Cabinet Kohen Avocats · Paris 16ᵉ
France’s Baghdad Embassy Lawsuit: Can a Paris Court Hear a Claim for 50 Years of Unpaid Rent?

Maître Hassan KOHEN intervient en urgence, du commissariat à la cour d'assises. Première analyse stratégique : 80 € TTC, réponse personnelle sous 24 heures.

100 % confidentiel · Secret professionnel · Sans engagement

Article généré par une intelligence artificielle, selon un processus conçu et contrôlé par le cabinet

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

Barreau de Paris Garde à vue, instruction, assises Fiche CNB avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Maître Hassan KOHEN
Avocat au Barreau de Paris

France’s Baghdad Embassy Lawsuit: Can a Paris Court Hear a Claim for 50 Years of Unpaid Rent?

Parler à un avocat 06 89 11 34 45

On 3 September 2026, AFP reported that descendants of the Jewish owners of a Baghdad building used by France as its embassy have brought a new civil action in Paris, seeking about €21.5 million for decades of unpaid rent and related harm. The claim follows a February 2026 judgment in which the Paris administrative court declined jurisdiction over the contractual and quasi-contractual claims. The court did not decide whether the heirs own a valid debt, whether Iraq’s historic measures made payment impossible, or whether France was legally responsible for the alleged loss. It decided that the administrative order was not the forum for a lease that was not shown to be governed by French law. The official judgment, no. 2412294/4-2, records a lease signed on 28 December 1964, an embassy occupation beginning on 16 April 1965, non-payment alleged from at least 1974, and a claim calculated at €21,482,790.31. The new filing therefore turns a diplomatic-property story into a live question of French civil jurisdiction, conflict of laws, prescription, proof and public-law boundaries. This analysis addresses what the Paris civil court would have to decide next, while separating reported allegations from findings that have actually been adjudicated.

I. Can the Paris court hear the Baghdad embassy claim?

A. Why the new civil claim is different from the administrative case

The first distinction is procedural, but it controls the entire dispute. The February judgment of the Tribunal administratif de Paris was not a ruling that the heirs were wrong about the rent, that the property was not taken from Jewish owners, or that France had discharged every contractual obligation. It was a ruling about the competence of the administrative court. Its operative Article 1 rejects the contractual and quasi-contractual claims “as being brought before a court without jurisdiction”. The surplus of the claim was rejected separately.

The judgment is unusually useful because it states the factual and legal route in detail. The court records that the original owners concluded the 1964 lease with the French ambassador in Iraq. The lease provided for the embassy to occupy the building from April 1965, for a renewable two-year period, against rent of 2,000 Iraqi dinars. The judgment also records the Iraqi measures described by the claimants: a 1951 law freezing the funds of Iraqi Jewish nationals deprived of nationality, a 1967 amendment concerning citizenship and frozen property, and a 1968 measure restricting leases longer than one year over property belonging to Jewish persons. The judgment states that the heirs moved to Canada, that no rent was received from France since at least 1974, and that later arrangements were made with an Iraqi administrator and the city of Baghdad.

Those facts remain allegations or recorded procedural facts unless a court makes a merits finding. The official decision can be read in full in the Paris administrative court judgment no. 2412294/4-2. It records the amount claimed, the parties’ competing arguments and the procedural history. It does not establish that every claimed rent instalment is due, that the Iraqi measures legally extinguished the owners’ rights, or that France acted unlawfully.

The administrative court’s central proposition was that “Le juge administratif français n’est toutefois pas compétent” for a dispute arising from the performance of a contract that is in no way governed by French law. It then explained that contracts concluded abroad by State services are, unless legislation provides otherwise, governed by the law chosen by the parties, if the choice can be established from the contract, and otherwise by the law of the country where the contract is performed. The court’s short formulation was that “ces contrats sont régis par la loi du pays où ils sont exécutés”. In this case, it found no sufficiently certain choice of French law in the lease. French drafting, a French signatory, the purpose of housing a French public service, some payments allegedly made in French francs, and the absence of an express Iraqi jurisdiction clause did not change that conclusion.

A civil action can respond directly to that reasoning. The heirs’ reported assignment before the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris is not an appeal of the administrative judgment in another disguise. It is an attempt to place the underlying private-law dispute before the ordinary civil order. The civil court will not be bound to accept the claim merely because the administrative court declined jurisdiction, but the new pleading must confront the same contract, the same place of performance, the same historic documents and the same choice-of-law problem.

