An American who moves to France often asks a deceptively simple question: must a U.S. Roth IRA be added to the French wealth-tax return? The short answer is that French impôt sur la fortune immobilière (IFI), meaning real-estate wealth tax, does not operate as a general tax on every bank or retirement account. It focuses on taxable real estate and, in defined situations, the real-estate fraction of an interest in a company or investment vehicle. A conventional Roth IRA invested in U.S. shares, bonds and cash is therefore not normally added to the IFI base merely because its owner is a French tax resident or because the account is worth a substantial amount. That conclusion is an application of the statutory perimeter, not a blanket exemption for every account called “Roth.”
The analysis changes if the retirement arrangement gives the account holder an interest in French property, a property-holding company, a real-estate fund or an unusual trust structure. It also changes when the owner is a recent arrival, has dual French nationality, owns property through several layers, or is trying to coordinate IFI with U.S. reporting and the France–United States tax treaty. This guide separates the account wrapper from its underlying assets, explains the treaty rules, and gives a practical evidence checklist. It does not address visa procedure or attempt to decide the U.S. income-tax treatment of a distribution.
I. Is a U.S. Roth IRA included in French wealth tax (IFI)?
A. What does French IFI actually tax for an American resident?
Start with the French tax rather than with the U.S. label. Article 964 of the French General Tax Code creates an annual tax on real-estate assets. The official text states: Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière.
The same article applies the tax when the value of the assets covered by Article 965 exceeds €1.3 million and assesses the relevant conditions on January 1 of each year. You can read the current Article 964 provisions on Légifrance and the administration’s English explanation of the IFI threshold and taxpayers.
Article 965 then defines the base. It includes the net value at January 1 of the real property and real-property rights owned by the relevant household. It also includes shares or units in a company or organization, but only to the extent that their value represents real property held directly or indirectly. The opening sentence is precise: L’assiette de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière est constituée par la valeur nette au 1er janvier de l’année
. The full Article 965 text also contains the fraction calculation and exclusions for certain operational businesses and minority interests.
This is the central distinction for a Roth IRA. A Roth IRA is a U.S. individual retirement account. “Roth” describes the U.S. contribution and distribution regime; it does not describe the French asset class. If the account holds ordinary U.S. listed shares, U.S. Treasury securities, investment funds, certificates of deposit or cash, those holdings are financial assets. Their value does not become French real estate because the owner lives in France, files a French income-tax return, or has used the account to plan retirement in France. The account’s balance is not, by itself, an item of French real-estate wealth.
The same reasoning applies to a diversified brokerage portfolio inside the Roth. The account may be very important for U.S. estate planning, beneficiary designations, required documentation, and the future taxation of distributions. Those are separate questions. IFI asks a narrower question: does the taxpayer or the relevant vehicle own a taxable building, a right in real estate, or a taxable interest representing such property? The answer cannot be inferred from the account’s market value or from the fact that an annual U.S. statement displays the balance.
The Constitutional Council confirmed the nature of the tax when it reviewed the 2018 finance law. In Decision No. 2017-758 DC of December 28, 2017, it described the legislative choice as follows: le législateur a entendu frapper la capacité contributive que confère la détention d’un ensemble de biens et de droits immobiliers.
The decision is available on Légifrance under Decision No. 2017-758 DC. The decision concerned the constitutionality of the new tax, not Roth IRAs specifically, but its reasoning is useful: the taxable capacity is tied to holding real estate assets and rights, not to owning wealth in every possible form.
Use a simple first-pass test. List the assets held by the Roth on January 1. If the list contains only ordinary securities and cash, there is normally no Roth amount to add to the IFI real-estate base. Separately list the French home, rental property, bare ownership, usufruct, shares in a property-holding company, real-estate funds and any rights in a trust or insurance product. The French property list, not the account label, determines whether an IFI return is required. If the net taxable real-estate value stays at or below €1.3 million, the ordinary threshold is not met, even if the Roth and other financial assets push the person’s total global wealth far above that number.
