Tax United Kingdom
Portsmouth City Council v The Commissioners for HMRC
Neutral Citation: [2026] UKFTT 01462 (TC)
Case Number: TC10062
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL
TAX CHAMBER
Taylor House, Rosebery Avenue, London
Appeal reference: TC/2021/02780
VALUE ADDED TAX – welfare services – item 9 Group 7 Schedule 9 Value Added Tax Act 1994 – whether services of Home Improvement Agency to support elderly and disabled residents with home adaptations exempt from tax – no – appeal dismissed.
Heard on: 15,16 September 2026
Judgment date: 20 October 2026
Before
JUDGE ASHLEY GREENBANK
HELEN MYERSCOUGH
Between
PORTSMOUTH CITY COUNCIL
Appellant
and
THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HIS MAJESTY’S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS
Respondents
Representation:
For the Appellant: Leslie Allen, of counsel, instructed by direct access
For the Respondents: Harry Winter of counsel, instructed by the General Counsel and Solicitor to HM Revenue and Customs
DECISION
Introduction
1. This decision notice relates to appeals by the Appellant, Portsmouth City Council (the “Council”), against two decisions of the Respondents, the Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (“HMRC”), denying two claims for overpayment of value added tax (“VAT”): the first in relation to the period from 17 February 2017 to 30 April 2020 in the amount of £148,484.95; the second in relation to the period from 1 May 2020 to 31 March 2024 in the amount of £333,869.53.
2. The issue between the parties on both appeals concerns the treatment of services provided by the Council’s Home Improvement Agency (the “HIA”) to elderly and disabled persons to assist them in applying for Disabled Facilities Grants (“DFGs”) and in dealing with contractors who undertake works to adapt their homes. The question for this tribunal is whether the services provided by the HIA are exempt from VAT as a supply of “welfare services” by a public body within item 9, Group 7, Schedule 9 Value Added Tax Act 1994 (“VATA”).
3. The appeals have been consolidated under reference number TC/2021/02780.
The hearing and witness evidence
4. We were provided with a hearing bundle of 258 pages and a bundle of authorities.
5. The hearing bundle included a witness statement given by Mr Brian Bull, the Housing Renewals Team Leader for the Council. Mr Bull gave evidence and was cross-examined on his statement.
6. It became apparent during cross-examination that parts of Mr Bull’s statement were not written by him. We have accordingly treated his statement with some caution and only relied upon it to the extent that his evidence was corroborated by other documentary evidence before us.
The facts
7. We have set out our findings of fact in this section. We have included references to the statutory provisions that govern the making of DFGs. There is no dispute between the parties concerning the scope of those provisions.
8. DFGs are means-tested capital grants for eligible disabled people to contribute to the cost of home adaptations and enable them to continue to live safely and independently at home and in their communities. Examples of home adaptations include ramps, stairlifts, hoists, and shower facilities. DFGs are administered by local housing authorities in England.
9. The main legislation governing DFGs is the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (“HGCRA”). Under section 1 HGCRA, DFGs are available from local housing authorities. Applications for DFGs are not limited to the costs of the home adaptations themselves, but can extend to “preliminary or ancillary services and charges” (section 2(2)(c) and section 2(3) HGCRA).
10. The “preliminary or ancillary services and charges” are specified in paragraph 2 of The Housing Renewal Grants (Services and Charges) Order 1996. They include services or charges for which the applicant is liable in respect of:
(a) confirmation, if sought by the local authority, that the applicant has an owner's interest,
(b) technical and structural surveys,
(c) design and preparation of plans and drawings,
(d) preparation of schedules of relevant works,
(e) assistance in completing forms,
(f) advice on financing the costs of the relevant works which are not met by grant,
(g) applications for building regulations approval (including application fee and preparation of related documents),
(h) applications for planning permission (including application fee and preparation of related documents),
(i) applications for listed building consent (including application fee and preparation of related documents),
(j) applications for conservation area consent (including application fee and preparation of related documents),
(k) obtaining of estimates,
(l) advice on contracts,
(m) consideration of tenders,
(n) supervision of the relevant works,
(o) disconnection and reconnection of electricity, gas, water or drainage utilities where this is necessitated by the relevant works, and
(p) payment of contractors.
