Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
Can an American Keep a U.S. Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) After Moving to France? Contributions, Withdrawals, Treaty, and Reporting

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

Can an American Keep a U.S. Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) After Moving to France? Contributions, Withdrawals, Treaty, and Reporting

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

Moving to France does not, by itself, force an American federal employee to cash out a Thrift Savings Plan (TSP). The TSP is a U.S. federal defined-contribution retirement savings plan, not the same benefit as a FERS or CSRS government annuity and not the same as Social Security. You can generally leave the account in place after separating from federal service, but the move creates a demanding cross-border tax question: what exactly is the payment under the France–U.S. tax treaty, when does France tax it, and which documents prove the answer? The treaty uses broad pension language, lists several U.S. plans without naming the TSP, and separately addresses public-service pensions. That combination makes a TSP-specific file more important than a generic “foreign pension” answer. This guide explains the legal decision points, the French and U.S. reporting sequence, the difference between traditional and Roth TSP money, required minimum distributions, and the evidence to assemble before the first withdrawal. It is general information for Americans living or preparing to live in France; the final treaty classification should be checked against the participant’s federal service, plan records, residence, and distribution history.

I. Can an American keep a U.S. Thrift Savings Plan after moving to France?

A. What happens to the account when federal service ends?

The short answer is usually yes: changing your residence to France is not the same event as taking a TSP distribution. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management’s official TSP explanation describes the plan as a defined-contribution retirement savings and investment plan for federal employees and uniformed-service members. In practical terms, the balance depends on employee contributions, agency contributions where applicable, investment performance, and the withdrawal option you later choose. It is an individual account inside a federal retirement system, rather than a promise by France or the United States to pay a fixed monthly pension. For the wider retirement context, see the firm’s guide on retiring in France as an American.

When a participant separates from federal service, the principal choices are administrative and financial: leave the vested balance in the TSP, request a permitted withdrawal, or move the balance through a rollover that satisfies U.S. plan rules. Official OPM guidance on separation from federal service states that a former employee may leave the entire balance in the TSP, continue to receive investment earnings, and change investments, even though employee contributions stop after separation. That rule is important for an American moving to France. A French address does not itself create a taxable withdrawal, and nothing in the relocation should be treated as an instruction to liquidate the account.

Before leaving the United States, check the TSP’s address, tax-residency information, bank-payment instructions, beneficiary designation, and contact details. A former employee should also download year-end statements and the plan’s current withdrawal materials. Keep a separate record of the traditional balance, the Roth balance, employee contributions, agency contributions, earnings, loans, prior withdrawals, and any rollover. A later French tax return may require the gross payment in U.S. dollars, the date on which it became available, the part identified as traditional or Roth, and U.S. tax withheld. A single account statement that shows only a total balance may not answer all of those questions.

Do not confuse the TSP with the other parts of a federal retirement package. A FERS basic annuity is a separate benefit. A CSRS annuity is a separate benefit. Social Security benefits are a separate payment governed by different treaty language. FEGLI life insurance is not retirement income. A federal employee can therefore have several U.S. payments that arrive during the same year but fall under different French rules. The relevant question is not simply whether the former employer was the U.S. government. The question is what legal right generated each payment, who paid it, whether it is a retirement-plan payment or a public-service pension, and which treaty article applies.

The account may also remain open while you are still working for the federal government and living outside the United States, but payroll eligibility, contribution limits, agency matching, and the treatment of an overseas assignment are separate TSP-administration questions. A move after separation is simpler because no new salary deferral is involved, yet the later distribution still has to be analyzed. If you take a loan, request an installment schedule, select an annuity, or ask for a one-time payment, preserve the election confirmation. The distribution method can affect the U.S. tax form and the factual description presented to the French tax administration.

Keeping the account is not the same as making the account invisible. FATCA, the U.S. Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, concerns information exchange and reporting by financial institutions; it does not replace the participant’s French income-tax analysis. Likewise, a U.S. tax withholding rate is not proof that France has no taxing right. Treat the TSP as an asset with a continuing reporting history: the account balance, the first withdrawal, each later payment, and the death-benefit or beneficiary event may require different documents.

