If you are an American named to receive a French retirement savings plan after a relative’s death, the answer is usually yes: French nationality is not a condition for inheriting a plan d’épargne retraite (PER), France’s regulated retirement savings plan. The difficult questions are different. Was the PER a bank or investment account, or an insurance contract? Did the holder die before retirement savings were unlocked? Does the contract contain a valid beneficiary clause? Is the payment part of the French estate, or is it paid directly by an insurer?
Those classifications determine both the French procedure and the tax calculation. An American beneficiary may need a French notaire, meaning a civil-law public officer who settles the succession, or may need to make a direct claim to an insurer. A French acte de notoriété, or deed of notoriety, may prove who the heirs are, but it does not replace a beneficiary clause. France may tax the payment under inheritance rules while the United States treats a later distribution as a foreign pension, a foreign financial asset, or an investment containing potentially problematic foreign funds. This guide gives a practical route for identifying the plan, proving entitlement, calculating the French exposure, and coordinating the U.S. filings. It does not turn a French PER into an inherited U.S. IRA: the documents and tax analysis must remain separate.
I. Can an American inherit a French PER after the account holder dies?
A. What happens to the plan when the French holder dies?
A PER is not one single type of account. Article L. 224-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code allows the plan to be opened as a securities account or, through an insurer or similar institution, as a group insurance contract. That distinction is the first fact to establish. Ask the provider for the legal form of the product, not merely its commercial name. A statement headed “PER” can conceal a bank PER, an insurance PER, an employer plan, or an older product transferred into a PER.
A bank or investment PER is normally held through a securities account. Article L. 224-31 of the Monetary and Financial Code says that an individual PER opened as a securities account is opened with a credit institution or investment firm and can have an associated cash account. The account belongs to one holder. When that holder dies, the securities and cash are dealt with through the estate process. The American does not simply log in, request a wire, and treat the balance as a payable-on-death bank account.
An insurance PER is different. The holder joined a group insurance contract, and the contract should contain beneficiary wording. The insurer checks the death, the beneficiary’s identity, the order of any beneficiaries, and the documents required to release the capital or establish an annuity. A French insurer can ask for documents even where the beneficiary is clearly named. It must know whether the named person is alive, whether the clause has been amended, and whether French tax has been paid or secured.
The timing of the death also matters. The current Article L. 224-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides, in its second paragraph: Le décès du titulaire avant l’échéance mentionnée à l’article L. 224-1 du présent code entraîne la clôture du plan.
In plain English, death before the retirement-savings deadline closes the plan. The balance is then paid to the heirs or contractual beneficiaries, usually as capital or, where the contract permits it, an annuity. This is not a rule that authorises an American beneficiary to keep the deceased person’s French plan open indefinitely.
The government’s official PER guidance describes the same basic result: before the savings are unlocked, the plan is closed and the savings are paid to heirs or designated beneficiaries. If the holder had already converted the plan into a life annuity, the answer can change. A surviving payment normally depends on an option for réversion, meaning a reversion of the annuity to another person. If no reversion or other death guarantee was selected, there may be no account balance for the estate to collect. The provider must therefore issue a statement showing the plan’s status on the date of death and the exact benefit available.
Do not confuse a beneficiary’s nationality with the plan’s legal form. An American citizen living in California, New York, Texas, or France can be a beneficiary. A beneficiary living in the United States may receive euros into a U.S. account. Neither fact decides whether the money is an estate asset, an insurance benefit, a French taxable transmission, or U.S. taxable income. The answer comes from the plan documents and the law applicable to the death benefit.
At the opening of the file, obtain these items from the institution or the family:
- the PER contract or account-opening document, including all amendments;
- the latest annual statement and a valuation at the date of death;
- the beneficiary designation, including primary and contingent beneficiaries and any representation wording;
- the record of contributions, transfers from earlier retirement products, and any option for a life annuity or reversion;
- the holder’s death certificate and the provider’s written list of release documents;
- the provider’s tax calculation, withholding statement, or request for a French tax certificate; and
- any letter from the French notary handling the rest of the succession.
