Property United Kingdom

Brickfield Properties Limited v Paul Haines & Anor

Official source

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKUT 421 (LC)

Case Nos: LC-2026-246

IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL (LANDS CHAMBER)

AN APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE FIRST-TIER PROPERTY CHAMBER

Ref: LON/OOBK/OLR/2025/0774

Royal Courts of Justice, Strand, London, WC2A 2LL

28 October 2026

TRIBUNALS, COURTS AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 2007

LEASEHOLD ENFRANCHISEMENT – PREMIUM – First-tier Tribunal substituting its own view of the short leasehold value for the valuers’ agreed position without giving the parties opportunity to comment – appeal allowed

BETWEEN:

BRICKFIELD PROPERTIES LIMITED

Appellant

-and-

PAUL AND SARAH HAINES

Respondent

33 Oslo Court, Prince Albert Road,

London, NW8 7EN

Judge Elizabeth Cooke

Determination on written representations

Ms Nicola Muir for the appellant, instructed by Wallace LLP

Mr Steven Harding MRICS for the respondents, instructed by Attwells Solicitors LLP

© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2026

The following cases were referred to in this decision:

Daejan Investments Limited v Collins [2024] UKUT 26 (LC)

Deritend Investments (Birkdale) Limitedv Fung Tai Engineering Company Limited [2025] UKUT 324 (LC)

Introduction

1. This is an appeal from a determination by the First-tier Tribunal ("the FTT") of the price to be paid for an extended lease of Flat 33 Oslo Court, Prince Albert Road, London, SW87EN pursuant to the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993.

2. The appeal has been decided under the Tribunal’s written representations procedure. The appellant landlord, Brickfield Properties Limited, was represented by Ms Nicola Muir of counsel; for the respondent leaseholders, Paul and Sarah Haines, written representations were provided by Mr Steven Harding MRICS.

The legal background

3. The Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 gives to qualifying tenants of flats the right to acquire a new lease, after giving notice in accordance with section 42, on payment of the premium calculated as provided by Schedule 13. Paragraph 2 of Schedule 13 provides that the premium payable for the new lease is the sum of (1) the diminution in the value of the landlord's interest resulting from the grant, (2) the landlord's share (50%) of the marriage value, and (3) any compensation payable to the landlord under paragraph 5.

4. The calculations both of the diminution in value of the landlord's interest and of the marriage value require a value to be ascribed to the new lease, and thence to the notional value of the freehold interest with vacant possession ("FHVP"). A further component of the calculation of the marriage value is the value of the existing lease. Conventionally that value is ascertained by the use of a "relativity", that is, a percentage figure that enables the value of the existing short lease to be calculated by reference to the FHVP where market evidence is unavailable or unreliable.

5. As the Tribunal (Judge Cooke and Mr Mark Higgin FRICS FIRRV) put it in Daejan Investments Limited v Collins [2024] UKUT 26 (LC):

“ Relativity is a figure that enables the value of the existing short lease, albeit without Act rights, to be calculated from the FHVP. In circumstances where there is little or no evidence of existing values it is normal valuation practice to use relativity graphs, based on a wider sample of transactions and published from time to time by surveying practices engaged in this specialist area of work. Relativity is expressed as a percentage, to be applied to the FHVP to yield the value of a lease of the length in question without Act rights. Relativity is thus used as a tool to derive a value.”

6. In Deritend Investments (Birkdale) Limitedv Fung Tai Engineering Company Limited [2025] UKUT 324 (LC) the Tribunal (the Deputy President, Martin Rodger KC and Mrs Diane Martin MRICS FAAV) observed, at paragraph 47, that where a short leasehold value derived from comparable properties gives rise to a relativity that is significantly different from what is indicated by the standard graphs, that should “have run alarm bells and … prompted a more critical examination of the evidence”.

The facts, and the FTT’s decision

7. Flat 33, Oslo Court, is a first-floor purpose built flat set in a seven-storey Grade 11 listed building constructed in about 1935 and containing about one hundred and thirty-three self-contained flats.

8. By a notice of claim dated 22 July 2024 the respondents exercised the right to the grant of a new lease of the flat; their notice proposed a premium of £73,250. At the time, they held their existing underlease for a term of 99 years with effect from 25 December 1974; the unexpired term at the valuation date was 49.42 years. On 17 March 2022 the appellant, as the competent landlord, served a counter-notice admitting the validity of the claim and proposing a premium of £168,900 for the grant of a new lease.

9. The parties were unable to agree the premium payable and the respondents made an application to the FTT for a determination of the premium on February 2025. Their valuer was Mr Steven Harding MRICS; the appellant relied on a valuation report by Mr Robin Sharp BSc FRICS. The elements of the premium that they could not agree were the FHVP and the relativity/short lease value.

10. The FTT determined the FHVP at £563,000, by reference to comparable properties. There is no appeal in respect of that decision.

11. Turning to the short leasehold value, the two valuers’ figures were very close to each other. Mr Sharp for the landlord took relativity as70.23%, being an average of the two standard graphs (Savills 2016 at 70.44% and Gerald Eve 2016 at 70.02%), giving a short lease value on the basis of his figure for the FHVP of £400,810. Mr Harding used market evidence, looking at four properties and weighting them to arrive at £400,000. Mr Sharp’s figure yielded a lower premium. The FTT said this:

“21. Mr Harding used evidence of four short leasehold transactions in the block. Mr Sharp considered three of these to be too dated and when he analysed 22 Oslo Court this calculates a relativity of 83.06% compared to the average of the two graphs' (Savills and Gerald Eve) Therefore, he took the average of the two graphs. This is, of course, now considered standard methodology where there is no suitable market evidence.