That last point prevents a common overstatement. A Roth IRA is not “ignored for all French taxes,” and the €1.3 million threshold is not a global-net-worth threshold. A French tax resident may still have French income-tax, social-contribution, gift-tax, succession, information-reporting or treaty questions concerning the account. A nonresident may have a French IFI liability for French real estate even without a French income-tax filing. The official nonresident IFI guidance from impots.gouv.fr should be read alongside the relevant treaty provisions.
B. When can a Roth structure expose French real estate?
The result is more difficult when the Roth is self-directed or connected to an investment that is not a plain portfolio of financial securities. Article 965 does not stop at the name of the holding vehicle. Shares or units may be included in proportion to the value of real property held directly or indirectly by the company or organization. A French société civile immobilière (SCI), meaning a civil real-estate company, is the familiar example, but the analysis can also involve a foreign company, a fund, a partnership or a layered holding structure.
Imagine that a custodian holds the Roth for the account owner and the account invests in shares of a French company that owns an apartment building. The question is not answered by saying either “the Roth is exempt” or “the entire Roth is real estate.” The file must identify the legal owner, the taxpayer’s rights, the percentage of the company held, the company’s assets, the property’s location, any operational-business exclusion, the valuation date, and any debt that can be taken into account. The taxable amount may be a fraction of the interest, but the correct fraction can require information from the company and from the custodian.
The current text of Article 968 of the French General Tax Code illustrates why legal rights matter. It allocates assets subject to an usufruct, a right to use, or a right of habitation between the person who enjoys the right and the bare owner in specified situations. A Roth IRA is not automatically an usufruct, and Article 968 should not be copied into an IRA analysis. It does show, however, that the French calculation follows the substance and allocation of rights when a real-estate interest is present.
Article 972 supplies a second important limit. It addresses redeemable insurance and capitalization contracts expressed in units of account and includes only the portion representing assets covered by Article 965. The statutory sentence states: La valeur de rachat des contrats d’assurance rachetables et des bons ou contrats de capitalisation exprimés en unités de compte mentionnées au deuxième alinéa de l’article L. 131-1 du code des assurances est incluse dans le patrimoine du souscripteur à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative des unités de compte constituées des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 appréciée dans les conditions prévues au même article 965 et à l’article 972 bis.
See the official Article 972 text. This rule concerns a particular insurance wrapper. It is not a ruling that every retirement account must be treated in the same way, nor does it turn a conventional Roth holding listed securities into real estate.
Article 972 bis can also matter for certain collective investment vehicles, with thresholds relating to the taxpayer’s percentage and the proportion of taxable real estate in the vehicle. A Roth holding a real-estate fund cannot be reviewed by looking only at the fund’s brand name. Ask what the fund owns, whether the property is French or foreign, whether the vehicle is within the statutory category, and whether the taxpayer’s percentage triggers an exclusion or an inclusion. A fund factsheet that says “real-estate exposure” is not enough to calculate the French taxable fraction.
Valuation is a separate stage. Article 973 on Légifrance provides that assets covered by Article 965 are valued under the rules used for death-transfer duties, with specific rules for a principal residence and listed securities. If a Roth arrangement indirectly holds an interest in a French property company, the file should preserve the property valuation, the company’s accounts, the capital table, the property percentage, and the calculation performed at January 1. Do not substitute a December 31 Roth statement for the required real-estate valuation date.
Debt is limited as well. Article 974 permits deductions for certain debts connected to taxable assets and imposes special rules for related-party loans, amortization and large patrimonies. A mortgage on a French property is not automatically deductible simply because the debt is visible in the same household’s financial records. A loan inside a company or an arrangement involving the Roth requires a document-by-document review. The deduction follows the statutory link to a taxable asset, not the taxpayer’s preferred allocation.
Four red flags justify a written analysis before the next filing:
- The Roth is self-directed and can acquire French land, buildings, property-company shares or real-estate funds.
- The account is connected to a trust, partnership, foreign company or nominee arrangement, and the custodian’s statement does not identify the underlying assets.
- The account owner controls the vehicle, reserves personal use of a property, or owns a large participation in a property-holding company.
- The taxpayer is relying on an “IRA exemption” without identifying the French statutory provision that would exclude the underlying real-estate asset.
These red flags do not prove that the Roth is taxable. They identify the point at which the answer can no longer be reached from the account title. A conventional Roth invested in broad U.S. index funds is materially different from a self-directed Roth holding a private interest in a French building. The file should show which case applies.