The starting point for ordinary subject-matter jurisdiction is Article L211-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation. It gives the tribunal judiciaire the civil and commercial matters not assigned to another court because of the nature of the claim. The statutory wording is broad: “Le tribunal judiciaire connaît de toutes les affaires civiles et commerciales” for which another jurisdiction has not been assigned competence. The article is available on Légifrance, Article L211-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation. It is a gateway, not a merits ruling. A claim can be civil in character and still face an international jurisdiction objection, a contractual arbitration clause, a public-law allocation rule, prescription or lack of proof.

Territorial jurisdiction creates a second filter. Article 42 of the Code of Civil Procedure ordinarily points to the defendant’s place of residence, stating that the competent court is “celle du lieu où demeure le défendeur”. A claim against the French State naturally raises the question of its institutional domicile and the proper representative authority. Article 46 adds optional fora for a contract, including “le lieu de l’exécution de la prestation de service”, and for a tort, the place of the harmful event or the place where damage was suffered. The provisions are set out in Article 42 CPC and Article 46 CPC. The fact that the building is in Baghdad may assist the factual connection with Iraq while making Paris jurisdiction more, not less, dependent on the legal character of the defendant and the pleaded cause of action.

The civil judge could therefore accept jurisdiction over a claim against France yet still apply Iraqi law to the lease. Jurisdiction and applicable law are separate questions. A Paris court may be the forum in which the case is heard even if the court must obtain evidence about Iraqi property, lease and prescription rules. That separation is the practical opening created by the new filing.

B. Does sovereign immunity bar a claim against France?

The phrase “sovereign immunity” needs precision here. The defendant is the French State before a French court, not Iraq or another foreign government sued in France. The classic foreign-state jurisdictional immunity cases therefore provide an analytical comparison, but they do not automatically give France a jurisdictional defence against its own nationals or former owners in its own courts. The immediate barrier identified in the February judgment was allocation between the administrative and civil orders, not a blanket declaration that France could never be sued.

French case law nonetheless supplies a useful functional test for state conduct connected with a lease. In the Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 17 January 1973, no. 71-11.793, the Court examined a lease entered into by Spain for premises used by a tourism agency. Its published principle began: “L’IMMUNITE DE JURIDICTION NE PEUT ETRE RECONNUE A UN ETAT ETRANGER” when the state contracted under private-law rules and did not perform an act of public authority. The case is not factually identical. It concerned a foreign state and commercial premises, not France’s own embassy. Its importance is methodological: the court looked at the nature of the act and the contractual setting rather than allowing the public purpose asserted by the state to decide everything.

The later Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 19 November 2008, no. 07-10.570, makes the same distinction in modern language. It held that a foreign state and its emanations benefit from jurisdictional immunity only when the act at issue participates by its nature or purpose in the exercise of sovereignty and is “n’est donc pas un acte de gestion”. The dispute concerned a wall adjoining property owned by Germany. The Court treated the acquisition and maintenance of real estate as private management in the circumstances before it, while separately discussing immunity from execution. Again, the judgment cannot decide the Baghdad case by itself. It shows why a court is likely to separate the signature and performance of a lease from later diplomatic decisions, security measures, or public-service conduct.

For the heirs, the strongest civil argument is likely to be that the dispute concerns a lease and payment obligation, not a challenge to France’s diplomatic recognition, foreign policy or exercise of coercive authority. That argument does not prove liability. It seeks to prevent the use of the embassy’s public function as a universal answer to an ordinary rent claim. France can respond that the premises were part of a diplomatic mission, that the relationship was inseparable from sovereign functions, that the historic lease was governed by Iraqi law, and that the pleaded loss arises from events in Iraq rather than from a private transaction governed by French civil law.

The February judgment also addressed a different immunity: immunity from execution. It stated that international custom generally protects states from execution for acts carried out abroad and that this protection may block seizure of state property. It then applied Article L111-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Proceedings, which says: “L’exécution forcée et les mesures conservatoires ne sont pas applicables aux personnes qui bénéficient d’une immunité d’exécution.” The provision is reproduced on Légifrance, Article L111-1 CPCE. The administrative court rejected the claim based on France’s no-fault responsibility for that immunity because the dispute was not linked to an action by a foreign state on French territory.

Execution immunity matters later, but it should not be confused with access to a court. Article L111-1-1 CPCE requires prior judicial authorisation for enforcement or conservatory measures against property belonging to a foreign state, “sur autorisation préalable du juge par ordonnance rendue sur requête”. Article L111-1-2 then lists the narrow circumstances in which a measure against foreign-state property may be authorised, including express consent or a final judgment connected with property used otherwise than for non-commercial public service. The official texts are available at Article L111-1-1 CPCE and Article L111-1-2 CPCE. Those provisions primarily concern foreign-state assets. They do not create a shortcut for seizing a diplomatic account, and they do not mean that a judgment against France would automatically be unenforceable.

