Administrative United Kingdom
Deborah Stevenson v The Nursing and Midwifery Council
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWHC 2844 (Admin)
Case No: AC-2026-LON-001441
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
KING'S BENCH DIVISION
ADMINISTRATIVE COURT
In the matter of an appeal under Articles 29 and 38
of the Nursing and Midwifery Order 2001
Royal Courts of Justice
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Date: 06/11/2026
Before :
HIS HONOUR JUDGE JARMAN KC
Sitting as a judge of the High Court
Between :
| DEBORAH STEVENSON | Appellant | |
| – and – | ||
| THE NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL | Respondent |
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Mr Arthur Lo (instructed by Royal College of Nursing) for the Appellant
Mr Benjamin D’Alton (in house counsel) for the Respondent
Hearing dates: 27 October 2026
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Approved Judgment
This judgment was handed down remotely at 10.30am on 6 November 2026 by circulation to the parties or their representatives by e-mail and by release to the National Archives.
………………………..
HIS HONOUR JUDGE JARMAN KC
HHJ Jarman KC:
1. The appellant appeals sanctions imposed upon her by a panel of the fitness to practice committee of the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC). After a hearing between 2 and 12 February 2026 the panel found proved eight allegations of misconduct against the appellant, who admitted two more, which cumulatively amounted to serious misconduct. It found that her fitness to practice was impaired. There is no challenge to those findings. The panel suspended her from practice for 9 months, when the suspension would be reviewed. The panel also imposed an interim suspension order for 18 months to cover the period for any appeal to be heard. That will end when this appeal is finally disposed of, and then the 9 months suspension will take effect.
2. There are three grounds of appeal, each of which is disputed by the NMC, which seeks to uphold the panel’s decision. First, it is said that the sanction imposed by the panel was disproportionate to the objectives set out in the NMC’s guidance. Second, it is said that the panel failed to take into account all of the mitigation advanced on her behalf at the hearing. Third, the panel erred in imposing an interim suspension order.
3. The appellant is registered with the NMC as a nurse, and as at 2021, when the misconduct first took place, had been so for some five years. At that time she was employed as a community staff nurse for the Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust. In August 2021 the NMC received referrals of several allegations against her which broadly fell into two categories: failures to maintain professional boundaries with patients; and bullying and harassing behaviour towards colleagues.
4. At an early stage, the appellant admitted two of the allegations, namely in Jnauary 2021 using a patient’s credit card to shop for that patient, and becoming a friend to a patient on social media. She disputed the rest. It took nearly five years for those to be considered by the panel. No interim suspension order was made in the meantime and she carried on her work as a nurse during which time no further allegations after April 2022 were made against her.
The panel’s decision on sanctions
5. In respect of the remaining allegations, the panel found that some five were either not proved or that there was no case to answer. The allegations found to be proved, in addition to those admitted as set out above, took place in April 2021 and April 2022 and on unknown or multiple dates, as follows: had a patient touch her breasts; made a joke about farting to a patient’s wife; hugged and/or kissed a patient; said to a patient with MS that they were grabbing her boobies and shook her breasts at that patient; on one or more occasions shouted at a colleague and asked another colleague to make a complaint about that colleague; made inappropriate comments about a colleague’s appearance and/or weight and about their health condition; and that some of that conduct amounted to bullying and/or intimidating and/or harassing behaviour.
6. The section of the panel’s written determination headed sanctions began as follows:
“The panel has considered this case very carefully and has decided to make a suspension order for a period of 9 months. The effect of this order is that the NMC register will show that your registration has been suspended.
In reaching this decision, the panel has had regard to all the evidence that has been adduced in this case and had careful regard to the Sanctions Guidance (SG) published by the NMC. The panel accepted the advice of the legal assessor.”
7. Both parties made submissions on sanctions before the panel through counsel, and these were summarised in the determination. It was submitted by the appellant’s counsel that the appopriate sanction was a conditions of practice order.
8. The panel began its determination as follows:
“Having found your fitness to practise currently impaired, the panel went on to consider what sanction, if any, it should impose in this case. The panel has borne in mind that any sanction imposed must be appropriate and proportionate and, although not intended to be punitive in its effect, may have such consequences. The panel had careful regard to the SG. The decision on sanction is a matter for the panel independently exercising its own judgement.”
9. What the panel took into account as aggravating features were then set out:
“• Abuse of your position of trust through repeated breaches of professional boundaries with patients, including inappropriate personal disclosures and physical boundary violations.