B. Why the TSP is not automatically the same as a federal pension under the treaty

The starting point is the France–U.S. income and wealth tax treaty published by Décret no. 96-222. In its current published text, Article 18 is headed pensions. Article 18(1)(a) covers pensions and similar remuneration, including sums paid under a retirement plan, paid to a resident of one state for former employment, whether paid periodically or as a lump sum. The treaty’s wording includes the phrase sous la forme de versements périodiques ou d’une somme globale, meaning “in the form of periodic payments or a lump sum.” That broad language is why a TSP distribution deserves an Article 18 analysis rather than being dismissed as an ordinary investment withdrawal.

Article 18(2) then addresses the treatment of contributions to certain cross-border retirement arrangements. Article 18(2)(c)(i) refers, among other plans, to qualified plans under section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, individual retirement plans, individual retirement accounts, and plans under sections 403(a) and 403(b). The TSP is not named in that list. The omission does not prove that every TSP payment falls outside Article 18(1)(a), because the contribution paragraph and the payment paragraph perform different functions. It does show why an adviser should not copy an IRA conclusion into a TSP file without checking the plan documents and the applicable administrative position.

In CAA Versailles, January 28, 2020, no. 18VE03035, the administrative court examined the treaty’s list of qualified U.S. plans. The judgment reproduces the phrase sont considérés de façon générale comme correspondant à un régime de retraite constitué, établi et reconnu aux fins d’imposition en France. The court explained that the assimilation of U.S. qualified plans serves the treatment of deductible contributions in the state of residence, subject to the treaty conditions. The decision is useful evidence of how the list operates, but it is not a TSP-specific judgment. It should support careful reasoning, not a categorical claim that the TSP has already been classified by French courts.

Article 19 is the second branch of the analysis. It concerns public remuneration. Article 19(1)(a) expressly begins with Les rémunérations, autres que les pensions, or “remuneration other than pensions,” paid by a contracting state or its public-law bodies for services rendered to that state. Article 19(2) separately deals with pensions paid by a contracting state, political subdivision, local authority, or public-law legal entity in respect of services rendered. Those provisions can matter greatly for a FERS or CSRS civil-service annuity. They do not automatically turn every account connected with federal employment into a public pension under Article 19.

A TSP is funded and administered as a defined-contribution plan. The legal source of a TSP distribution is the participant’s retirement account and its plan rules, even though agency contributions may have been made during federal service. That fact supports an Article 18 argument, while the public origin of the employment explains why Article 19 must be reviewed. The payer shown on Form 1099-R, the plan description, the participant’s service history, the nature of the contribution, and the distribution election should all be preserved. A conclusion based only on the words “federal employee” is too crude for a treaty return.

French case law illustrates the importance of identifying the precise payment. In CAA Versailles, May 27, 2015, no. 13VE01761, the court examined a civil-service pension received from the U.S. government by a U.S. citizen resident in France. Under the treaty provisions applicable in that case, it held that the pension was taxable only in the United States, using the words les pensions versées à M. A… citoyen américain et résident de France par le gouvernement américain ne sont imposables qu’aux Etats-Unis d’Amérique. The court nevertheless upheld the inclusion of the income in the French tax computation because the treaty’s credit mechanism avoided double taxation. That case concerns a government pension, not a TSP account; its value here is the method: identify the payment first, then apply the treaty and the French computation rules.

A useful working matrix is therefore:

  1. TSP balance with no distribution: a change of address is not a cash payment. Keep the account records and review any separate asset-reporting obligation, but do not report a fictional withdrawal.
  2. Traditional TSP distribution: analyze it as retirement-plan income, identify the applicable treaty article, and report the actual amount received or made available in the relevant tax year.
  3. Roth TSP distribution: separate after-tax contributions and earnings and verify whether the distribution is qualified under U.S. law. Do not assume that a U.S. exclusion automatically produces the same result under French law.
  4. FERS or CSRS annuity: analyze the separate annuity under the public-pension and treaty rules; do not merge it with the TSP merely because the payments come from the same period of employment.
  5. Social Security: analyze the separate social-security rule in Article 18(1)(b), rather than using the conclusion for a private or federal retirement account.

