Commercial United Kingdom

Camstar Herbs Limited v Advisory Insurance Brokers Limited

Official source

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWHC 2649 (Comm)

Case No: LM-2024-000177

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE

BUSINESS AND PROPERTY DIVISION

LONDON CIRCUIT COMMERCIAL COURT

Royal Courts of Justice, Rolls Building

Fetter Lane, London, EC4A 1NL

Date: 27/10/2026

Before :

HIS HONOUR JUDGE BIRD SITTING AS A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Between :

CAMSTAR HERBS LIMITED Claimant
– and –
ADVISORY INSURANCE BROKERS LIMITED (T/A MORGAN LAW INSURANCE BROKERS) Defendant

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Ben Elkington KC (instructed by Edwin Coe LLP) for the Claimant;

Daniel Shapiro KC & James Sharpe (instructed by CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP) for the Defendant

Hearing dates: 21, 22, 23, 27, 28 and 30 April 2026

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Approved Judgment

This judgment was handed down remotely at 14.00pm on 27 October 2026 by circulation to the parties or their representatives by e-mail and by release to the National Archives.

………………………..

HHJ BIRD

His Honour Judge Bird:

Introduction

1. The Claimant is the largest producer of dried parsley in the world outside China. It has 2 processing plants in Suffolk (Camstar 1 and Camstar 2) where it takes freshly harvested parsley, dries it and then prepares it for sale. About 60% of the harvested parsley goes through Camstar 1.

2. In the early evening of 16 August 2021 there was a fire at Camstar 1. No one was injured, but the Claimant’s capacity to process parsley was severely limited. After the fire Camstar made substantial payments (“ongoing payments”) to farmers and to its harvester. Whether those payments could be claimed under a business interruption insurance policy lies at the heart of this claim.

3. At the time of the fire Camstar had the benefit of an insurance policy issued by Aviva and recommended by the Defendant, Camstar’s broker. The policy included business interruption cover on an “insured profit” or “gross profit” basis.

4. This is a claim against Camstar’s insurance broker. Camstar’s case is that, in breach of contract or negligently, the broker failed to arrange adequate insurance cover so that the ongoing payments were covered. The nature of its business was such that a gross profit policy would be insufficient. An alternative form of business interruption policy, written on a gross revenue basis, ought to have been in place.

5. The extent of the duties owed to Camstar by the Defendant is not in issue. The broad issues that arise for determination are therefore issues of breach, causation and loss: Is the broker in breach? If so, has that breach caused loss to Camstar which the law would see as recoverable against the broker?

6. The Defendant asserts that the ongoing payments were in fact insured and so could have been the subject of a valid claim. If that is right, then a further causation question arises: was the failure to claim those payments sufficient to break any causal connection between the Defendant’s breach (if established) and Camstar’s loss?

7. The Defendant also argues that if gross revenue cover had been arranged, Camstar would have been in no better position because it would need to give credit in the same amount as the ongoing payments.

8. There are separate issues on quantum, particularly on how the amount of the ongoing payments was calculated.

9. In order to decide these issues it is necessary to explore how Camstar’s business worked before the fire, understand the workings of the incepted policy and ascertain the nature of the ongoing payments.

Dealings between the parties and the placement of insurance

10. It is important to understand that there is a “critical difference” between a policy written on an insured profit (or gross profit) basis and a policy written on a gross revenue basis. There was common ground between the insurance professionals I heard from (experts and those experienced in the field) that a gross profit policy affords no cover for “purchases”. A gross revenue policy on the other hand covers purchases. Both types of policy require credit to be given for “savings” brought about as a result of the insured peril.

11. Before 2018, Camstar’s insurance was written on a gross revenue basis. In 2018 before renewal, with a 36-month indemnity and a sum insured of £45,000,000 the premium for gross revenue cover (provided by AXA) had been £34,000. Renewal was quoted at £37,009. Having provided that quote and recommended that cover, the Defendant then changed its mind and recommended a cheaper quote of £29,904 from Aviva, apparently believing it was for the same cover. However, the Aviva policy offered “insured profit” cover. That appears from a letter to the Defendant from Aviva dated 27 March 2018 which immediately preceded the Defendant’s recommendation. In opening, Mr Elkington KC suggested that the Defendant did not understand the difference between the two bases of cover. He referred to an email sent to Camstar on 28 March 2018 which referred to a substantial saving in this alternative quotation and to a recommendation letter of the same date also sent to Camstar. Any reasonable reading of the recommendation would lead to the plain and obvious conclusion that Aviva was offering the same cover offered by AXA but at a substantially lower price. The letter noted that Camstar required a Gross revenue policy but recommended a gross profit policy.

12. Unsurprisingly when offered the alternative to pay less for what was said to be the same cover, Camstar took it. No advice about the change in cover was given. There is no indication that the Defendant was aware of the difference. The same cover carried on at different premiums up to and including the renewal immediately preceding the fire.

13. The evidence on which the liability claim is based was not in issue. I did not hear from Ms Shearing the broker who is said to have acted negligently. She did provide a two page witness statement in which she explained she had retired in May 2022, she said she cannot remember any details of the Claimant’s account and she stated she was not willing to consider a small bundle of contemporaneous documents.