22. Again, the Tribunal agrees with Mr Sharp and considers three of the transactions put forward by Mr Harding are too dated and provide an unacceptable margin of tolerance. Where the Tribunal departs from Mr Sharp is to include 22 Oslo Court which completed in May 2023 with an unexpired term of 50.5 years.

23. In the First Tier Tribunal case for 11 Oslo Court (LON/ooBK/OLR/2021/0005) the relativity was determined at 82.95% for a unexpired lease term of 53.65 compared to the Savills graph of 73.7%.

24. Therefore, the Tribunal preferred a blended approach in the calculation of the existing lease value. The Tribunal accepted Mr Sharp's calculations for 22 Oslo Court at 83.06% and 70.23% based on the graphs.

Relativity Calculation

25. The Tribunal took an average of the two figures at 76.65%.

26. Therefore, the Tribunal adopts a freehold value of £563,000 and a short lease value of £433,510 (77% relativity).

Accordingly, the Tribunal determines the appropriate premium for the lease extension to be £87,815. A copy of its valuation calculation is annexed to this decision.”

12. The landlord appeals that calculation of the short leasehold value with permission from this Tribunal.

The grounds of appeal

13. In the grounds of appeal Ms Muir points out that the FTT’s short lease value of 433,510 was considerably higher than the figure put forward by either expert, and thus overrode the experts’ consensus despite the fact that neither expert had been cross-examined on the short lease value because of that consensus. Furthermore it was based on a relativity higher than the relativity produced by the accepted graphs (Savills 2016 at 70.44% and Gerald Eve 2016 at 70.02%), derived by averaging the market evidence and the graph evidence; yet that methodology had not been put to the parties for comment at the hearing, and indeed was disapproved in Daejan Investments Limited v Collins at paragraph 83 and 85.

14. Accordingly it is said that the FTT erred in its assessment of the market evidence, erred in its assessment of the valuers’ evidence, and was wrong to reach a conclusion that had not been put to the experts.

15. It is also said that the FTT was wrong to place such heavy reliance on the value of 22 Oslo Court, which neither expert regarded as reliable, and wrong to round its relativity figure of 76.65% to 77% without explanation.

The respondents’ case in the appeal

16. In response Mr Harding points out that although the experts’ figures for the short leasehold value were not far apart, they were not reached by the same method. Neither argued that it was wrong to take an average of the market evidence and the figures from the graphs, and a blended approach is not unusual. The FTT was entitled to have regard to 22 Oslo Court. In a previous case, as the FTT said, it had determined a relativity for 11 Oslo Court of 82.95%. There is no reason why the FTT should not round up its relativity figure to 77%.

17. The respondents’ case in the appeal is that the FTT reached its conclusion on the basis of the evidence before it; all the evidence was exposed to the parties.

Discussion and conclusion

18. I agree that the FTT used the evidence that was before it; but the problem is that what it did with that evidence was not proposed by either party and not put to either party. It is basic to the fair resolution of disputes that if a court or tribunal favours an idea or a solution that neither party has suggested it must allow the parties the opportunity to comment on it. Neither expert here was cross-examined on the short leasehold value because their figures were so close; the FTT was, according to Ms Muir, “invited to take a view on which figure should be adopted between £400,000 and £400,810.”

19. The fact that neither expert was cross-examined on the short leasehold value is crucial; if the FTT was not prepared to accept that the matter was pretty much agreed it should have told the parties so and offered its view for their comment.

20. That alone makes the FTT’s conclusion unfair and I set it aside.

21. In addition, I agree with the appellant that the averaging of the average of the graphs with the market evidence was unsatisfactory. Market evidence is of course always best where it is available; the graphs are used where it is not, and where it is they can be used as a cross-check. But the graphs themselves are the product of a great deal of data. To add in an isolated figure and re-average is to distort the graphs. In the absence of any support for that method from the experts the FTT’s adoption of it was unsatisfactory and irrational. It appears to have been influenced by its own conclusion in a previous case from Oslo Court (see paragraph 23 of the FTT’s reasons, set out at paragraph 11 above) but how that conclusion was derived is not known.

22. Accordingly there is ample reason to set aside the FTT’s decision, without the need to consider whether 22 Oslo Court was a sensible comparable or whether it was right to round up 76.65% to 77%.

23. The FTT was presented with two figures for the short leasehold value, one derived from market evidence and the other from the average of the two graphs. The figure derived from market evidence is so close to the average of the graphs that that in itself indicates its likely reliability. Accordingly, and in light of the Tribunal’s consistent preference for market evidence where possible, I substitute the Tribunal’s decision that the short leasehold value was £400,000 as Mr Harding argued on the basis of market evidence. The parties have agreed that that means the premium payable for the new lease is £104,570.

Judge Elzabeth Cooke

28 October 2026

Right of appeal

Any party has a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal on any point of law arising from this decision. The right of appeal may be exercised only with permission. An application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal must be sent or delivered to the Tribunal so that it is received within 1 month after the date on which this decision is sent to the parties (unless an application for costs is made within 14 days of the decision being sent to the parties, in which case an application for permission to appeal must be made within 1 month of the date on which the Tribunal’s decision on costs is sent to the parties). An application for permission to appeal must identify the decision of the Tribunal to which it relates, identify the alleged error or errors of law in the decision, and state the result the party making the application is seeking. If the Tribunal refuses permission to appeal a further application may then be made to the Court of Appeal for permission.

At Kohen Avocats, our real estate lawyer in Paris can review your situation.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.