Administrative United Kingdom
KS v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: PA/81581/2025
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
| Heard at Manchester | |
| On 28 October 2026 |
Before
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL Judge MCQUILLAN
Between
KS
(anonymity direction MADE)
Appellant
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellants: Ms Talbot, Counsel
For the Respondent: Mr Payne, Home Office Presenting Officer.
DECISION AND REASONS
1. The Appellant, who is a citizen of Somalia, appeals under the provisions of the Nationality, Immigration, and Asylum Act 2002 against the Respondent’s decision dated 9 July 2025, to refuse their protection claim made on 17 April 2025.
Anonymity Direction
2. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because the importance of facilitating the discharge of the obligations of the United Kingdom (‘UK’) under the Refugee Convention outweighs the principle of open justice.
Background
3. The background to this appeal is set out in the documentation contained on myHMCTS. The Appellant is a 24 year old Somalian man. He arrived in the UK on 17 April 2025 having left Somalia on 20 January 2025 by plane.
4. The Appellant claims to fear persecution if returned to Somalia on the basis that in 2018 he was accused by Al Shabaab of being a spy and was beaten by them. He was being forced to pay Al-Shabaab money and when he was unable to pay them due to ill health he was detained and asked to join them. He refused and was released and given 5 days to change his mind. He left and went to Mogadishu for nearly 3 weeks during which time they Al-Shabaab killed his father and arrested his brother. He fears if he is returned to Somalia Al-Shabaab will kill him.
5. The Respondent accepted the Appellant’s nationality and identity and that he was a member of the Sheekhaal sub clan, Loboge. They also accepted that he had issues with Al-Shabaab and refusing to join them.
Hearing
Issues in dispute
6. I discussed the position with Mr Payne and Ms Talbot and it was agreed that the issues in dispute were;
(a) Can the Appellant relocate to Mogadishu
(b) Has he family support
(c) In the alternative has he clan support
(d) Would relocation be reasonable (based on the factors in MOJ[1])
7. Ms Talbot confirmed that she would be pursuing any claim based on a breach of the Appellant’s article 8 rights or those under article 3 in respect of any medical condition. It was agreed by both representatives that the case was about the risk he faced on return and the steps he could take to seek protection by relocation and that this would be assessed on the lower standard.
Evidence and submissions
8. The Appellant gave evidence with the assistance of a Somalian interpreter and was cross examined. Mr Payne and Ms Talbot made submissions.
Legal Framework
9. To succeed in an appeal on asylum grounds, the Appellant must show a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason (race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, political opinion). The burden of proof rests on the Appellant. As the asylum claim was made on or after 28 June 2022, pursuant to s32 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 (‘the 2022 Act’), in considering whether the Appellant qualifies as a refugee, I must apply a two stage test. I must first determine the following matters on the balance of probabilities:
(a) whether the Appellant has a characteristic which could cause them to fear persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion (or has such a characteristic attributed to them by an actor of persecution), and
(b) whether the Appellant does in fact fear such persecution in their country of nationality as a result of that characteristic.
10. If I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the Appellant does have such a characteristic, and fears persecution as a result of that characteristic, I must go on to determine whether, applying the lower standard of proof, there is a reasonable likelihood that:
(a) the Appellant would be persecuted for a Convention reason on return;
(b) that there would be insufficient protection; and
(c) they could not internally relocate.
11. To succeed on an appeal on humanitarian protection grounds the Appellant must not be a refugee; they must show substantial grounds for believing that they would face a real risk of suffering serious harm in their country of origin. The burden of proof rests on the Appellant.
Findings
12. In this decision, I refer to JCK (Botswana) [2024] UKUT. I am directed by that case to address each of the questions posed by section 32 NABA 2022 expressly and sequentially and I do so. I have taken account of everything I have heard, and considered all the documentary evidence I have been referred to by the parties. I have carefully considered all the evidence in the round, in line with the guidance in Ravichandran v SSHD [1996] Imm AR 97 and Karanakaran v SSHD 2000 EWCA Civ.