This checklist is especially important where a French parent or spouse worked in France but retired in the United States. The family may possess a U.S. will and an American retirement plan while the French PER remains governed by a separate contract. A U.S. will can be evidence of the deceased person’s intentions, but it does not automatically rewrite a beneficiary clause or transfer control of an account held by a French institution.
B. Which beneficiary or heir can claim the funds, and what proof is required?
Start by reading the beneficiary clause word for word. Look for the exact identity of the primary beneficiary, the order of substitute beneficiaries, the percentages, the phrase “my heirs,” and any clause dealing with a beneficiary who dies before the plan holder. A clause naming “my children, living or represented” is not equivalent to a clause naming one child alone. “Representation” is a technical concept in some succession situations; it should not be assumed from a family tree.
For the bank PER, the central question is the identity of the heirs called to the succession. Article 724 of the French Civil Code states: Les héritiers désignés par la loi sont saisis de plein droit des biens, droits et actions du défunt.
The phrase means that heirs designated by law are vested by operation of law in the deceased person’s property, rights, and claims. It does not mean that a bank may pay an unknown person without proof. The institution still needs evidence of the death and of the person entitled to receive the particular account.
That evidence may be supplied by an acte de notoriété. Article 730-1 of the Civil Code provides: La preuve de la qualité d’héritier peut résulter d’un acte de notoriété dressé par un notaire, à la demande d’un ou plusieurs ayants droit.
The same article requires the document to refer to the death certificate and to identify supporting civil-status records and, where relevant, dispositions made on death. For an American heir, the notary may need a chain of birth, marriage, divorce, and death certificates linking the beneficiary to the deceased person.
A practical American beneficiary’s document package often includes the following:
- a certified copy of the death certificate, with an apostille and French translation if the provider or notary requires them;
- a clear copy of the beneficiary’s passport and proof of address;
- full civil-status records proving the relationship, rather than a family-tree summary prepared by the family;
- the deceased person’s French and U.S. wills, trusts, marriage contract, and prior beneficiary changes;
- the PER number, provider contact information, and statements covering the last several years;
- the beneficiary’s U.S. taxpayer identification information and any tax self-certification requested for cross-border payment;
- bank instructions for receiving euros, checked against the provider’s anti-fraud procedure; and
- a written explanation of whether the beneficiary accepts the succession, disclaims it, or claims only the contractual insurance benefit.
An apostille does not prove the substance of a family relationship. It authenticates the origin of a public document. The French notary or provider may still ask for a certified translation, a more recent copy, or an additional record because American vital-record systems are state-based. A birth certificate issued in one state and a marriage certificate issued in another can create a gap in names. Resolve that gap before asking the insurer to make a final payment.
Send the death notice promptly and keep proof of delivery. The notice should identify the plan, the date of death, the person making the claim, and the request for the provider’s written procedure. Ask the provider to confirm whether it has located the beneficiary clause, whether the plan was a securities account or insurance contract, whether another beneficiary has made a claim, and whether a tax form or certificate is required before payment. A phone conversation is useful, but a dated email or registered letter establishes what information was supplied and when.
The most difficult clause is often a beneficiary who died before the plan holder. The Court of Cassation dealt with that problem in a life-insurance case, Second Civil Chamber, 10 September 2015, no. 14-20.017. Its published reasoning says that, without a representation clause, the designation is presumed conditional on the beneficiary being alive when the capital becomes payable and, à défaut, elle est caduque et le capital ou la rente garantie font partie du patrimoine ou de la succession du contractant
. In English, a beneficiary who died first does not automatically transmit the benefit to that person’s children. The contract wording controls the result. The decision concerned assurance-vie, or life insurance, rather than every possible PER contract, so use it as a warning to examine the clause, not as a substitute for reading the PER terms.
An insurance-based PER can also create a dispute with other family members. French law distinguishes the réserve héréditaire, the protected portion of an estate that the law preserves for certain protected heirs, from the quotité disponible, the portion that the deceased could freely give away. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines those two concepts. For descendants, Article 913 limits the freely disposable portion according to the number of children, subject to the detailed rules in the current statute.
