Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
EU Brussels Ia Reform: What French Companies Must Do Before the 24 November 2026 Consultation Deadline

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

EU Brussels Ia Reform: What French Companies Must Do Before the 24 November 2026 Consultation Deadline

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

The European Commission has reopened the most practical weakness in the EU’s cross-border civil procedure system: what happens when a French company must sue a defendant located outside the European Union. A public consultation and call for evidence opened on 1 September 2026 and is scheduled to close on 24 November 2026. The review also covers collective redress, digital procedure, contractual and tort claims, consumer protection, and the cross-border risks created by strategic lawsuits against public participation. A possible legislative initiative is indicated for the fourth quarter of 2027. Nothing has changed in the law today. The deadline matters because the evidence submitted now may shape the jurisdictional rules that businesses will use for years.

The starting point is the Brussels Ia Regulation, Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012. It normally creates predictable rules when the defendant is domiciled in a Member State, but Article 6 sends many disputes involving a non-EU defendant back to the national law of the court seized. In France, that means a company may need to combine EU rules, Article 14 of the Civil Code, the Code of Civil Procedure, the contract, and the law of the defendant’s country before it can answer a simple question: where may I sue, and will the resulting judgment be enforceable?

I. What the Brussels Ia consultation changes — and what it does not change yet

A. Why cases against non-EU defendants are the pressure point

Brussels Ia is built around mutual trust between the courts of Member States. Its central bargain is simple: a claimant should be able to identify a competent court through common European rules, and a judgment delivered in one Member State should circulate in another without a second trial on the merits. The Regulation has applied since 2015 and remains the principal EU instrument for jurisdiction, recognition, and enforcement in civil and commercial matters.

That bargain is strongest when the defendant is domiciled in the European Union. Article 4 starts from the defendant’s domicile. Articles 7 and 8 add special grounds for contractual claims, tort claims, and proceedings involving several defendants. Article 24 reserves certain disputes, such as rights in rem in immovable property, to courts with an exclusive connection to the subject matter. Article 25 protects a sufficiently formed agreement choosing the courts of a Member State. Article 26 addresses the defendant’s appearance. Articles 36 and following then organise recognition, while Article 39 removes the need for a declaration of enforceability for judgments that qualify under the Regulation.

The architecture is less uniform when the defendant is domiciled in a third country. Article 6(1) provides that, subject to the special safeguards and exclusive rules preserved by the Regulation, “if the defendant is not domiciled in a Member State, jurisdiction shall, subject to Articles 18(1), 21(2), 24 and 25, be governed by the law of that Member State”. The immediate consequence is not that French courts lack jurisdiction. The consequence is that the claimant must identify the French jurisdictional rule that fills the gap. The answer can differ from the answer that would apply if the same defendant had its registered office in Germany, Italy, or Spain.

Article 6(2) is equally important. It prevents the national rule from operating only for French nationals. A person domiciled in a Member State may invoke the jurisdictional rules available to nationals of that State against a defendant who is not domiciled in a Member State. The provision is designed to prevent nationality from distorting access to the national jurisdictional rules once the EU Regulation has referred the question back to domestic law.

The Commission’s September review is therefore not a technical clean-up. It addresses a competitive and procedural problem. A French SME negotiating with a company based in the United States, the United Kingdom, Switzerland, the United Arab Emirates, China, or another third country may not know at the contracting stage whether an EU court will hear the dispute. The answer can depend on the place of performance, the claimant’s domicile, a jurisdiction clause, the characterisation of the claim, a consumer or employment protection, or a national rule such as Article 14 of the Civil Code. That uncertainty affects the price of legal advice, the design of terms and conditions, the value of a claim, and the decision to trade across borders at all.

The review also matters beyond bilateral commercial litigation. In a collective action, the injured customers may live in several Member States, the defendant may be outside the Union, and the harmful conduct may have produced effects in multiple markets. The claimant’s first strategic problem is not merely whether the collective redress mechanism exists. It is whether one court can receive the case, determine the relevant group, order effective measures, and produce a judgment that can travel.

Digital business models sharpen the same issue. A platform can advertise in France, contract through a website hosted elsewhere, process data in a third country, use a European subsidiary for payments, and deliver a service with no obvious physical centre. A rigid connection between a dispute and one physical place may be less persuasive than it was when cross-border commerce was organised through branches and paper contracts. The Commission is considering whether digital procedure and clearer connecting factors could reduce the cost of proving jurisdiction without weakening the protections reserved for consumers, employees, or freedom of expression.

