been effectively served on the appellant company. It could not therefore reasonably have been expected to comply with that Enforcement Notice. In considering unreasonableness, the FTT confirmed that whilst the company acknowledged a Notice of Intent (“NOI”), it was unreasonable to proceed with the CPN. This was because it needed time to gather large quantities of information from its various offices in England and USA, the office was shut down during the Covid-19 global pandemic and difficulties placed on staff in accessing the information. The EA had not fairly considered these reasons for the delay when issuing the CPN.
9. It is submitted that the background, and FTT and UT determinations in Elizabeth Arden are pertinent because:
9.1 HFS did not receive the ‘awareness letters’ from the EA dated 14 December 2023, 5 June 2024 and 2 August 2024, asking it to review the ESOS guidance and determine its status, and/or contact the EA for more information.
9.2 HFS did not receive the CN dated 11 September 2024 or the EN dated 27 November 2024.
9.3 Despite its request, HFS says that the EA has not provided proof of delivery demonstrating that any of the above documents were correctly served. Following the UT Decision in Elizabeth Arden, the starting point is that the EA must prove the CPN was sent in accordance with Regulation 51 and section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978. The same principle applies to the CN and EN. In the absence of proof, service cannot be established.
9.4 If service of these documents was ineffective, HFS cannot reasonably be expected to have known about its obligations under ESOS and complied with the CN or EN.
10. HFS considers the CPN completely unreasonable as HFS took steps to comply with its ESOS obligations in less than 4 weeks after receiving the NOI on 17 July 2025. In the Elizabeth Arden case, the company did not bring itself into compliance until approximately 4 months after a NOI.
11. Given its prompt action, HFS considers that imposing a penalty to mark the breach and encourage future timely compliance is unnecessary. Non-compliance was not purposeful or intended, it was simply unaware of its obligations until receiving the NOI. Had it received the earlier notices, it would have acted from the outset.
12. The EA failed to take account of (i) service issues with earlier correspondence (ii) HFS’s conduct in bringing itself into compliance promptly (iii) its willingness to work with the EA. In addition, the EA did not assess all other relevant factors in setting he penalty. For example, it did not take account that HFS has been operating for more than 10 years, has never had any form of enforcement action taken by any regulatory body, or other enforcement authority. It also failed to consider HFS’s strong commitment to Environment, Social and Governance (“ESG”) principles.
13. HFS is shocked that in calculating the civil penalty under the Enforcement and Sanctions Policy, dated 10 October 2025, (“the ESP”), the EA assessed its culpability as ‘negligent’. The EA appears to have disregarded HFS’s complete lack of knowledge of the ESOS Regulations and requirements. HFS also considers it unfair, unsound and excessive for the EA to have significantly increased the penalty due to ‘aggravating factors’ given how swiftly it put things right and its willingness to work with the EA.
The Response
14. The EA contests the appeal and says in summary:
14.1 ‘Awareness letters’ were posted to HFS’s registered office address on 14 December 2023, 10 June 2025 (dated 29 May 2024) and 26 July 2024. The awareness letters, CN and EN were all sent to the correct address. The EA has no record of post not being delivered to HFS on its ‘return to sender’ log. There is no requirement for an appellant to have opened the letters or become acquainted with them.
14.2 The circumstances in the Elizabeth Arden case differ slightly to this appeal. In Elizabeth Arden the registered office was closed between March 2020 and October 2021 due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the Respondent had no record of posting. In this case, the Appellant’s office remained open over the relevant time. The EA does have record of posting. It is the EA’s position that the CN and EN should be treated in law as having been given and received.
14.3 The FTT has previously held that the stepped approach in Annex 2 of the ESP “provided it is correctly followed provides a sound and therefore reasonable basis for determining the appropriate civil penalty in a given case” (Judge Bird KC in Marshell Oil LLP v EA [2023] UKFTT 948 (GRC)).
14.4 The Appellant’s latest registered accounts recorded at Companies House for the year ended 31 March 2025 indicate a turnover exceeding £93 million and an operating profit over £4.4 million. It has responsibility to ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations. It did not do so. Quite clearly, it did not have processes or procedures in place to ensure compliance. Even if the EA had been entirely silent, it would still be the Appellant’s obligation to comply with the law.
14.5 The EA considers that its assessment of HFS’s culpability as “negligent” was correctly categorised. Even if HFS was of low or no culpability (which is not accepted), this would not mean the issue of the CPN was unreasonable, it would merely affect the penalty amount.
14.6 The lack of communication and action was a significant aggravating feature for increasing the penalty starting point from £13,000 to £25,650. The steps taken by HFS were recognised, but those steps were necessary to remedy the breach.
14.7 Nothing indicates that the penalty was unfair, unsound or excessive (per Marlborough), particularly bearing in mind the weight to be given to the EA’s view as primary decision maker (per the FTT decision in Safeguard World International).
Appellant’s Reply
15. In reply, HFS maintains its position that the CPN is unreasonable. It notes the Respondent’s submissions regarding the decision of Judge Bird KC in Marlborough. Such comments did not seek to limit the ability of the Tribunal to modify or cancel penalties, as seen in other recent FTT decisions.
16. It reiterates having robust arrangements in place to ensure that post is properly sorted and disseminated and there has never been any issue in the past with receiving post. This leads the Appellant to believe there may have been a clerical or administrative error on the part of the Respondent and that all earlier correspondence before the NOI was never correctly issued or posted.
17. In circumstances where HFS has not received information or guidance in relation to its obligations under ESOS, it would be unfair to expect HFS to have complied, particularly as ESOS is a relatively new scheme. Therefore, it is inappropriate to penalise HFS for a lack of awareness. HFS has been operating for more than 10 years and during this time it has never been subject to any form of enforcement actions by any regulatory or enforcement body. It would have taken steps at the outset is all early correspondence had been sent and received.