11. Under sections 23 and 24 HGCRA, applications for DFGs for certain types of costs must be approved if the local housing authority is satisfied that the relevant works are necessary and appropriate to meet the needs of the disabled occupant, and that it is reasonable and practicable to carry out the relevant works having regard to the age and condition of the property. The relevant purposes are set out in section 23(1) HGCRA, which provides as follows:
(1) The purposes for which an application for a grant must be approved, subject to the provisions of this Chapter, are the following—
(a) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to and from—
(i) the dwelling, qualifying houseboat or caravan , or
(ii) the building in which the dwelling or, as the case may be, flat is situated;
(b) making—
(i) the dwelling, qualifying houseboat or caravan, or
(ii) the building,
safe for the disabled occupant and other persons residing with him;
(c) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to a room used or usable as the principal family room;
(d) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to, or providing for the disabled occupant, a room used or usable for sleeping;
(e) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to, or providing for the disabled occupant, a room in which there is a lavatory, or facilitating the use by the disabled occupant of such a facility;
(f) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to, or providing for the disabled occupant, a room in which there is a bath or shower (or both), or facilitating the use by the disabled occupant of such a facility;
(g) facilitating access by the disabled occupant to, or providing for the disabled occupant, a room in which there is a washhand basin, or facilitating the use by the disabled occupant of such a facility;
(h) facilitating the preparation and cooking of food by the disabled occupant;
(i) improving any heating system in the dwelling, qualifying houseboat or caravan to meet the needs of the disabled occupant or, if there is no existing heating system there or any such system is unsuitable for use by the disabled occupant, providing a heating system suitable to meet his needs;
(j) facilitating the use by the disabled occupant of a source of power, light or heat by altering the position of one or more means of access to or control of that source or by providing additional means of control;
(k) facilitating access and movement by the disabled occupant around the dwelling, qualifying houseboat or caravan in order to enable him to care for a person who is normally resident there and is in need of such care;
(l) such other purposes as may be specified by order of the Secretary of State.
12. Under section 169 of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989, a local housing authority may provide professional, technical and administrative services for owners and occupiers of dwellings in connection with works to their dwellings in certain circumstances. Those circumstances include works within section 23 HGCRA. The services may be free or subject to such charge as the local housing authority determines.
13. Under those powers, the Council established the HIA, which is an internal team that provides many of the “preliminary or ancillary services” to residents to assist them in applying for DFGs and arranging with contractors for home adaptations.
14. In the hearing bundle, we were provided with a copy of the form that is completed by applicants who wish to use the services provided by the HIA, to which both parties referred. We set out some of the key points from that form below.
(1) The services provided by the HIA are described in general terms as a “Project Management service that is provided to private applicants undertaking works within the Private Sector Housing Financial Assistance Scheme”.
(2) The fee structure is described in the following terms:
A minimum fee of £350 +VAT will be applied for the Councils Home Improvement Agency Service regardless of the cost of the works.
Where the cost of the building work is up to (and including) £30,000 the fee applied for the Councils Home Improvement Agency Service will be 15% of the cost of the works +VAT.
Where the cost of the building work exceeds £30,000 the fee applied for the Councils Home Improvement Agency Service will be 12% of the cost of the works + VAT
(3) It is noted that the cost of the fee “is covered within the Disabled Facilities Grant once approved”.
(4) It is made clear that applicants will have to engage directly with contractors to do the home adaptations as “Portsmouth City Council do not directly employ contractors to do this work”.
(5) The form includes a list of services provided by the HIA in the following terms:
Before building work starts:
– Discuss the customer's needs and set a budget for both the agency service and the building work.
– Carry out a basic survey of the site where the work is to be undertaken and advice on any specialist surveys which should be obtained.
– Advice on any permission's [sic] which would need to be obtained such as building regulations, or planning consent.
– Advise on whether any other consultants should be appointed.