13. In a case such as this where it is not in question that there is a convention reason and a subjective fear the burden is on the Appellant to show to the lower standard that there is a real risk of persecution on return. It is well established that this ‘standard of proof’ could more accurately be described as an assessment of risk and that even with a risk as low as 10% an Appellant could succeed.[2]
14. Mr Payne submitted that the Appellant could obtain protection from his uncle who had helped him flee to Mogadishu and funded his departure from Somali. He questioned that the Appellant had said that he had lost contact with his uncle and although he had tried to contact neighbours he had not had contact with his uncle since he spoke to him when in France. Mr Payne also submitted that it was not credible that the Appellant had lost all contact with his wife, his ex-wife and his 5 children. He suggested that the Appellant’s wife was receiving support from the family and potentially from the clan too and that if returned the Appellant could access this support also. He submitted that the Appellant’s uncle was a businessman and had access to funds and that the Appellant would have the support of his clan and could work.
15. Ms Talbot submitted that the Respondent’s submissions were in relation to the plausibility of the Appellant’s account and that his credibility had been largely accepted. She cautioned against making adverse plausibility findings. I accept that at hearing and in the reasons for refusal letter and Review (which Mr Payne did not consider to assist the Tribunal) there was little in the way of an attack on the Appellant’s credibility outside of a reliance on section 8 of the 2004 Act. She submitted that the Appellant would be returning to Somalia with no money and having lost contact with his family. She highlighted that he gave oral evidence that when he asked his clan for support they told him to leave the country.
16. In terms of risk Mr Payne submitted that because the Appellant was not linked to the Government he would not be targeted by Al-Shabab[3] and when I asked about the risk he faced as a previous victim of torture Mr Payne submitted that this torture took place other than in Mogadishu and therefore the presumption in paragraph 399K of the Rules is neutralised to an extent. He submitted that the objective evidence was that the humanitarian situation did not amount to a breach of article 2 or 3[4].
17. I accept Ms Talbot’s submission that there is a real risk Appellant would face persecution on return to Mogadishu. The Respondent’s own CPIN on Al-Shabab confirms at 3.1.2
3.1.2 Al Shabab remains the primary militant group active in Somalia and the main threat to peace and security including in Mogadishu. Their goal is to establish an Islamic state across the country; it vigorously opposes the ‘western’ backed government and its allies. The group’s strongholds are in south and central Somalia but its sphere of influence extends beyond these areas. While Mogadishu remains under the control of the FGS and Al Shabab does not have an overt presence, the group is able to infiltrate the city and maintains a network of informants and members there.
18. The Appellant’s account that he had previously been tortured by Al-Shabab was, in effect, accepted by the Respondent. I acknowledge Mr Payne’s point that this did not happen in Mogadishu but note that there is an Al-Shabab presence in Mogadishu. Ms Talbot submits that the Appellant is not an ordinary civilian because of his previous past encounters with Al-Shabab, his brother’s detention and his father’s death. The network of informers referred to by the Respondent do pose a real risk to someone in the Appellant’s position and whilst he was able to evade detection previously the risk is that his kinship and clan ties may in fact be the route that his presence becomes known to Al-Shabab.
19. Whilst the Appellant’s account of his loss of contact with his family and Uncle is less convincing I acknowledge that otherwise truthful Appellants can embellish and even fabricate aspects of their claims to increase their prospects of succeeding in their Appeal and I do not find that any doubts I may have about aspects of the Appellant’s evidence are sufficient to lead me to conclude that there is not a reasonable degree of likelihood that the Appellant will face a risk of persecution on return. I have considered the issues set out at headnote ix of MOJ and whilst it is possible that there may be more family support to establish himself than the Appellant admits, the risk at the hands of Al-Shabab that exists would not be alleviated by such support, which is largely to do with the reasonableness of return.
The 2022 Act
20. Adopting the approach of the Upper Tribunal I now turn to the specific provisions of section 32 of the 2022 Act.
Section 32(2)(a): Convention Ground.