The Hearing
18. The remote hearing was attended by Toby Fisher, Counsel, for the Appellant who called Paul Balderson, and Simon West to give evidence. The Environment Agency was represented by William McBarnet, Counsel, who called Rory Belcher and Celia Hollinshead to give evidence. The witnesses’ oral evidence is encompassed within our findings and assessment below.
19. Some technical problems were encountered during the online hearing with both panel members losing connection at different points. When this occurred, evidence and submissions were repeated to ensure that nothing was missed. We are satisfied that no prejudice arose to either party from these technical difficulties during the hearing.
The Law
20. ESOS is a mandatory energy assessment and energy saving scheme which applies to certain undertakings in the United Kingdom.
21. The CPN was issued for failure to carry out an energy audit in accordance with Chapter 3 of Part 4 within the required timescale. Regulation 26 of Chapter 3 of Part 4 sets out the duty to carry out an energy audit and regulation 27 stipulates what an energy audit must do. An energy audit must, so far as reasonably practicable, address matters such as analysing the participant’s energy consumption, identify ways in which it can improve energy efficiency and make recommendations on reasonably practicable and cost-effective measures to be implemented.
22. Regulation 35 provides for the service of compliance notices. It says:
35. —(1) A compliance body may serve a notice on a responsible undertaking requesting such information as it considers necessary to enable it to monitor compliance with these Regulations (a “compliance notice”).
(2) A compliance notice must— (a) be in writing, (b) be served on the person to whom it is addressed, (c) specify the date by which compliance with it is required.
(3) A compliance notice may be varied or revoked in writing at any time by the compliance body that issued it.
23. An enforcement notice may be served under regulation 38(1) where the EA reasonably believes that a responsible undertaking has failed to comply with a requirement of the ESOS Regulations. Under regulation 38(2) an enforcement notice must—
(a) be in writing,
(b) be served on the person to whom it is addressed,
(c) specify—
(i) the provision of these Regulations which the compliance body believes has been breached,
(ii) the matters constituting the breach,
(iii) the steps that must be taken to remedy the breach,
(iv) the date by which those steps must be taken, and
include information about appeals under Part 9.
(3) An enforcement notice may be varied or revoked in writing at any time by the compliance body that issued it.
24. Regulation 39(1) provides that a compliance body may serve a penalty notice in any case where it is satisfied that a responsible undertaking is liable to a civil penalty under Part 8 of the ESOS Regulations.
25. Under regulation 39(2) of Chapter 1 of Part 8, a penalty notice must:
(a) be in writing,
(b) be served on the person to whom it is addressed,
(c) specify—
(i) the breach of the Regulations in respect of which the penalty is imposed, (ii) the steps that must be taken to remedy the breach, (iii) the nature of the penalty, and
(d) include information about appealing.
26. Where a financial penalty is imposed, and no daily penalty applies or the total amount of daily penalty can be determined, the penalty notice must, under regulation 39(3), specify: (i) the total amount due (ii) where applicable, how it has been calculated, and (iii) to whom, and the date by which it must be paid. The daily rate must be calculated by reference to working days (regulation 39(5)).
27. Regulation 45 identifies the financial penalties that can be imposed for failure to undertake an energy audit, as follows:
45. —(1) The penalties in paragraph (2) apply where a responsible undertaking fails to carry out an audit, contrary to Chapter 3 of Part 4, where the alternative routes to compliance in Part 6 do not apply.
(2) The penalties are—
(a) the financial penalties of—
(i) an initial penalty of £50,000, or such lesser amount as the compliance body may determine, and
(ii) a daily penalty of up to £500 for each working day the responsible
undertaking remains in breach, starting on the day after the
service of the compliance notice subject to a maximum of 80
working days, and
(b) the publication penalty.
(3) The penalty notice may specify the steps the compliance body requires the responsible undertaking to take, including conducting or completing an ESOS assessment, to remedy the breach, and the date by which such steps must be taken.
28. This appeal is made under regulation 48, which provides:
48. —(1) A responsible undertaking served with a determination under regulation 35(5) or paragraph 13(2) of Schedule 2, or with an enforcement notice, or a penalty notice, may appeal to the relevant appeal body on the grounds that the determination, enforcement notice or penalty notice (as the case may be) was—
(a) based on an error of fact,
(b) wrong in law, or
(c) unreasonable.
29. Under regulation 50, the Tribunal “may”:
(a) cancel the CPN,
(b) affirm the CPN in its original form or with such modification as it sees fit,
(c) instruct the scheme administrator or the relevant compliance body to do, or not to do, anything which is within the power of the scheme administrator or compliance body.
30. By virtue of regulation 5 of Chapter 2, the EA is the “scheme administrator”.
31. The discretion available to the compliance body is set out within regulation 42(1). Where the compliance body considers appropriate it may—
(a) waive a civil penalty, (b) allow additional time to pay any financial penalty, (c) substitute a lower financial penalty, or (d) modify the application of a publication penalty.
32. In terms of service requirements, regulation 51 provides:
51. —Any determination or notice required to be served on a responsible undertaking, may be served by—
(a) delivering or sending it to, or leaving it at— (i) the responsible undertaking’s registered office (where applicable), (ii) the responsible undertaking’s principal place of activity, or (iii) another place address in the United Kingdom specified by the responsible undertaking as its address for service, or
(b) sending it by electronic means to the email address provided by the responsible undertaking pursuant to paragraph 1(b) of Schedule 3.
33. Section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 provides:
7— References to service by post.
