Property United Kingdom
Lekan Saromi & Anor v Vincent Bell & Anor
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKUT 00403 (LC)
Case No: LC-2026-166
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL (LANDS CHAMBER)
AN APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 84 OF THE LAW OF PROPERTY ACT 1925
Royal Courts of Justice, Strand,
London, WC2A 2LL
21 October 2026
TRIBUNALS, COURTS AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 2007
RESTRICTIVE COVENANT – DISCHARGE OR MODIFICATION – planning permission to demolish former chapel to erect a single dwelling – covenant not to use any building for a purpose other than that of a place of worship – restriction discharged subject to payment of compensation
BETWEEN:
LEKAN SAROMI AND YEMISI SAROMI
Applicants
-and-
VINCENT BELL AND KATHRYN BELL
Objectors
Gospel Church, 1A Alfan Lane,
Wilmington, Kent
DA2 7HB
Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV
Determination on written representations
© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2026
The following case was referred to in this decision:
Newton Poppleford and Harpford Parish Council v Preston [2026] UKUT 69 (LC)
Re Fermyn Wood [2018] UKUT 0411 (LC)
Introduction and background
1. This is an application by Mr Lekan Saromi and Mrs Yemisi Saromi (“the applicants”) to discharge or modify a restrictive covenant which affects their property known as Gospel Church at 1A Alfan Lane, Wilmington, near Dartford in Kent (“the application land”).
2. The application land was bought by the applicants on 3 August 2021. It is around 545 sqm in size and is the site of a dilapidated single storey church building, which has been unoccupied since 2008. Alfan Lane is an unmade narrow lane giving access to the application land and 11 further houses and bungalows. The application land was originally part of the rear garden of 176 Birchwood Road (“No 176”) which has the benefit of the restriction. No 176 has been the home of Mr Vincent Bell and Mrs Kathryn Bell for over 28 years. The plan below shows the location of the respective properties.
3. The restriction was imposed by a conveyance dated 19 September 1950, between (1) Annie Elizabeth Ridenton and (2) Alice Hunt, Arthur James Selvage and Leonard Wiseman which stated as follows:
“The Transferees hereby jointly and severally covenant with the Transferor and so that this covenant shall so far as may be run with the land that the building now standing there on and any future building to be erected in place thereof shall be used for no other purpose than that of a place of worship.”
4. In 2022 the applicants twice applied unsuccessfully for planning permission to demolish the former gospel church and erect a dwelling in its place. They also made an application to this Tribunal for discharge or modification of the restriction, which was withdrawn after the second refusal of planning permission. Reasons given for refusal of planning permission included the scale of the proposed dwelling and the need to provide better evidence that there was no longer a need for a community facility on the site. On 7 March 2025 Dartford Borough Council (“the Council”) granted Permission in Principle to demolish the existing building and erect a single dwelling. On 20 January 2026 the Council granted Technical Details Consent for the erection of a 1.5 storey, 4 bedroom dwellinghouse with associated parking and amenity space. The approved plans show a gross internal area floorspace of 278.6sqm, including a basement pool and gym.
5. The schematic drawing below shows the siting of the dwelling in the southern end of the application land, close to the boundary with the objectors’ garden. Parking for two cars is provided at the end furthest from No 176.
6. Although the objectors had objected to the applicants’ previous application, their initial response to this application was that they were prepared to agree modification of the restriction to permit a dwelling, subject to certain conditions. The conditions included moving the footprint of the dwelling away from their boundary. I held a case management hearing, attended by Mr Saromi and Mr Bell, and explained that the Tribunal would not modify a covenant to permit a planning permission to be implemented, while at the same time imposing a condition which would prevent that planning permission from being implemented. Mr Bell confirmed on behalf of the objectors that they would accept modification but maintain their claim for compensation of £20,000 as stated on their notice of objection. In this decision they remain referred to as objectors, which is the status which gives them the opportunity to make submissions.
7. The parties agreed that it was proportionate for the matter to be dealt with by written representations. The objectors filed and served their evidence by 28 August 2026, confirming the nature of the practical benefits they believed were secured to them by the restriction. The applicants filed and served their response by 4 September 2026. I carried out a site inspection on 15 September 2026, accompanied by Mr Saromi and Mr Bell.
Legal background
Legislation
8. Section 84(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 gives the Tribunal power to discharge or modify any restriction on the use of freehold land on being satisfied of certain conditions.