SLAPP litigation raises a different but related concern. A journalist, researcher, or civil society organisation may face a civil claim in one country because of a publication or campaign directed at another. The procedural risk is not limited to the final merits. The claimant may attempt to choose a forum whose cost, language, or interim measures place pressure on the defendant before the court reaches the substance. The Brussels Ia review is examining whether the jurisdictional framework should work more coherently with European safeguards against abusive cross-border litigation.

Article 79 of the Regulation supplies the legal background for the review. It required the Commission to examine the application of the instrument and, in particular, whether jurisdictional rules should be extended to defendants who are not domiciled in a Member State. The current consultation is an opportunity to test the options against evidence rather than slogans. A broad extension could improve predictability, but it could also create jurisdictional overreach, increase parallel litigation, and complicate recognition in third countries. A narrower clarification could protect access to a court while preserving the existing allocation of sensitive matters.

For a French company, the key point is temporal. The consultation is policy work, not a new jurisdictional rule. The 24 November deadline does not suspend a limitation period, extend a contractual notice period, or create an automatic right to sue in France. A company must litigate today under the rules currently in force. It may contribute evidence about those rules, but it cannot rely on a reform that has not been adopted.

The distinction prevents two opposite mistakes. The first is to ignore the review because nothing has changed immediately. That loses a rare opportunity to explain how uncertainty affects real contracts, claims, and enforcement budgets. The second is to write a contract or issue proceedings as if the future proposal already existed. That can lead to a defective forum choice, an avoidable jurisdiction challenge, or a judgment that cannot be used where the assets are located.

B. What French courts can do under the current framework

French analysis begins with the scope of Brussels Ia. The court must ask whether the dispute is civil or commercial and whether a European rule applies to the jurisdictional issue. If the defendant is domiciled in a Member State, Article 4 and the special grounds in Chapter II generally control. If the defendant is outside the Union, Article 6 becomes the gateway, subject to the protected fields and any valid jurisdiction agreement.

The first domestic reference is Article 14 of the French Civil Code. Its official wording states that a foreigner, even one who does not reside in France, “pourra être cité devant les tribunaux français” for obligations contracted in France with a French person or for obligations contracted abroad towards French persons. The text must be read with the European framework, the facts, and the way the claim is pleaded. It is not a universal forum for every dispute that has a French claimant or a French commercial interest.

The Court of Cassation’s First Civil Chamber gave the rule a significant procedural reading in its judgment of 29 June 2022, no 21-11.722, official decision. The case concerned an employee who had worked in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and defendants based in the Congo and Gabon. The Court retained the importance of the national rule after applying Article 6 and stated: “Il incombe aux juridictions des États membres d’assurer la protection juridique”. It also explained that, where the relevant domicile and employment connections were outside the Union, the conflict was governed by national provisions notified to the Commission, including Article 14.

The companion judgment of the same date, First Civil Chamber, no 21-10.106, official decision, is even more direct for a non-French claimant living in France. The claimant was a Congolese refugee domiciled in France. The Court held that Article 6(2) allowed him to rely on Article 14 and stated that Article 6 “permet à l’étranger de se prévaloir de l’article 14 du code civil” when the claimant is domiciled in France and the defendant is outside a Member State. The result did not turn the French forum into an automatic forum. It required the factual conditions identified by the Court and the absence of a more specific European rule that displaced the national rule.

The next question is whether a special ground applies before Article 14 is used. Article 7 of Brussels Ia can locate contractual proceedings at the place of performance and tort proceedings at the place where the harmful event occurred or the damage was suffered, but its operation must be tested against the Regulation’s personal and material scope. Article 8 may support proceedings against several defendants when the claims are sufficiently connected. In a non-EU case, the claimant should explain which provision applies directly and which part of the argument relies on French domestic law.

Consumer contracts require separate care. Sections 4 and 5 of Brussels Ia protect consumers and employees through rules that may apply even when the other party is outside the Union. The Court’s First Civil Chamber addressed a Lebanese bank and a consumer domiciled in France in its judgment of 18 September 2024, no 23-13.732, official decision. Recalling Article 18(1), the judgment states that “l’action intentée par un consommateur contre l’autre partie au contrat peut être portée” before the court of the consumer’s domicile in the circumstances defined by the Regulation. The Court also examined whether the bank had directed its activities towards France. A .com website, international transfers, telephone access, and foreign-currency services cannot be assessed in isolation; the overall activity and the consumer-protection framework matter.