The insurance framework must be separated from the inheritance framework. Article L. 132-12 of the Insurance Code says that capital payable at death to a determined beneficiary or the heirs does not form part of the insured’s succession. Its wording is: Le capital ou la rente stipulés payables lors du décès de l’assuré à un bénéficiaire déterminé ou à ses héritiers ne font pas partie de la succession de l’assuré.
This is a civil-law rule about the contractual benefit. It does not mean that the payment is exempt from French transfer tax, or that the provider may disregard a tax filing or a dispute about the contract.
Article L. 132-13 of the Insurance Code adds that the capital is generally not subject to contribution to the succession or reduction for infringement of protected heirs’ rights, while preserving an exception for premiums that were “manifestement exagérées eu égard à ses facultés,” meaning manifestly excessive in light of the subscriber’s resources. The statutory text also states that the capital or annuity payable at death is not subject to the rules of contribution or reduction. The result is not a simple “insurance always wins” rule: the source of the premiums, the holder’s age, the family situation, the contract’s usefulness, and the identity of the claimant can all matter.
The French courts apply a fact-sensitive test to excessive premiums. In First Civil Chamber, 6 July 2016, no. 15-21.643, the Court stated that the assessment is made at the time of payment, “au moment du versement, au regard de l’âge, des situations patrimoniale et familiale du souscripteur.” The same decision refers to the usefulness of the contract. In First Civil Chamber, 10 July 2013, no. 12-13.515, the Court upheld the conclusion that payments were not manifestly excessive where the holder retained redemption capacity and the investment served a personal savings purpose. These cases concern life insurance, so a PER dispute still requires analysis of the specific contract and the rules governing PER insurance.
Other decisions show why a family member should not rely on a label. In First Civil Chamber, 10 October 2012, no. 11-17.891, the Court examined whether testamentary language showed an intention to include insurance capital in the succession. In First Civil Chamber, 1 April 2015, no. 14-15.184, the Court considered whether premiums were excessive in light of the subscriber’s age, family and financial circumstances. In First Civil Chamber, 25 May 2016, no. 15-14.737, it addressed the treatment of insurance benefits in a marital community. Those precise decisions are useful because they identify the evidence a court may examine; none authorises a beneficiary to skip the provider’s procedure.
If the insurer refuses to identify the benefit, accepts another claimant’s interpretation, or remains silent after receiving complete evidence, preserve the complete file. A formal request should identify the contractual clause, the death date, the legal status claimed, the documents already supplied, and the remedy requested. Depending on the dispute, the next step may involve the insurer’s complaint process, the notary, a French court, or an application for payment and damages. A U.S. probate order may support the factual case, but it does not itself bind a French insurer in the same way as a French judgment or notarial instrument.
II. How are French inheritance tax and U.S. reporting handled?
A. How much French tax can apply to a bank PER or insurance PER?
The French tax calculation begins with the product form, not with the beneficiary’s American passport. The French government’s PER guidance says that a PER held as a securities account is included in the estate and taxed under inheritance-tax rules. It says that a PER held through a group insurance contract is taxed under rules close to life insurance. This two-line distinction can change the tax base, the allowance, the rate, the person who files, and the document that releases the funds.
For a bank or investment PER, the account is combined with the other estate assets for the French succession calculation. The net estate, the relationship between the deceased person and each heir, prior gifts, debts, the will, and any applicable international succession rule must be reviewed together. The French inheritance-tax allowance for a child is not the same as the allowance for a sibling, niece, unrelated beneficiary, or person named only in an insurance clause. A U.S. beneficiary should ask the notary for a written calculation showing the taxable estate, the applicable relationship, each allowance, and the rate bands.