Where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post (whether the expression “serve” or the expression “give” or “send” or any other expression is used) then, unless the contrary intention appears, the service is deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing the document and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post. [emphasis added]
Main issues
34. The appeal is expressed to be brought on the ground that the CPN was ‘unreasonable’ under regulation 48(1)(c). However, the grounds of appeal raise issues over service of documents from EA prior to the NOI. This is developed in the Appellant’s skeleton argument which refers to the “sole aggravating factor” in the CPN being “based on an erroneous factual presumption”. The skeleton argument proceeds to say that none of the letters, the CN or EN were received “despite the EA’s claim they were sent”. The CPN cites the CN and calculates the daily penalty imposed in reference to the date of issue of the CN. With all these factors in mind, the Tribunal checked with Counsel for HFS whether a case was being advanced on the ground that the CPN was based on an error of fact under regulation 48(1)(a). Counsel confirmed that HFS does maintain there was an error of fact albeit not explicitly described in that way in the grounds of appeal.
35. The EA was aware of the arguments raised regarding non-receipt of communications, which would have placed the EA on notice of the need to ensure that evidence of service was addressed. Indeed, its witness evidence sought to do this. The EA was also represented by Counsel at the hearing with opportunity to make submissions in reply. In the circumstances, the Tribunal alerted the parties during opening announcements that the Tribunal proposed to consider arguments pursuant to both regulation 48(1)(a) and (c). No issue was raised with this approach and we proceeded on that basis.
36. The following issues were identified:
• As a prerequisite, was the CPN properly served on the Appellant? If so, was the Appellant aware of it?
• Was correspondence and notices from the EA prior to the NOI sent to and received by the Appellant?
• Was the CPN based on an error of fact?
• Was the CPN unreasonable?
• If so, should the Tribunal exercise its discretion to (i) cancel the CPN, or (ii) affirm it with or without modification, or (iii) should the EA be instructed to do something else falling within the powers of the scheme administrator?
Findings of fact
37. The Appellant is a large undertaking for the purposes of the ESOS Regulations to whom the scheme requirements applied at all material times. Its accounts up to year ending March 2025 disclose an annual turnover exceeding £93 million.
38. The Appellant was required by the ESOS Regulations to undertake an energy audit by 6 August 2024. The deadline for compliance was extended in the EN to 27 February 2025. HFS failed to do undertake an energy audit within the extended timescale.
39. The EA says that it sent letters to HFS dated 14 December 2023, 29 May 2024 and 26 July 2024 to inform the company of ESOS, that HFS was considered to qualify and may need to take action to comply with the scheme. These letters are referred to as ‘awareness letters’.
40. The EA says that it sent a CN to the Appellant by post on 11 September 2024 with a deadline of 25 September 2024 for response. HFS did not respond.
41. The EA says that it then sent an EN to HFS dated 27 November 2024. The EN identified breaches of the ESOS Regulations by: (i) failure to carry out an ESOS assessment, including an energy audit, by 6 August 2024, and/or (ii) failure to notify the EA whether HFS had complied with Part 4 or 6 of the ESOS Regulations by the same date. The EN outlined the steps required for compliance by 27 February 2025.
42. A NOI to impose a civil penalty was sent by post to the Appellant on 7 July 2025. The Appellant confirms that the NOI was received on 17 July 2025. The NOI identified three breaches:
(i) failure to notify EA of compliance with Part 4 or Part 6 of the ESOS Regulations, contrary to regulation 29, and/or
(ii) failure to undertake an energy audit by 6 August 2024, contrary to Chapter 3 of Part 4 of the ESOS Regulations, and/or
(iii) failure to comply with the EN dated 27 November 2024 by the date specified in the EN, contrary to regulation 46.
43. The NOI erroneously stated that a CN had been issued in September 2025. The EA intended to say that the CN was issued on 11 September 2024.
44. Following receipt of the NOI, HFS emailed EA the same day (17 July 2025). When no reply was received HFS emailed EA again on 18 July 2025 and 21 July 2025. EA responded on 22 July 2025.
45. HFS held an initial meeting with a specialist ESOS consultancy on 23 July 2025. It instructed the consultancy on 29 July 2025 for the conduct of the energy audit. The Lead Assessor conducted an audit of the HFS registered office on 30 July 2025. HFS received the audit report on 7 August 2025 and sent it to its landlord who has control of the office on 11 August 2025.
46. The CPN was issued by the EA on 21 January 2026 for a failure by HFS to undertake an energy audit contrary to Chapter 3 of Part 4 to the ESOS Regulations by 5 June 2024. No issue is taken over service of the CPN.
47. At the time of issue of the CPN, HFS had submitted a Notification of Compliance to confirm that the energy audits had been done. A Notification of Compliance was submitted to EA via its online portal on 12 August 2025.
48. It is agreed that HFS was a new entrant to the ESOS scheme.
Analysis and Conclusions
Service and awareness of the CPN
49. The CPN was properly served by post upon the Appellant at its registered office address. It was aware of the CPN. Neither point is in dispute. The Tribunal is content that these preliminary points are met.
Was correspondence from the EA served on the Appellant?
50. It is necessary to distinguish between the service of notices and correspondence as different provisions apply. We start with the three awareness letters, which HFS disputes were sent or received.
51. There was no statutory requirement or provision within the ESOS Regulations for awareness letters to be served before taking enforcement action. There was a general duty upon the EA to raise awareness of ESOS, but there was no duty to make individual companies aware of their obligations under the requirements of ESOS.
52. The service of the letters is governed by common law. It is not for the EA to prove receipt of the letters. At common law there is a rebuttable presumption that a properly directed letter that is proved to have been put in the post has reached its destination according to the regular course of post, and that it was received by the person to whom it is addressed (Khan v D’Aubigny [2025] EWCA Civ 11 at [77] to [79]). A mere assertion of non-receipt does not suffice to rebut the presumption. It is for the Tribunal to make an assessment with reference to the relevant facts and an assessment of the witness’ credibility and reliability.