A jurisdiction clause may provide a cleaner route, but it must be checked before it is treated as decisive. Article 25 applies without regard to the parties’ domicile when the agreement selects the courts of a Member State and satisfies the Regulation’s formal and substantive requirements. It does not override exclusive jurisdiction under Article 24 or the protections for consumers, employees, or insured persons. It also does not answer the separate question of which law governs the contract or tort claim.

The First Civil Chamber’s judgment of 2 September 2020, no 19-15.377, official decision, illustrates the hierarchy. The clause designated English courts. The Court held that the issue had to be resolved under Brussels Ia rather than by extending French internal rules to the international sphere. The judgment reproduces Article 25’s core effect: “ces juridictions sont compétentes”. For a French company, the practical lesson is to read the clause through the Regulation first, not to assume that the French Code of Civil Procedure supplies the answer merely because the claimant is suing in France.

The Court returned to a jurisdiction clause involving a French commercial court and a Cameroonian connection in its judgment of 17 September 2025, no 23-18.785, official decision. The case concerned an asymmetric clause and the tribunal de commerce of Paris. The decision restates the Article 25 framework: “Cette compétence est exclusive, sauf convention contraire des parties”. The Court also referred to the need for objective criteria that allow the seized judge to identify the competent court. A clause that says only “the courts of France” may not present the same issues as a clause that identifies Paris or a defined group of courts, but both must be reviewed in their contractual context.

Domestic procedure still supplies important tools when French law governs the jurisdictional gap. Article 42 of the Code of Civil Procedure states that the territorially competent court is, as a rule, the court of the defendant’s domicile. Its phrase “celle du lieu où demeure le défendeur” is a starting point, not the end of an international analysis. Article 46 offers additional options in contractual and tort matters; its opening words are “Le demandeur peut saisir à son choix”. Those options must be connected to the facts actually pleaded and must not be used to bypass a mandatory European rule.

Article 48 of the Code of Civil Procedure controls certain domestic territorial clauses between commercial parties. The provision says that a clause departing from territorial jurisdiction is, in principle, “réputée non écrite” unless its conditions are met. That domestic rule should not be confused with the autonomous European regime for a valid Article 25 agreement. The 19-15.377 judgment is the warning: determine the governing jurisdictional instrument before arguing about the clause’s effect.

Finally, a claimant must file in a form that gives the defendant and the court enough information to test jurisdiction. Article 54 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires the initial claim to identify the court and the object of the claim, among other information. Its text says, “A peine de nullité, la demande initiale mentionne”. A French company suing abroad or suing a foreign defendant in France should set out the jurisdictional chain in the originating document: defendant’s domicile, contract or harmful event, any clause, the reason Article 6 does or does not apply, and the evidence supporting the connection.

Costs are part of forum strategy. Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows the judge to order payment for costs not included in the recoverable costs. The official text begins, “Le juge condamne la partie tenue aux dépens”. It does not make an unsuccessful jurisdiction challenge automatically ruinous, but it makes a weak or poorly documented forum argument financially consequential. The company should budget for translation, service, evidence of foreign law, jurisdiction motions, and enforcement in the country where the defendant’s assets are located.

II. How a French company should react before and after 24 November 2026

A. How to map jurisdiction, evidence and enforcement before filing

The consultation deadline should not distract from immediate case preparation. A business facing a live dispute should run a jurisdiction map before sending a formal demand, issuing a claim, or accepting a settlement that contains a forum clause. The map should be short enough for management to use and detailed enough for counsel to defend in a jurisdiction hearing.

First, identify every relevant party and every legally relevant location. Record the defendant’s registered office, principal place of business, branch, agent, and assets. Do not treat a trading name, website domain, or payment intermediary as proof of domicile. Record the claimant’s domicile and, for a consumer or employee, the protected status that may activate a special section of Brussels Ia. If the dispute involves a group, identify the parent, subsidiary, distributor, platform, insurer, guarantor, and individual decision-maker separately. A court cannot be asked to apply a multiple-defendant rule to entities that are not properly connected in the claim.

Second, classify the claim before choosing the forum. Is it contractual, tortious, restitutionary, an action on a guarantee, a claim connected with insolvency, a dispute about property, or a consumer or employment matter? The label is not conclusive, but it determines which European rule may be engaged. A payment claim under a supply agreement may have a place of performance. A claim about pre-contractual statements may require a different analysis. A claim for misuse of data may involve several events and several places of damage. A claim against a guarantor may not follow the same jurisdictional route as the claim against the borrower.

