Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
Saitama CEO Manpreet Kohli Faces U.S. Extradition: What French and EU Safeguards Would Require

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

Saitama CEO Manpreet Kohli Faces U.S. Extradition: What French and EU Safeguards Would Require

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

The extradition fight involving Saitama crypto executive Manpreet Kohli has moved from a headline about a collapsed token to a live test of cross-border criminal procedure. On 19 August 2026, a United Kingdom judge rejected Kohli’s challenge to his extradition to the United States, according to Reuters reporting published on 26 August. The ruling sends the case to the UK ministerial stage, while an appeal remains possible. It does not decide whether the American allegations are true. It also does not create a French precedent. Yet the case is highly relevant for anyone arrested in France on a United States request: the same questions about double criminality, medical evidence, authenticated documents, detention and the division between judges and government would arise under a different legal timetable.

The American case began with the US Department of Justice’s 2024 prosecution of alleged market manipulation and wire fraud around Saitama, a crypto project that once reached a reported peak value of about $7.5 billion. The indictment alleges secret sales, false statements about the token and proceeds of tens of millions of dollars. Kohli is presumed innocent. The legal question at an extradition hearing is narrower than guilt: can the requesting state’s conduct and documents satisfy the treaty and the requested state’s safeguards? This analysis explains what the UK ruling changes, what a comparable request would require in France and what a person should do in the first hours after a provisional arrest.

I. Can the United Kingdom send Manpreet Kohli to the United States after the Saitama ruling?

A. What did Judge Goozee decide, and what remains open?

The reported decision by Judge Samuel Goozee is a judicial extradition decision, not a transfer order. That distinction matters. In a modern extradition system, the court normally decides whether the statutory and treaty bars are satisfied. If the court rules that the request may proceed, an executive authority then decides whether the person should actually be surrendered. The defence may also have appeal routes. The result is a sequence, not a single moment at which a newspaper headline turns into physical removal.

Reuters reported that Judge Goozee rejected arguments centred on Kohli’s health and the conditions he would face in the United States. The same report stated that Kohli was granted bail of £200,000 and that an appeal remained available. Those facts should be read carefully. Bail means that the court has managed the risk of flight and the risk to the process; it does not mean that the extradition request has disappeared. An appeal can challenge an error of law, a failure to apply the statutory test or an inadequate assessment of evidence. It is not a second opportunity to litigate every allegation as though the extradition court were the trial court.

The case is also separate from the American merits litigation. The US prosecution concerns alleged wire fraud, market manipulation, conspiracy and unlicensed money transmission. The American court’s treatment of an argument that the Saitama token was not a security may affect the domestic prosecution, but it does not automatically decide extradition. An extradition judge can ask whether the conduct described in the request is criminal in both jurisdictions, whether the supporting documents are valid and whether surrender would breach a protected right. That judge generally does not weigh all of the evidence in order to decide whether a jury should convict.

This separation protects both sides. The requesting state is not forced to prove its whole case before trial, and the requested state does not surrender a person on the basis of a label alone. The request must still identify the conduct, the chronology, the legal provisions, the warrant or charging document and the applicable penalty. A defence that simply says “this is a crypto dispute” may be too broad. A defence that identifies a missing act, a mismatch between the indictment and the warrant, an offence created after the alleged conduct or a material failure in the health assurances addresses the actual legal controls.

Kohli’s nationality is another fact that must not be blurred. Public reporting describes him as an Indian national. A French court would apply French law and the France–United States extradition framework to a person arrested in France, not the UK’s Extradition Act. The UK decision therefore cannot be cited as authority for the proposition that a French court must reach the same outcome. Its value is practical: it shows how a current crypto prosecution can convert a medical argument, a treaty request and a cross-border custody risk into a contested multi-stage proceeding.

