Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
Usmanov’s EU Sanctions Challenge: Can Media Corrections Make French Banks Unfreeze Assets?

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

Usmanov’s EU Sanctions Challenge: Can Media Corrections Make French Banks Unfreeze Assets?

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

Alisher Usmanov’s lawyers are asking the European Union to revisit his sanctions designation, according to a report published on 1 September 2026 by bne IntelliNews. The reported request is built around a difficult allegation: thousands of media reports relied on in the sanctions narrative were later corrected, withdrawn or shown to be inaccurate. That is a politically powerful story. It is not, by itself, a delisting decision.

The practical question for an international client is narrower and more urgent. If a media correction weakens part of the material behind an EU listing, can a French bank release the client’s account, securities or property? The answer normally runs through three separate legal layers: the Council’s decision to list or maintain a person, the directly applicable EU asset-freeze regulation, and the French bank’s own duties to implement sanctions and anti-money-laundering controls. Each layer has a different decision-maker, evidentiary record and remedy.

This distinction matters because a bank is not an appellate court for the Council. It cannot privately declare an EU listing invalid because a newspaper has amended a sentence. Conversely, a bank cannot treat every historic media allegation as permanently conclusive if the official designation no longer applies, the identity match is wrong, or a competent authority authorises a release. The correct response is an evidence-led review of the exact listing, ownership chain, legal basis and requested transaction.

The new Usmanov request therefore offers a useful test of the boundary between public evidence, judicial review and day-to-day compliance. It also gives French account holders a concrete route: isolate the point that has changed, prove why it changes the legal test, ask the competent authority the right question, and preserve an urgent remedy if the freeze has no remaining legal basis.

I. Can media corrections overturn an EU sanctions listing?

A. What did Usmanov’s lawyers ask the EU to review?

The reported request should first be described accurately. It is a request by lawyers, not a finding by the European Commission, the Council of the European Union or a court that the underlying reporting was false. The report says that a letter sent on 14 August 2026 by Omnia Strategy LLP to senior EU officials urged a review of the designation and referred to thousands of media corrections. Until the letter, its supporting exhibits and the Council’s response are available for examination, the correction count remains an asserted part of the client’s case.

That qualification does not make the issue legally irrelevant. EU restrictive measures must be supported by reasons and evidence capable of connecting the listed person to the statutory criterion. The central EU instrument for the Ukraine regime is Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014. Its Article 2 freezes funds and economic resources belonging to, owned, held or controlled by a listed person and prohibits making funds or economic resources available to that person. Its Annex I records the reasons for the designation. A correction that directly undermines a reason in that Annex is therefore more important than a general complaint that the press environment was unfair.

The legal work begins by turning the media story into a reason-by-reason evidence table. The table should identify the exact sentence relied on, the article or broadcast in which it appeared, the correction or withdrawal notice, the date of the change, the source that made the correction, and the paragraph in the Council’s statement of reasons that allegedly depends on it. It should then state the proposition that remains independently proved. A correction that changes a date, job title or quotation may be material to identification. A correction that changes an incidental description may have no effect on the legal test.

There is also a difference between a correction and a judicial finding. A newspaper can correct a report because it cannot substantiate a detail, because a source withdrew cooperation, or because its editorial standard requires more precision. That may be valuable new evidence. It does not automatically establish that the Council’s inference was unlawful when it adopted or renewed the listing. The applicant must connect the correction to the Council’s evidence and show why the remaining record no longer supports the legal criterion.

The designation criterion identified in the official case record includes the concept of a leading businessperson operating in Russia or a businessperson involved in an economic sector providing a substantial source of revenue to the Russian government. That is an EU-law test, not a reputational test. It does not ask whether every press report was perfect. It asks whether the Council could lawfully maintain the person on the list on the basis of a sufficiently reasoned and factually supported assessment.

The same distinction applies to allegations about political proximity. A corrected article might remove one description of a relationship, but other evidence could remain: corporate records, public appointments, ownership documents, government contracts, contemporaneous statements, sanctions history or evidence of material support. An evidence challenge is strongest when it shows that multiple reasons collapse together, not merely that one journalistic source used an inaccurate adjective.