9. Ground (a) of section 84(1) is satisfied where it is shown that by reason of changes in the
character of the property or neighbourhood or other circumstances of the case that the
Tribunal may deem material, the restriction ought to be deemed obsolete.
10. Ground (aa) of section 84(1) is satisfied where it is shown that the continued existence of the restriction would impede some reasonable use of the land for public or private purposes or that it would do so unless modified. By section 84(1A), in a case where condition (aa) is relied on, the Tribunal may discharge or modify the restriction if it is satisfied that, in impeding the suggested use, the restriction either secures “no practical benefits of substantial value or advantage” to the person with the benefit of the restriction, or that it is contrary to the public interest. The Tribunal must also be satisfied that money will provide adequate compensation for the loss or disadvantage (if any) which that person will suffer from the discharge or modification.
11. Section 84(1) also provides in general that where the Tribunal makes an order any discharging or modifying a restriction it may award a sum in compensation to a person entitled to the benefit of the restriction to make up for any loss or disadvantage suffered by that person in consequence of the discharge or modification.
12. Ground (c) is satisfied where it is shown that discharge or modification would cause no injury to persons entitled to the benefit of the restriction.
13. In determining whether the requirements of sub-section (1A) are satisfied, and whether a restriction ought to be discharged or modified, the Tribunal is required by sub-section (1B) to take into account “the development plan and any declared or ascertainable pattern for the grant or refusal of planning permissions in the relevant areas, as well as the period at which and context in which the restriction was created or imposed and any other material circumstances.”
14. If the applicant is able to establish that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to modify the covenant, the Tribunal must then decide whether to exercise its discretion to do so. If it does, the Tribunal may also direct the payment of compensation to any person entitled to the benefit of the restriction to make up for any loss or disadvantage suffered by that person as a result of the discharge or modification, or to make up for any effect which the restriction had, when it was imposed, in reducing the consideration then received for the land affected by it.
15. If the applicant agrees, on modifying a restriction the Tribunal may also impose some additional restriction over the land.
The application for discharge or modification
16. The applicants seek primarily discharge of the restriction under ground (a) of s84(1) and alternatively modification under grounds (aa) and (c) to permit implementation of the recent planning permission.
17. Under ground (a) the applicants say that the restriction ought to be deemed obsolete because the purpose of the restriction, that a building on the application land should only be used as a place of worship, can no longer be achieved. The last use as a place of worship was 18 years ago in 2008 and no alternative viable religious or community use was secured through the marketing exercise undertaken by the applicants. Previous planning applications had been refused, in part, on the grounds that loss of a community facility required evidence that the application land was not needed by the community and evidence that reasonable efforts had been made to preserve such a use.
18. When Permission in Principle was granted in March 2025 the planning officer’s report confirmed that sufficient evidence had been provided that replacement of the community facility use with a residential use was acceptable in principle. The evidence included marketing of the site for more than 12 months at a price considered reasonable for community use, communications with local parish and ward councillors, and provision of a community facility needs assessment.
19. The applicants also say that the character of the neighbourhood has changed since the restriction was imposed in 1950. In 1992 a close of houses known as Clarendon Place was built in the rear gardens of other properties on Birchwood Road adjoining the application land.
20. Under grounds (aa) and (c) the applicants say that the restriction does not secure practical benefits of substantial value or advantage to the objectors and that modification to permit the proposed use would not give rise to any material loss or detriment. They say that there is no evidence to support a claim that modification would cause a reduction in value of the objectors’ property.
The objectors’ grounds for claiming compensation for discharge or modification
21. The objectors say that when they bought their property 28 years ago the restriction on the application land behind it was one of its appealing aspects, which they anticipated would remain in place. The building there was low level, and remote from their rear boundary, allowing uninterrupted views of Joyden’s Wood on the far side of Alfan Lane. At the rear of their long garden, adjoining the application land, the objectors have created a “secret garden”, where they can sit in peace and tranquillity in a small area surrounded by shrubs and trees.
22. The applicants’ proposed dwelling will sit very close to their rear boundary with a bin store immediately adjacent to the fence. The elevation facing their garden will have two opening rooflights giving potential for overlooking from bedrooms. It will therefore cause a substantial loss of privacy and outlook and have a major negative impact on the enjoyment of their home and its secret garden. Over the last five years the objectors have allowed the trees and shrubs in their garden to “overgrow” in order to mitigate the impact of a new building on the application land. This has compromised the views they previously had from the rear of the house.
23. The objectors are therefore concerned that the applicants’ development will cause a loss of value to their home when they come to sell it in future. However, they did not provide any evidence of the current value of the house, nor any evidence to support a claimed loss of £20,000.