For an international business executive, the immediate consequence is often operational rather than theoretical. An arrest can affect wallets, company accounts, employees, counsel, travel documents and parallel regulatory inquiries before any final surrender decision. The person and the defence team must preserve the record of treatment, medication, hospitalisation, diagnosis and suicide-risk assessments while also reconstructing the digital evidence. The two tracks should not be confused: medical evidence addresses the human-rights and detention question; transaction records and communications address the factual and double-criminality questions.

B. Why does the crypto indictment still matter at the extradition stage?

The US Department of Justice announced the Saitama prosecution in its release on the international market-manipulation operation. The release says that Kohli was arrested in the UK on 7 October 2024 and was awaiting extradition. It describes allegations that the Saitama leadership represented that regulators had reviewed the project, that insiders were not selling their holdings and that the token’s code prevented manipulation, while allegedly selling tokens secretly and making tens of millions of dollars. The release also records the presumption of innocence. Those are allegations, but they give the extradition court the factual map that a bare reference to “crypto fraud” would not provide.

The superseding indictment identifies the federal case as United States v. Kohli et al., Case No. 1:24-cr-10189-AK, filed on 19 September 2024. The charging document matters because an extradition request is document-led. A French judge needs to know who is sought, which acts are attributed to that person, when and where they allegedly occurred, which provisions are said to have been violated and what punishment is available. The relevant French provision on request documents, Article 696-8 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, requires the judgment, indictment or arrest warrant and the legal texts relied on. It also says, in the official wording, Les pièces ci-dessus mentionnées doivent être produites en original ou en copie certifiée conforme.

That document discipline creates several possible defence questions. Does the warrant cover the same conduct as the indictment? Has the requesting state supplied a certified and translated copy? Does the chronology show acts that occurred in France, the United States or a third country? Is the accused’s personal role particularised, or is the person grouped into a corporate narrative? Does the alleged benefit come from representations to investors, from trading activity, from transmission of funds or from a combination? Each answer may affect the legal characterisation without asking the extradition court to conduct the trial.

The treaty threshold is not a demand for identical vocabulary. The bilateral treaty published in the French Official Journal and codified in Decree No. 2002-117 provides for reciprocal surrender for extraditable offences. Its Article 2 uses a conduct-and-penalty test: the offence must be punishable under the laws of both countries, with a maximum custodial penalty of at least one year, or, where a sentence has already been imposed, a remaining sentence of at least six months. The EU–United States extradition agreement also works through treaty cooperation rather than replacing the France–US bilateral framework with a European arrest warrant.

A French court would therefore ask what conduct the American papers actually allege and whether French law criminalised that conduct at the relevant time. A false representation used to obtain funds may invite comparison with Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code, the French offence of fraud. That is not a conclusion that the Saitama allegations satisfy the article. The court would have to examine the representations, the intended victims, the causal link, the alleged benefit and the accused’s role. A market-manipulation label may also engage other financial rules, but a label cannot substitute for facts.

The timing of the French offence is decisive. In Criminal Chamber judgment No. 15-84.426 of 14 October 2015, the Cour de cassation required the extradition court to verify that the facts were punishable in France at the date of commission. It quashed a decision that lacked a legal basis because that temporal double-criminality check had not been properly made. For a fast-moving token project, the defence should build a dated legal and technical chronology: token launch, public statements, sales, code changes, exchange listings, investor communications and the dates on which the relevant French and European provisions were in force.

None of this turns an extradition hearing into a crypto trial. The point is narrower and more powerful: a precise indictment can support a precise challenge. If the papers are internally inconsistent, if the alleged conduct is not punishable in France at the relevant time or if the requested person’s role is not sufficiently identified, the defence can attack the statutory gateway. If the papers are complete, the defence must focus on the separate bars, rights and guarantees rather than asking the judge to resolve every disputed blockchain fact.

II. What would France require if a comparable U.S. request reached Paris?

A. How do French judges test mental health, evidence and double criminality?

France would start with the ordinary extradition procedure in the Code of Criminal Procedure, adjusted by the bilateral treaty. It is not the European arrest warrant procedure used between EU Member States. That distinction is especially important for a person who has seen recent headlines about rapid surrender within the European Union. A US request reaches France through diplomatic and ministerial channels, then moves through the prosecutor general and the investigating chamber of the relevant court of appeal, before an executive decision if the judicial opinion is favourable.

