Tax United Kingdom
D Brown & Anor v The Commissioners for HMRC
Neutral Citation: [2026] UKFTT 01484 (TC)
Case Number: TC10068
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL
TAX CHAMBER
By remote video hearing
Appeal reference: TC/2023/16239
INCOME TAX – whether earnings of a diver within Section 15 ITTOIA 2005 can be regarded as earnings of a partnership – no – appeal dismissed
Heard on: 18 August 2026
Judgment date: 22 October 2026
Before
TRIBUNAL JUDGE STAPENHURST
MS GILL HUNTER
Between
MR & MRS D BROWN
Appellants
and
THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HIS MAJESTY’S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS
Respondents
Representation:
For the Appellants: Mr I P Evans of MTL McHardy Trenfield, on behalf of the Appellants
For the Respondents: Mr Gyasi, litigator of HM Revenue and Customs’ Solicitor’s Office
DECISION
Introduction
1. This appeal concerns a closure notice issued by HMRC under section 28B Taxes Management Act 1970 ("TMA") on 5 October 2023 in respect of the partnership return submitted by Mr and Mrs Brown for the tax year ending 5 April 2016. The closure notice amended the partnership return by reducing the reported partnership profit of £146,013 to nil.
2. The partnership return treated income earned by Mr Brown through his diving activities as partnership income and allocated the profits equally between Mr and Mrs Brown.
3. HMRC concluded that the income arose from Mr Brown's personal engagement with Subsea 7 Crewing Services Pte Ltd ("Subsea 7") and did not constitute income of any partnership.
4. Prior to the hearing, the Appellants provided a skeleton argument in which they accepted that Mr Brown had been employed by Subsea 7 under a minimum-days commitment contract until November 2015 and contended that he subsequently worked as a self-employed diver under a day-rate worker arrangement.
5. During the hearing it became common ground that all of the income included within the partnership return for the 2015/16 tax year arose during the period in which Mr Brown had been employed by Subsea 7 under the minimum-days commitment contract.
6. In those circumstances, the principal issue for determination was whether income earned personally by Mr Brown, under an engagement which the Appellants accepted constituted employment, could nevertheless properly be treated as partnership income and allocated between Mr and Mrs Brown for tax purposes.
Background
7. On 7 August 2015 Mr and Mrs Brown registered a partnership for self-assessment purposes.
8. On 3 January 2017 Mr and Mrs Brown submitted a partnership tax return for the tax year ending 5 April 2016. The return reported partnership profits of £146,013 which were allocated equally between Mr and Mrs Brown.
9. On 18 January 2017 HMRC opened an enquiry into the 2015/16 partnership return pursuant to section 12AC TMA.
10. During the course of the enquiry HMRC sought information concerning the basis on which income arising from Mr Brown's diving activities had been returned through the partnership. Correspondence subsequently passed between HMRC and the advisers acting for Mr and Mrs Brown.
11. The dispute between the parties continued over a number of years. During that period HMRC obtained documentation and information relating to Mr Brown's engagement by Subsea 7 and the treatment of the income in issue.
12. On 5 October 2023 HMRC issued a closure notice in respect of the 2015/16 partnership return. HMRC concluded that the income returned through the partnership arose from Mr Brown's personal engagement with Subsea 7 and did not constitute partnership income. HMRC accordingly amended the partnership return by reducing the reported partnership profit of £146,013 to nil.
13. By letter dated 16 October 2023 Mr and Mrs Brown's advisers appealed against HMRC's decision.
14. On 25 October 2023 the appeal was notified to the Tribunal.
15. The appeal was initially registered in the name of David Brown, the nominated partner. As this appeal concerns amendments made to a partnership return, the Tribunal has amended the title of the proceedings to reflect that the Appellants are Mr and Mrs Brown.
Findings of Fact
16. Mr Brown is a professional mixed gas diver.
17. We find that Mr Brown was:
(1) a salaried employee from 1 January 2013 to 15 November 2015 under a minimum-days commitment contract; and
(2) a day-rate worker from 21 March 2016 onwards under an "as and when" type arrangement.
18. However, no income arising from that later arrangement forms part of the profits returned in the partnership return which is the subject of this appeal.
19. On 3 January 2017 the Appellants submitted a partnership return for 2015/16 reporting profits of £146,013 and allocating those profits equally between them.
20. The income reported in the return was derived from diving services personally performed by Mr Brown for Subsea 7 under the minimum-days commitment contract.
21. Subsea 7 contracted with Mr Brown personally and not with any partnership.
22. No evidence was produced of any assignment, novation or other arrangement transferring contractual rights or obligations to a partnership.