21. Under s32(2)(a) I am firstly required to determine, on the balance of probabilities:
(a) whether the asylum seeker has a characteristic which could cause them to fear persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion (or has such a characteristic attributed to them by an actor of persecution)
22. It was submitted by Ms Talbot, and not disputed by the Respondent, that the Appellant had the characteristic of imputed political opinion, namely a view contrary to that of Al-Shabab, and I find on balance that this could cause them to fear persecution.
Section 32(2) (b); Subjective Fear
23. Section 32(2)(b) requires the decision-maker to also determine, on the balance of probabilities.
(b) whether the asylum seeker does in fact fear such persecution in their country of nationality (or in a case where they do not have a nationality, the country of their former habitual residence) as a result of that characteristic.
24. Similarly it was not disputed that the Appellant did, in fact, fear persecution as a result of their imputed political opinion and I accept that, on balance, this is correct.
25. Having satisfied myself on the balance of probabilities that the Appellant does have a convention reason, and fears persecution as a result of that reason, I must go on to determine whether, applying the lower standard of proof, there is a reasonable likelihood that:
(a) the Appellant would be persecuted for a Convention reason on return;
(b) that there would be insufficient protection; and
(c) they could not internally relocate.
26. The Upper Tribunal characterised the first of these questions as an evaluation of objective risk.
Section 32(4)(a); risk of persecution
27. To answer this question I must ask myself whether there is a reasonable likelihood that if the Appellant were returned to XXXXX:
(a) they would be persecuted as a result of the characteristic mentioned in subsection (2)(a)
Section 32(4)(b): protection
(b) they would not be protected as mentioned in section 34.
28. Section 34 states
Article 1(A)(2): protection from persecution
(1)For the purposes of Article 1(A)(2) of the Refugee Convention, protection from persecution can be provided by—
(a)the State, or
(b)any party or organisation, including any international organisation, controlling the State or a substantial part of the territory of the State.
(2)An asylum seeker is to be taken to be able to avail themselves of protection from persecution if—
(a)the State, party or organisation mentioned in subsection (1) takes reasonable steps to prevent the persecution by operating an effective legal system for the detection, prosecution and punishment of acts constituting persecution, and
(b)the asylum seeker is able to access the protection.
Section 32(5): internal relocation
(5) The determination under subsection (4) must also include a consideration of the matter mentioned in section 35 (internal relocation).
29. I take all of these questions, which are to be answered applying the lower standard of proof, together. For the reasons given above I find that there is a real risk that the Appellant would be persecuted if returned to Somalia. It was accepted that he could not seek protection but I further find for the reasons above that relocation to Mogadishu would not provide him with protection from the risk of persecution. The continued presence of Al-Shabab in Mogadishu and the accepted network of spies together with the Appellant’s past interactions with them including past persecution and his family background all lead me to conclude that there is a reasonable degree of likelihood that the Appellant would not be protected from the risk of persecution by relocating to Mogadishu.
30. I find that the Appellant has a well founded fear of persecution and allow his Asylum appeal.
Humanitarian protection
31. As I have found that the Appellant has a well-founded fear of persecution for a convention reason and is therefore a refugee his claim under Humanitarian Protection must fail.
Notice Of Decision
The appeal on Asylum grounds is allowed
The appeal on Humanitarian protection grounds is dismissed.
Anonymity Direction
Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellant is granted anonymity.
No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including their names or addressed, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify him. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
To The Respondent
Fee Award
No fee has been paid or is payable and therefore there can be no fee award.
Signed CA McQuillan Date: 9 November 2026
First-tier Tribunal Judge C McQuillan
Notes
[1] MOJ & Ors (Return to Mogadishu) Somalia CG [2014] UKUT 00442 (IAC)
[2] MAH (Egypt) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2023] EWCA Civ 216 paragraphs 51-52, Singh LJ.
[3] Country policy and information note: Mogadishu: Al Shabab and the security situation, Somalia, July 2025 paragraph 3.1.1
[4] Country policy and information note: humanitarian situation in Mogadishu, Somalia, July 2025 paragraph 3.1.1
For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our immigration lawyer in Paris.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).