The first statutory filter is found in Article 696-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which prevents surrender for prosecution or punishment for a different act from the one that motivated extradition, subject to the specialty rules. Article 696-3 sets out the punishable facts that may ground extradition. It opens with the words Les faits qui peuvent donner lieu à l’extradition, qu’il s’agisse de la demander ou de l’accorder, sont les suivants : and requires, among other things, a criminal or sufficiently serious correctional offence. Its final double-criminality safeguard means that extradition cannot be granted where the conduct is not punishable in France as a criminal or correctional offence.

The next filter is the list in Article 696-4, introduced by the categorical words L’extradition n’est pas accordée :. The article covers, among other matters, French nationality in the circumstances defined by the code, a political offence or a request made for a political purpose, facts committed in France, a final French decision, limitation, an offence contrary to French public order, a proceeding that does not provide fundamental guarantees of defence and certain military offences. A court must work through each potentially relevant bar. It cannot reduce the analysis to the seriousness of the accusations or to diplomatic pressure.

For Kohli, the French-nationality bar would not appear on the public facts because reporting describes him as Indian. The point remains essential in another case: Article 696-4 assesses French nationality at the legally relevant time, including the date of the alleged offence. Nationality, place of conduct and a pending French prosecution should therefore be documented at the beginning, not added as an afterthought. A French resident who is not French does not receive the French-nationality protection, but still receives the procedural, treaty and human-rights safeguards.

Mental health is not an automatic exemption from extradition. It is a fact-sensitive risk analysis. The Article 6 of the France–US treaty allows refusal when surrender could have exceptionally serious consequences because of the person’s age or state of health. The treaty’s official text states: L’extradition peut être refusée par les autorités compétentes françaises ou par le Pouvoir exécutif des Etats-Unis, lorsqu’elle est susceptible d’avoir des conséquences exceptionnellement graves pour la personne dont l’extradition est demandée, en raison de son âge ou de son état de santé. The question is not whether the person has a diagnosis in the abstract. It is whether the evidence shows a sufficiently serious and concrete consequence in the actual receiving system.

The Cour de cassation’s approach to detention evidence is instructive. In Criminal Chamber judgment No. 22-80.654 of 11 October 2022, a US extradition case involving alleged cryptocurrency-related wire fraud and money laundering, the Court referred to the need for éléments objectifs, fiables, précis et dûment actualisés when assessing the risk justifying detention. That decision does not say that a crypto allegation creates a detention risk, nor that medical evidence always defeats surrender. It shows the evidential standard: the court needs current and reliable material, not a general assertion that the prosecution is international or severe.

In the France–US setting, the treaty also contains a death-penalty safeguard. The United States would have to address the treaty conditions if an offence could lead to capital punishment. The Saitama allegations described publicly do not make that the central issue, but the example illustrates why the full charging provisions and maximum penalties must be read rather than inferred from a media headline. The request may also contain assurances about custody, medical treatment, psychiatric assessment, medication, suicide prevention and access to counsel. A defence must test whether those assurances are specific, enforceable and matched to the person’s condition.

European human-rights case law reinforces that individualised method. In Aswat v. the United Kingdom, application No. 17299/12, judgment of 16 April 2013, the European Court of Human Rights examined whether a person with severe mental illness faced a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 in the receiving state. The case did not create a general rule that mental illness prevents extradition. It required the court to examine the illness, the proposed detention environment and the available assurances. In a French file, the evidence should address diagnosis, functional limitations, past crises, suicide risk, treatment continuity, medication supply, language, isolation, prison healthcare and the precise facility or regime likely to receive the person.