Third, assemble the contract in a form a court can read. Preserve the signed version, the general terms incorporated at the time of contracting, the version supplied in the relevant language, click-acceptance records, order confirmations, invoices, delivery records, and correspondence about the forum. A clause copied into a later invoice may not have the same effect as a clause accepted before the contractual relationship. A clause in a framework agreement may not cover every later transaction. If the wording is asymmetric, identify which party may choose another court and whether that choice is tied to objective criteria.

Fourth, separate jurisdiction from applicable law. A French court may apply foreign substantive law. A foreign court may apply French law. The Brussels Ia Regulation addresses jurisdiction and the circulation of judgments; Rome I and Rome II address important questions of applicable law, subject to their own scope and exceptions. A clause saying “French law applies” does not necessarily select a French court. A clause selecting Paris does not necessarily make French law govern every issue. The legal memo should contain two different headings: forum and governing law.

Fifth, identify the enforcement target at the beginning, not after judgment. List bank accounts, receivables, shares, real estate, inventory, intellectual property, and contractual counterparties in each country where enforcement might occur. A French judgment may circulate efficiently within the Member States under Brussels Ia, but assets outside the Union may require the law of the enforcement state, a treaty, or a separate recognition process. The best forum on paper may be a poor forum if it produces a judgment that cannot reach the defendant’s assets or if translation and service costs consume the likely recovery.

Sixth, preserve evidence of the cross-border connection. A court will need more than an assertion that the transaction was “international”. Keep delivery documents, server and platform records, call logs, invoices, bank records, product destinations, customer addresses, negotiations, and proof of where the harmful effects were suffered. For a digital service, capture the pages and terms shown to French users at the relevant time. For a group structure, obtain corporate records showing who contracted, who performed, and who received the benefit. For a consumer dispute, preserve evidence that the trader directed activities toward the consumer’s Member State.

Seventh, plan service and language. A claim can fail procedurally even where the forum analysis is sound if the defendant was not served in a manner the court and the enforcement jurisdiction will recognise. Confirm the applicable European or international service instrument, the address, translation requirements, proof of receipt, and the time allowed for a response. Keep the original and certified versions of material documents. The language used in a contract, the language used in the proceedings, and the language required for enforcement are three separate questions.

Eighth, test the jurisdictional objection before filing. Write the defendant’s best motion to dismiss or decline jurisdiction. Ask whether the defendant can argue a valid choice-of-court clause, an exclusive jurisdiction rule, lack of connection with France, lis pendens, forum non conveniens under the applicable national law, defective service, limitation, or lack of authority by the signatory. Then answer each point with a fact, a rule, and a document. The exercise exposes weak assumptions while the company can still choose a better forum.

This preparation is particularly important for Article 14. The 2022 BGFI judgments show that the provision can protect access to French courts in a dispute involving a non-EU defendant, including for an eligible foreign claimant domiciled in France. They do not abolish the need to establish the relevant facts. A company should identify the French connection that makes Article 14 relevant, explain why the ordinary European grounds do not already govern, and address any special protection or jurisdiction agreement that takes priority.

B. How to respond to the consultation without waiting for a reform

The most useful response to the Commission is evidence with a procedural consequence. A general statement that cross-border litigation is “uncertain” carries less weight than a short file showing the steps, cost, delay, and commercial loss created by the uncertainty. French companies, trade bodies, legal teams, and advisers can use the period before 24 November 2026 to turn recurring problems into concrete proposals.

The response should identify the company and the type of cross-border disputes it handles, without disclosing confidential information. It should explain whether the company is usually claimant, defendant, platform, intermediary, creditor, consumer-facing trader, or member of a corporate group. It should state the countries involved, the location of customers and assets, the clauses used, and the stage at which the current rules create a decision problem. An anonymous fact pattern can be enough if it is precise about the procedural sequence.

A useful submission can be organised around five questions.