For that reason, a request for review should ask the Council to do more than “read the corrections”. It should request an updated assessment of the statement of reasons, identify the non-confidential evidence that still supports each proposition, and explain whether any renewal decision relies on the same material. It should also separate three outcomes: complete removal from the list, amendment of the reasons, or confirmation of the listing on a materially different evidentiary basis. Those outcomes have different consequences for French banks and for pending litigation.

A client should preserve authenticated copies of every correction. Useful material includes the original publication, the publisher’s correction page, archived versions, a statement from the journalist or editor, the underlying public record, and a certified translation where the decision-maker works in another language. A bare social-media post saying that a story was “debunked” is weaker than a dated editorial correction tied to a specific factual proposition. The file should also explain why the corrected fact matters to the legal criterion, rather than asking the authority to infer the connection.

Finally, the new request must not be confused with a defamation judgment. A successful claim against a publisher may support a sanctions review, but it does not command the Council to delist. The legal question remains the lawfulness of the EU measure and the adequacy of the evidence as a whole. That is why the most useful submission is restrained: it concedes what the official record proves, isolates what has changed, and demonstrates the precise legal consequence.

B. Why does the General Court’s T-1117/23 judgment matter for the evidence?

The immediate obstacle for the new request is the existing judicial record. On 3 September 2025, the General Court delivered its judgment in Case T-1117/23, Alisher Usmanov v Council, ECLI:EU:T:2025:810. The official case entry describes an action for annulment concerning the maintenance of Usmanov’s name on the list and records the procedure as “Action for annulment – unfounded”. The case description expressly includes effective judicial protection, the duty to give reasons, error of assessment, proportionality, property and private-life rights.

That result does not make later corrections irrelevant. It does mean that a new review cannot simply repeat the arguments already rejected. The new material must be identified as new, or it must explain why the earlier judgment did not decide the particular factual point now raised. A client needs to read the judgment’s reasoning, identify which evidence the General Court accepted as sufficient, and distinguish an evidentiary attack on the original acts from a challenge to a later maintenance decision.

The procedural position also matters. EUR-Lex records an appeal brought by Usmanov on 13 November 2025 in Case C-725/25 P. An appeal is not the same as a suspension of the listing, and the existence of an appeal does not authorise a French bank to release assets. Unless the official EU measure ceases to apply or a competent authority grants a lawful derogation, the bank must continue to treat the applicable freeze as binding.

The evidentiary lesson is that the Council’s reasons and the judicial record must be read together. The official listing material may contain a general description of the person’s business activity, political relationships and alleged benefit from Russian decision-makers. The court record may explain which propositions were disputed and how the General Court assessed them. A new correction should be placed against both documents. If it contradicts a proposition that was central to the judgment, it may support a serious request for reconsideration. If it concerns a point the judgment did not need to decide, its value may be narrower.

There is no automatic “media correction defence” in Regulation 269/2014. The remedy is institutional. The person can make a documented representation to the Council, seek review of continued designation, and challenge a review or renewal act within the EU judicial system. Article 263 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union provides the judicial route for an action for annulment against an EU act under its conditions and time limit. A French administrative court cannot annul the Council’s EU listing merely because the frozen account is located in France.

French law still matters because the national implementation layer can be distinct. The French Monetary and Financial Code allows a national freeze in defined circumstances. Article L562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code states that the Minister for the Economy may decide, for six months renewable, to freeze funds and economic resources belonging to persons designated under certain United Nations or EU-related acts. Its opening rule is not a substitute for the Council’s listing; it is a separate national power with its own decision, publication and challenge route.

This distinction is critical for an Usmanov-linked account. There may be an EU designation, a French national measure, a United Nations measure, a United Kingdom or United States measure, and an independent anti-money-laundering restriction. A correction to the media material behind the EU listing does not erase the other layers. The first question to the bank must therefore be: “Which exact measure, list, identifier and legal provision currently prevents this transaction?” A request that asks only for “unfreezing after the news correction” is too imprecise to produce a reliable answer.