23. No partnership agreement was produced to the Tribunal. Neither Mr Brown nor Mrs Brown attended the hearing, and neither provided witness evidence.
24. We therefore make our findings on the basis of the documentary evidence before us and the parties' submissions.
Relevant Legislation and Authorities
25. Section 15 ITTOIA 2005 applies to certain employed divers and diving supervisors. Where its conditions are met, the performance of qualifying duties of employment is treated for income tax purposes as the carrying on of a trade.
26. The effect of s. 15 was considered by the Supreme Court in Fowler v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2020] UKSC 22 (“Fowler”). The provision deems the performance of qualifying duties of employment to be the carrying on of a trade for specified income tax purposes.
27. The effect of s. 15 in the context of partnership arrangements involving offshore divers has been considered by this Tribunal in Puttnam v HMRC [2019] UKFTT 389 (TC) (“Puttnam”), Green v HMRC [2019] UKFTT 390 (TC) (“Green”), Corrigall v HMRC [2022] UKFTT 163 (TC) (“Corrigall”) and Lowe v HMRC [2022] UKFTT 164 (TC) (“Lowe”).
28. In each of those cases the Tribunal rejected the contention that s. 15 converts qualifying earnings into partnership income or creates a trade capable of being carried on by, or owned by, a partnership.
29. During the hearing we raised with Mr Evans the relevance of s. 15 ITTOIA 2005 and the authorities considering its effect. No developed submissions were made on behalf of the Appellants concerning the operation of that provision.
Discussion
30. The Appellants accepted that Mr Brown was employed by Subsea 7 under the minimum-days commitment contract until November 2015 and it became common ground that all of the income included in the partnership return arose during that period.
31. The Appellants' case, as ultimately advanced at the hearing, was not founded upon any developed analysis of section 15 ITTOIA 2005 or the authorities considering its effect. Rather, Mr Evans submitted that a partnership existed between Mr and Mrs Brown and that previous accountants had prepared the relevant returns on that basis. We have considered those submissions with care. However, despite being invited during the hearing to identify the legal basis for the Appellants' position, we were unable to discern any coherent explanation as to how earnings derived from Mr Brown's employment with Subsea 7 could become income of a partnership consisting of Mr and Mrs Brown.
32. The fact that a partnership may have existed does not, without more, establish that income earned by one partner is income of the partnership. Whether particular receipts constitute partnership income depends upon the legal and factual basis upon which those receipts were earned.
33. In the present case, the earnings in question arose from contractual arrangements between Subsea 7 and Mr Brown personally. Mr Brown personally performed the diving duties. Subsea 7 did not contract with any partnership involving Mr and Mrs Brown and there is no evidence of any assignment, novation or other arrangement by which the contractual rights and obligations were transferred to a partnership.
34. The income in issue was earned through services personally provided by Mr Brown pursuant to contractual arrangements between himself and Subsea 7. On the evidence before us, the right to receive that income belonged to Mr Brown and not to any partnership.
35. Section 15 ITTOIA 2005 does not assist the Appellants. As explained by the Supreme Court in Fowler, the provision deems qualifying employment activities to be the carrying on of a trade for specified income tax purposes. It does not alter the source of the income or the identity of the person entitled to it.
36. Consistently with Fowler, the Tribunal held in Puttnam, Green, Corrigall and Lowe that s. 15 does not convert qualifying earnings into partnership income and does not create a trade capable of ownership by a partnership. We respectfully agree with that reasoning.
37. Accordingly, neither the existence of a partnership between Mr and Mrs Brown, nor the preparation of previous tax returns on a partnership basis, nor the operation of s. 15 ITTOIA 2005 provides any basis upon which earnings received by Mr Brown from Subsea 7 under his employment could properly be returned as partnership income.
38. We therefore conclude that the income returned through the partnership return did not constitute partnership income and that HMRC was correct to amend the return accordingly.
Decision
39. We conclude that:
(1) the income in dispute arose from Mr Brown's employment with Subsea 7;
(2) section 15 ITTOIA 2005 does not convert qualifying earnings into partnership income or create a trade capable of being carried on by, or owned by, a partnership;
(3) the income arising from Mr Brown's diving activities did not constitute partnership income; and
(4) HMRC correctly amended the partnership return for 2015/16 by reducing the reported partnership profit to nil.
40. The appeal is dismissed.
Right to apply for permission to appeal
41. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice.
Release date: 22nd OCTOBER 2026
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our tax lawyer in Paris.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).