– Prepare a specification for the building work.
– Arrange for detailed drawings for the building work, if necessary, through a third party.
– Apply for planning permission, if necessary.
– Apply for Building Regulations approval, if necessary.
– Advise on the procedures for and costs of getting Party Wall consents, and give the occupiers of neighboring [sic] properties any party wall notices if needed.
– Help the customer to obtain estimates and appoint an appropriate contractor to carry out the works.
– Advise the client on using a building contract and help to fill in the details for a contract.
After Building Work has started:
– Inspect the site to see whether the contractor is generally keeping to his responsibilities under the contract.
– Advise on any changes to the specification or unforeseen works that might arise and the cost implications.
– Check the builder's invoices to ensure they are accurate.
– When the building work is complete to his reasonable satisfaction, issue a certificate which shows the finish date.
– Give the contractor a list of any faults which have appeared at any time up to 3 months after the finish date which the contractor must put right.
– When the contractor has put right all the faults listed by the agency service, issue a certificate to confirm this.
15. Housing Renewals Officers (“HROs”), who work within the HIA, are introduced to potential applicants following a referral from the occupational therapy team. An occupational therapist will have completed a “Request for Consideration for Grant Aid” form, which sets out the needs of the individual, any adaptations that may be necessary, and details such as whether the individual is entitled to any passporting benefits.
16. From that point onwards, assuming that the applicant wishes to proceed, the HRO will be responsible for:
(1) an initial visit to explain the process, assess the site, and advise applicants on the DFG and other sources of funding;
(2) preparing plans, specifications and a tender package, and organizing a tender process;
(3) liaising with interested parties such as landlords, Housing Associations and managing agents;
(4) where appropriate, applying for planning permission, Building Regulations approvals and listed building consents;
(5) requesting approval for a DFG and arranging contracts with contractors;
(6) inspecting the works while they are in progress and certifying works when they are completed.
17. It was common ground before us that a DFG is awarded to the applicant. It is then used by the applicant to pay the costs of the adaptation whether they are the costs of any contractors or the HIA’s fee.
18. It was Mr Bull’s evidence, which is also relied upon by HMRC, that 95% of those who are offered the HIA’s service to assist with home adaptations take up the service. Mr Bull suggested that the HIA’s service “only tends to not be used where there would be a significant cost to the client in cases where the [DFG] is far exceeded”.
Procedural background
19. The dispute concerning the VAT treatment of these services has a long history. Most of that history is not of particular relevance to this appeal. It is sufficient to note that, in relation to periods prior to 17 February 2017, HMRC made repayments of overpaid VAT in relation to VAT on fees charged by the HIA on the grounds that the Council was entitled to rely on HMRC guidance in respect of supplies made before that date. However, HMRC guidance changed on 17 February 2017 and HMRC asserts that supplies made after that date are standard-rated for VAT purposes.
20. As regards the periods that remain under appeal:
(1) On 23 April 2021, HMRC rejected the Council’s claim for overpaid tax for the period between 17 February 2017 and 30 April 2020. On 1 August 2021, the Council appealed to this tribunal. The appeal was given reference number TC/2021/02780.
(2) On 16 July 2024, HMRC rejected the Council’s claim for overpaid tax for the period between 1 May 2020 and 31 March 2024. On 13 August 2024, the Council appealed to this tribunal. The appeal was given reference number TC/2024/04474.
21. On 27 November 2024, the Council applied to consolidate TC/2024/04474 and TC/2021/02780.
22. On 7 August 2025, the tribunal directed that TC/2021/02780 and TC/2024/04474 be consolidated under TC/2021/02780.
The relevant legislation and HMRC guidance
23. The supplies which are the subject of this appeal relate to periods both before and after the UK ceased to be a member state of the European Union (the “EU”). There was, however, no dispute between the parties that the supremacy of EU law continues to have effect in relation to the matters that are the subject of this appeal. Furthermore, although decisions of the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) following “IP completion day” (as defined in the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020) are not binding on this tribunal, none of the CJEU authorities to which the parties referred was decided after IP completion day.