There is also a difference between a Roth IRA and a French assurance-vie, an insurance-based savings contract. The French wealth-tax rules expressly address the real-estate fraction of certain insurance contracts. That does not mean that a U.S. IRA receives an automatic exemption or an automatic inclusion. It means that the legal wrapper must be classified before the asset rules are applied. A comparison with the broader IFI guide for Americans who own French property can help organize the property-side calculation, but the Roth’s contract and custody documents still control the facts.
II. How should an American calculate and document the Roth IRA position?
A. How do residence and the France–U.S. treaty affect the result?
Residence determines the scope of French taxation, but it does not change a financial account into real estate. Under Article 964, a person whose tax home is in France is generally considered in relation to French and foreign assets within Article 965. A person who is not a French tax resident is generally considered for French real estate and the relevant French real-estate fraction of company interests. The administration states that the conditions are assessed on January 1. The first question is therefore the tax residence and household position on that date; the second is the nature and location of the asset.
France also has a newcomer rule in Article 964. A person who had not been fiscally domiciled in France during the five calendar years before establishing a French tax home is, for the relevant period, subject to IFI on the French assets described in the provision. That domestic rule is not the same as an exemption for every foreign investment account. It is a scope rule for the first years of French residence and must be checked against the precise dates of the move, prior French residence, and return to France.
The France–United States tax treaty contains a separate wealth provision. Article 23(1)(a) assigns taxing authority over wealth constituted by real property to the country where the property is located. Article 23(1)(b) addresses shares or rights in an entity whose value is at least 50 percent derived, directly or indirectly, from real property in a contracting state. Article 23(1)(c) reaches rights in another person where the assets or value derive from property in a contracting state. These rules matter when a Roth arrangement is genuinely linked to real estate; they do not enlarge the French IFI base beyond the domestic statutory definition.
For other wealth elements, Article 23(5) states: Tous les autres éléments de la fortune d’un résident d’un Etat contractant ne sont imposables que dans cet Etat.
In practical terms, the treaty’s allocation is consistent with asking whether a Roth asset is a non-real-estate financial asset or a real-estate-derived right. It is not safe to cite Article 23(5) as a universal “Roth exemption,” because the classification, the treaty’s other provisions, the U.S. citizenship rules and the domestic IFI statute still have to be read together.
Article 23(6) is particularly relevant to an American who has just moved to France. For a person who is a French resident and a U.S. citizen without also holding French nationality, the treaty provides that foreign assets held on January 1 during each of the five calendar years following the year of becoming a French resident do not enter the wealth-tax base. The official text says: les biens situés hors de France que cette personne possède au 1er janvier de chacune des cinq années civiles suivant celle au cours de laquelle elle devient un résident de France n’entrent pas dans l’assiette de l’impôt afférent à chacune de ces cinq années.
The wording contains conditions that matter: citizenship, absence of French nationality, the year residence begins, the January 1 date, and the type and location of the asset. The official France–United States income and wealth-tax treaty text should be cited in the file, not a summary from an investment platform.
A conventional Roth invested in U.S. securities will usually be outside the IFI base because it is not French real estate, even after the newcomer period ends. Article 23(6) becomes especially important where a U.S. resident has foreign real property or an entity interest that could otherwise enter a wealth-tax calculation. It should not be presented as a way to avoid reporting a French home. French property is located in France, and Article 23(1)(a) points to the situs rule. Nor should a dual national assume that the special treaty paragraph applies without examining its express nationality condition.
Do not confuse Article 23, which concerns wealth, with Article 18, which concerns pensions. Article 18(1) allocates certain pension and similar retirement payments, and Article 18(2)(c)(i) identifies several U.S. arrangements that are generally treated as corresponding to a tax-recognized retirement plan. The treaty’s wording includes les comptes individuels de retraite (« retirement individual accounts »)
. That language can be relevant when a Roth distribution is classified for income tax. It does not answer whether an account balance contains a taxable French building for IFI.