That distinction also protects against an expensive rollover mistake. U.S. law may allow a direct rollover from a TSP to another qualified plan or to an IRA without current U.S. income inclusion. The IRS rollover guidance explains the difference between a direct rollover and a distribution paid to the participant. Moving the account to an IRA, however, changes the legal identity of the plan. It may bring the account closer to the treaty’s express IRA language, but it may also create a new French timing or classification question. Do not roll over solely to obtain a treaty label that has not been established for the TSP itself.

II. How should a TSP be taxed and reported in France?

A. How do French tax residence and the France–U.S. treaty interact?

First determine whether France treats you as a tax resident for the year. French tax residence is called domicile fiscal, meaning the legal connection that makes a person subject to French income-tax rules as a resident. Article 4 A of the French General Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, states that a person with a French tax domicile is liable on the whole of his or her income, while a person domiciled outside France is liable on French-source income. The residence question is separate from citizenship, the place where the TSP is administered, and the place where a check is deposited.

Article 4 B of the French General Tax Code identifies the principal domestic tests: the household or principal place of stay in France, a professional activity in France, or the center of economic interests in France. The same article says that a person meeting a domestic test is not treated as a French resident when an international tax treaty assigns residence elsewhere. For a retiree, the treaty tie-breaker and the factual pattern of the year matter. Count the days, identify the home available to the family, review the spouse’s residence, and record where economic and personal interests were actually centered.

Once French residence is established, the domestic starting rule is broad. Article 158 of the French General Tax Code says that net income categories are assessed without distinguishing whether income comes from France or abroad. The official wording is sans qu’il y ait lieu de distinguer suivant que ces revenus ont leur source en France ou hors de France. That does not override the treaty; it explains why a U.S. TSP payment can appear in the French computation even when the treaty limits the country that may finally collect tax.

Article 79 adds the domestic income category: salaries, pensions, life annuities, and retirement benefits paid as capital contribute to the global income used for income tax. For an installment TSP payment, the pension or retirement-income analysis is obvious. For a lump-sum withdrawal, the capital wording is a warning not to assume that a single payment is outside the French income tax base. The applicable treaty provision can change the final tax result, but the factual event and amount must still be identified.

French law also contains an ordinary pension allowance. Article 158 includes a 10 percent reduction for pensions and retirement benefits, subject to statutory limits and conditions. Do not mechanically apply the allowance to every TSP payment: the treatment of a lump sum, a Roth distribution, a rollover, a treaty-exempt amount, and a payment included only for rate-setting can differ. Use the current filing instructions for the year and preserve the computation showing which part was treated as taxable French income, which part was included for the rate, and which credit or treaty relief was claimed.

The treaty then supplies the allocation rules. Article 18(1)(a) generally assigns qualifying retirement-plan payments to the state of residence, subject to the public-pension rule in Article 19(2). Article 18(1)(b) treats social-security payments separately. Article 19(2) can assign a pension paid by a state for public service to the source state, subject to its nationality exception. For a U.S. citizen who is resident in France, the nationality wording can be decisive. It is not enough to state that the payer was a government body; determine whether the amount is a pension paid by that body for services or a distribution from a separate retirement plan.

The treaty’s double-tax article is equally important. Article 24(1)(a) says that certain U.S.-origin income that is taxable or taxable only in the United States is included in the French calculation, with a French tax credit rather than a deduction for the U.S. tax. Article 24(1)(b)(iv) contains a special rule for some Article 18(1)(a) income tied to services whose principal place of employment was in the United States. The exact result depends on the income category and service history. A U.S. payer’s withholding is not automatically the amount of the French credit, and a treaty credit is not necessarily a dollar-for-euro refund of every U.S. tax withheld.

The Conseil d’État, July 26, 2011, no. 308968, applied the treaty credit method to U.S.-source income and emphasized that the French credit calculation uses net U.S.-source income in relation to net global income. The court’s decision is a useful warning against copying the amount on Form 1099-R into a simplistic credit calculation. Keep the French income computation, the exchange-rate method, deductible charges, and the treaty worksheet together.