Relevant EU law
24. The parties set out their arguments in this appeal almost exclusively by reference to the provisions of EU law. The relevant provision is Article 132(1) of Council Directive 2006/112/EC (the “Principal VAT Directive” or “PVD”), which required EU member states to exempt certain transactions from VAT. At all material times, it provided, so far as relevant, as follows:
1. Member States shall exempt the following transactions:
…
(b) hospital and medical care and closely related activities undertaken by bodies governed by public law or, under social conditions comparable with those applicable to bodies governed by public law, by hospitals, centres for medical treatment or diagnosis and other duly recognised establishments of a similar nature;
…
(g) the supply of services and of goods closely linked to welfare and social security work, including those supplied by old people's homes, by bodies governed by public law or by other bodies recognised by the Member State concerned as being devoted to social wellbeing;
(h) the supply of services and of goods closely linked to the protection of children and young persons by bodies governed by public law or by other organisations recognised by the Member State concerned as being devoted to social wellbeing;
…
25. The key provision for our purposes is Article 132(1)(g), but we have included some of the other paragraphs of Article 132(1) in the extract above as they are referred to in some of the CJEU decisions to which we will need to refer in this decision.
26. Article 134 PVD is also relevant. At all material times, it provided:
The supply of goods or services shall not be granted exemption, as provided for in points (b), (g), (h), (i), (l), (m) and (n) of Article 132(1), in the following cases:
(a) where the supply is not essential to the transactions exempted;
(b) where the basic purpose of the supply is to obtain additional income for the body in question through transactions which are in direct competition with those of commercial enterprises subject to VAT.
Relevant UK legislation
27. The relevant provisions of the Principal VAT Directive are given effect in UK law by item 9 Group 7 Schedule 9 VATA, which provides that the following supplies are exempt from VAT:
9. The supply by—
(a) a charity,
(b) a state-regulated private welfare institution or agency, or
(c) a public body,
of welfare services and of goods supplied in connection with those welfare services.
28. Notes (5) and (6) to Group 7 are also relevant. They provide:
(5) In item 9 “public body” means —
(a) a Government department within the meaning of section 41(6);
(b) a local authority;
(c) a body which acts under any enactment or instrument for public purposes and not for its own profit and which performs functions similar to those of a Government department or local authority.
(6) In item 9 “welfare services” means services which are directly connected with—
(a) the provision of care, treatment or instruction designed to promote the physical or mental welfare of elderly, sick, distressed or disabled persons,
(b) the care or protection of children and young persons, or
(c) the provision of spiritual welfare by a religious institution as part of a course of instruction or a retreat, not being a course or a retreat designed primarily to provide recreation or a holiday,
and, in the case of services supplied by a state-regulated private welfare institution, includes only those services in respect of which the institution is so regulated.
29. There was no argument before us that item 9 Group 7 Schedule 9 VATA could not be interpreted in light of the wording and purpose of Article 132(1)(g) and Article 134 PVD and in order to achieve the result pursued by Article 132(1)(g) and Article 134 PVD.
HMRC guidance
30. As we have mentioned above, HMRC changed its guidance in relation to the provision by local housing authorities of support services such as those provided by the HIA in February 2017. The current guidance is found in HMRC VAT Government and Public Bodies Manual at VATGPB8350, which provides, in part, as follows:
Local authority acts as agent
The local authority may act as agent of the homeowner in organising the building work. Nevertheless, the authority’s contribution remains third party consideration without entitlement to section 33 recovery.
If the local authority charges the homeowner for its agency services, the fee is taxable. This was confirmed by the High Court in Ashfield District Council (CHD [2001] STC 1706).
The case did not concern agency fees as such. The Council claimed that, when acting on the householders’ behalf, it entered into contracts as principal and not as the householders’ agent. In rejecting this argument the High Court held that once an authority agrees to award grants it holds these monies on trust for the applicant householder. Once awarded the grant money ceases to be the property of the local authority.