For an insurance PER, the holder’s age at death is central. The official Service Public page and the French tax administration’s Form 2705-A information notice for PER insurance benefits describe a specific division:
- where the holder died before age 70, the benefit is generally described with an allowance of €152,500 per beneficiary, followed by a 20% levy on the taxable share up to €700,000 and 31.25% above that threshold; and
- where the holder died after age 70, the benefit is brought into the inheritance-tax calculation after a global €30,500 allowance, with the rate determined by the relationship between beneficiary and holder.
The after-70 rule is expressly addressed by Article 757 B of the French General Tax Code. The provision says that amounts due from an insurer because of the death, after age 70, of a PER holder are subject to death-transfer rights according to the relationship to the insured for their total amount. It then provides: L’ensemble des sommes, rentes ou valeurs visées au I dues à raison du ou des contrats conclus sur la tête d’un même assuré fait l’objet d’un abattement global de 30 500 €.
For a PER insurance benefit, this is materially different from assuming that only contributions made after age 70 are relevant.
Article 757 B must be read with the PER-specific text and the current administrative forms. The general life-insurance levy in Article 990 I of the General Tax Code contains references to a €152,500 allowance and 20%/31.25% rates, but its wording also contains an exclusion for contracts under Articles L. 224-1 and following of the Monetary and Financial Code. That drafting detail is precisely why a beneficiary should not copy an ordinary assurance-vie calculation onto a PER without checking the current PER guidance, the contract, the tax notice, and the date of death.
Consider two simplified illustrations, using euros because the French tax is calculated in euros. If an insurance PER worth €600,000 is paid to one beneficiary after the holder dies before age 70, the administrative schedule would first apply the €152,500 per-beneficiary allowance, leaving €447,500 for the stated 20% band. The illustrative levy would be €89,500 before considering exemptions, treaty effects, contract details, or a different tax classification. If the same amount is paid after age 70, the €30,500 global allowance leaves €569,500 for inheritance tax, but the final amount depends on the relationship and the applicable inheritance-tax scale. If the €600,000 is a bank PER, the balance is instead added to the estate and cannot be priced accurately without the rest of the estate file.
These examples are not a quote. The value can change between the date of death and payment; several contracts may share one global allowance; a spouse or civil partner may have a special exemption; and a treaty may alter which country taxes or grants relief. The insurer may withhold a levy directly in a pre-70 insurance case. A notary or the French tax administration may require a certificate before a post-70 benefit is released. Ask for the legal basis of each line rather than accepting a provider’s unexplained net payment.
French filing deadlines also need to be identified early. The tax administration’s succession filing guidance generally distinguishes six months for a death in France from twelve months where the death occurred abroad, subject to the detailed exceptions. A death in the United States does not erase a French filing obligation for a French estate or French insurance benefit. Form 2705-A and a certificate of payment or non-liability can be relevant to an insurance benefit, while a bank PER normally travels through the ordinary estate declaration. The date to use is the date of death, not the date when an American beneficiary finally receives the wire.
Keep a calculation file containing the date-of-death valuation, every PER statement, contribution history, beneficiary percentages, the age of the holder at each relevant payment, the French tax notice, and proof of payment. If there are several French assurance-vie contracts, ask whether the €30,500 or other global allowance has been allocated across all contracts. If the holder made gifts to the same beneficiary, ask whether the notary has included them in the succession calculation. A payment that is contractually outside the civil estate can still be relevant to a tax computation or to a protected-heir dispute.
The France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention must then be tested. The official consolidated treaty published by the French tax administration is the 1978 France–U.S. convention as amended by the 2004 protocol. Article 1 says the convention applies to estates of people domiciled in France and to estates of people subject to U.S. tax because of U.S. domicile or citizenship. That is a rule about the deceased person and the taxable estate, not a rule that makes every American beneficiary a U.S. estate-tax taxpayer.
Article 12 of the treaty sets out credit mechanisms. In some situations, the United States grants a credit for French tax on property that is taxable in both countries; in other situations, France grants a deduction or credit under the treaty’s conditions. The treaty also contains limits, documentation requirements, and a prohibition on increasing the tax merely through treaty application. A French inheritance-tax payment is not automatically a U.S. foreign tax credit against ordinary income on a later pension distribution. The estate-tax computation, the beneficiary’s income-tax return, and the foreign financial-asset forms are separate analyses.