Camstar’s business in outline

14. Parsley is a difficult crop to grow and harvest.

15. Once harvested, it must be dried within a short time. That means that all growers must be close to the processing plant. All Camstar’s growers were within 25 miles. Camstar engages the services of a specialist contractor to harvest the parsley. The harvester uses bespoke machinery and is paid a variable rate depending on how far the grower is from the processing plant.

16. Growers can expect 2 or 3 harvests (or cuts) of parsley in a year. They are paid per kilogram of dried parsley derived from their crop. The rate of payment varies according to the quality of the crop. There are 3 grades. A is the best quality, C the worst, and B is between the two. Non-irrigated (or “heavy”) land would usually yield 2 good “cuts”. Irrigated (or “light”) land would usually require a third cut to reach the same total yield.

17. The average yield of dried parsley per acre of parsley cut (explained by Mr Keach) was 1,209.16kg in 2021 and 1,124.23kg in 2025 (“not as good a year as 2021” but with some record-breaking yields).

18. Parsley cannot be grown in the same field year after year. It requires a rotation of around 1 in 5 years. There is some doubt about the precise contractual terms on which growers agreed to grow parsley for Camstar. The precise detail of the contracts does not matter. For the purposes of this judgment, I am satisfied the following is an accurate summary of the arrangements:

a. Growers buy parsley seed from Camstar.

b. They plant (or drill) the seed in early Spring and cultivate it.

c. At appropriate times between July and November (with the interval depending on the weather) the crop is harvested (or cut). There may be 2 or 3 cuts.

d. After the first cut (which takes the leaves at the top of the parsley plant) the grower would then mow the stalk. The parsley then regrows from the root.

e. After the third cut, the plant would be ploughed in.

f. The cost of harvesting is met by Camstar but charged back to the grower.

g. After drying of each batch following each cut, Camstar informs the grower of the dried weight and grade for the crop received.

h. In 2021 Camstar paid growers a gross rate of £1.52 per kilo for grade A parsley; £1.45 for grade B and 70p for grade C. The charge back in respect of harvesting (a deduction from the price that would be paid) was 40p, 38p or (for at least 1 farm very close to the plant) 32p per kilo depending on the location of the farm. For grade A the price paid was £1.12; £1.14 or (in at least 1 case) £1.20 per kilo.

i. The grower invoices Camstar with an allowance for the cost of harvesting.

19. Camstar is wholly reliant on the growers for its business. If the growers decided not to grow parsley Camstar would not be able to function because it would have nothing to process.

The incepted policy

20. The relevant policy includes business interruption cover.

21. The policy covers gross profit which it calls “Insured Profit" (“IP”) defined as the sum of 2 elements: “reduction in Turnover” (“Tr”) and any “increase in cost of working” (“ICoW”) less certain savings (“S”) made as a result of the occurrence of the insured peril.

22. Savings are defined as “any savings during the Indemnity Period in business charges or expenses, payable out of Insured profit, which reduce or cease due to damage”

23. The following definitions appear:

a. Reduction in Turnover is calculated as the product of the “Rate of Insured Profit” (“RiP”) and the drop in turnover caused by the peril (“Td”).

b. The Rate of Insured Profit is “Insured Profit”(“IP”) “earned on and expressed as a percentage of Turnover during the financial year immediately before the date of damage”

c. Insured Profit is calculated (on the facts of the present case) as Turnover (during the financial year immediately before the date of damage (“Tprev”)) less “Uninsured Working Expenses”

d. Uninsured Working Expenses (“UWE”) are defined as “purchases of materials for production or re-sale less any discounts received”

e. Increase in cost of working is defined as “any additional expense [the insured] necessarily and reasonably incur solely to prevent or limit a reduction in turnover during the Indemnity Period [36 months] which but for such additional expenses would have taken place due to the Damage”

24. The insured sum is therefore arrived at as follows, with each of the following sub paragraphs applying relevant definitions:

a. The insured sum = Tr + ICoW – S

b. = (RiP)Td + ICoW – S

c. = [(Tprev – UWE)/Tprev]Td + ICoW – S

25. In summary, as a matter of mathematics and as was common ground, the cover is intended to be adequate where the insured’s purchases of “material for production” (uninsured working expenses) decline in proportion to turnover after the occurrence of an insured peril.

26. Where the insured’s purchases of “material for production” or purchases (uninsured working expenses) do not decline in proportion to turnover, the outcome is inadequate. The following demonstrates the point:

a. In the following example, the sum insured is 14.

Defined term
Tprev Turnover in the 12 months pre-peril 100
UWE 30
Td Drop in turnover 20
ICoW Increase cost of working 0
S Savings 0
Sum insured = [(100 – 30)/100] x 20 = 0.7 x 20 14

b. The pre-peril “profit” would have been 70 (100 – 30). If, post peril, the UWE/cost of materials stays constant:

i. The post-peril turnover is 80 (100 – 20 from the table above)

ii. The UWE/cost of materials post peril remains at 30

iii. The “profit” post peril (turnover less materials) is 50

iv. The true loss is 20 (70 – 50)

v. The payment of 14 is therefore inadequate.

c. If post peril, the UWE/cost of material decreases in line with turnover (by 20%):

i. The post-peril turnover is the same

ii. The UWE/cost of materials post peril is 24

iii. The “profit” post peril (turnover less materials) is 56

iv. The true loss is therefore the difference between the pre-peril profit (70) and the post peril profit (56)

v. The payment of 14 is therefore a true measure of loss.