This distinction is supported by the case law on the older wealth tax and its income-based cap. In Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, January 27, 2021, No. 18-22.113, the court stated that les revenus à prendre en compte sont les revenus réalisés, même non nécessairement appréhendés par celui-ci
. The case concerned the former ISF cap and realized gains held in an employee savings plan; it did not decide the IFI treatment of a Roth IRA. Its value here is methodological: a future income or cap calculation is not the same exercise as identifying the assets in the wealth-tax base.
In Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, March 28, 2019, No. 17-23.671, concerning a real-estate gain retained by a civil company under the former ISF regime, the court referred to les revenus nets du contribuable entrant dans le calcul du plafonnement de l’ISF devant s’entendre des revenus réalisés et non nécessairement perçus par le contribuable
. Again, this is not a Roth ruling. It prevents an error in the opposite direction: an American should not assume that an account’s French wealth-tax treatment can be settled by the tax result of a later distribution or by whether cash was withdrawn.
A third useful distinction appears in Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, December 20, 2023, No. 22-17.612. The court stated that la notion de revenus doit être distinguée de celle de recettes en ce qu’elle correspond aux sommes effectivement perçues par les contribuables
in a dispute about professional furnished rentals and the former wealth-tax rules. These decisions involve the previous ISF framework and different facts. They should never be cited as direct authority that a Roth IRA is included or excluded from IFI. They do, however, demonstrate why account value, income, receipts, distribution timing and real-estate ownership must be placed in separate columns in the analysis.
B. What should be filed and kept for the French tax authority?
If the household has no taxable French or foreign real estate within Article 965 above the threshold, a conventional Roth balance normally does not create a separate IFI line. Keep the Roth statement anyway. The absence of an amount in the IFI base is a legal position that should be supported by the account’s holdings, not by silence. A later audit, property acquisition, self-directed investment or change of custodian can make the same account relevant to the analysis.
If taxable real estate or a taxable real-estate fraction exists, the IFI is filed with the annual income-tax return through Form 2042-IFI in the ordinary case. The administration’s current IFI declaration page states that the IFI return is an annex to the income-tax return and explains the 2026 filing and payment process. The official 2026 Form 2042-IFI page confirms that the form is required when net taxable real-estate wealth at January 1 exceeds €1.3 million. The Roth is not reported because it is a Roth; a taxable real-estate interest connected to it is analyzed because it falls within the Article 965 perimeter.
Prepare the file in five layers. First, preserve the residence timeline: arrival date, prior French tax residence, departure periods, January 1 residence status, U.S. citizenship and any French nationality. Second, preserve the Roth documents: custodian statement, account agreement, investment menu or holdings report, beneficiary and ownership information, and any document showing that the account is self-directed or restricted. Third, map the underlying investments: ticker, issuer, fund legal form, percentage of real-estate assets, country of property, direct or indirect ownership, and control rights. Fourth, collect the property evidence: title, appraisal, company accounts, capital table, debt statements, rental or occupancy documents and any valuation supplied by a fund manager. Fifth, record the legal conclusion and the calculation that turns those facts into the declared figure.
Currency conversion must be reproducible. If a property company’s accounts are in dollars or another currency, the calculation should show the source value, the relevant date, the exchange-rate method, and the euro result. A Roth statement with a dollar market value does not replace the valuation of a French building or of a real-estate fraction. A later wire transfer into France is also not the event that creates or removes an IFI asset. The relevant date and the asset’s legal nature come first.
Use the following decision path before signing:
- Were you a French tax resident on January 1, and what was your household composition on that date?
- Does the Roth hold only ordinary financial assets, or does it hold a direct or indirect interest in real estate, a property company, a real-estate fund, a partnership or a trust?
- If a vehicle is involved, what percentage of its value comes from taxable real property, and does an operational-business or minority-interest rule apply?
- Is the asset in France, in the United States or elsewhere, and does Article 23 of the treaty change the allocation or newcomer analysis?
- What was the gross and net taxable value on January 1, and which debts are legally connected and deductible under Article 974?
- Does the resulting household real-estate base exceed €1.3 million, requiring the relevant Form 2042-IFI filing?
