Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
Squatters in Your French Second Home: How an American Owner Gets Them Out

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

Squatters in Your French Second Home: How an American Owner Gets Them Out

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

You land at Charles de Gaulle in late June, train down to your stone house in the Dordogne or your two-bedroom in the 11th arrondissement, and the key does not turn. The shutters are closed from the inside. Someone is living in your French second home — someone you never invited, who pays no rent, and who has no lease. As an American owner, your first instinct may be to call a locksmith, change the locks, and move back in. Do not do that: under French law, self-help eviction can expose you to criminal liability even when you hold the deed. The good news is that France has spent the last several years making the law significantly tougher on squatters, and a furnished second home owned by an American who lives abroad is one of the best-protected categories of property in the system. This guide explains, in plain English and with the exact legal references, how the fast administrative track works, when you need a judge instead, how to run the whole case from the United States, and what to do in Paris and the Île-de-France region where procedures have their own local specifics. Every French term is defined the first time it appears, and every key rule is linked to its official source so you — or your lawyer — can verify it.

I. Is Your Second Home Legally Your « Domicile »? Why That Single Question Decides Everything

French squatter law runs on a single threshold distinction: is the occupied property your domicile (your home, in the criminal-law sense) or merely an empty building, a vacant lot, or an unfinished project? If the answer is domicile, a fast administrative procedure — complaint, request to the préfet (the state-appointed prefect who represents the national government in each département), and forced removal in as little as 48 hours after a formal notice — is available. If the answer is not domicile, you are sent to the slower civil courts. For an American owner of a furnished vacation home, the answer is almost always domicile, and understanding why is the foundation of the entire strategy.

A. What « domicile » really means: your furnished second home counts even if you live in Ohio

The criminal offense that protects you is called violation de domicile (unlawful entry into a person’s home), punished by Article 226-4 of the Criminal Code (Code pénal). The official English-language page of the French public service states the penalty plainly: « Unlawful entry into a person’s home is punishable by up to 3 years in prison and €45,000 a fine ». That same page gives the definition that matters most to you: « a person’s domicile is any dwelling place containing movable property belonging to him, whether or not that person lives there and whether or not it is his principal residence ». And it draws the conclusion explicitly: « Secondary residences are therefore also concerned by the offense of violation of domicile. »

In practice, this means the test is furniture, not presence. A second home containing your beds, kitchenware, books, bicycles, and clothing is a domicile even if you spend ten months a year in Boston and visit only in July. The Cour de cassation (France’s supreme court for civil and criminal matters) has held this line for decades. In a frequently cited criminal ruling, the Court stated: « LE TERME DE DOMICILE AU SENS DE L’ARTICLE 184 DU CODE PENAL NE DESIGNE PAS SEULEMENT LE LIEU OU UNE PERSONNE A SON PRINCIPAL ETABLISSEMENT MAIS ENCORE LE LIEU, QU’ELLE Y HABITE OU NON, OU ELLE A LE DROIT DE SE DIRE CHEZ ELLE » (Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, decision no. 81-92.708). In plain English: the word « domicile » covers not only the place of your main establishment, but any place where you have the right to feel at home, whether or not you actually live there. Keep that sentence in your file: it is the legal sentence that turns your shuttered vacation house into a protected home.

The practical consequence for Americans is immediate. Before you file anything, photograph and inventory the furniture: dated photos of furnished rooms, the taxe d’habitation (residence tax) or taxe foncière (property tax) bills in your name, electricity and water subscriptions, the acte de vente (notarized deed of purchase), and any caretaker or neighbor statements confirming the house was furnished and lived in. A commissaire de justice (a sworn enforcement officer, formerly called huissier de justice) can draw up a constat (an official written record of observed facts) documenting the furnishings and the break-in — that document carries strong evidentiary weight before both the préfet and the courts. Conversely, the one fact pattern that destroys the domicile argument is a genuinely empty shell: a ruin with no furniture, a building under heavy renovation with no movable property inside, or bare land. If your property is in that state, say so to your lawyer upfront, because you will likely need the civil-court route described in Part II instead of the fast track.