The response of the applicants
24. The applicants responded at length to the evidence of the objectors, and I will summarise the content as it is relevant to the points made by the objectors.
25. The applicants say that the objectors have not challenged their case under ground (a) that the restriction should be deemed obsolete.
26. Regarding the practical benefits secured by the restriction the applicants say that the requirement that any building on the application land should remain in use as a place of worship was not a requirement that the building should remain single storey, nor that it should remain on its original footprint away from the objectors’ boundary. Therefore the restriction does not preserve the outlook of the objectors as a practical benefit. The impact of the development in terms of potential loss of privacy and overlooking of No 176 was considered by the Council when granting Technical Details Consent. The applicants were required to have obscured glazing in the three rooflights on the elevation facing No 176 to address the potential for overlooking.
27. The applicants say that the objectors’ enjoyment of peace and tranquillity at the end of their garden must be viewed in the context of the site having been vacant since 2008. It has been artificially quiet during that period, which is not a valid comparison with the impact of the proposed dwelling. Moreover, in the planning officer’s report on Permission in Principle, it was stated that because the site has constraints, including its size and the narrow access lane, it was considered that a dwelling would generate less impact on the neighbouring residential properties than modern church use.
28. The concern of the objectors about potential future loss of value to their home are concerns which have not been quantified or evidenced and the applicants say that compensation should not be based on speculation.
Discussion
Ground (a) – should the restriction de deemed obsolete?
29. In the case of Re Fermyn Wood [2018] UKUT 0411 (LC) the Tribunal (Deputy President Martin Rodger QC and Mr Andrew Trott FRICS) identified four connected matters to be considered under ground (a):
“35. In determining whether the 1929 covenant can be discharged under ground (a) it is therefore necessary to consider a number of connected matters. It is first necessary to identify the purpose or object of the covenant, which may be stated in the instrument imposing the restriction or may be inferred from the nature of the restriction or from the known circumstances. Next it is necessary to ask whether the character of the property or the neighbourhood has changed since the covenant was imposed. Thirdly, whether the restriction has become obsolete by reason of those changes, in the sense that the object for which the restriction was imposed can no longer be achieved. Fourthly, and finally, whether some material circumstance other than a change in the character of the property or the neighbourhood has had that effect.”
30. In the recent decision of Newton Poppleford and Harpford Parish Council v Preston [2026] UKUT 69 (LC) the Tribunal (Deputy President Martin Rodger QC) considered whether a restriction which prevented the use of a building for any purpose other than as a doctor’s surgery could have become obsolete because nobody could be found to use it for that purpose. At [32] he said:
“The covenant did not guarantee that a surgery will always be available, and the purpose for which it was imposed can be, and is being, achieved. That purpose was a negative one, the prevention of any use other than as a doctors’ surgery. In my judgment the restriction is not obsolete.”
31. The restriction in this case is similarly negative, in preventing any use other than as a place of worship. Cessation of use as a place of worship happened 18 years ago, and absence of current demand for religious or community use has been demonstrated in the applicants’ marketing exercise. But that does not make the restriction which prevents other uses obsolete.
32. In identifying the purpose of the negative restriction when it was imposed, it might be inferred, with caution, that the restriction on use of the application land, which had previously formed part of her garden, provided to the owner of No 176 protection from residential development at the rear. The specific incidental benefits which that would provide can only be surmised, noting that at the date the restriction was imposed the neighbouring properties in Birchwood Road retained long, undeveloped gardens, so the overall density of residential properties around No 176 was low.
33. It is clear that the character of the property has changed since 2008, and it is also clear that the character of the neighbourhood has changed since the restriction was imposed in 1950. The residential development at Clarendon Place has created a neighbourhood which is substantially residential in character, with a higher density than before. But neither of those factors renders the restriction obsolete, because it can still protect No 176 from residential development at the rear.
34. Planning decisions are based on public policy, and the Council’s grant of Permission in Principle for residential use expresses a policy acceptance of that alternative use now that there is no demand for use as a place of worship. It is a separate matter from a decision on property rights and is not determinative of obsolescence.
35. My conclusion is that, due to its negative nature, the restriction should not be deemed obsolete and the applicants’ case under ground (a) is not made out.
Ground (aa) – Does the restriction impede a reasonable use of the application land, without securing to the objectors practical benefits of substantial value or advantage, and would money be an adequate compensation for any loss or disadvantage suffered on discharge or modification?