B. What must an American beneficiary report in the United States?
Separate the U.S. questions into three dates: the holder’s date of death, the date the beneficiary becomes entitled to the benefit, and the date cash or securities are actually distributed. The U.S. tax result may depend on whether the payment is treated as an inherited foreign pension interest, a death benefit, a distribution of previously taxed capital, or investment income. A French PER is not a U.S. IRA, and the U.S. inherited-IRA ten-year rule should not be imported without a tax adviser’s written analysis.
The Internal Revenue Service’s guidance on foreign pension and annuity distributions explains that a foreign pension or annuity payment may be fully or partly taxable in the United States even if the foreign institution does not issue a Form 1099. A beneficiary who receives a lump sum should obtain the French provider’s statement separating contributions, gains, withholding, and the legal nature of the payment. Do not report the entire wire as wages, and do not assume the entire wire is tax-free inheritance. The correct U.S. treatment depends on the plan, the deceased person’s history, the beneficiary’s status, and the applicable treaty article.
The France–U.S. income-tax treaty is a different document from the estate and gift tax convention. The French tax administration publishes the official France–U.S. income and wealth-tax treaty, and the IRS maintains its France treaty documents page. A pension-distribution article, an estate-tax article, and a foreign-asset reporting rule do different work. Start with the nature of the payment and the beneficiary’s residence in the year of receipt; then test the relevant treaty article.
Form 8938 is often the first information-reporting question. The IRS Form 8938 questions and answers expressly discuss an interest in a foreign pension or deferred-compensation plan. If the American beneficiary has an interest in the French PER and the total value of specified foreign financial assets exceeds the threshold applicable to that taxpayer, the interest may need to be reported on Form 8938. The current IRS instructions explain that the foreign pension interest is reported in Part VI and that the underlying assets are not separately reported on that form.
That statement is not a conclusion that every beneficiary must file Form 8938. Thresholds differ for a person living in the United States and a person living abroad; marital status and filing status also matter. A beneficiary who has not yet acquired an enforceable interest may have a different position from a beneficiary who can demand payment. Once the money is paid into a French or U.S. bank account, the reporting analysis may change again. Preserve the account statements and the exchange-rate method used for any U.S. form.
FBAR is separate from Form 8938. FinCEN’s official FBAR guidance states that a U.S. person with a financial interest in or signature authority over foreign financial accounts generally files when the aggregate maximum value exceeds $10,000 at any time during the calendar year. A French bank PER can raise an FBAR question while it is held through a foreign financial institution, but the answer depends on the account’s legal nature, the beneficiary’s present rights, and the applicable FBAR definitions. Do not infer that a beneficiary owes an FBAR merely because a French notary lists the PER in an estate inventory; do not ignore the question if the benefit remains in a foreign account under the beneficiary’s control.
Form 8938 can also reach a foreign pension interest even where the account is not treated exactly like a bank account for FBAR. Conversely, an FBAR filing does not replace Form 8938. Each form has a different statutory basis, threshold, filing channel, and penalty regime. A U.S. return preparer should see the French contract and not merely the final wire receipt. The return file should identify the provider, account or contract number, date-of-death value, year-end value, distributions, French tax withheld, and whether the interest was held personally, through an estate, or through a trust.
PFIC risk must be screened before the beneficiary sells or receives securities. A passive foreign investment company, or PFIC, is a foreign corporation meeting U.S. passive-income or passive-asset tests. The IRS Form 8621 guidance explains that a U.S. person may need Form 8621 after certain distributions from, or a gain on the disposition of, PFIC stock. A French insurance PER may hold funds or units that require a look-through analysis. The PER wrapper does not automatically make every underlying French or Luxembourg fund a U.S. mutual fund, and it does not automatically eliminate PFIC classification.