Finally, remember the treaty’s saving clause. Article 29(2) permits the United States to tax its citizens and residents as if the treaty did not exist, subject to the treaty’s listed exceptions. This is why an American citizen living in France normally continues to file a U.S. federal return and may have U.S. tax on a TSP distribution even when the treaty assigns a taxing right to France. The published treaty text, Article 29, should be read together with Article 24 rather than quoted in isolation. Residence in France does not erase U.S. citizenship-based filing obligations.

U.S. domestic treatment still affects the evidence. The IRS’s Publication 721, Tax Guide to U.S. Civil Service Retirement Benefits, explains that traditional TSP money is generally taxed as ordinary income when distributed, while a qualified Roth TSP distribution can be tax-free in the United States. It also explains that the TSP issues Form 1099-R and that withholding depends on the distribution type. A qualified distribution is a U.S. concept. It does not, without a French-law analysis, decide whether France sees the same contribution, earnings, basis, or distribution distinction.

Required minimum distributions, or RMDs, create a timing issue. An RMD is the minimum amount that U.S. law requires a participant to take from a retirement account once the applicable starting rules apply. The IRS RMD FAQs describe the general rules for employer-sponsored plans and beneficiaries. If the TSP requires an RMD, keep the calculation, the notice, the payment date, and the Form 1099-R. France normally needs the actual distribution year and amount; an American RMD deadline does not create a French exemption. Conversely, a French filing position should not be used as a reason to miss a U.S. RMD.

Traditional and Roth balances should be separated before the first French return. A traditional balance generally contains amounts whose U.S. tax was deferred. A Roth balance contains after-tax contributions and may contain earnings that receive favorable U.S. treatment only when the statutory qualified-distribution conditions are met. If the statement aggregates both balances, ask the TSP for the breakdown. The French return should not present a blended figure when the treaty analysis depends on the nature of the payment.

B. What should you file, preserve, and challenge?

For a French resident, the practical reporting sequence starts with the foreign-income forms. The French tax administration explains on its page about pensions and retirement benefits that foreign-source pensions are reported through Form 2047, the supplementary return for income received abroad, and then carried into the main income return where required. Form 2042 is the main French income-tax return. The correct box depends on the payment and the current year’s instructions, so use the official form and guide for the year being filed rather than an old screenshot or a box number copied from an earlier return.

Build the return from the payment record, not from the amount that reached your French bank account. Collect the gross distribution, the payment date, the U.S. dollar amount, the exchange-rate source and calculation, U.S. federal withholding, state withholding if any, and the part attributable to traditional contributions, Roth contributions, earnings, or an RMD. If a distribution was rolled over, obtain the transaction confirmation showing whether it went directly to an eligible receiving plan. A check paid to the participant and later deposited into another account is not documented in the same way as a trustee-to-trustee rollover.

Then write a short treaty memorandum for the file. It should identify your French residence for the year, the TSP’s legal nature, the payment type, the possible application of Article 18, the reason Article 19 was considered or rejected, the Article 24 relief method, and the U.S. filing position under Article 29. This memo is useful even when no tax is ultimately due in France. A future audit may occur after the original TSP statement, the federal employment file, and the distribution election are difficult to obtain.

The French collection mechanism is separate from treaty classification. Article 204 A provides that income taxed under the rules for salaries, pensions, life annuities, and several other categories gives rise to a payment at the time of receipt or realization under the French withholding system. A direct TSP payment may not have French withholding deducted by the U.S. plan administrator. That does not mean the income is outside French collection; it may mean that the taxpayer must use the French tax account, an advance payment, or a later regularization. The amount withheld by the United States is not a substitute for checking the French payment schedule.

Review the foreign-account question separately. Article 1649 A requires persons domiciled or established in France to declare references for foreign accounts that are opened, held, used, or closed abroad, subject to the rules and forms in force. Whether a particular TSP arrangement is treated as a reportable account, a retirement plan, or another category should be checked against the current Form 3916 instructions and the plan’s legal documentation. Do not infer the answer from FATCA, FBAR, or the mere fact that the TSP has an account number.

That review matters because Article 1736 sets tax penalties for failures involving certain foreign-account declarations, including a penalty per undeclared account and higher amounts in specified situations. The exact penalty depends on the statutory provision and facts. A cautious file keeps the completed form, a copy of the submitted return, and a written explanation if the position is that the TSP is not within the particular declaration. “The bank never asked me” is not a legal analysis.