At the time of the case, authorities were permitted to apportion the taxable treatment of the agency fee according to the proportion of the work paid for by the householder. With it being held that the grant money, once awarded, was no longer the property of the local authority it followed that VAT should be accounted for by the authority on the whole of the agency fee.
The parties’ submissions in outline
31. We will address the issues raised by the parties in more detail in our discussion below. However, we will first set out a summary of the parties’ submissions.
32. Mr Allen, for the Council, contends that the fees charged by the HIA for assisting disabled and elderly residents to obtain DFGs and to manage home adaptation works are exempt welfare services. He submits:
(1) the HIA provides assessment-led support, advice, guidance, property visits, liaison with contractors, project management, monitoring of works, and ongoing assistance tailored to the needs of vulnerable individuals;
(2) HMRC’s characterization of the services as merely administrative ignores their substance and welfare-focused purpose. The essential purpose of the services is to promote the physical and mental welfare, independence and quality of life of disabled and elderly people by enabling them to remain safely in their own homes;
(3) the services are directly connected with the provision of care and welfare within Article 132(1)(g) PVD and item 9(c), Group 7 (see The Lilias Graham Trust v HMRC [2021] UKUT 36 (TCC)). The limitations in Article 134 PVD are not relevant.
33. Mr Winter, for HMRC, submits that the HIA’s supplies are not exempt welfare services. They are project management and intermediary services connected with the procurement of building works. HMRC accepts that the Council is a public body and that the adaptations to homes funded by DFGs may serve welfare objectives. However, he argues that the HIA’s activities are not themselves welfare services. He says:
(1) the HIA’s services are not sufficiently closely linked to welfare work within Article 132(1)(g) PVD because they are not “logically part” of the provision of welfare and social security work and do not constitute “an indispensable stage” in the process of the supply of those services: Joined Cases C-394/04 and C-395/04 Diagnostiko & Therapeftiko Kentro Athinon-Ygeia AE v Ipourgos Ikonomikon [2006] STC 1349 (“Ygeia”);
(2) the HIA’s services are not “essential” to welfare and social security work for the purposes of Article 134: Case C-415/04 Staatssecretaris van Financiën v Stichting Kinderopvang Enschede [2007] STC 294 (“Kinderopvang”);
(3) the exemption in Article 132(1)(g) can only apply if the underlying transactions that are facilitated by the HIA’s services are themselves exempt supplies (see Article 134 and Kinderopvang); the building works are not exempt supplies.
Discussion
34. There is no dispute between the parties that the Council is a “body governed by public law” for the purposes of Article 132(1)(g) PVD and a “public body” for the purposes of Note (5) Group 7 Schedule 9 VATA. The parties also agree that Article 134(b) is not relevant in this case.
35. The issues before the tribunal therefore fall into the following broad categories:
(1) Are the HIA’s services closely linked to welfare and social security work within Article 132(1)(g) PVD?
(2) If so, can Article 134(a) PVD apply to exclude the services from exemption either:
(a) because the supplies are not “essential” to the welfare services; or
(b) because the underlying transactions are building works, which are not “exempted transactions”?
Article 132(1)(g): closely linked to welfare and social security work
36. We have set out above the provisions of Article 132(1)(g) PVD. As we mentioned, the parties conducted their arguments in this appeal by reference to the wording of the PVD rather than the UK legislation. For the most part, we have adopted the same approach in this decision.
Matters not in dispute
37. We will begin with some general points, which we do not understand to be in dispute.
(1) The first is that Article 132(1)(g) provides an exemption from VAT. Exemptions from VAT are to be interpreted strictly as they constitute exceptions from the general principle that VAT is to be levied on all services supplied for a consideration by a taxable person (see, for example, Kinderopvang [13]).
(2) The second is that the strict interpretation cannot be so strict as to deprive the exception of its purpose. The purpose of the exception in Article 132(1)(g) to reduce the cost of services in the social sector and to make them more accessible to the individuals who may benefit from them (Case C-498/03, Kingscrest Associates Limited and Montecello Limited v HMRC [2005] STC 1547 at [30]).