• Abuse of a position of power in relation to a more junior colleague…
• Bullying and harassment of colleagues within a healthcare setting, including repeated insensitive comments regarding an eating disorder.
• Failure to work collaboratively with colleagues, in breach of the Code.
• A pattern of misconduct over a period of time with different patients and different colleagues.
• Limited insight into the impact of your behaviour and failure to address concerns raised with you at a local level.
• Risk of psychological and emotional harm to patients and colleagues, and the creation of an unsafe working environment.”
10. The panel then set out what it took into account as mitigating features:
“• Early admissions to some of the charges.
• Completion of mandatory training including safeguarding and conflict resolution.
• Written reflections, albeit limited and not always addressing the root causes of the misconduct.
• Positive testimonials from colleagues regarding your current practice, although they did not directly address the specific misconduct found proved.
• Your attendance and involvement throughout the proceedings, despite the evident personal distress caused.”
11. Consideration was given to whether to make no sanction, but the panel determied that that would be inappropriate given the serious of the misconduct found to be proved. For similar reasons it was found that a caution would not be proportinate or in the public interest. The next consideration was as to a conditions of practice order, as advocated on behalf of the appellant. The panel cited the guidance as to when such an order would be appropriate, including where there was no evidence of deep seated personality of attitudinal problems, and then concluded:
“The panel recognised that, whilst professional boundary training and targeted development can address some of the identified concerns, the behaviour stemmed from underlying attitudinal issues. It was not satisfied that workable, measurable and enforceable conditions could be formulated to adequately address those concerns nor that this would meet the public interest.
The panel noted that the misconduct arose over a prolonged period and across different contexts, demonstrating a pattern of behaviour. The panel also noted that, despite the passage of time since the events and your early admissions to some charges, there was limited evidence of targeted remediation specifically addressing professional boundaries. It considered that meaningful attitudinal change would require significant reflection and development, which would be difficult to monitor effectively through conditions of practice.”
12. Accordingly, the panel acknowledged the passasage of time since the misconduct occured. The panel then went on to consider a suspension order at some length, which included the following passages:
“The panel was satisfied that a suspension order would protect the public and uphold professional standards, whilst also preserving the integrity of the register in the eyes of fellow registrants and the public. It considered that a period of suspension would provide you with the opportunity to step back from registered practice, reflect meaningfully on your conduct, undertake relevant professional boundary training and develop deeper insight into the impact of your behaviour on patients, colleagues and the reputation of the profession.
The panel considered that there was a realistic prospect that, with time and appropriate remediation, you could return to safe and effective practice. Although insight to date had been limited, you had engaged with the proceedings and shown some developing understanding and remorse. The panel was satisfied that in your case; the misconduct was not fundamentally incompatible with remaining on the register and suspension order would therefore serve both the protective and rehabilitative aims of sanction.”
13. The panel then indicated that 9 months was the approprate and proportionate length of the suspension, after which the matter would be reviewed. It was noted that the appellant was entitled to ask for an early review. The determination then continued:
“Any future panel reviewing this case would be assisted by:
• A detailed reflective piece addressing the root causes of your misconduct, not merely describing events but analysing why you acted as you did and what underlying attitudinal issues were present.
• Clear reflection on the impact of your misconduct on:
– Patients (including emotional and psychological impact and breach of trust);
– Colleagues (including bullying, intimidation, undermining and harassing type behaviours); and
– The wider nursing profession and public confidence in it.
• A demonstrated and developed understanding of professional boundaries, including why boundaries exist, how they protect patients and staff, and how your previous conduct breached those standards.
• Evidence of a strengthened understanding of the role, responsibilities and professional expectations of a registered nurse, including adherence to the NMC Code, workplace policies and professional standards.
• Evidence of completed, relevant CPD and training specifically focused on professional boundaries, professional conduct, communication and workplace behaviours, together with reflection on what you have learned and how this will change your thinking and practice.
• A clear, forward-looking explanation of how you would change and manage your practice in the future, with practical examples of what you would do differently in similar situations, rather than stating that the behaviour will not be repeated.
• Evidence of work undertaken in a health and social care assistant or similar role during suspension, if applicable, supported by testimonials.
• Up-to-date testimonials from managers or supervisors who are aware of the findings in this case, confirming your conduct, professionalism, boundaries, teamwork and insight in practice.
• Evidence of sustained reflection and strengthened practice over time, demonstrating that the risk of repetition has been meaningfully reduced. “
The interim suspension order
14. The panel then went on to consider an interim order, and stated:
“The panel was satisfied that an interim order is necessary for the protection of the public and is otherwise in the public interest. In reaching this decision, the panel had regard to the seriousness of the facts found proved and the reasons set out in its determination for imposing the substantive suspension order.