53. At the hearing the argument was put by HFS’s Counsel that the EA has not provided proof of delivery for any of the awareness letters (or the CN or EN). Two possibilities were suggested. Either: (a) some or all of the communications were posted by EA or its agents and were delivered to HFS’s registered office address but never made their way to the appropriate people within the company, or (b) none of the correspondence was posted or received at all. It was suggested that (b) is more likely given the systems in place to ensure that post is properly managed and routed within the organisation.
54. Rory Belcher, a Senior Technical Officer at the EA provided a witness statement and gave oral evidence at the hearing. Mr Belcher works within a team responsible for regulating ESOS and bringing undertakings into compliance. His witness statement was written on the understanding that the receipt of the letters was disputed, not that they were sent. His statement, nevertheless, provided details of the process of posting applicable in this case.
55. The first awareness letter was dated 14 December 2023. The letter was sent to over 11,000 companies in batches of 1,000 letters at a time. We disagree with the Appellant that there is no evidence of posting. There is not a ‘proof of posting’ document, but Mr Belcher gave clear evidence from his own personal knowledge of the despatch process. He was also able to rely upon EA’s records. He stated that the letter was sent to HFS at its address in Harrogate (i.e. its registered office) on 15 December 2023 in the fourth batch, to which 428 responses were received.
56. Mr Belcher was cross-examined on the type of envelopes used and manual folding process. Window envelopes were used and the letters folded to display the address within the envelope. He could not discount the possibility of human error in the folding process. The possibility of this was minimised by a check undertaken at the time by the person folding the letter to ensure the address is displayed, and re-folded if necessary, and a further check of some of the envelopes by Mr Belcher himself.
57. We find no significance in there being around a 43% response rate to the fourth batch, which Mr Fisher suggested was low. It is not indicative of letters not being sent or delivered. As explained by Mr Belcher (and can be seen from the copies produced) the awareness letters set out the qualification criteria for ESOS, they ask organisations to determine if they qualify for ESOS and give information on what to do if they do qualify. Thus, the letters are informative. They do not invite a response but serve to raise awareness and prompt action by qualifying undertakings.
58. We found Mr Belcher’s evidence of despatch of the first awareness letter to be sufficiently clear to demonstrate that it is probable the letter was posted to HFS.
59. A different process was followed with the second and third awareness letters. They were handled on the EA’s behalf by a contractor called HH Global. Mr Belcher produced two ‘mailing dockets’ headed ‘CITIPOST MAIL’ which he said showed the number of items handed over to the Royal Mail. When cross-examined on these dockets, Mr Belcher admitting not knowing if they could be considered order forms placed by a company called ‘Precision Printing Co Ltd’ instead of evidence of posting. Mr Belcher said this was not a point that had been raised with him before and he was uncertain of the answer.
60. When Celia Hollinshead, the Account Director of HH Global was called to give evidence, she confirmed the dockets were not an order form. She explained that HH Global outsources the work from EA to Precision Printing Co Ltd. They run the mail merge to produce the letters and envelope them. The dockets are a statement of the number of items handed over by Precision Printing to CITIPOST MAIL. It was explained that CITIPOST MAIL is a ‘downstream’ provider that sorts the mail according to postcodes at a hub so that Royal Mail does not need to and thereby making the service cheaper. Ms Hollinshead also confirmed that CITIPOST MAIL does not count the number of items collected.
61. The EA’s records show that it gave the details and letter template to HH Global for over 7,121 awareness letters, dated 29 May 2024, to be sent out and 1,600 responses were received. Mr Belcher said the letters were sent out on 10 June 2024. The number of items in the docket fell short of the number of companies to whom the EA instructed letters to be sent. Mr Belcher fairly acknowledged that he could not be sure if HFS was one of the 23 (i.e. 0.3%) of companies who were not sent the second awareness letter.
62. Mr Belcher stated that he had checked the EA’s files and the text for the third awareness letter was sent to HH Global with a list of 5,408 companies. The docket shows exactly the same number of letters were handed over to CITIPOST MAIL for posting on 3 August 2024. There were 2,300 responses.
63. We find that the dockets do not demonstrate evidence of posting in the way that Mr Belcher had understood to be the case when writing his witness statement. After this issue emerged during the hearing, there was no application for adjournment to produce further evidence, and the Tribunal can only go on the evidence before us.
64. As Ms Hollinshead confirmed, the dockets demonstrate that CITIPOST MAIL had agreed to collect the specified number of letters, but they are not proof of posting. The witness confirmed that the docket merely acted as a handover document and that letters were not counted upon receipt. Ms Hollinshead conceded that there was no evidence that a specific number of letters had been collected. Furthermore, the act of handing enveloped letters to CITIPOST MAIL did not constitute ‘posting’ as the recipient was an intermediary contracted to sort the letters, not deliver them. The point of posting was when they were passed to Royal Mail.
65. We accept that the process was as described by Ms Hollinshead with awareness letters being posted by CITIPOST MAIL. This oral evidence from Ms Hollinshead is evidence of posting, albeit hearsay. Clearly, letters were sent as there were replies. The gap arising is the uncertainty over whether the second and third awareness letters addressed to HFS were among those posted. No record is produced of how many letters CITIPOST MAIL sent to Royal Mail, or other confirmation of posting. This is in circumstances where HFS claims non-receipt. There is a significant difference between the number of letters due to be sent and the number of replies. The numbers are nowhere near close enough to give rise to a probability of posting.
66. We cannot be satisfied that the second and third awareness letters were sent to HFS and the presumption of service does not arise in this particular case.