The meaning of “welfare”
38. Our starting point is the meaning of “welfare and social security work” in Article 132(1)(g). The only authority to which we were referred on this question was the opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-335/14, Les Jardins de Jouvence SCRL v État Belge (“Les Jardins AG”). That case concerned the application of Article 13A(1)(g) of the Sixth Directive – the predecessor provision to Article 132(1)(g) PVD – to the recovery of input tax on construction services relating to serviced residences. In his opinion, Advocate General Bot gave the following definitions of “social security” and “welfare”.
39. At Les Jardins AG [32], the Advocate General described “social security” as:
“all regimes which ensure protection by indemnifying the population against the various social risks, such as sickness, maternity, old age or accidents in the workplace”.
40. At Les Jardins AG [38], the Advocate General described “welfare” in the following terms:
38. Unlike services falling within the scope of social security, welfare is characterised by the individual assessment of needs. In my opinion, it is precisely because these needs are not covered by social security that it becomes necessary – even vital – to the person concerned for an organisation governed by public law or recognised as charitable by the Member State to cater for them. The same is true of taking responsibility for the needs of elderly or disabled people, which requires the provision of accommodation and care adapted to their vulnerable condition.
41. In accordance with these comments, social security work usually involves regimes protecting the population as a whole from various social risks, whereas welfare is the provision of a personalized care or assistance adapted to the needs of vulnerable individuals. In this appeal, we are concerned with the provision of welfare services.
The meaning of “closely linked”
42. Article 132(1)(g) refers to services that are “closely linked” to welfare and social security work. As to the meaning of this phrase, Mr Winter directed us to the decision of the CJEU in Ygeia.
43. Ygeia concerned the application of Article 13A(1)(b) of the Sixth Directive, the predecessor provision to Article 132(1)(b) PVD, which provided, in similar terms, an exemption for supplies of “hospital and medical care” and “closely related activities”. The supplies in question were the provision of accommodation and meals to persons accompanying inpatients at hospitals and the supply of televisions and telephone services to inpatients themselves. The CJEU found that the supplies were not “closely related” to the provision of hospital care and so not exempt.
44. The CJEU said this at Ygeia [23]-[25]:
23. The exemption of activities closely related to hospital and medical care provided for in art 13A(1)(b) of the Sixth Directive is designed to ensure that access to such care is not prevented by the increased costs of providing it that would follow if it, or closely related activities, were subject to VAT (EC Commission v France [2001] ECR I-249, para 23).
24. The hospital and medical care envisaged by this provision is, according to the case law, that which has as its purpose the diagnosis, treatment and, in so far as possible, cure of diseases or health disorders (Dornier [2005] STC 228, [2003] ECR I-12911, para 48).
25. Accordingly, taking account of the objective pursued by the exemption provided for in art 13A(1)(b) of the Sixth Directive, it follows that only the supply of services which are logically part of the provision of hospital and medical-care services, and which constitute an indispensable stage in the process of the supply of those services to achieve their therapeutic objectives, is capable of amounting to 'closely related activities' within the meaning of that provision. Only such services are of a nature to influence the cost of health care which is made accessible to individuals by the exemption in question.
45. The CJEU concluded at Ygeia [29]:
29. It follows that the provision of services which, like those at issue in the main proceedings, are of such a nature as to improve the comfort and well-being of in-patients, do not, as a general rule, qualify for the exemption provided for in art 13A(1)(b) of the Sixth Directive. It can be otherwise only if those services are essential to achieve the therapeutic objectives pursued by the hospital services and medical care in connection with which they have been supplied.
46. Mr Winter asserted that these comments are applicable by analogy to the exemption within Article 132(1)(g) which uses the words “closely linked” rather than the words “closely related”. Subject to one reservation, to which we refer below, we agree. Indeed, the CJEU in Ygeia (at Ygeia [26]) suggests that similar constraints would apply to the other exemptions within Article 132(1) which refer to supplies that are “closely related” or “closely linked” to an otherwise exempt supply. On that basis, and adapting the wording in Ygeia [25], a supply would only be regarded as “closely linked” to welfare or social security work if it is “logically part” of the provision of welfare and social security work, and constitutes “an indispensable stage in the process” of the supply of those services to achieve their welfare objectives.