The policy in practice

27. The policy centres on what might be described as basic pre-peril profit. That sum (which is not easily describable in accounting terms) is calculated as the pre-peril turnover less the costs of purchasing materials for production (UWE). That sum (basic pre-peril profit) is then expressed as a proportion of pre-peril turnover, allowing the insurer to understand what percentage of pre-peril turnover was basic profit. That proportion is then applied to the loss in turnover suffered as a result of the peril. The result is (on the assumption the ratio of profit to turnover remains the same post-peril) the amount of basic profit lost as a result of the reduction in turnover.

28. In closing Mr Elkington KC summarised the position as follows: “An insured taking out insured profit cover deducts UWE (such as purchase costs) from turnover in order to calculate the insured profit. Thus, the UWE (including purchase costs) are not insured. The insurer is then obliged to pay a rate in the pound that assumes that the UWE including purchase costs will reduce in line with turnover whether they actually do or not.”

29. Mr Glynn (whose evidence I return to below) described the workings of the policy in general terms. He was not called as an expert witness but I found his explanations helpful:

a. He referred several times to the concept of an insured person “uninsuring” certain costs. In effect, by choosing this policy, Camstar had elected to exclude the purchase cost of materials for production from the cover.

b. By taking this policy, Camstar was “uninsuring the level of cost that persisted before the fire”. Dealing with the post peril position he said: “the physical delivery of parsley, that’s not what this is about”.

c. What is in fact insured is the “rate of cost to each pound of turnover”

30. Mr Samuelson (whose evidence I again deal with below) was clear in his evidence that the cost of purchases post peril was quite simply excluded. He “concluded that [post peril payments to growers and the harvester] were therefore purchases and were thus an uninsured working expense”. In other words, such costs were simply not insured.

31. I accept these descriptions of how the policy worked in practice. In particular, I accept that “purchases” made post peril are not insured (unless they are ICOW). It seems to me that is simply a consequence of applying the policy definitions in the manner I have described above. Leaving aside the issue of ICOW, post peril purchases are not entirely ignored. Their relevance is however limited. They are only relevant if they impact the drop in turnover. If purchases do not influence turnover (as they do not in the present case) then the purchases are not covered.

32. That is not the same as saying that post-peril purchases fall within the policy definition of UWE. Strictly in my view they do not because they are not purchases “for production”. But the question is not “are post peril purchases UWE?” the question is “are post peril purchases insured?” That is why, in my view, Mr Glynn was right to say that the physical delivery of parsley is irrelevant.

33. The next policy-based question is: are the ongoing costs ICOW? If so, they are insured and should have been claimed. Before turning to that question, I deal with the oral evidence and then the documents that shed light on what happened after the fire.

Evidence from growers and the harvester

34. This evidence is important to understand the nature of the payments made by Camstar. To put the evidence in context it is important to note that the fire happened after the harvesting season had started. A good number of growers had achieved a first cut and some had achieved a second. To reach that stage the land had been prepared, the seed bought and planted, and the crop cared for to the point that it was ready to be harvested.

35. I heard evidence from Mr Adrian Smith. He is the sole director of Evergreen Harvesting Limited (the company engaged by Camstar to harvest the parsley). In addition to running a harvesting business, the company also operates a small farming business at Low Farm to grow parsley. He was asked how the work he did post fire compared to the work he would have done if there had been no fire. His answer was: “I still harvested every field but just in a different manner. So, if it was harvested with parsley harvesters or it was harvested with forage harvesters, to clear the land for the next cuts or to be ploughed in, … I still had to cover all the land with my harvesters”.

36. I also heard evidence from Mr Hull. He farms 320 acres. In 2021, 32 acres were dedicated to parsley production. He had produced evidence to Camstar that in 2021 he had achieved “a very encouraging first cut” of 459kg/acre and was “looking forward to a great year”. He noted, by reference to precise figures, that in previous years when the first cut was over 400kg/acre (2013, 2014, 2017 and 2019) the average yield was 1422kg/acre (and the relevant range was from 1268 kg/acre to 1661 kg/acre) and that the remainder of the 2021 season “continued to be near perfect growing conditions” so that the crop, had it been harvested, would have “easily achieved or surpassed the 1200kg/acre agreed”. In fact, Mr Hull was paid compensation based on invoices he presented of around 1309kg/acre: 450kg/acre for the second cut, 400kg/acre for the third cut and the already achieved 459kg/acre for the first cut. When pressed by Mr Sharpe, Mr Hull denied he was trying to maximise the level of compensation he would receive. Mr Hull said, “I was trying to get fair compensation” and explained the figures were arrived at by reference to past performance. Mr Hull was described by Richard Heaton, the loss adjuster at Sedgwick as “one of the top flight producers.”