The French Court has also insisted that the requested person have an effective opportunity to contest the risk. In Ruling No. 541 of 30 March 2021, No. 21-80.421, concerning the France–US treaty and detention conditions, the Cour de cassation stated in its English presentation that The ordinary court is under obligation to guarantee a preventive and effective remedy to degrading treatment. The decision is useful for two reasons. First, custody can require judicial scrutiny before transfer. Second, a medical or detention argument must be supported by evidence capable of producing a real, current risk; a speculative concern may not be enough.

The requested person should separate three documents that are often mixed together: an expert report describing the condition; a country and facility report describing the likely detention conditions; and a legal submission explaining why those facts satisfy the treaty or Article 3 standard. A letter from a treating doctor may establish continuity of care but not prove the conditions in a US facility. A country report may describe a system generally but not show the individual’s specific risk. The strongest dossier connects the two and explains what safeguard would reduce the risk, whether the requesting state has offered it and who would monitor compliance.

The mental-health argument also interacts with bail. Under Article 696-19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, La mise en liberté peut être demandée à tout moment. The person may ask the court to replace custody with judicial supervision or another measure, supported by a stable address, reporting obligations, surrender of travel documents, medical appointments and a documented plan to prevent flight. A release application is not a concession on the merits. It protects the person while the extradition court examines the request and protects the proceeding through enforceable conditions.

B. What should a French resident or crypto business do after a provisional arrest?

The first hours determine whether the later file will contain usable evidence. A provisional arrest can be ordered urgently when a foreign request is on its way. Article 696-23 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets out the urgent-arrest framework and the information that must accompany the request, including identity, nationality, the offence, the place and date of the alleged acts and the applicable penalty. The France–US treaty can impose its own time limit for receipt of the formal request. In No. 21-80.421, the Cour de cassation applied the treaty’s 60-day period in the relevant provisional-arrest context. The treaty period must therefore be checked alongside the code, not replaced by a generic internet countdown.

Once brought before the prosecutor general, the requested person must understand the procedure and have access to counsel and an interpreter where necessary. Article 696-10 governs that appearance and the choice between consenting to extradition and opposing it. Consent can accelerate the case and narrows the dispute, but it should never be given merely because the arrest is frightening or because the person has not yet seen the papers. Before making that choice, counsel should obtain the warrant, indictment, treaty materials, translations, the alleged chronology and any medical or detention assurances.

If the person does not consent, the investigating chamber examines the request. Article 696-15 requires a reasoned opinion on whether extradition may be granted. The opinion is not the final executive surrender decision. An unfavourable final judicial opinion prevents extradition under Article 696-17. A favourable opinion allows the request to reach the executive stage, where Article 696-18 provides for an extradition decree on the report of the Minister of Justice and a one-month challenge period before the competent administrative court. The architecture matters because a defence may have a different argument at each stage: identity and documents before the court, guarantees and proportionality before the executive, and legality of the decree before the administrative judge.

Detention must be challenged as its own issue. Article 696-11 sets out the procedure when the person is not released after appearance before the prosecutor general. The court can also consider supervision measures. A person who waits for the merits hearing without asking for release may lose time that cannot be recovered, especially where the medical evidence concerns a rapidly deteriorating condition. The application should propose a credible alternative: a known residence, electronic monitoring if appropriate, regular police reporting, a prohibition on new travel documents, a guarantor and a treatment schedule.

The practical checklist for the defence should contain at least six tracks.

First, preserve identity and residence evidence. Keep passports, visas, French tax records, lease documents, family records, employment information and medical appointments. These documents can support a release plan, clarify nationality and show connections that make a structured measure workable. They should be copied lawfully and stored securely; no document should be altered after the arrest.

Second, obtain a complete health file. Ask treating doctors for dates, diagnoses, medication, prior admissions, risk assessments and the consequences of interruption. Request an independent expert assessment where the legal issue is disputed. The report should answer concrete questions: what happens if medication is delayed, what observation level is required, what kind of prison healthcare is adequate, whether transfer by air is safe and whether language or cultural barriers affect treatment.