Consider three examples. In the first, an American living in Lyon has a Roth worth $650,000 invested in U.S. index funds and cash. The person owns a French principal residence whose net taxable value after permitted adjustments is €1.15 million. The Roth is not added to the real-estate value merely to cross the threshold, so the ordinary €1.3 million IFI threshold is not reached on these facts. Income-tax treatment of future Roth distributions remains a separate question.
In the second, the same person has a French rental property with a net taxable value of €1.45 million and a Roth holding only U.S. listed securities. The Roth remains outside the IFI base on the stated facts. The French property may place the household above the threshold, so the person must calculate the IFI base, review eligible deductions, and use the appropriate declaration. The amount of the Roth may be relevant to global planning and liquidity, but it is not a substitute for the statutory real-estate calculation.
In the third, the Roth is self-directed and holds an interest in a foreign company that owns a French apartment building. The custodian reports a $400,000 account value, but the company’s property accounts show a French real-estate component. A responsible calculation cannot simply add $400,000 to the household’s property or ignore the investment. It must identify the rights held through the retirement arrangement, determine whether Article 965 reaches the entity interest, calculate the real-estate fraction, apply the relevant valuation and debt rules, and then test the treaty and newcomer conditions. The answer may be zero, partial or taxable, depending on the documents.
These examples also explain why an account statement alone is insufficient. The statement proves market value at a particular date; it may not prove legal ownership, beneficial rights, control, look-through percentages, real-estate situs or the availability of a statutory exclusion. Ask the custodian for a complete holdings report and for the account agreement. Ask the property vehicle for its accounts and valuation method. If the administrator refuses to provide information, preserve the written request and response. Article 965 contains a good-faith information rule in some indirect-holding situations, but it is not a general permission to estimate without evidence.
Article 982 governs the declaration of the gross and net taxable value of the assets within Article 965 and the supporting schedules. The official text is available in the Légifrance chapter on Articles 964 to 983. Article 977 sets the progressive IFI rates, from 0.50 percent for the tranche above €800,000 up to 1.50 percent above €10 million, once the relevant threshold and calculation rules are met; see the official calculation section. Do not calculate a liability by applying a single rate to the Roth balance. The tariff applies to net taxable real estate after the statutory rules, not to global wealth.
Foreign wealth-tax relief must also be separated from foreign income-tax credits. Article 980 allows an imputation for foreign taxes similar to IFI, limited to foreign real-estate assets or the corresponding real-estate fraction. A U.S. income-tax payment on a Roth distribution is not automatically a credit against French IFI. Article 24 of the France–U.S. treaty contains its own mechanism for eliminating double taxation, while the domestic IFI rules contain the property-tax limitation. The official treaty explains that a French resident with wealth taxable in the United States under the treaty can be taxed in France with a credit limited to the French tax corresponding to that wealth. That mechanism does not convert an income-tax payment into a wealth-tax credit.
Finally, keep the IFI file separate from the French income-tax file even if both are submitted in the same annual season. The income-tax file may contain a distribution, treaty position, foreign tax credit or proof of U.S. withholding. The IFI file needs the January 1 real-estate inventory, ownership chain, valuation, eligible debt and treaty scope. For the income-tax side of a living retiree’s Roth distribution, see the separate analysis of Roth IRA taxation in France. That article addresses a different legal event. A distribution can be tax-sensitive even when the account balance is outside IFI, and an account can require an IFI analysis if its underlying assets include taxable real estate even when no distribution occurred.
Conclusion
A standard U.S. Roth IRA invested in ordinary U.S. securities is ordinarily not added to French IFI simply because an American has become a French resident. The French tax is directed at real estate and defined real-estate-derived rights. The decisive work is to identify the Roth’s underlying assets, test any company, fund or trust connection, value a taxable real-estate fraction on January 1, and then apply the residence and treaty rules. The France–U.S. treaty’s pension article may help classify later distributions; it does not replace the separate wealth analysis.
Before filing, preserve the account agreement, holdings, custodian correspondence, property and entity records, valuation date, currency method, debt evidence, residence timeline, nationality information and written legal position. Do not rely on the word “Roth,” a U.S. tax-free label, a generic account statement or an unverified assumption that the five-year newcomer rule applies. If the account is conventional, the file should demonstrate why it is outside the IFI base. If it is self-directed or connected to French real estate, the file should show the complete ownership chain and calculation.