The panel considered that, in the absence of an interim order, you would be able to practise unrestricted during the 28-day appeal period and any appeal thereafter. This would be inconsistent with its substantive decision and would not adequately address the public protection concerns identified. The panel acknowledged the submissions made by Mr Trussler regarding potential prejudice and financial hardship but concluded that the need for public protection and the wider public interest outweighed those considerations.
For the reasons already identified in its substantive determination, the panel concluded that an interim conditions of practice order would not be appropriate or proportionate. The panel therefore imposed an interim suspension order for a period of 18 months to allow time for any possible appeal.If no appeal is made, the interim suspension order will be replaced by the substantive suspension order 28 days after you are sent the written decision of this hearing.”
The legal framework
15. The 2001 Order, made under the Health Act 1999 establishes the NMC to set standards of education, training, conduct and performance for nurses and midwives and to ensure the maintenance of those standards. Article 22 of the Order provides that where it is alleged that fitness to practise is impaired due to misconduct the allegation shall be referred to an investigating committee, which must refer the case to the conduct and competence committee under article 26 if it concludes that there is a case to answer. The committee then holds a hearing into the merits of the allegations and determines the nurse's fitness to practise.
16. The 2001 Order also provides for an appeal to the court, which is governed by CPR 52.21(3). The present appeal is limited to the issue of sanction, so the appellant must show that the sanction imposed was wrong or unjust because of a serious procedural or other irregularity (see Cheatle v General Medical Council[2009] EWHC 645at [12] – [15], General Medical Council v Jagjivan[2017] EWHC 1247 at [40], and Adefidiya v NMC [2026] EWHC 1373 (Admin) at [13]).
17. Article 31 provides that either committee may make an interim order to suspend a nurse from practice or to be made subject to conditions if satisfied that it is necessary for the protection of members of the public or is otherwise in the public interest, or is in the interests of the person concerned. Paragraph 12 provides that the court, may, on an application being made by the person concerned terminate an interim suspension order or revoke or vary any condition imposed by the order.
18. The NMC has produced guidance to panels considering sanctions, updated to January 2026 at the time of the panel’s consideration It makes clear that sanctions are not intended to punish, but to protect the public, to maintain public confidence and to uphold standards. The sanction imposed must be the least restrictive in order to achieve one of more of those aims. In terms of mitigation the guidance provides;
“As with aggravating factors, the Committee must also consider what mitigating factors are present and the evidence about them. Mitigating factors are aspects of the case that make it less serious because they reduce the level of risk that the professional poses to public protection. They may mean that the risk to the public is reduced and a lesser sanction can manage the risk.
Mitigating factors will always be case-dependent but can broadly be grouped as related to either insight and strengthened practice or to personal mitigation.”
19. Some possible mitigating factors related to insight and strengthened practice are then set out. As for personal circumstances, the guidance provides as follows:
“Some possible personal mitigating factors include (but aren’t limited to):
periods of stress or illness (including addiction or substance misuse)
personal and financial hardship
level of experience at the time in question
level of support in the workplace
Personal mitigating factors will have more weight if there is evidence to support them, such as a letter from the professional’s GP, community or faith leaders the professional may have engaged with, or evidence from colleagues.
Because the purpose of sanctions is to protect the public, personal mitigation is usually less relevant than other forms of mitigation. The Committee may consider positive references and testimonials, however these are only likely to be relevant if it is clear the person providing them is aware of and understands the full extent of the concerns about the professional, so they understand the issues the Committee is considering.”
20. The last paragraph cited above chimes with the decision of the court in Adefidiya v NMC [2026] EWHC 1373 (Admin) where it was said at [44] that it will often be the case that a regulatory body considering (amongst other things) the need to maintain public confidence in the profession for which it is responsible will give less weight to personal mitigation than might otherwise be the case.
21. Paragraph 10 of the guidance sets out the matters to be taken into account by a committee considering whether to impose an interim order and provides that the panel may only impose an interim order if it is satisfied that such an order is necessary for the protection of members of the public, or otherwise in the public interest or in the interest of the nurse in question. It is not enough for the panel to consider that an order is merely desirable. The panel must take into account that such an order will impact upon the nurse's right to practise their profession and may also impact financially and on the nurse’s reputation. The panel must balance the need for an interim order against the consequences for the nurse and satisfy themselves that the consequences of the order are not disproportionate to the risk from which the panel is seeking to protect the public. If an order is imposed, clear and adequate reasons should be given why the panel has chosen the period of time for which the order should be imposed.