One more American-specific trap to avoid: do not confuse the criminal concept of domicile with the tax concept of residence. You can be a US tax resident, hold no French visa beyond the 90-day Schengen stay, and still have a criminal-law domicile in France. The two regimes answer different questions, and the préfet deciding your eviction request does not care where you pay income tax.

B. The 2023 anti-squat law: tripled penalties, faster removal, and what changed for second homes

On July 27, 2023, France enacted Law no. 2023-668 of July 27, 2023 to protect housing against unlawful occupation (loi visant à protéger les logements contre l’occupation illicite), published in the Journal officiel (the official gazette) on July 28, 2023. The public-service summary confirms that the law « triples penalties » for squatting a domicile. Concretely, unlawful occupation of someone’s home now exposes the occupants to up to three years’ imprisonment and a €45,000 fine, and related offenses — such as fraudulently obtaining the use of a property — were hardened in parallel under the same reform.

Three changes in that law matter most for an American second-home owner. First, the scope of the fast administrative procedure was widened: owners of secondary residences benefit expressly from the préfet-led removal track, ending years of argument about whether a vacation home qualified. Second, the timetable was compressed: once the préfet issues a mise en demeure (a formal order to vacate), the occupants have a short deadline — 48 hours at a minimum in the standard configuration — after which the préfet must have the premises cleared by law enforcement unless there is a reasoned, exceptional refusal. Third, the law strengthened the criminal response around fraudulent occupation schemes, including fake leases and fake rental listings used to install occupants — a pattern Americans who buy through unfamiliar intermediaries or leave keys with informal caretakers should know about, because discovering that your « tenant » holds a forged lease does not weaken your case; under the post-2023 framework it can actually reinforce the criminal dimension of the file.

Put the 2023 reform together with the older pillars and you get the full protective stack. The Civil Code (Code civil) states the bedrock principle in Article 544 — ownership is the right to enjoy and dispose of things — which is why a squatter, defined in French case law as an occupant sans droit ni titre (an occupier with neither right nor title), has no legal ground to remain once the owner acts. The Construction and Housing Code (Code de la construction et de l’habitation) organizes the winter protections that squatters often invoke — and here is the point the official English page makes explicitly: « for squatters, the winter truce does not apply. Their forced evacuation can take place throughout the year. » The trêve hivernale (the winter truce, roughly November 1 to March 31, during which most tenant evictions are suspended) simply does not protect squatters. An occupant who tells you in January that nothing can happen until spring is wrong as a matter of law. Finally, the framework law behind the administrative procedure, Law no. 2007-290 of March 5, 2007 (the DALO law), Article 38, is the text that empowers the préfet to order evacuation of unlawfully occupied domiciles — the provision your lawyer’s request letter will cite on page one.

II. How Do You Actually Get Squatters Out When You Live 5,000 Miles Away?

Knowing the law is one thing; running the case from Chicago, Austin, or San Francisco is another. France offers two tracks — a fast administrative track before the préfet and a slower civil track before the courts — and an American owner should almost always try the fast track first, prepare the civil track in parallel as a backup, and set up the powers of attorney and evidence chain that let everything happen without boarding a plane. Paris and the Île-de-France region add local wrinkles worth a dedicated section, because that is where many American-owned second homes sit and where the competent offices are most congested.