67. The position differs from the first awareness letter where the EA was able to rely upon the evidence of Mr Belcher that the EA had posted the batch that included the letter to HFS. We go on to consider if there is any evidence to rebut the presumption of service of the first awareness letter.
68. The Tribunal had witness statements and heard oral evidence from Mr Balderson, Group Legal Director and Mr West, Group Compliance Director for HFS. Both stated that HFS had not received any letters or notices from EA prior to the NOI. If they had been delivered, Mr Balderson was sure they would have been passed to one of senior officers, and they had not. We found both Mr Balderson and Mr West credible witnesses and we do not doubt that they had no personal knowledge of communications for EA until receipt of the NOI. Nevertheless, the issue for the Tribunal is whether the communications were received as a matter of law.
69. In evidence, Mr Balderson explained the company’s postal arrangements. Its registered office is a multi-tenanted building shared with a number of other companies. Post carriers have a fob to access the ground floor and place the post in trays allocated for each company. This gives scope for human error. One tray is clearly marked “Homes For Students Ltd”. Each working day a member of HFS’s Client Finance Team checks the post tray, sorts the post and places it into the appropriate pigeonhole. There is a designated pigeonhole intended for senior officers, three of whom are based in the building.
70. Mr Balderson thought it “virtually impossible” for the letters and notices to have been delivered and not come to the attention of one of the senior officers. However, Mr Balderson said that in reviewing the company’s incoming post processes, he had identified there was typically 7 to 10 days lag in allocating post. HFS manages around 250 properties and receives large volumes of post. Mr Balderson confirmed that he had only been in post for around 13 months at the time of writing his witness statement dated 15 May 2026. Therefore, he could not have had knowledge of events at all relevant times.
71. Notably, Mr Balderson confirmed in response to the Tribunal’s questions that there is no policy or procedure for items of post to be logged either manually or electronically. Whilst Mr Balderson operated a practice himself of scanning letters, this was not a system adopted for all post. The Tribunal does not consider the process, as explained, of using pigeonholes and without recording receipt is in any way a “robust” system.
Conclusion of service of the awareness letters
72. The Tribunal is satisfied that the first awareness letter dated 14 December 2023 was presumed served on HFS and its evidence does not suffice to rebut that presumption. It cannot be presumed that the second and third awareness letters were sent to HFS on the evidence available in this particular case.
Service of the Compliance Notice and Enforcement Notice
73. The issue turns to service of the formal notices which preceded the CPN. Specifically, whether the CN dated 11 September 2024 was properly served under regulation 35 and the EN dated 27 November 2024 was properly served under regulation 38. In both cases the notice must “be served on the person to whom it is addressed.” Service is the process by which the notice becomes legally effective.
74. The CPN was issued for failure to carry out an energy audit. The significance of proper service of the CN which preceded it is the impact upon the amount of financial penalty that can be imposed. Pursuant to regulation 45, the applicable penalty for failure to carry out an audit contrary to Chapter 3 of Part 4 is an initial financial penalty of £50,000, or such lesser amount as the compliance body may determine (reg 35(2)(a)(i)). The initial penalty is unaffected by the service of any CN.
75. It is the additional daily penalty that is calculated with reference to service of the CN. A daily penalty of may be imposed of up to £500 for each working day the responsible undertaking remains in breach, starting on the day after the service of the CN, subject to a maximum of 80 working days i.e. £40,000 maximum (regulation 35(2)(a)(ii)). It follows that if the CN was not served, then a daily penalty could not be imposed because there is no starting point for the purposes of regulation 35(2)(a)(ii).
76. Service of the EN is potentially relevant to culpability and aggravating/mitigating factors in the calculation of the amount of penalty, if found appropriate to impose.
77. As confirmed by the Upper Tribunal in Environment Agency v Elizabeth Arden (UK) Ltd [2023] UKUT 180 (AAC) at [11], while regulation 35, 38 and 39 provide that the EA may serve the appropriate notice, the requirements of regulation 51 nevertheless apply. It has to be interpreted in the context of the EA exercising its powers as the ESOS regulator. This means that “when the circumstances justify a notice being issued, it is proper to say that there is a requirement that it be served.” The Upper Tribunal went on to say that:
“12. As regulation 51 applies, section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 becomes relevant because it provides for: (a) the means by which service may be effected; and (b) a rebuttable presumption of when service is effected.”
78. Where post is addressed to the registered office, the Upper Tribunal stated at [14] to [15] that the “starting point was for EA to prove that the penalty notice had been sent in accordance with regulation 51 and section 7. If EA could show posting, [the company] would then have the opportunity to prove that the notice did not arrive.”
79. As set out more fully above, service is deemed to be effected under section 7 by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing a document. Unless the contrary is proved, service is deemed to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post.
80. Under regulation 35, a CN must be served on the person to whom it is addressed. The person to whom the CN was addressed was the company, being a body corporate. The requirements for the service of documents are explicitly addressed in regulation 51. Service is effected by delivering or sending a notice or leaving it at a company’s registered office address (regulation 51(a)(i)). There are corresponding provisions under regulation 38 for the EN.
81. Both the CN and EN were correctly addressed to the registered office address and marked for the attention of the Director or Company Secretary. However, there is a difference in the evidence before the Tribunal in terms of their posting. As with the second and third awareness letters, the issuing of the batch of compliance notices was outsourced by the EA. Mr Belcher gave evidence that the CN template and details of 4,025 intended recipients, including HFS, were sent to the contractor for issue and at least 2,300 replies were received. Clearly, a significant number of the compliance notices must have been delivered. That alone does not make it probable that the CN was issued to HFS. As before, the docket produced by Mr Belcher demonstrates that the correct number of items were sent by the subcontractor onto the next company for sorting, but this suffers the same evidential weakness as the final two awareness letters. The CN was not sent by recorded delivery post and there is no proof of posting or record of any kind from the company who sorted the CNs before posting.