37. I heard from Mr Grzelak. At the relevant time he was the farm manager for L. E. Tuckwell Limited. It farms around 1655 acres of which about 99 were used for growing parsley. The evidence was that there had been 2 cuts by the time of the fire. Tuckwell’s were compensated on the basis of a loss of 8695.02 kg at £1.14 per kg. They farmed 4 fields (BRI 1, 3, 4 and 5) with a total acreage of around 102.6 acres. The yields, which Mr Grzelak accepted were lighter than expected and lower grade, were 924kg/acre and 880 kg/acre. There was also an additional sum agreed as compensation in respect of “inputs” of £1,217.30.

38. Mr Forrest is a partner in a firm that runs a 4,000-acre farm. Around 109 acres of the farm were dedicated in 2021 to growing parsley for the purposes of the compensation claim. By the time of the fire the first cut had been finished. The first cut achieved a yield of 402.9kg/acre, so Mr Forrest was compensated for 597kg/acre over 108.6 acres. The rate was £1.12/kg giving a total sum of £72,626.47. In common with other growers Mr Forrest was clear in evidence that he would have hoped, if he had the chance, to have produced a better yield. He was clear that he was not “overcompensated”.

39. Mr Middleditch is a director of R & R Farms (Wrentham) Limited. It farms 1900 hectares, 76 of which were dedicated in 2021 to growing parsley. At the time of the fire, the first cut had been taken, and the second cut was ready to be done. He was clear in evidence that had Camstar failed to pay for parsley that had been grown but not harvested he would have sought legal advice and would not have grown for Camstar again. A small portion of his parsley fields were ploughed up. The second cut was not taken on the remaining fields, instead the crop was cut back. Mr Middleditch was able to manage a third cut of the cut back crop he did grow. His evidence was that that cut was harvested late (because of the decreased processing capability as a result of the fire) and so the crop was of lower quality than would have been the case with a timely harvest. In an email sent to Camstar in 2022, he confirmed that the 2021 growing season was a “very good growing season with yields averaging out around 1200kg/acre”. His evidence was that he met with Camstar at the farm where the crop was examined and an agreement was reached for the crop in certain fields to be destroyed and for compensation in respect of the second cut for the rest of the fields on the basis of a yield of 475kg/acre and in one case 500kg/acre. Because there was a third cut for which Mr Middleditch was paid, those figures resulted in total payments based on yields of more than 1000kg/acre.

40. Mr Fairs is the partner in Hillfairs which runs Hill Farm. It dedicated 173 acres to growing parsley for Camstar in 2021. Like Mr Middleditch, had there been no payment for the parsley that could not be used by Camstar, Mr Fairs would have taken legal advice and not grown for Camstar again. He is clear that the compensation agreed with Camstar was worked out “according to what we would have been paid if the fire did not happen.” Some of the crop (field 131, 1 out of 5 fields) was used for seed for Camstar. That meant the crop remained for a second year and Camstar paid for the second year. Hillfairs was compensated at the basic rate of 1000 kg/acre as suggested by Camstar. A payment to compensate for the absence of a third cut in field 131 appears to have been greatly reduced (and paid at 350kg/acre when Mr Fairs’ evidence was that he would have expected a yield of around 1200 kg/acre for that field). I accept that was to take account of the fact that there was a payment for seed in respect of that field.

Evidence from Camstar

41. The first witness to be called was Mr Starke. He is the Chief Executive and managing director of Camstar. The business is a family business; Mr Starke’s father was the managing director before him and his family have occupied Chestnuts Farm from where the business is carried on for over 100 years. In his oral evidence, during cross examination when asked about the payments he said: “We had to pay them because it was a purchase. As I say, it was a purchase that would have happened had we not had a fire and a purchase that would have happened if we had the fire.” He told me that before the growers were contacted, he had spoken to his staff and made it clear “the growers will be paid as normal”. He explained that because it was impossible to “look into the future and… actually know what the tonnage would be at the end of the processing for the year” that Camstar “looked at what the average would be, and we really paid our growers as normal. So, you know, had we not had the fire…. they would have been paid near enough the same….”. He felt that the emails, addressed to concerned farmers and sent out by Camstar in the immediate aftermath of the fire “[clarify] the point that [the farmers] would be paid as normal”. He said, “I have to …..look at what they would have produced had there not been a fire and continue to pay for that….”. He explained farmers were paid in line with an estimation “our best estimation of what would have happened had we not had the fire”. As Mr Elkington put it when describing the payments in opening: “the whole thesis of this was to work out what would have been paid had there been no fire.”

42. I heard from Tracey Dewsbury-Clark, Camstar’s sales director. She had responsibility for sales, finance, purchasing and what she described as “general overview”. She created a spreadsheet that was referred to during the course of the trial as a record of payments made to growers and the harvester. She describes the spreadsheet as recording “a summary of the payments made to the growers following the fire in respect of the parsley which they grew for Camstar, but which Camstar was unable to process, due to the reduced capacity caused by the fire. [It] lists the payments made to each grower in respect of each individual field.” Her evidence is that some growers received additional compensation over and above the flat rate of 1000kg at grade A. In some cases that was to account for “inputs” (growing costs including fertilisers) and in others because the likely yield was judged to be greater than the base payment would allow for. I formed the clear view from her evidence that the spreadsheet recorded global figures which had been agreed between the growers, the harvester and Camstar. It was in that sense not a primary document because it did not set out the basis of payment, it was simply a record of the payments.