France’s publication rule is also relevant. Article L562-9 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides for publication of ministerial freeze decisions and states when they become enforceable. The applicant should obtain the official designation notice, any amendment, the identification details and the effective date. A private database, an old press article or an undated screening extract cannot safely establish the current legal status.

The practical conclusion from T-1117/23 is therefore balanced. The judgment makes a casual delisting narrative unsustainable, but it does not prevent a focused evidence challenge based on later, authenticated corrections. The stronger case is not “the press made mistakes, so the freeze is void”. It is “the precise facts that the Council used have changed, the remaining evidence no longer satisfies the stated criterion, and the authority must reassess the current measure”.

II. Can a French bank unfreeze Usmanov-linked assets?

A. What must a French bank check before releasing frozen funds?

A French bank’s first obligation is implementation, not adjudication. Under Article 2 of Regulation 269/2014, funds and economic resources within the regulation’s scope are frozen and cannot be made available to the listed person. The European Commission’s current asset-freeze guidance for Regulation 269/2014 addresses the implementation of those restrictions and the available derogation framework. If the client remains covered by an applicable listing, a bank cannot release money simply because the client supplies a lawyer’s letter or points to a corrected article.

French domestic law reinforces the speed of the obligation. Article L562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code requires covered persons to apply measures without delay. The statutory phrase is appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel, which means that a bank is expected to stop a prohibited movement promptly once the measure is identified. The provision also requires immediate information to the Minister for the Economy and reaches certain foreign institutions for their activities carried out in France.

The bank’s compliance architecture is not optional. Article L562-4-1 requires the relevant institutions to maintain an internal organisation et des procédures internes for implementing asset freezes, prohibitions on making funds available and the prohibition on circumvention. A release decision should therefore be supported by a documented re-screening, an ownership and control review, a check of current official lists and an analysis of any separate legal basis for the hold.

French case law confirms that this preventive work must operate before a transfer leaves the institution. In Conseil d’État, 15 November 2019, No 428292, the court upheld a major supervisory sanction against La Banque Postale and held that financial institutions must maintain preventive systems capable of detecting transfers to or at the request of a designated person so as to suspendre immédiatement l’exécution. The decision concerned cash mandates and a different factual period, but its compliance lesson is directly relevant: a French bank must be able to stop a transaction while it verifies the legal basis, not repair the screening failure afterwards.

The prohibition is wider than a direct payment to the listed individual. Article L562-5 prohibits covered persons from using or making funds or economic resources available directly or indirectly for the benefit of a person whose assets are frozen. A bank must ask whether a company, trust, nominee, family member or intermediary is merely a different name for the same controlled economic resource. A correction to a person’s biography does not answer that ownership question.

The next guardrail is anti-circumvention. Article L562-6 prohibits participation, knowingly and voluntarily, in activity intended to circumvent a freeze. Its exact phrase is contourner les mesures. That rule does not permit a bank to invent a freeze where none exists, but it does explain why a bank will not route a payment through a new entity merely because the old account is blocked. The transaction must be legally permitted in substance, not only cosmetically renamed.

The bank should separate a true sanctions hit from a false positive. A person may share a name, date of birth or nationality with the listed person. A company may have a historic relationship but no ownership or control by the listed person. An account may belong to a non-listed third party even though the listed person once gave instructions. Each fact changes the analysis. The client’s file should prove identity, beneficial ownership, signing authority, control rights, payment purpose and the asset’s source. It should not ask the bank to ignore an actual match.

If an official EU delisting occurs, the bank still needs an operational release process. It must verify the exact effective date, the precise person or entity removed, the amended Annex entry and whether another designation remains. It should review linked entities, beneficial owners and payment counterparties. A release from one EU measure does not necessarily remove a United States, United Kingdom, United Nations or French national restriction. The client should request a written statement of what has been cleared and what, if anything, remains blocked.

Where the hold is based on a French national measure, the release route can involve the competent minister. Article L562-11 allows the competent authority, in the situations covered by the provision, to autoriser le déblocage et la mise à disposition of part of the frozen funds or resources subject to the statutory conditions. The request can be made by the person concerned or by a third party with a right over the assets. The application should state the legal basis of the freeze, the precise amount, the proposed use and the safeguards that prevent onward benefit to a listed person.