The practical rule is to request a full look-through inventory before electing a cash or securities distribution. Identify each fund, its legal issuer, its ISIN, the dates held, the value at death, and the amount distributed. Ask the U.S. adviser whether the beneficiary owns the underlying interest directly, indirectly, or only has a contractual claim against an insurer. That determination affects Form 8621, Form 8938, basis, ordinary income, capital gain, and the timing of any tax. It is safer to resolve the classification before a sale than to discover a PFIC issue after a statement arrives.
French withholding does not automatically eliminate U.S. tax. A French tax paid on a death benefit may be a transfer tax for treaty purposes, while tax on a later pension distribution may be an income tax. The U.S. foreign tax credit rules are category-specific and can limit the credit to income in the same category. The estate may have a treaty claim that the individual beneficiary cannot make on the beneficiary’s Form 1040. Keep the French assessment, proof of payment, and treaty analysis rather than entering one blended number as “foreign tax.”
The treaty also contains a time limit for relief requests. Article 13 of the official France–U.S. estate and gift convention provides, among other conditions, a period tied to the longest applicable local refund period, five years from the death or gift, or one year after a final determination and payment where the treaty’s ten-year condition is met. A beneficiary or executor should not wait until the fifth year to ask whether France or the United States has charged the same transfer twice. The request must be supported by the relevant declarations, assessments, proof of payment, domicile evidence, and asset valuation.
A disciplined cross-border workflow looks like this:
- Freeze the factual record: date and place of death, age, residence, citizenship, marital status, children, wills, trusts, and the date the PER was opened.
- Classify the PER: securities account or insurance contract; individual or employer plan; pre-unlock or annuity phase; capital or reversion benefit.
- Identify the claimant: named beneficiary, substitute beneficiary, statutory heir, legatee, estate, or trust trustee.
- Build the proof file: death certificate, civil-status chain, identity, beneficiary clause, statements, translations, apostilles, and provider correspondence.
- Obtain a French calculation that shows the tax base, age-at-death rule, allowances, relationship, levy or inheritance-tax rate, and certificate needed for payment.
- Give the same documents to a U.S. tax adviser before accepting a cash or securities distribution, with a request for a written Form 1040, Form 8938, FBAR, PFIC, and treaty analysis.
- Record every filing deadline and every tax payment, then compare the French and U.S. results under the correct convention rather than assuming a credit is automatic.
This process also protects the beneficiary against a false choice between “take the money immediately” and “lose the benefit.” If the provider’s request is incomplete, ask for the precise missing document. If another heir contests the beneficiary clause, do not sign a release or family settlement before reviewing the contract, the protected-heir rules, and the tax consequences. If the French notary has included the PER in the estate but the insurer says it is an outside-estate contractual benefit, request a written explanation of how the two positions fit together. The apparent contradiction often reflects a civil-law classification on one side and a tax or procedural classification on the other.
Finally, remember that a U.S. estate plan is evidence, not a universal key. A revocable trust, a pour-over will, a beneficiary designation, and a French PER may each control a different legal question. A French notary can need the complete American trust even where an insurer is prepared to pay a named beneficiary. A U.S. executor can need a French certificate even where the beneficiary receives the benefit directly. The reliable answer is the one supported by the contract, the death record, the succession evidence, the French tax calculation, and the U.S. reporting position together.
Conclusion
An American can inherit a French PER, but the route is not determined by citizenship. First determine whether the plan is a securities account or an insurance contract, whether death occurred before retirement unlocking, and whether a beneficiary clause names a living person. Then prove entitlement with the correct French or contractual documents. A bank PER generally enters the estate; an insurance PER may be paid to a named beneficiary under a separate contractual and tax process. The €152,500 pre-70 framework and €30,500 global post-70 framework must be checked against the current PER rules, the contract, and the holder’s age at death.
On the U.S. side, the payment, the continuing foreign pension interest, the bank account, and the underlying funds can trigger different questions. Form 8938, FBAR, Form 8621, Form 1040 reporting, and the France–U.S. income and estate-tax treaties should be analysed from the original French documents. A coordinated file is usually faster and safer than asking the French provider, the notary, and the U.S. tax preparer to reconstruct the facts separately.