43. I heard from Mr Gavin Keach, Camstar’s operations director. In 2021 he was the operations manager. He dealt with the internal discussions at Camstar following the fire and provided some detail about expected and later yields. He was also responsible for business continuity. He was shown a “business continuation plan” which he accepted had been found to be completely useless.

44. Mr Heaton, Sedgwick’s loss adjuster, noted that the general sentiment amongst the growers he was able to speak to, was that the 2021 growing season was “better than average, but not up to 2019 season.”

The documents after the fire

45. At 9.50am on 17 August 2021, the morning after the fire, Harry Wilkins, emailed the growers. After formally telling them what they already knew (that there had been a fire) he wrote: “a strategy for maximising the remaining crop will be forthcoming, and losses growers suffer as a direct result of reduced processing capacity will be compensated for”. That was followed by a promise that the growers would each receive a call from Camstar “to discuss things in greater detail”.

46. A week later, Mr Wilkins at Camstar emailed Evergreen with a new harvesting schedule to the end of September 2021. It identified fields that were to be harvested, ploughed up, topped or foraged in place of a second cut. It identified fields where there would be a second and third cut. The fields that were to be ploughed up (by the grower) were denuded of crop and so would cease to produce. Those where the crop was to be harvested would continue to produce Parsley and undergo further “cuts”, those that were topped or foraged would also go on to produce a further cut.

47. On 25 August 2021, Mr Wilkins sent a second email to the growers with the subject line: “compensation scheme for crops affected by loss of production due to fire…”. He explained that, because of a reduced processing capacity, some crop would need to be topped or foraged or ploughed up altogether. He went on: “Fields that have the second of three cuts topped/foraged will have the second cut compensated at an agreed approximation of kg/acre. Any fields that are destroyed without a cut, or have the final cut destroyed will have the season’s total yield compensated at the equivalent harvested value of 1000 kg A grade/acre. To be eligible crop must be maintained in the harvestable condition until mid-December, unless specifically instructed otherwise”.

48. It was suggested to Mr Smith and other witnesses that the proposed method of arriving at compensation was generous for 2 reasons: first it assumed all harvested Parsley would have been A grade and secondly, the proposed weight of the harvest was generous. Mr Smith, whose experience is as the harvester was content to describe the 1000 kg/acre as a “fair average”. He told me yield could be well above 1000 kg with some growers able to produce up to 1600 kg/acre. When Mr Smith was pressed about the yield he might have expected on his farm he said, “I think it’s hard to suggest what the future is when you’re reliant on the weather”. The consistent answer to the point was that 1000 kg was a reasonable estimate (Mr Hull told me that was “the minimum we aim for each year”).

49. Dr Chris Bishop, the agricultural expert called by the Defendant thought the average yield may be lower. He expressed the view that 900 to 950 kg/acre would be more realistic. I prefer the evidence of the growers as to average yield. They are familiar with their land, their farming methods and the history of their previous yields. The growers gave specific evidence whereas Dr Bishop’s evidence was based on a general view of the average yield for growers in the UK. In any event Mr Heaton had effectively agreed that the claim should be assessed on the basis of a yield of 1,042 kg per acre.

How the payments were arrived at

50. Camstar’s pleaded case is that it had “had no commercial option other than to make the payments. If [Camstar] had not made the payments, then: a) the Growers would not have continued to do business with [Camstar] and would not have planted parsley for harvest in 2022; b) the Harvester would have ceased transporting parsley for [Camstar] (and may have gone into liquidation), with the result that: c) [Camstar] would have lost its future supply of parsley.”

51. There was no precise mechanism that could be applied to work out what the payments would have been if there had been no fire, and so the sums paid were necessarily arrived at as a matter of judgment and common sense.

52. The evidence from the harvester, the growers and Mr Starke in particular was not challenged on the central points and presented a uniform picture: Mr Starke’s initial instructions were that the growers and harvester should be paid as normal (as if there had been no fire). That instruction set the direction of travel going forward and I accept his evidence that the payments were based on a “best estimate”. A sensible method was adopted and a flexible approach that allowed growers to explain their position was used. The fact that the methodology might be described as generous is difficult to sustain without good evidence of what would have happened had there been no fire.

53. There can be no criticism of Camstar’s approach to the exercise. Unsurprisingly, the growers in particular were keen to talk up the quality and quantity of their crop. Camstar was in the best position to judge the level of appropriate payments and did so. The fact that the quantum of payment was arrived at in a different way to the norm does not make the payments an “increased cost” or additional.

Are payments covered as ICOW?

54. Against this evidence, I now turn to consider if the ongoing payments were covered by the terms of the policy.

55. The ICoW element of Insured Profit is defined as “any additional expense [the insured] necessarily and reasonably incur solely to prevent or limit a reduction in turnover during the Indemnity Period [36 months] which but for such additional expenses would have taken place due to the Damage.”