82. We do not repeat but rely on the same reasons given in relation to the second and third awareness letters to conclude that the EA has not shown in this particular case that the CN was posted for the presumption of service to arise.
83. Turning to the EN. Mr Belcher gave evidence that he was responsible for issuing enforcement notices to large companies that failed to respond to the CN. Under cross-examination he accepted that there was always some possibility of human error in the enveloping process. As Mr Belcher had personally checked all the enforcement notices, he was confident that all addresses were visible in the window envelopes. A quality control process was in place, and we accept from what Mr Belcher told us that an error in the enveloping process was highly unlikely.
84. For the EN, there is a certificate of posting signed by a Facilities Assistant at the EA on 28 November 2024. It certifies that an EN was sent on 27 and 28 November 2024 by second class post to the companies whose names and addresses are listed in the Annex. Mr Belcher could not explain why the list of companies is not reproduced in the Annex within the bundle. We do not find this omission to be critical. A screenshot of the EA’s database entry is exhibited confirming an EN was issued to HFS on 27 November 2024. Moreover, Mr Belcher gave clear evidence that he had printed off the EN to HFS and personally taken the ENs to the EA’s facilities management team for posting. He had received the certificate of posting the day after. In the circumstances we find it probable that the EN, which was correctly addressed, was sent to HFS’s registered office.
85. On the facts, we are satisfied that the EN was sent by the EA to HFS at the proper address and effective service is presumed.
86. Once service is presumed, the Appellant bears the burden of rebutting the presumption of receipt. If the presumption is rebutted, then the legal burden returns to the EA. In London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar [2017] UKUT 150 (LC), a case concerning notices under a lease, the operation of this approach was described, as follows:
“82. A legal presumption like the one in s.7 has the effect of reversing the burden of proof. Once the landlord has proved that the notice was properly addressed, pre-paid and posted it has nothing further to do – unless the contrary is proved. If the contrary is proved, then the landlord must, as it were, go the long way round and actually prove service without the help of the presumption and must therefore convince the tribunal on the balance of probabilities that the notice was actually received. But it is only required to do that if the contrary is proved, and not if the contrary is merely asserted.”
87. When applying section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978, the Tribunal finds that the EN was received by the Appellant “at the time the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post”. That would have been around the first week of December 2024, which we take that as the approximate time of service.
88. Provided a notice is received at the ‘proper address’ there is no requirement within the ESOS Regulations for a EN to be passed on to a particular individual within the company or for any such individual to respond before service of a notice is effective. The person to whom the notice was addressed was the body corporate. It was the intended recipient and the legal person affected.
89. As made plain by the Court of Appeal in R(Alam) v SSHD [2020] EWHC Civ 1527 the burden of proving non-receipt will not be lightly discharged in the face of convincing evidence leading to the expectation of receipt. In particular, it will not be discharged by evidence, far less mere assertion, that the notice did not come to the attention of the person affected [31].
90. We rely on our same reasons and findings on HFS’s evidence of non-receipt as set out at paragraphs 68 to 71 above when we considered the first awareness letter. They apply equally to the EN. Indeed, not recording incoming post was a significant omission in HFS’s process when handling official notices. Even though the EN was not received by a senior officer of HFS, the Appellant has not rebutted the presumption that the EN was, as a matter of law, received by HFS.
Conclusion on service of the Compliance Notice and Enforcement Notice
91. For the reasons given, the EA has not shown as a matter of fact that the CN was sent to HFS for service to be presumed.
92. As a matter of law, the EN was deemed served on HFS in early December 2024.
Was the penalty notice based on an error of fact?
93. Having found that effective service of the CN has not been shown, it follows that it was wrong for the CPN to refer to the issue of the CN on 11 September 2024. It is plainly right that as the CN was not served then the amount of penalty in the CPN could not include a daily rate under regulation 45(2)(a)(ii). As a principle, that was accepted by the EA’s Counsel. It follows that there was an error of fact in the CPN relying upon the service of the CN. In calculating the financial penalty, it had wrongly included a daily penalty for non-compliance with the CN.
94. The Tribunal’s powers under regulation 50 include cancellation of a penalty notice. However, we do not agree with HFS that the CPN was fatally flawed and should be cancelled due to non-service of the CN. That may have been so had the CPN been issued under regulation 46 for failure to comply with the CN, but it was not. This is not an appeal against the CN. Instead, the CPN is explicitly stated to be issued under regulation 45 for failure to undertake an energy audit. The relevance of a CN to the CPN goes to the imposition of a daily penalty under regulation 45(2)(a)(ii). It does not defeat the issue of the CPN in totality.
95. We go on to consider the reasonableness of the CPN under the second ground of appeal before deciding how to exercise our discretion under regulation 50. The relevance of the EN and awareness letters goes to culpability and aggravating/mitigating factors in calculation of the penalty, as considered below.
Was the penalty notice unreasonable?
96. The next question for the Tribunal is whether the imposition of the penalty and the amount are ‘unreasonable’.
97. The EA refers us to the previous First-tier Tribunal decision of Marlborough Sterling Investment Group v EA [2023] UKFTT 681 (GRC) where Judge Bird KC said at [18]: “Unreasonable in this context bears its ordinary meaning i.e. one which having regard to the circumstances is unfair, unsound or excessive.”
98. Our attention is also drawn to the words of Lord Hoffman in SSHD v Rehman[2003] 1 AC 153 at [49] that an inherent limitation of the judicial function in the appellate process is “the need, in matters of judgment and evaluation ofevidence, to show proper deference to the primary decision-maker.”