  1. What factual connection should permit an EU court to hear a claim against a defendant outside the Union? Compare domicile, place of performance, place of damage, targeted activity, local branch, local assets, and the claimant’s domicile. Explain which connection is predictable before litigation and which can be manipulated after the dispute begins.
  2. Should the same rule apply to a single claimant, a group action, a consumer claim, and a claim involving a public-interest publication? A single formula may be too broad for one category and too narrow for another. Explain where a tailored rule would protect access to justice without inviting forum shopping.
  3. How should a future rule deal with a jurisdiction clause? Set out the wording businesses actually use, the information supplied to the weaker party, and the practical effect of exclusive, non-exclusive, or asymmetric clauses. Include examples of clauses that a court can apply without a second dispute about what the clause means.
  4. What digital evidence should establish the place of activity or damage? Describe the records available to a claimant and the records that are normally controlled by a platform or foreign defendant. A rule that depends on evidence a claimant cannot obtain may remain unpredictable even if its wording looks precise.
  5. How will a new jurisdiction rule interact with recognition and enforcement outside the Union? Identify whether the proposed basis would be accepted in the country where assets are located, and whether a judgment based on that basis could trigger a public-policy objection or parallel proceedings.

The submission should distinguish a targeted clarification from a full reform. A targeted clarification could define how Article 6 interacts with national rules, clarify the treatment of digital activity, improve coordination with collective redress, or standardise information about jurisdiction clauses. A full reform could extend a common set of direct jurisdiction rules to non-EU defendants. The first approach may be faster and easier to apply. The second may produce greater predictability but requires a more demanding assessment of sovereignty, reciprocity, enforcement, and the risk of overlapping proceedings.

Companies should also tell the Commission what must not be lost. Mutual recognition reduces the incentive to relitigate the merits in every Member State. Consumer and employee protections prevent contractual power from dictating the forum in every case. Exclusive jurisdiction rules protect the authority of the courts most closely connected to property and corporate registers. Any reform should preserve those functions while making the third-country gap easier to navigate.

The submission should not be written as a disguised pleading in a current case. It should not disclose privileged advice, personal data, trade secrets, or a litigation position that could harm the company. It should focus on the rule’s operation and the evidence needed to apply it. If a live claim is involved, the company should separately protect limitation periods, contractual notice requirements, interim relief, and evidence preservation. A policy contribution never replaces a procedural deadline.

The legal team should retain a dated copy of the contribution, the questions answered, the supporting documents, and any acknowledgement of receipt. The review may last well beyond November. A record helps the company monitor whether a future proposal addresses the problem it reported and whether transitional provisions protect claims already in progress. It also creates a concise institutional memory for contract drafting and dispute planning.

Until a new instrument is adopted, contracts should be drafted for the current framework. The forum clause should identify the chosen courts with enough precision, preserve mandatory protections, and avoid language that conflicts with a separate arbitration agreement. The contract should allocate responsibility for service addresses, document retention, language, notices, and cooperation in enforcement. It should also identify whether the parties expect claims by consumers, employees, distributors, or group members, because those categories may limit the freedom to choose a forum.

The 2025 First Civil Chamber decision, no 23-18.785, is a useful reminder that the court clause must be tested for precision and effect rather than admired as boilerplate. The 2020 decision, no 19-15.377, shows why the European instrument comes first when a clause selects the courts of a Member State. The 2024 consumer decision, no 23-13.732, shows why a website and cross-border activity can affect the analysis without automatically deciding it. The two 2022 judgments, nos 21-11.722 and 21-10.106, show why a claimant’s domicile and the non-EU status of the defendant can make French domestic law decisive.

This is the practical French lawyer’s contribution to the international debate. The question is not simply whether France is a convenient place to sue. The question is whether the facts, the instrument, the clause, the evidence, and the enforcement plan fit together before the first writ is issued. The Commission’s review creates a moment to improve the system. The live dispute still requires a disciplined answer under the law that exists today.

Conclusion

The Brussels Ia review is important because it targets the point at which cross-border civil litigation becomes least predictable: a defendant outside the European Union. The consultation opened on 1 September 2026 and closes on 24 November 2026. Its possible outcomes range from targeted clarification to a broader extension of common jurisdiction rules. None of those options changes the law before adoption.

For a French company, the immediate task is twofold. Protect the live case under the present framework by mapping domicile, claim type, contract, forum clause, evidence, service, and assets. Then give the Commission a fact-based account of the costs and procedural choices created by the third-country gap. Articles 6, 18, 21, 24, 25, and 26 of Brussels Ia must be read alongside the applicable French rules, including Articles 14 of the Civil Code and 42, 46, 48, 54, and 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The 2022, 2020, 2024, and 2025 decisions cited above show that the answer turns on the exact connection and the exact instrument.

The strongest strategy is therefore neither to wait for Brussels nor to assume that reform has arrived. It is to preserve rights now, document the real cross-border problem, and submit a precise answer before the 24 November deadline. A predictable future system will be built from those concrete procedural facts.

📄 Circulaire officielle