The evidence pack should contain at least:

  1. the TSP participation statement and current plan description;
  2. year-end statements for each year in which the account was held or paid;
  3. the traditional/Roth balance breakdown and contribution history;
  4. the separation date, federal agency, service classification, and any FERS or CSRS annuity statement;
  5. the distribution election, RMD notice, withdrawal schedule, rollover confirmation, or beneficiary instruction;
  6. Form 1099-R, the U.S. federal return, proof of U.S. tax paid or withheld, and any IRS transcript;
  7. the French residence evidence, Forms 2042 and 2047, tax notices, and exchange-rate calculation; and
  8. all correspondence with the TSP, the IRS, the French tax administration, and any tax adviser about the classification.

Challenge the position promptly if a French assessment treats the TSP as a public pension without examining the plan, taxes a treaty-exempt amount without the required credit, or omits a payment from the rate computation. Article R*196-1 of the French Tax Procedures Book, the Livre des procédures fiscales, currently states the general deadline as December 31 of the second year following the relevant assessment, payment, or event, subject to the specific branch that applies. Tax deadlines can depend on the type of assessment and the event, so calculate the deadline from the notice and payment records rather than relying on a general internet summary.

A treaty dispute can also raise the mutual-agreement procedure. Article 26 of the treaty allows a person who considers that actions by one or both states result, or will result, in taxation contrary to the treaty to submit the case to the competent authority of the state of residence or nationality. The treaty text sets a three-year period from the first notification of the measure that produces the non-compliant taxation. This route is not a replacement for domestic French objections or U.S. filing compliance. It is an additional treaty procedure that should be evaluated when the two administrations maintain incompatible classifications.

The French administrative courts show why a complete return matters. In the 2015 CAA Versailles case cited above, the taxpayer had declared a U.S. government pension on an annex Form 2047 but had not included it in the overall income used to determine the French rate. The court upheld the reassessment while recognizing the treaty credit. The lesson for a TSP holder is practical: reporting a payment on the foreign-income schedule is not always the end of the calculation. You must also check whether the amount is included in the French global-income or rate-setting calculation and whether the treaty relief is recorded in the right place.

Do not treat a U.S. tax return as a complete French tax file. The two countries may use different tax bases, different currency conversions, different notions of gross income, and different treatment of pension allowances. The treaty may require France to include U.S. income in a calculation while granting a credit, or it may assign the final taxing right to one state with a saving-clause consequence in the other. Keep the U.S. Form 1040, Form 1099-R, any Form 5329 or RMD worksheet, and the French return as one cross-referenced file.

For the same reason, do not use a generic online statement that “retirement income is taxed where you live” or “government pensions are taxed where they come from.” Both statements can be directionally correct for one treaty article and wrong for the next. The TSP’s defined-contribution structure, the account’s traditional/Roth composition, the participant’s federal service, the distribution format, and U.S. citizenship all affect the analysis. The official sources linked here provide the legal starting points; they do not replace an examination of the actual plan documents.

Before the first distribution after the move, ask three concrete questions in writing: (1) is the proposed payment a distribution, an RMD, an annuity, or a rollover; (2) under the treaty facts, is it closer to Article 18 retirement-plan income or Article 19 public-service pension income; and (3) which French form, treaty credit, and U.S. form will show the amount? If the answers are not consistent across the TSP statement, the U.S. return, and the French return, stop before submitting the filing and obtain a documented review.

Conclusion

An American can generally keep a TSP after moving to France, and the move alone does not create a distribution. The legal risk begins when money leaves the account. A TSP is not automatically the same as a FERS or CSRS pension, yet it cannot be analyzed as an ordinary brokerage account without considering Article 18’s retirement-plan language. Article 19 must be reviewed because the employment was federal, but the public origin of the job does not by itself settle the classification. The safest approach is to preserve the plan evidence, separate traditional and Roth money, document RMDs and rollovers, determine French residence, report the payment consistently on Forms 2047 and 2042, and coordinate the treaty credit with the continuing U.S. filing. If the French administration or a preparer applies the wrong branch, the assessment should be challenged within the applicable deadline using the TSP records and the treaty text.

📄 Circulaire officielle