EU derogations are a separate matter. Article 4 of Regulation 269/2014 includes authorisation categories such as basic needs, reasonable legal fees and routine holding or maintenance costs, subject to the competent authority’s assessment and conditions. A bank cannot create that authorisation itself. Legal fees should be requested through the competent channel with an engagement letter, invoice, capped amount and segregation plan. A request for a full release of commercial assets cannot be disguised as a request for legal fees.

There is a further layer that sanctions counsel must not overlook. A bank may have an anti-money-laundering concern independent of the listing. Article L561-15 of the Monetary and Financial Code requires covered persons to report sums or operations where they know, suspect or have good reason to suspect a qualifying criminal origin or terrorist-financing link. The statutory wording includes savent, soupçonnent ou ont de bonnes raisons de soupçonner. A client who wins a sanctions review may still face a separate compliance review, and the bank may be legally restricted in what it can disclose about a suspicious-transaction report.

A recent civil decision illustrates why an ordinary creditor cannot bypass that control by seeking payment from a frozen asset. In Cour de cassation, Second Civil Chamber, 5 February 2026, No 23-15.936, the court examined the effect of a sanctions freeze and recorded that enforcement affecting frozen funds was subject to prior authorisation by the competent national authority under the applicable EU regulation. The case concerned Libyan assets rather than Usmanov and must not be treated as an identical merits ruling. Its operational principle remains useful: where the regulation requires an authorisation, a private enforcement step cannot substitute for that authorisation.

The best request to a French bank is consequently precise and limited. It should ask for the applicable legal basis, the identifier that generated the alert, whether the bank is dealing with an EU measure or a national measure, whether an authorisation is required, and which documents are needed to review ownership or a false positive. It should not demand the disclosure of confidential reporting material. A clear request gives the bank a route to correct a mistake while preserving the controls that the law requires.

One provision protects the bank’s position while also explaining the client’s difficulty. Article L562-10 states that measures under the chapter are opposables à tout tiers who claims a right over frozen funds or economic resources, even where that right arose earlier. A creditor, purchaser or contractual counterparty cannot simply argue that its claim predates the freeze. The bank must respect the freeze unless the applicable law supplies an exception or an authority releases the asset.

That is why “unfreeze” can mean several different things: correct a false name match, release an asset belonging to a non-listed third party, obtain a limited authorisation, challenge a national decision, or remove a person from an EU list. Each route needs a different evidence pack. Confusing them is a common reason for delay.

B. What urgent court remedies exist when a bank keeps the account blocked?

The remedy depends on the measure that actually causes the loss. If the problem is the EU Council listing, the main challenge is brought in the EU judicial system. If the problem is a French ministerial decision, the French administrative courts may review that decision. If the problem is a bank’s independent refusal after the sanctions basis has disappeared, the dispute may concern the banking relationship and the bank’s contractual or regulatory duties. The first procedural act is therefore not a lawsuit; it is a written request that fixes the decision, date, legal basis and requested relief.

For a French national administrative decision, the ordinary time limit must be protected. Article R421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice provides that the court may be seized within les deux mois from notification or publication of the challenged decision, subject to the applicable rules and exceptions. The client should not wait for a bank’s internal review if an official decision has already been published. A settlement discussion with the bank does not automatically preserve a judicial deadline.

Urgency may justify an application for suspension. Article L521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice allows the interim judge to suspend execution when l’urgence le justifie and a ground creates serious doubt about legality. The applicant must show concrete harm: inability to pay essential costs, an imminent contractual loss, a threatened enforcement measure, business paralysis or another immediate consequence. The evidence should be dated and quantified. A general assertion that the freeze is inconvenient is rarely enough.

The merits argument should follow the same disciplined structure as the review request. It can concern a wrong identity, a failure to apply the correct legal test, a missing or contradictory statement of reasons, a manifest evidentiary error, an unlawful duration, or refusal to consider a competent authority’s release. The court will not replace a sanctions policy with a general fairness assessment. It will ask whether the challenged measure has a legal basis, was adopted by the competent authority and is supported by the required reasoning and evidence.