The practical answer to the headline question is therefore conditional. A Paris civil court may be able to hear a private claim against the French State, subject to its own jurisdictional analysis. Sovereign immunity is not a complete answer on the facts currently reported. The court will have to identify the legal nature of the lease, the applicable law, the cause of action and the relief sought. A claim aimed at compelling a diplomatic act or seizing mission property would raise very different issues from a claim for a money judgment based on non-payment of rent.

II. What must the heirs prove, and what happens next?

A. Which contract, limitation period and evidence control the €21.5 million claim?

The reported figure is not self-proving. A court assessing €21,482,790.31 would have to identify the legal source of each component: rent, interest, currency conversion, loss of use, moral damage, restitution for enrichment, or compensation for a separate wrong. The 1964 lease is the first document, but not necessarily the last. The 1978 arrangement with an Iraqi administrator, the 1983 agreement with Baghdad, renewals, diplomatic correspondence, payment instructions and any acknowledgment of debt could change the legal period and the person against whom a payment obligation is enforceable.

If French contract law governs all or part of the lease, Article 1103 of the Code civil supplies the familiar starting point: “Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits.” The official text is at Article 1103 of the Code civil. The principle protects the agreed bargain, but it does not answer whether the contract was transferred, modified, frustrated, replaced or rendered unenforceable by Iraqi legislation. It also does not prove that a later state administrator had authority to receive rent on behalf of the owners or their heirs.

Article 1217 of the Code civil describes the contractual remedies available when an undertaking has not been performed or has been performed imperfectly. It lists suspension, specific performance, price reduction, termination and compensation; it also states that “des dommages et intérêts peuvent toujours s’y ajouter”. The full provision appears at Article 1217 of the Code civil. Article 1231-1 adds that “Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts” for non-performance or delay unless force majeure is established; see Article 1231-1 of the Code civil. These provisions are conditional tools, not findings that French law applies. If Iraqi law governs, the court must first determine the content and effect of that law, often through expert evidence and properly authenticated legal materials.

Conflict of laws will be central. The administrative court found the place of performance to be Iraq in the absence of a certain choice-of-law clause. A civil court might reach the same result, or it might consider a different pleaded basis, a later agreement, a mandatory rule, a claim independent of the lease, or the effect of a French State decision taken in Paris. The pleadings must make those alternatives explicit. Calling every head of loss “unpaid rent” may invite the defendant to argue that the entire case is governed by the foreign law and limitation rules of the place where the property and lease operated.

Prescription is the second major vulnerability. Article 2224 of the Code civil provides a five-year period for personal or movable actions, beginning when the right-holder knew or should have known the facts allowing the action. The statutory phrase is “se prescrivent par cinq ans”, and the current text is available at Article 2224 of the Code civil. A claim based on non-payment beginning in 1974 faces an immediate objection if French prescription applies. The 2024 demand letter and the 2026 proceedings may be important to establish diligence, but a recent demand does not automatically revive every historic instalment.

The heirs may argue that each unpaid rent instalment was a separate breach, that the breach continued, that the State’s conduct or the Iraqi measures prevented an earlier action, that there was a later acknowledgment, or that they seek compensation for a more recent refusal rather than the whole historical period. France may answer that the owners knew of non-payment long ago, that the claim is a single time-barred contractual dispute, or that the applicable Iraqi limitation law produces a different result. None of those positions can be selected from the press report alone.

Article 2232 establishes a long-stop rule: postponement, suspension or interruption cannot normally push extinction beyond twenty years from the birth of the right. It says that the limitation period cannot be carried “au-delà de vingt ans à compter du jour de la naissance du droit”, subject to statutory exceptions. The official version is at Article 2232 of the Code civil. The court must also address transitional rules because the lease and alleged breaches predate the 2008 reform and later amendments. If Iraqi law controls prescription as part of the applicable law, French Articles 2224 and 2232 may operate as arguments about French public policy or not govern at all.

The evidential file must be built around that chronology. At minimum, the heirs would need to organise:

  • the original lease, every renewal, amendment and termination document, with a reliable translation and proof of authenticity;
  • title records identifying the original owners, the succession chain and the legal capacity of each claimant;
  • the Iraqi statutes and administrative measures said to have frozen property, removed nationality or restricted leases, together with expert evidence of their legal effect;
  • bank records, receipts, diplomatic accounts or correspondence showing payments, non-payment, attempted payment and the recipient France treated as landlord;
  • the 1978 and 1983 arrangements and subsequent renewals, to test whether they replaced the 1964 lease or merely reflected an imposed administration;
  • the calculation of rent, exchange rates, interest, loss of use and moral damage for each period; and
  • the documents proving the 2024 administrative demand, its rejection, the administrative case and the new civil assignment.