56. The Defendant suggests that the ongoing payments were ICOW. If that is correct then there would have been a good claim for them under the terms of the policy. It would follow that the loss of such sums would not be attributable to any breach of duty on the part of the broker.

57. I heard evidence from Mr Samuelson, Camstar’s appointed and very experienced loss adjuster. He was clear in his evidence that there was no legitimate argument that the payments made to growers and the harvester were covered by the policy.

58. He worked on the claim with Mr Damian Glynn of Sedgwick on behalf of the insurer. Mr Glynn is an acknowledged expert in the field of business interruption insurance. He gave his evidence with the confidence and ease of a man secure in his own expertise and knowledge. He told me “it was obvious” that the ongoing costs were not insured (or, as he put it, “uninsured”). He said: “if I’d thought that there was a way that these uninsured costs could be converted into [ICOW] I wouldn’t have waited….[I would have raised it]”

59. These views are of practical significance in that they are the views of those involved in the process who shape its outcome (particularly in Mr Glynn’s case because he would make the ultimate recommendation to the insurer about the acceptance or rejection of the claim). But they do not determine the legal question that I have to resolve.

60. Mr Shapiro KC pointed out that the policy defines an ICOW as:

a. an expense which is additional to normal business expense being a particular expense which is not normally incurred and/or incurred in an amount which is greater than that normally incurred for such particular expense;

b. Necessarily and reasonably incurred solely to prevent or limit a reduction in Turnover during the Indemnity Period; and

c. To avoid a reduction in Turnover which would otherwise have resulted from Damage caused by the Peril.

61. He points out that Camstar aver that: “the Ongoing Payments were necessarily and reasonably incurred solely to prevent or limit a reduction in Turnover during the Indemnity Period which, but for such payments, would have taken place due to the damage to [Camstar’s] premises”: (see its Amended Reply at paragraph 13d). Accordingly, Camstar accepts that the ongoing payments satisfy two of the three essential elements of the definition of ICOW within the Policy.

62. That gives rise to the principal dispute in this action between the parties as to whether the Ongoing Payments were “an additional expense”.

63. On the evidence of the experts an “additional expense” for the purposes of ICOW is either

a. an extra amount of a particular cost which was incurred before the Fire (or as Mr Finnegan, Camstar’s broking expert put it: “an additional cost over and above that that the insured would normally incur had the fire not occurred” and “an expense you don’t normally spend”) or

b. a particular cost or type of cost which was not incurred before the Fire. For example, the cost of air freight or the cost of temporary premises.

64. The additional payments cannot in my view be classified as falling within the first category. There was some discussion of payments being made to growers over and above sums initially calculated on the basis that the growers felt the sums offered were too low (a stark example was a payment of £3000 to Mr Alexander because he was irked that his neighbour might have received a more generous payment). In my view that approach does not change the underlying essential character of the payments. They were intended and treated by Camstar and the growers (and the harvester) as the amount that would have been paid to them had there been no fire (even if Mr Alexander’s approach to negotiation was rough and ready). It is not possible to say with precision what would have been paid had there been no fire, but I accept that the approach of all parties was to do their best to arrive at a figure that put everyone into the position they would have been in had there been no fire. The precise mechanics of the negotiations do not change that fundamental fact. Because of the uncertainties surrounding what would have happened had there been no fire it is not possible in my judgment to conclude that any of the payments made to any grower or the harvester was “extra”.

65. Do the payments fall into the second category? The experts rightly agree that the issue is one of fact and so an issue for me. The argument advanced is that the payments were ex gratia financial support (in the sense that they were paid without obligation and not for parsley) so that they were not in the same category or “type” of cost paid to growers and the harvester before the fire.

66. The determination of this issue would have been straightforward if Camstar’s case was that the payments were contractual. But that argument is not open to them.

67. In my view whether the costs are of the same “type” does not turn on whether they are ex gratia or not. It turns on an objective assessment of the purpose of the payment. In that assessment, the subjectively intended and shared purpose of the payment is a relevant factor. I have concluded that the purpose was to put the growers and harvester in the position they would have been in had there been no fire. I regard that as wholly different from providing financial support (on an ex-gratia basis or not).

68. I regard the fact that the growers had planted, fed and dealt with the growing crop over some considerable time (most of the season) as important. So did Camstar. It seems to me they saw the exercise as one of simple quantification: what would the growers have been paid? That underlines in my judgment the fact that (to all intents and purposes) the growers’ work (the thing, on one view, they were in fact paid for) had been done. In practice the only thing that was left to do was to collect the crop and work out what it was worth. The crop was ready. The growers had done their work.

69. That does not mean that the payment was contractually due. Indeed, I have not determined the precise contractual arrangements between Camstar and the growers (or the harvester).

70. I accept Mr Elkington KC’s point that quite irrespective of the contractual position Camstar had a “commercial commitment” to make the payments. Indeed, Mr Shapiro KC accepted in closing (albeit in support of his argument that the payments were in fact ICOW) that a decision not to pay the growers would not only be “dishonourable” but “commercial lunacy”.