Third, audit the extradition documents. Compare the warrant, indictment, affidavit, treaty certificate, translations and criminal provisions line by line. Check names, dates, aliases, nationality, locations, alleged transactions, account identifiers and the person’s individual role. A crypto prosecution can contain multiple entities, wallets and co-defendants; an imprecise attribution can be more significant than the broad label “market manipulation.” Counsel should identify whether the request is for prosecution, sentence enforcement or both.

Fourth, build the French double-criminality analysis from conduct. Do not begin with the English name of the US offence. Create a table of each alleged act, its date, its place, the persons allegedly deceived or affected, the benefit obtained and the French offence that might correspond. Then test whether the correspondence is legally sound and whether the French offence was in force at the date. The analysis may show a genuine equivalent, a partial equivalent or no equivalent. It may also reveal that France has jurisdiction over part of the conduct, which raises a separate strategy question rather than an automatic victory.

Fifth, secure digital evidence without creating a new offence or damaging the defence. Preserve exchanges with counsel, wallet histories, smart-contract versions, investor communications and compliance records. Do not wipe a device, move assets to hide them, contact a witness, coordinate testimony with a co-defendant or publish a public defence that could be used as evidence. A forensic image and a chain-of-custody record are more valuable than an improvised deletion or a rushed social-media statement. A French lawyer may also need to coordinate with US defence counsel and a digital-forensics team under privilege rules that differ across jurisdictions.

Sixth, decide the procedural posture deliberately. The person may contest identity, challenge the urgency or regularity of the request, oppose detention, dispute double criminality, invoke a treaty refusal ground, contest medical assurances or reserve arguments for the executive and administrative stages. Consent, by contrast, can remove some of those questions. There is no universally correct choice. The correct choice depends on the papers, the evidence, the health risk, the likely US sentence, parallel French proceedings and the client’s objectives. That decision should follow a document review, not a headline.

For a crypto company, the response must also be corporate. The arrest of one executive does not establish wrongdoing by every employee or entity. The company should preserve records, appoint an independent contact for counsel, separate legal holds from ordinary document retention, review sanctions and AML exposure, and avoid moving assets in a manner that could appear designed to defeat seizure. If French banks or exchanges freeze accounts after foreign allegations, the company may need a parallel challenge under banking, sanctions, insolvency and criminal-procedure rules. That work should not be folded mechanically into the extradition brief, but the timelines must be coordinated.

This is where the Saitama case is a useful warning. A prosecution can combine a public token, alleged investor representations, trading activity, money transmission and an international custody request. Each component can carry a different legal test. The media story may use one sentence; the extradition court will need a chronology, authenticated documents, a treaty analysis and a rights assessment. The person who prepares those materials early has a better chance of turning a broad accusation into a set of questions a court can actually decide.

Readers who need the EU comparison can consult our separate analysis of medical delay in a European arrest warrant surrender. The procedure is different from a US extradition request, but the contrast clarifies why a French resident should identify the legal instrument immediately. Our analysis of an Interpol Red Notice and extradition in France addresses another common source of confusion: a police alert may trigger an arrest or a request, but it is not itself a conviction or an automatic order to surrender.

Conclusion

Manpreet Kohli’s reported UK ruling moves the Saitama case forward, but it does not end it and does not decide guilt. The remaining appeal and ministerial stage matter. For France, the lesson is not that a crypto executive will necessarily be surrendered or protected. The lesson is that the outcome would turn on the instrument, the treaty, the factual chronology and the evidence supporting each safeguard.

A comparable US request in France would require the court to test the authenticated papers, double criminality, the relevant dates, specialty, refusal grounds, detention and the person’s ability to receive a fair and humane procedure. A medical objection would need current, objective and individualised evidence. A crypto objection would need conduct-based analysis rather than a dispute about labels. A release application would need a workable plan. The fastest route to a defensible decision is to preserve the health and digital record, obtain the complete request, and coordinate French and US counsel before choosing consent or opposition.

📄 Circulaire officielle