47. Our reservation is this. We note that the exemption in Article 132(1)(b) extends to both the supply of “hospital and medical care” and the supply of services that are “closely related” to such supplies. By contrast, Article 132(1)(g) simply refers to supplies that are closely linked to “welfare and social security work”. There is no separate reference to a principal supply of “welfare and social security work” which falls within the exemption. In this respect, we note that the UK legislation is worded differently; it refers to “welfare services” and separately to “goods supplied in connection with welfare services”. We raised this question with the parties at the hearing. Both parties took the view that the principal supply of welfare services would fall within the scope of the exemption in Article 132(1)(g). We have proceeded on that basis.
Application to the facts of this case
48. In the present case, HMRC accept that the provision of home adaptations funded by DFGs is capable of being a welfare service. HMRC, however, dispute that the HIA service is “closely linked” to the provision of that welfare service. In summary, Mr Winter says that the HIA service is not an “indispensable part” of the welfare service. This can be seen by the fact that where applicants would have to pay for the service (because of the means-testing), they tend not to take it up.
49. We disagree. It seems to us that the HIA service is a fundamental part of the overall service. DFGs can only be approved for building work that meets certain conditions (in section 23 HGCRA). Grants are only given in relation to assessed and identified social needs. In our view, the provision of home adaptations to disabled and elderly persons funded by DFGs meets the definition set out by the Advocate General in Les Jardins.
50. Furthermore, the HIA service is an integral part of delivering that service. The services interact with all aspects of the service – the arrangement of funding, the agreement of contracts with builders, the supervision of work, and the arrangement of payment following completion. These are all aspects that we would regard as necessary in order to complete the provision of the building work funded by a DFG. For that reason, in our view, they are “logically part” of the provision of that service within the description of welfare services given by the Advocate General in Les Jardins (at Les Jardins AG [38]). If VAT were to be charged, it would have the effect of increasing the overall cost of delivering the welfare service. The inclusion of the HIA services within Article 132(1)(g) therefore meets the overall rationale of the exemptions in Article 132 as explained by the CJEU in Ygeia (at Ygeia [23]).
Article 134: essential to the transactions exempted
51. The second issue is whether the HIA services fall outside the exemption by virtue of Article 134(a) PVD because their supply is not “essential to the transactions exempted”.
“essential”
52. As regards the meaning of “essential” in this context, Mr Winter referred us to the opinion of the Advocate General in Kinderopvang (“Kinderopvang AG”). Kinderopvang concerned the tax treatment of introductory services provided by a Dutch charitable foundation whereby it introduced parents to approved carers who would provide childcare. The Advocate General said this at paragraphs [55]-[57] of his opinion:
55. It seems to me that if the Foundation were to do no more than keep a list of all people known to offer childcare and to make that list available to parents, the service could in no way be described as essential. There are many other ways in which parents can enter into contact with would-be carers.
56. However, if the Foundation's screening and training activities are such that its services as intermediary provide access to only such competent and trustworthy carers as parents would otherwise have been unable to identify, then the latter services may be viewed as essential in order to gain access to childcare of that quality, even if the Foundation does not accept responsibility for any shortcomings in the childcare actually provided.
57. I am thus of the view that the relevant factual assessment is whether the care to which access is provided is of such a kind or quality as parents could not be assured of without the Foundation's services as intermediary.
53. These comments were endorsed by the CJEU (Kinderopvang [27]).
54. On the basis of these comments, we would regard “essential” in this context as meaning an element that is important to attaining the objective of the welfare services and that contributes to the value of those services to the recipient.
“the transactions exempted”
55. Article 134(a) also requires that the supply must be essential to the “transactions exempted”. In Ygeia, the CJEU (Ygeia [26]) relied on this provision as confirmation of its conclusion that the provision of televisions and telephone services to inpatients and accommodation for persons accompanying inpatients were not closely related to the principal supply of healthcare. That was a decision based on the provisions of what is now Article 132(1)(b).