71. It follows that the payments, properly understood, were not of a different “type” to the payments made before the fire. Not because they were contractual (if that was the case, they would be plainly of the same type) but because they were paid for parsley. In my view the payments are in truth for parsley; for growing a crop and having it ready to be harvested. I accept that the payments were not contractual but in my judgment that does not change the conclusion, in particular it does not change the purpose of the payment. They were paid by reason of a pressing and overarching commercial imperative (or, as Camstar’s case is pleaded, it “had no commercial option other than to make the payments”) with the primary aim of benefitting Camstar.

72. In re-examination Mr Glynn was asked how he would have reacted if Mr Samuelson had suggested that these payments were ICOW. His answer was “I’d have told him to take a running jump.” When asked why, he said:

“Because if you've uninsured your purchases, the fact that you subsequently realise you've got to carry on making them, you should have had a gross revenue policy. I don't differentiate between payments to the growers for the parsley that you can still use and payments to the growers for the parsley you can't use. The simple answer is that you've uninsured that cost and you shouldn't have done.”

73. In my view Mr Glynn here is making a different but important point. In short: it would be nonsensical if the very cost that was uninsured (ie the very cost which was not insured under the terms of the policy) could be brought back into account as ICOW.

74. Mr Glynn has co-authored a book on business interruption insurance. He described it as a basic text. In it, he and his co-authors provide various examples of payments that would be considered as ICOW. One example is “Payments to a key supplier to stop them becoming bankrupt (the insured are the only customer, and they give no orders to the supplier for 6 months)”. Mr Shapiro KC pointed out that the hypothetical increased cost in the example is “financial support to a supplier and it replaces…. payments that would otherwise have been made for the purchase of goods”. In other words, the example of ICOW provided in the book is close to that in the present case, so that the payments made by Camstar are ICOW and so recoverable.

75. I do not accept Mr Shapiro’s point. It is based on the assumption that what is said in the book is correct. But Mr Glynn accepted (at least in his oral evidence) that the example in the book was not right. He explained that the scenario was based on an actual claim. He said the claim was paid “because of…. fantastic mitigation” and that the payment “obviously isn’t an increased cost” and “insurers would have been [within their] rights to say, “we’re not paying it””. He said this was an example of insurers paying out in respect of losses “that aren’t strictly covered”. His final comment on the point was this:

“I wrote it and I know what I meant to write….the words are wrong. [Where] we say “Covered?"….I shouldn't have put "yes", I should have put, "No, but insurers may be amenable to consider such payments, subject to …"

76. It is important not to elevate a view expressed in the book into an immutable statement of fact or a precedent that is binding on me. In his written evidence Mr Glynn sought to distinguish the book example by noting that the existential threat that existed in that case was to the supplier whereas here (at least in respect of the growers) the existential threat was to Camstar. In his oral evidence he has distanced himself from what is said in the book.

77. There was criticism of Camstar’s appointed loss assessor, Harris Balcombe and of Mr Samuelson the appointed assessor, because there was no attempt to advance an ICOW claim. For the reason I have given there is nothing at all in these criticisms and they are not well founded.

78. In my view it is plain that the price paid by Camstar after the fire for parsley it could not process was not, properly understood, an “increased” cost. It was an estimate reached in good faith of the costs that would have been incurred if there had been no fire.

How the ICOW point arose

79. The Broker’s averment that the ongoing payments were covered by the policy as ICOW came late in the day. In its Defence, amended Defence and a response to a request for further information it had admitted that the payments were not ICOW. For the reasons I have set out, that admission was entirely proper and in my clear view correct. It may be that the broker could have been held to the pleaded case or required to seek permission to formally withdraw the admission. As the trial progressed the matter was dealt with without the need to resort to points of pleading.

80. The point arose (or at least was given some prominence) in the broking expert report relied on by the Defendant. Ms Taylor in that report suggested that the payments were “likely” to be covered.

81. That suggestion was met by Mr Samuelson and by Mr Glynn (an admitted leading expert in issues of business interruption cover instructed by the insurer) with a degree of surprise bordering on incredulity.

82. For the reasons I have set out I reject Ms Taylor’s view and her evidence on the point.

Duty and Breach

83. It is unsurprisingly common ground that a broker must take reasonable steps to ensure that its client understands the basis on which the insurance offered is written (see JW Bollom v Byas Mosley & Co Ltd [2000] Lloyds Rep IR 136). Plainly, a broker cannot discharge that duty if the broker does not understand the basis on which the insurance is written. The broker’s duty is extensive but includes an obligation to identify the type and scope of cover the client needs and advise the client accordingly. It follows (as was common ground) that the broker must understand the basics of the client’s business and take reasonable care to place insurance that was suitable for the client and met its requirements.

84. I heard expert evidence on the issue of breach. Even without that evidence, it is clear from the uncontested facts I have set out above that Ms Shearing, and so the Defendant, failed in the duty owed to Camstar. Put simply, it recommended replacing the right policy with the wrong policy where a reasonably competent broker would have understood that to be the case and would have understood the type of policy needed.

85. Mr Shapiro KC advanced a number of arguments to support his position that there was no breach. He relied on the fact that the broker could not have been expected to identify the need for insurance cover in respect of payments that Camstar itself had not foreseen. I reject those arguments.