36. The objectors have accepted modification in principle, so do not dispute that the proposed development is a reasonable use of the land. The development is clearly impeded by the restriction.
37. The submissions of the objectors on the practical benefits they believe are secured to them by the restriction, and for which they claim compensation, focus essentially on the proximity of the proposed new dwelling to the rear boundary of their garden where they now enjoy peace and tranquillity. From my site inspection I can understand why the objectors feel that the development may have an impact on their enjoyment of the secluded area they have created there. Of course the current situation, with no use being made of the application land at all, is not the right starting point for assessing the impact of the proposed development. Its impact must be compared with that of a hypothetical church building in current use.
38. I accept the submissions of the applicants that the restriction has no provisions which limit the scale or siting of a church building on the application land. Redevelopment for the purpose of worship could include a replacement building of the same size and location as the proposed development, which would not be in breach of the restriction. Would use of such a building as a place of worship have the same impact on the objectors as residential use? The planning officer considered that use of the application land as a dwelling would generate less impact on neighbouring properties than modern church use, based on “…comings and goings of congregants, noise from activities such as amplified music and other disturbance associated with use of the site by multiple (church) members.”
39. The point is speculative and the planning officer did not expressly compare regular but intermittent use as a place of worship with all day, every day, use as a dwelling. I consider that there is a difference and that the restriction does provide some limited, but not substantial, practical benefits to the objectors. Modification to permit the applicants’ proposals will affect the objectors’ enjoyment of their secluded sitting area because in future it will be in close proximity to domestic activity on the other side of the fence. The bedroom skylights adjacent to the boundary will have obscured glazing, so overlooking would only happen if the occupants deliberately opened them and looked out. This is unlikely to happen on a regular basis, but will be a possibility in the minds of the objectors.
40. The objectors have not provided any valuation or other evidence to explain why they should receive the sum of £20,000 as compensation for their loss of practical benefits. Their garden is large enough that they have other sitting areas, so the loss of seclusion at the end of the garden is unlikely to have an influence on the market value of their house. None-the-less I accept that the objectors will suffer a modest loss in their personal enjoyment of the property they have lived in for 28 years.
41. The applicants say that compensation should not be based on speculation but, as an expert Tribunal, I am able to make a judgment on an appropriate figure to compensate the objectors for the personal loss they will suffer. In my judgment the sum of £10,000 is an appropriate figure to reflect that loss.
42. I conclude that the application is made out under ground (aa) and so I have jurisdiction to discharge or modify the restriction. I have explained that the restriction is a negative one, which prevents use other than as a place of worship. The restriction will cease to have effect once the application for residential use is allowed and it should therefore be discharged.
43. The application is not made out under ground (c) because I have concluded that the objectors will suffer some loss.
The Tribunal’s discretion
44. S.84(1B) requires the Tribunal to take into account the development plan and any declared or ascertainable pattern for the grant or refusal of planning permissions in the relevant area. The Permission in Principle granted by the Council in 2025, following refusal of two earlier applications, is evidence that the development proposed in this application met the requirements of their development plan. The grant of planning permission in 1992 for residential development in other rear gardens at Birchwood Road is evidence of a pattern for granting residential planning permissions in the relevant area.
45. The Tribunal is also required to take into account the period at which and context in which the restriction was created or imposed and any other material circumstances. The restriction was imposed over 70 years ago, at a time when there was a need for a place of worship and there was no residential development of gardens behind Birchwood Road.
Determination
46. I am satisfied that the restriction should be discharged under ground (aa) and I assess the compensation due to the objectors at £10,000.
47. An order discharging the restriction shall be made by the Tribunal provided, within four months of the date of this decision, the applicant shall have provided evidence that the sum of £10,000 has been paid to and received by the objectors.
48. This application has been dealt with under the written representations procedure where costs are not normally awarded.
Mrs Diane Martin TD MRICS FAAV
21 October 2026
Right of appeal
Any party has a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal on any point of law arising from this decision. The right of appeal may be exercised only with permission. An application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal must be sent or delivered to the Tribunal so that it is received within 1 month after the date on which this decision is sent to the parties (unless an application for costs is made within 14 days of the decision being sent to the parties, in which case an application for permission to appeal must be made within 1 month of the date on which the Tribunal’s decision on costs is sent to the parties). An application for permission to appeal must identify the decision of the Tribunal to which it relates, identify the alleged error or errors of law in the decision, and state the result the party making the application is seeking. If the Tribunal refuses permission to appeal a further application may then be made to the Court of Appeal for permission.
Our real estate lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).