56. In Kinderopvang, the CJEU decided that the provision of the introductory services by the Dutch foundation was unlikely to be within the scope of the exemption on the grounds that the services of the carers were unlikely to qualify as exempt themselves. The CJEU says this at Kinderopvang [22]-[23]:
22. The Netherlands government refers with good reason in this regard to the wording of art 13A(2)(b) of the Sixth Directive, which provides that:
'the supply of services or goods shall not be granted exemption as provided for in (1)(b), (g), (h), (i), (l), (m) and (n) above if … it is not essential to the transactions exempted.'
It is apparent from these provisions that the main transaction, to which the supply of goods or services in question is closely linked, must itself also be an exempted transaction. In the case in the main proceedings, the exemption of the Foundation's services as intermediary between the parents of the child being cared for and the host parents thus presupposes that the childcare service provided by the latter is itself exempt from VAT.
23. Given that host parents are independent persons who cannot be regarded as bodies governed by public law, the childcare services can be covered by the exemption under art 13A(1)(g) or (h) of the Sixth Directive only to the extent that they are provided by 'organisations recognised as charitable by the Member State concerned'. The national authorities have a discretion in this regard which they must exercise in accordance with Community law (see, to that effect, Kingscrest Associates Ltd v Customs and Excise Comrs [2005] STC 1547, [2005] ECR I-4427, paras 48 to 53). In this connection the Court has held inter alia that the expression 'other organisations recognised as charitable by the Member State concerned' in art 13A(1)(g) of the Sixth Directive does not exclude from that exemption natural persons running a business, in that case a private entity seeking to make a profit (KingscrestAssociates Ltd, para 36). It is for the national court to determine whether the childcare services provided by host parents satisfy the conditions for exemption set out in those provisions, in particular the condition that the service provider must fulfil the criterion of 'charitable'.
57. In Kinderopvang there was clearly a separate supply of childcare to which the introductory service was linked. That ‘principal supply’ – we use that term loosely and not in any technical sense – was unlikely to be exempt within the scope of the exemption because the carers were unlikely to be public bodies or charities.
58. That analysis leads us to the critical question in this case. Mr Allen argued that Article 134 cannot apply. As we understand his argument, it is that there is a supply of welfare services made by the Council. That supply includes the HIA services. They are exempt within Article 132(1)(g). Article 134 can only apply to services that are closely linked or closely related to another supply of welfare services. It cannot apply to the supply of welfare services itself.
59. We think that there may be some merit in that point in other cases. However, it does not assist us here. The overall welfare service in this case is the provision of home adaptations funded by DFGs. As described by Sir Andrew Morritt VC in Ashfield District Council v Customs & Excise Commissioners [2001] STC 1706, the manner in which that service is provided is by funds being made available to applicants, which applicants then use to spend on approved services. The contract for the provision of the adaptations is between the applicant and the contractor. The contract for the HIA service is between the applicant and the council. The HIA acts as the applicant’s agent in dealing with other parties.
60. The HIA’s services may well be “essential” to the overall provision of welfare – the provision of home adaptations funded by DFGs – and assist in achieving a welfare objective, but they are not essential to “transactions exempted”. The transactions that provide the home adaptations in this case are the provision of building works by the contractors. The contractors are not charities or public bodies. Their services will not fall within the exemption. The HIA services coordinate those services and assist in their provision. But the building works are not “exempted” transactions and so the HIA services are not essential to “transactions exempted”.
61. For this reason, in our view, Article 134(a) applies. The HIA services cannot fall within Article 132(1)(g).
62. As we have described, the parties have argued this case by reference to the relevant provisions of EU law. It was no part of either party’s case that the UK legislation was not capable of a conforming interpretation. On that basis, our conclusions on the EU law issues determine this appeal.
Disposition
63. We dismiss this appeal.
Right to apply for permission to appeal
64. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice.
Release date: 20th OCTOBER 2026
At Kohen Avocats, our tax lawyer in Paris can review your situation.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).