86. I accept that the business continuity plan (identified as useless by Mr Keach) did not identify the need for ongoing payments. That failure is no doubt part of the reason the plan was found to be inadequate. The plan does not alter the plain fact that the broker failed in its duties to Camstar. It would have been wholly wrong for the broker to rely on the plan and make no inquiries of its own into the business. Had those inquiries been made with the aim of determining what type of policy was suitable I have no doubt the correct answer would have been discovered. In effect, the broker would have been investigating whether UWE (including costs of purchase) would reduce in line with turnover or not. That would have been an obvious and fundamental question to which the answer would have been plain.

87. Faced with this difficult position, the Defendant argues first, that even if a gross revenue policy had been put in place the payments would not have been recovered and secondly, the policy was in fact suitable because payments to growers and to the harvester (the ongoing payments) were in fact covered by the policy.

88. The first argument relies on the fact that even where a gross revenue policy is in place any savings made as a result of the insured peril would be deducted. Mr Shapiro KC argued that the reduction in the cost of purchasing parsley would be a deductible saving. I reject that argument. I do not accept that on any sensible view that the purchase costs (the UWE costs under the actual policy) could be regarded as “savings”. There would in practice be no “saving” because the payments would have been made for the reasons I have already set out.

89. The definition of “savings” in the actual policy (“expenses…. Which reduce or cease due to the Damage”) requires a factual investigation into whether the payments ceased or were reduced (they did not) and if so whether the reduction or cessation was because of the damage. The parties proceeded on the basis that the wording of a gross revenue policy would adopt a similar approach.

90. Mr Shapiro KC distinguishes between parsley purchase costs (which he says reduced so that there was a saving) on the one hand, and the payments that were actually made (which he suggests were made in mitigation) on the other. In my view, and for the following reasons, that distinction is a false one.

91. For the reasons I have explained the payments should be treated as the payments that would have been made had there been no fire. There was therefore no saving because the relevant payments were made and there was no reduction in their amount.

92. Further, if the payments had not been made Camstar’s business would have suffered and may have come to an end as a direct result. Such payments do not in my judgment fall within the definition of “saving”.

93. For the reason I have set out above, I reject the second argument.

94. Had Camstar been properly advised I have no doubt it would have arranged and paid for cover on a loss of revenue basis. There was no real suggestion to the contrary. As an alternative I accept Camstar might have opted for insured profit cover but with the parsley purchase costs not amounting to UWE or for a specific extension of cover.

95. Had any of those options been adopted I am satisfied that the ongoing costs would have been covered.

Damages

96. The total of the ongoing payments was £1,249,362.50. In my judgment that sum should be awarded as damages.

97. The Defendant’s attack on the amount was based on a number of factors, including apparent over-compensation, a lack of clarity in the method of arriving at final figures and the methodology adopted not being consistent between the invoices and in the spreadsheet.

98. The sum is a product of negotiation between parties experienced in the growing and selling of parsley. I am satisfied that those negotiations were carried out in good faith (and there was no real suggestion to the contrary) with a view to arriving at the figure that would have been paid if the harvest had proceeded. There is no mathematical modelling that can be done to work out a “correct” amount. It follows that there is likely to be more than 1 reasonable outcome to the exercise.

99. Based on the evidence I have heard I am satisfied that if that sum had been claimed, it would have been recovered had there been no negligence on the part of the Defendant. Camstar would have had proper and adequate cover and that would have included the ongoing costs. In fact, it received nothing towards those costs.

Further points

100. A claim for contributory negligence based on a failure to claim ICOW was advanced. For the reasons I have given, there was no ICOW. It follows there was no contributory negligence.

101. If my conclusion on ICOW is wrong, then Camstar says the loss it suffered remains attributable to the Defendant’s breach. The Defendant submits that the causal link between the broker’s breach and the loss suffered would have been broken.

102. If I concluded that there was a valid ICOW claim (there plainly was not), I would have considered whether the failure to make the claim was the cause of Camstar’s loss in place of the broker’s breach. I would have concluded that the failure to make the ICOW claim was not the cause of Camstar’s loss. It seems to me, given Mr Glynn’s experience in the field, his evidence that he would have firmly rejected such a claim (as he put it: “take a running jump”) justifies the conclusion that Harris Balcombe acted reasonably at all times by concluding that there was no claim (even if as a matter of law there had been). A finding that there was an ICOW claim would not have led me to conclude there was a break in the chain of causation between Camstar’s loss and the broker’s breach.

103. Camstar suffered a second fire on 9 July 2023. By then there was appropriate cover in place in the form of a costs fine and penalties extension. On the basis of the findings I have made, the nature of the insurance cover for the second fire is not relevant.

104. Mr Elkington KC suggested interest should run from the date of settlement with Aviva (6 June 2022) at the rate of 2 percentage points above base. It seems to me there is some force in that position. The parties should try to agree an order including interest payable. If they cannot agree, I will determine the matter on paper or at a short consequentials hearing.

105. Finally, I express my thanks to all counsel and solicitors involved in the hearing for the efficient and good-spirited handling of a difficult case.

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our business lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.