A. The fast track that works: police report, préfet request, and the 48-hour clock

The procédure administrative d’évacuation (administrative eviction procedure) runs in four steps, and each step has a concrete action you or your representative must take. Step one is the criminal complaint. Go — or have your representative go — to the local commissariat (police station) or gendarmerie (military-status police force covering smaller towns and rural areas) to file a plainte (criminal complaint) for violation de domicile, attaching proof of ownership (the acte de vente or the latest taxe foncière bill), proof the place was furnished (photos, utility bills, insurance contract or assurance habitation), and any evidence of forced entry (the constat of the commissaire de justice, photos of broken locks or shutters, neighbor attestations). Insist that the complaint be recorded under the domicile-entry offense rather than as a generic neighborhood dispute: the legal qualification on the complaint drives everything downstream. Ask for the receipt (récépissé de plainte) and the complaint number, because the préfet will want them.

Step two is the request to the préfet. Your lawyer sends a registered letter (lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception) to the préfecture (the prefect’s office) of the département where the property sits, requesting evacuation under Article 38 of the DALO law, and enclosing the complaint receipt, the ownership titles, and the evidence that the premises are a furnished domicile. The official public-service guidance for victims of squatting, available in English at service-public.gouv.fr, « Squatting: what to do? » with full procedural detail in French at service-public.gouv.fr, fiche F34724, describes exactly which office to contact and which documents to attach — follow that checklist line by line, because an incomplete file is the most common cause of delay.

Step three is the mise en demeure. After verifying the file, the préfet issues the formal order to vacate, served on the occupants, giving them a short deadline to leave voluntarily — 48 hours at a minimum in the standard configuration. Step four is forced execution: if the occupants have not left when the deadline expires, the préfet calls on law enforcement (concours de la force publique) to remove them. The whole sequence, in a clean file with a furnished second home and a cooperative préfecture, can run in a matter of weeks rather than the many months a civil trial takes. That speed is precisely why proving domicile-status with furniture evidence, as explained in Part I, is the highest-value work in the file.

Two practical warnings. First, the préfet can refuse, but a refusal must be reasoned and is subject to challenge before the administrative courts (recours devant le tribunal administratif), where your lawyer can seek emergency interim relief through a référé (fast-track emergency hearing). A silent or dilatory préfecture is therefore not the end of the road; it is the start of a second, judge-led phase. Second, Paris specifics: if the property is in Paris, the competent authority is the Préfecture de police de Paris, whose procedures and reception offices differ from an ordinary départemental préfecture — filings go through its dedicated housing-occupation channels, and waiting times for the on-site police verification visit (constatation sur place) run longer than in a small Dordogne town simply because of volume. In the inner suburbs (Hauts-de-Seine, Seine-Saint-Denis, Val-de-Marne), the départemental préfecture is competent; allow extra calendar time and have your commissaire de justice and lawyer lined up before you file so no week is lost to logistics. For owners in the Île-de-France region generally, add one more layer: buildings managed by a syndic (professional building manager) or guarded by a gardien (resident caretaker) often hold CCTV footage, entry logs, and witness statements that corroborate the break-in date — request preservation of those records in writing within days, because many systems overwrite footage after two to four weeks.

A final caution that surprises Americans: never change the locks yourself, never cut utilities to force occupants out, and never remove their belongings onto the sidewalk. French criminal law punishes expulsion illégale (unlawful self-help eviction) and related acts of coercion even when you are the rightful owner; the statute books protect the procedure, not vigilantism. Every euro you would spend on a locksmith is better spent on the commissaire de justice‘s constat, which achieves the same evidentiary goal without any legal risk.