99. The EA highlights how the First-tier Tribunal reflected such deference in Safeguard World International Holdings Ltd v EA[2024] UKFTT 34 (GRC) at [12] where Judge Neville (as he then was) also applied the same interpretation of ‘unreasonable’ as Judge Bird KC, but added:
“while [the Tribunal] decides the matter for itself, appropriate weight must be afforded to the view taken by the Environment Agency: the regulator entrusted by Parliament to administer the scheme and maintain its integrity and effectiveness, and having expertise and experience in doing so; see Hesham Ali v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 60 at [45].”
100. This Tribunal is not bound by previous FTT decisions, but we concur with both the interpretation and approach taken in those previous decisions. Of course, showing proper deference does not mean that the EA’s decision must be right. The evidence as a whole must still be considered and weighed up before reaching a view. We have taken care to do this.
101. The Tribunal’s powers under regulation 50 of the ESOS Regulations include affirming a penalty notice with such modification as it thinks fit.
102. In essence, the Appellant’s arguments may be distilled to the penalty being disproportionate because: (i) the ESOS scheme was relatively new (ii) it had no knowledge of the scheme or its requirements (iii) it acted quickly to become compliant once aware of the NOI (iv) it is committed to being compliant and has a strong ESG principles (v) it has a 10-year record of compliance with regulatory and enforcement regimes prior to this matter.
103. The ESP published by the EA, as updated in October 2025, has three annexes. Section D of Annex 2 applies to ESOS. It sets out a 4-stepped approach which the EA applied to set the penalty level:
• Step 1 – determine the statutory maximum penalty for the breach.
• Step 2 – decide whether to waive the penalty or set the initial penalty amount by assessing the nature of the breach and any other enforcement positions, in line with section D, in the case of ESOS.
• Step 3 – if a penalty is to be imposed, work out the penalty starting point and penalty range based on culpability (blame) and the size of the organisation.
• Step 4 – set the final penalty amount by assessing the aggravating and mitigating factors and adjust the starting point as appropriate.
104. The Tribunal has applied the same stepped approach to determine if the penalty was unreasonable, it being the established methodology which provides a rational and consistent approach to ESOS enforcement. In doing so, we recognise that the ESP does not have the force of law. It is policy guidance only.
Step 1
105. Pursuant to regulation 45(2)(a)(i) the statutory maximum initial penalty is £50,000. The statutory maximum daily rate is £40,000 calculated at £500 per day starting on the day after the service of the CN. As already indicated, the daily penalty cannot be imposed having found the CN was not effectively served.
106. Therefore, the statutory maximum amount was £50,000 and not £90,000 as stated in the CPN.
Step 2
107. As there was a breach of the ESOS Regulations for failure to undertake an energy audit, we do not consider it appropriate to waive the penalty altogether. That would undermine the integrity of the enforcement provisions and the importance of timely compliance with ESOS. Indeed, waiver could serve to encourage other undertakings to defer compliance for as long as possible.
108. In addition, the CPN specifies that the energy audit was due by 5 June 2024. The very latest date to secure compliance with ESOS was 27 February 2025, being the extended deadline imposed in the EN. It was not until 12 August 2025 that compliance was achieved. Thus, there was a long delay before HFS fulfilled its duties under the ESOS Regulations.
109. At step 2, the initial penalty amount is set by assessing the nature of the breach and the position in line with Section D of the ESP. Section D2.3 of the ESP applies to a failure to undertake an energy audit, as in this case. It states that undertaking an energy audit is a key requirement of ESOS. This breach impacts on the integrity of the ESOS, and the EA will therefore normally issue a penalty for failure to undertake an energy audit.
110. For new entrants to ESOS, in the compliance period in which they first enter the scheme, EA will normally impose a lower initial penalty of up to £5,000 for failure to undertake an energy audit. The EA applied this policy provision to reduce the initial penalty to £5,000 in recognition of the Appellant being a new entrant to the ESOS scheme.
111. The ESP does not elaborate on when the initial penalty starting point might be lower than £5,000. As these are important environmental requirements, we concur that £5,000 is an appropriate initial penalty amount.
Step 3
112. Next, we consider the penalty starting point and penalty range, based on culpability i.e. level of blame, and size of the organisation. The ESP identifies four categories of culpability in descending order of seriousness (i) deliberate (ii) reckless (iii) negligent (iv) low or no culpability.
113. There is no suggestion that HFS intentionally breached or showed a flagrant disregard for the law for its conduct to be deliberate. Nor is there reason to conclude that there was reckless failure by HFS to put in place, and to enforce, such systems as could reasonably be expected in all the circumstances to avoid a breach.
114. ‘Negligent’ means failure by the organisation as a whole to take reasonable care to put in place and enforce proper systems for avoiding commission of the breach. In our judgement, the EA was right to conclude that the conduct of HFS falls within this category. It cannot be considered to be ‘low or no culpability’, which applies to a breach with little or no fault on the part of the organisation as a whole.
115. We found the evidence of Mr Balderson and Mr West credible when they said they had not personally received anything from the EA prior to the NOI. Even so, the system of ensuring official notices were directed to the right person relied on the use of pigeonholes without any record keeping of their receipt. Furthermore, the company had nothing in place to ensure its compliance with the ESOS Regulations. The witnesses said they had never heard of ESOS before receiving the NOI, but the onus was on the company to ensure that someone took responsibility for its ESOS compliance.
116. A categorisation of low or no culpability applies to a breach committed with little or no fault on the part of the organisation as a whole. Reliance cannot be placed on ignorance of the law. The ESOS Regulations 2014 were not new. HFS may have been a fast-growing company, but it still had a duty to be familiar with relevant regulatory requirements such as ESOS and to ensure its own compliance with the law. Its approach had been passive, relying on the fact that sustainability conferences had not mentioned ESOS. It squarely blamed EA for not doing enough to alert HFS to its obligations. That argument goes nowhere. The EA had a general duty to raise awareness, rather than to alert individual undertakings of their responsibilities. As it is, the Tribunal has found that one awareness letter was served as well as the EN prior to the NOI.