For a bank dispute, the evidence should establish that the bank has either misidentified the client or continued a hold after its legal basis ended. The core documents are the bank’s freeze notice, account and asset statements, the official listing entry, all subsequent amendments, the client’s identity documents, corporate registers, shareholder and control agreements, trust or mandate instruments, proof of beneficial ownership, transaction purpose and correspondence with the bank. A timeline should show exactly when the listing changed, when the correction was published, when the client notified the bank and what answer followed.

If the client is a third party whose funds were caught in a listed person’s structure, the file must prove the separation in economic terms. A company name alone is not enough. The analysis should cover voting rights, appointment powers, veto rights, financing, guarantees, instructions, beneficial ownership, distributions and the practical ability to use the asset. A non-listed company can still be frozen if the listed person owns or controls it. Conversely, a historic commercial relationship does not by itself establish current ownership or control.

In an urgent application, the requested order must be carefully framed. The client may seek suspension of a national decision, a direction to reconsider a false positive, permission for a limited payment, or release of an asset proven to belong to a non-listed third party. Asking a French court to order a bank to disregard an active EU prohibition is unlikely to succeed and can create an avoidable circumvention concern. The court needs a lawful and technically executable remedy.

The client should also protect essential expenses without presenting them as an argument for total delisting. A request for legal fees, rent, medical costs or ordinary maintenance may fall within an EU or national derogation category, but the amount, recipient and purpose must be controlled. Use of an unauthorised intermediary, cash withdrawal or nominee account can create a new issue under the anti-circumvention rule. The safer approach is a formal authorisation request with a segregated account and direct payment to the verified provider.

Privacy and confidentiality require realistic expectations. The bank may explain the regulatory category and the documents needed for a review, but it may not be able to disclose a suspicious-transaction report or the identity of a reporting person. The client should ask for an actionable reason code or legal basis, not for confidential intelligence. Counsel can then address the issue with evidence that does not depend on disclosure of protected material.

Cross-border coordination is equally important. Usmanov-linked assets may be held by a French bank, a Luxembourg custodian, a Swiss company, a United Kingdom intermediary or a United States correspondent. Each jurisdiction can apply its own sanctions regime and licensing rules. A French release may permit one transaction under French and EU law while another bank remains blocked by a different designation. The release plan must map the payment chain from origin to final beneficiary and check every relevant jurisdiction.

The practical sequence is short but demanding. First, obtain the official measure and freeze notice. Second, separate the EU listing, any French measure, and independent AML concerns. Third, build the reason-by-reason correction file. Fourth, ask the Council or competent French authority for the remedy that matches the legal defect. Fifth, send the bank a structured re-screening request with proof of identity, ownership and transaction purpose. Sixth, calculate any two-month administrative deadline and prepare interim relief if the harm is immediate.

This sequence also creates an audit trail. It shows that the client is asking for lawful implementation, not trying to defeat the sanctions regime. It gives the bank an evidence-based way to correct a false positive or request permission. It gives the authority a focused question to answer. And it preserves the ability to challenge an unlawful national decision without treating every delay as proof of bad faith.

The reported Usmanov letter may ultimately lead to a Council review, a renewed litigation record or no change at all. The legal value of the story will depend on the documents behind it. If corrections materially alter the evidence relied on for a listing, they should be tested through the review and judicial mechanisms. If they merely show that some reporting was imprecise while independent evidence remains, a French bank will still be required to maintain the freeze. In both cases, the answer comes from the legal basis and evidence, not the headline.

Conclusion

Media corrections can become important new evidence in an EU sanctions challenge, but they do not operate as an automatic unfreezing order. The General Court’s judgment in T-1117/23, the pending appeal, the current EU listing and any French national measure must be read together. A French bank must apply an active freeze without delay, while also correcting a false positive or processing a lawful derogation when the evidence and authority support it.

For a client affected by an Usmanov-linked freeze, the decisive document is a reasoned, authenticated file: the exact corrected proposition, the official legal measure, the ownership chain, the transaction purpose and the urgent harm. The file should ask the right authority for the right relief and preserve the applicable court deadline. That is the route from a breaking sanctions story to a legally reviewable request.

📄 Circulaire officielle