B. The backup tracks: civil court orders, occupancy indemnities, and the adverse-possession clock you must not ignore

When the fast track is unavailable — the building was genuinely unfurnished, the préfecture refused, or the occupants wave a plausible-looking lease — the civil courts take over. Your lawyer files an assignation en expulsion (a summons seeking eviction) before the tribunal judiciaire (the ordinary civil court), usually with a request for a référé-expulsion (emergency eviction hearing) on the ground that the occupation is manifestly unlawful (trouble manifestement illicite). Emergency hearings deliver an enforceable order in weeks to a few months; ordinary proceedings take longer but allow full damages claims. Either way, ask the judge for three things beyond the eviction itself: an astreinte (a daily financial penalty for each day the occupants stay after the order), an indemnité d’occupation (an occupancy indemnity, roughly the rental value, owed retroactively for the whole period of unlawful occupation), and provisional enforcement (exécution provisoire) so the eviction can proceed even if the occupants appeal. The Cour de cassation has expressly approved this logic: where unlawful occupation without right or title is established, the appellate court « SOUVERAINEMENT DETERMINE LE MONTANT DE L’INDEMNITE D’OCCUPATION » — freely sets the amount of the occupancy indemnity (Cour de cassation, civil chamber, decision no. 82-13.936). Keep every receipt — travel, locksmith invoices after the court order, repairs, the commissaire de justice‘s fees — because the damages schedule (évaluation du préjudice) presented to the judge converts your American travel and out-of-pocket costs into a recoverable claim.

Two long-term doctrines complete the picture, and both cut in opposite directions. The favorable one is that squatters never become tenants: French rental law, principally Law no. 89-462 of July 6, 1989 on residential leases, protects locataires (leaseholders) with notice periods, winter-truce protection, and rehousing duties — none of which applies to an occupant sans droit ni titre. An occupant who claims « I have lived here two years, I have rights now » is confusing squatting with tenancy; time alone creates no lease and no winter-truce shield, exactly as the official guidance confirms. The unfavorable doctrine is usucapion, known in English as adverse possession or acquisitive prescription: under the Civil Code, thirty years of continuous, peaceful, public, unequivocal possession as owner can theoretically transfer ownership even to a bad-faith occupier. Thirty years is a long time, and no American second-home owner should panic — but the doctrine is a real reason never to let an occupation drift. Every month without a complaint, a préfet request, or a summons is a month in which the occupants consolidate their factual position, degrade the property, and complicate the file. Act within days of discovery, not months.

Now the logistics of acting from the United States. Everything above can be done without flying to France if you set up three instruments. First, a procuration (power of attorney) authorizing your French lawyer and your commissaire de justice to file, receive service, and represent you; have it signed, notarized, and apostilled under the Hague Apostille Convention so French authorities accept it without further legalization — your lawyer will give you the exact wording, and the apostille is obtained from the Secretary of State of the state where the notarization occurred. Second, a document pack sent digitally and by courier: passport copy, acte de vente, property-tax bills, utility contracts, insurance policy, caretaker correspondence, and dated interior photos proving furnishings. Third, maintained insurance: confirm with your insurer that the assurance habitation covers unlawful-occupation damage and theft of furnishings, declare the incident promptly, and keep the claim number in the litigation file — insurers frequently fund part of the repair bill and sometimes the legal costs under a protection juridique (legal-expenses) rider. If you bought the property through a société civile immobilière (SCI, the family property company many Americans use to hold French real estate), the company’s gérant (manager) signs the complaint and the préfet request on the company’s behalf — align the corporate paperwork before filing so the standing of the claimant cannot be challenged. Readers who have not yet purchased will find the full pre-purchase checklist in our companion guide, Buying Property in France as an American: Legal Checklist, which covers holding structures, notarial due diligence, and the insurance setup that makes a future squatter file far easier to win.

Conclusion

An American owner who discovers squatters in a French second home is not powerless — far from it. If the house was furnished, it is your criminal-law domicile, and the 2023 anti-squat law gives you a fast administrative track running from complaint to préfet request to a 48-hour vacate order and forced removal, available year-round with no winter-truce obstacle. If the fast track stalls, the civil courts offer emergency eviction hearings with daily penalties and retroactive occupancy indemnities, while the thirty-year adverse-possession clock supplies the one genuine reason for urgency. Run the case from the United States with an apostilled power of attorney, a sworn officer’s factual record, and a complete ownership-and-furniture file, respect the Paris-region procedural specifics, and never resort to self-help. Do that, and the key will turn again — this time with the law standing behind the door.

📄 Circulaire officielle