22. In The General Dental Council v Aga [2025] EWCA Civ 68, the Court of Appeal pointed out that the period of an interim suspension order and a substantive order should not be aggregated as each has a different purpose to the other. Whilst the effect may be to extend the period of suspension, that is not unfair or contrary to the public interest. The period can be reviewed. The touchstone is the protection of the public.
Ground 1
23. Turning to the first ground, in my judgment it has not been shown that the sanction imposed was wrong or unjust. The findings of serious misconduct and impairment are not challenged. The panel carefully went through all the options and gave a reasoned determination why it considered a conditions of practice order, advocated on behalf of the appellant, to be unworkable on the facts of the present case.
24. It also gave a reasoned determination as to why it was considered that a suspended order was the appropriate order. It observed that despite the passage of time since the serious misconduct it found, there was limited evidence of targeted remedial training as to professional boundaries. It found that a period of suspension would provide the appellant with an opportunity to reflect meaningfully on her conduct, undertake relevant professional boundary training and develop deeper insight into the impact of her behaviour on patients, colleagues and the reputation of the profession.
25. The panel noted the possibility of applying for an early review. It was at pains to set out at some length the sort of information or evidence that may assist on such a review. There was no challenge as such to these findings of the panel as to limited evidence of remedial training and the sort of information or evidence which may assist on review.
26. It was submitted on behalf of the appellant before the panel that given that she was 58 years of age at the time a period of suspension would be likely to amount to the end of her career. There was no direct evidence to this effect before the panel or before me, but Mr Lo, on behalf of the appellant, submitted that I should take judicial notice of this factor. However, the panel expressly considered that there was a realistic prospect that, with time and appropriate remediation, the appellant could return to safe and effective practice, and was satisifed that the in her case the misconduct was not fundamentally incompatible with remaining on the register. I see no grounds for finding that those conclusions were wrong or unjust, and they should assist the appellant in returning to work, as should the list of information or evidence which would assist on review.
Ground 2
27. As to the second ground, the panel expressly set out what mitigation it took into account. In my judgment these went to ameliorate the risk to the public. Personal circumstances were mentioned in the determination of impairment, such as bereavement, and illness of the appellant and family members. There was also some corroboration of the appellant’s evidence that she herself was bullied. Such factors, however, were not repeated when it came to sanctions. Mr Lo accepted that the question of weight of such factors was a matter for the panel, but submitted that what the panel was not entitled to do was not to take them into account at all on the issue of sanctions, as that was contrary to the sanctions guidance.
28. That guidance recognises that as the purpose of the sanction is to protect the public, maintain public confidence and uphold standards, personal circumstances will usually be less relevant than other forms of mitigation. The panel in this case found misconduct over a prolonged period across different contexts, demonstrating a pattern of behaviour. It found underlying attitudinal issues and limited evidence of addressing professional boundaries in the intervening time. It was entitled, in my judgment, to proceed on the basis that the personal circumstances which obtained almost five years earlier were not germane to those issues.
Ground 3
29. Finally, Mr Lo did not submit that the interim suspension order should not have been imposed at all, as ground 3 suggests, but instead submitted that 18 months was too long. In my judgment that was a proper and realistic concession. Mr D’Alton, in house counsel for the NMC, submitted this was a departure from the ground as pleaded, which needed permission and which should not be granted. In my judgment, whilst the heading of ground 3 refers to an error in imposing an interim suspension order, the body of the ground itself in referring to the overall length of that order and the suspension order to follow is just about wide enough to encompass Mr Lo’s concession.
30. This appeal has taken just over seven months to be heard. Mr D’Alton submitted that the time such appeals take to be heard varies, but concedes that it is not usual to take 18 months. In my judgment the panel did not give proper reasons as to why the maximum was appropriate. As events have turned out, taking into account further time to appeal this judgment, the period of interim suspension will almost equal the substantive suspension. However, given that it is open for the appellant to apply for an early review, in my judgment it is not appropriate to interfere with the duration of the interim suspension order. Any application for a review should be mindful of the panel’s list of information or evidence which may assist, as summarised above.
31. I invite counsel to submit a draft order, agreed as far as possible, within 14 days of hand down of this judgment, together with written submission on any consequential order which cannot be agreed, which will then be determined on the basis of any such submissions. I thank counsel for their assistance.
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our administrative lawyer.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).