117. The Tribunal concurs with the EA’s finding that the Appellant was negligent “due to the failure by the organisation as a whole to take reasonable care to put in place and enforce proper systems for avoiding [the] commission of an offence.”
118. The size of the organisation is determined under the ESP by reference to its turnover. With recorded annual turnover over £93 million for the year ending March 2025, the Appellant falls into the category of a ‘large’ company being one with a turnover of £50 million or more, even if its operating profit is much less.
119. Once the culpability category and size of the company is established, it is an arithmetical exercise to identify the appropriate penalty starting point and penalty range. The EA has correctly applied the ESP by using a multiplier of 0.3 to the initial penalty amount. However, given our finding that the daily penalty amount must be disregarded, it applied the multiplier to the incorrect sum. It should have been applied to the figure of £5,000 instead of £45,000 to set the penalty starting point at £1,500. The penalty range was also incorrect set at £6,300 to £33,750. It should have been £700 to £3,750.
Step 4
120. Consideration turns to assessment of the aggravating and mitigating factors.
121. In Annex 2 of the ESP, four aggravating factors are identified that could justify an increased penalty. There is no evidence adduced of any financial gain for HFS and we disregard it as a factor against criterion a. As a first-time entrant, there is no history of non-compliance, to engage factor b. No personal circumstances, are identified in respect of factor d. That leaves factor c., being the “Attitude of the no-compliant person – the persons reaction, including cooperation, self-reporting, acceptance of responsibility, exemplary conduct and steps taken to remedy the problem”
122. The EA identified one aggravating factor in the CPN falling within factor c. It refers to the absence of communication or action until after the issue of the NOI. HFS considers this harsh and unfair given its prior lack of knowledge of the ESOS Regulations and requirements. We disagree. We have found that the first awareness letter dated 14 December 2023 was deemed served as was EN that was served early December 2025. Moreover, it is apparent from the stated lack of awareness that HFS clearly did not have appropriate measures in place to identify and respond to its obligations under the ESOS Regulations.
123. Whilst we accept that HFS takes its regulatory responsibilities very seriously, as illustrated by its ESG policy, that does not mitigate its non-compliance with the ESOS regime.
124. By the time of issue of the CPN on 21 January 2026, HFS was compliant with ESOS having submitted its Notification of Compliance on 12 August 2026. This was identified by the EA in the CPN as a mitigating factor. In addition, the EA recognised that there had been communication by HFS in response to the NOI and engagement with a Lead Assessor. We agree that these are mitigating factors to which we attribute moderate weight.
125. HFS argued a genuine lack of awareness. We accept that the communications from Mr Balderson to EA following receipt of the NOI are consistent with someone previously unaware of ESOS and earlier communications. We also recognise that HFS’s reactions demonstrated willingness to engage with EA and an intent on behalf of the company to become compliant. That was reinforced by compliance being achieved quickly thereafter. We give credit to HFS for the steps taken to promptly and proactively engage with the EA albeit late in the process, and ones that were required to be taken.
126. We found the witnesses plausible in their evidence that they did not personally know of ESOS prior to the NOI. Nevertheless, ignorance of legal obligations is not good mitigation. The responsibility was that of the company as a legal entity. It was incumbent upon the corporate body to ascertain and comply with any applicable legal requirements. That included its legal obligations under the ESOS Regulations.
127. We do not consider that HFS’s compliance with other regulatory requirements over a period of 10-years or so is a matter to which much weight can properly be given by way of mitigation. Our focus is on what HFS did or did not do in respect of ESOS.
128. Achieving compliance did not prevent the subsequent issue of the CPN or render its issue unreasonable. There had been non-compliance with the law after all. The issue of a penalty is intended to be punitive, and the compliance is a matter to be reflected in the amount, where appropriate having considered all relevant matters.
129. The Appellants draw attention to ITH Group Limited v Environment Agency [2026] UKTT 00740 (GRC) where the EA had set the penalty at the top point of the identified penalty range. On appeal, the FTT reduced this by half in circumstances where there was a lack of effective response to the NOI, there remained non-compliance with ESOS at the date of issue of the CPN, and no proper systems were in place to avoid commission of the breach. The Appellant argues that HFS’s conduct was more favourable and warrants a greater reduction or cancellation. Of course, every appeal must be determined on its individual merits which will be fact sensitive. The circumstances of this appeal differ.
130. In reaching our conclusion on the appeal under regulation 48(1)(a), the penalty has already been reduced from £25,650 to a maximum of £5,000 at step 2 and a penalty range of up to £3,750 at step 3.
131. In our view, it is not appropriate to separate out the duties of the company as the legal entity holding statutory responsibility under ESOS from its individual directors. We do not consider that the lack of knowledge of HFS’s directors of the statutory scheme in any way mitigates the severity of the breach. If an undertaking could avoid or achieve a reduction in a penalty by reason of its officers or directors’ ignorance of the law, then it would open the floodgates to such arguments and undermine enforceability of the scheme.
132. Whilst giving a level of deference to the EA as the appointed body tasked with enforcing the ESOS Regulations, we consider it reasonable on balance to keep the amount of penalty at the starting point of £1,500.
133. We conclude that it was unreasonable for the CPN to set a penalty with reference to the issue of the CN which has not been demonstrated to have been served.
Conclusion
134. The Tribunal concludes that the CPN in this case should be affirmed but modified with a financial penalty of £1,500.
135. The appeal therefore succeeds in part, and the Tribunal directs accordingly.
Signed: Judge Saward Date: 4 November 2026
For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our environmental lawyer in Paris.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).