The burden is not only historical. The heirs must connect France’s conduct to the specific amount claimed. If France paid rent to an Iraqi administrator under a legal order, the court may have to determine whether payment discharged the lease, whether the payment was made in bad faith, and whether a state instrument prevented the original owners from collecting. If France stopped paying without a lawful release, the question may be contractual. If the property was taken by Iraq and France merely remained in occupation, causation may be analysed differently. If the claim is framed as unjust enrichment, the court must identify the enrichment, the impoverishment and the absence of a legal basis, while respecting the rule that a valid contract normally governs the relationship.

B. What remedies, appeals and French procedure remain open?

The new civil proceedings will probably begin with procedural objections before any full accounting. Article 122 of the Code of Civil Procedure defines a “fin de non-recevoir” as a means seeking dismissal without an examination of the merits, including lack of standing, lack of interest, prescription, a time limit or res judicata. The key words are “sans examen au fond”. The official text is available at Article 122 CPC. France can therefore challenge prescription or the claimants’ capacity without first debating every rent receipt. A jurisdictional exception is a different procedural device: it asks the court to decline the case because another court or order has competence. The new pleadings need to anticipate both.

The February administrative decision may be invoked by both sides, but its legal effect must be read carefully. The heirs can rely on the court’s finding that the administrative order was not competent to hear a contract not governed by French law, supporting their move to the civil order. France can rely on the same passages to argue that Iraqi law governs and that the civil judge should not simply apply French contractual remedies. The administrative judgment’s rejection of the no-fault claim based on foreign-state execution immunity may also narrow any attempt to convert a diplomatic enforcement difficulty into a general compensation claim against France.

If the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris accepts jurisdiction, the court can order the parties to exchange the lease, the succession documents, the payment history and the foreign-law evidence. It may appoint a translator or expert, request clarification of the calculation, and separate liability from quantum. It may also decide an incidental question of foreign law before deciding whether the claim is prescribed. A preliminary jurisdiction ruling could be appealed to the Cour d’appel de Paris, and a legal error could ultimately reach the Cour de cassation. Those possibilities make the first civil-order decision significant even if it says nothing about the final amount.

A judgment for money is not the same as authorisation to interfere with a diplomatic mission. The execution analysis depends on the debtor and the asset targeted. Articles L111-1-1 and L111-1-2 CPCE specifically regulate enforcement against foreign-state property and protect assets used for diplomatic functions. A judgment against the French State would be enforced under the rules applicable to a domestic public debtor, subject to the public-account and state-property rules that the parties would need to identify. The heirs would still need to secure a judgment, serve it correctly and identify assets or payment mechanisms that the law permits them to pursue. The existence of a large award would not itself authorise seizure of an embassy.

The remedy may also be narrower than the headline amount. A court could find that some rent periods are prescribed, that some payments were effective, that the 1978 or 1983 contracts altered the debtor, or that the moral-damage claim lacks a sufficient legal connection to the alleged contractual breach. It could award damages for a defined period, order production of documents, reject a restitution theory because a contract exists, or dismiss the action after finding that Iraqi law provides no enforceable right on the evidence submitted. Conversely, proof of continuing occupation, a valid title chain, an unbroken rent obligation and a legally ineffective transfer to an administrator could produce a meaningful award without accepting every component of the €21.5 million calculation.

The diplomatic dimension may influence settlement even when it does not determine liability. France will want to avoid a precedent suggesting that every historic foreign mission lease can be reopened in Paris. The heirs will want a forum in which the interaction between anti-Semitic Iraqi property measures, succession, state contracting and decades of occupation can be examined rather than ended on an order-of-jurisdiction objection. A negotiated solution could address payment, recognition, access to archives, property documentation or a structured resolution without deciding every historical question. Settlement, however, would not establish the legal truth of the reported allegations for other property owners.

For lawyers and international owners watching the case, the most important procedural lesson is practical. A foreign building used by a state does not automatically answer whether the lease is public or private, whether the forum is administrative or civil, whether a court can apply foreign law, or whether execution is possible. The claim must be pleaded in layers: jurisdiction, applicable law, standing, prescription, breach, causation, valuation and remedy. Each layer requires a different document. A translated lease cannot replace title proof; a title record cannot replace a calculation; and a newspaper account cannot replace the text of the Iraqi law or the payment trail.

Conclusion

France’s Baghdad embassy dispute has moved into a new procedural phase, not a final merits phase. The February 2026 administrative judgment rejected the contractual and quasi-contractual claims for want of administrative jurisdiction and rejected the separate no-fault theory linked to foreign-state execution immunity. The reported civil assignment in Paris now asks the ordinary courts to decide whether a private-law claim can proceed against France, what law governs a lease performed in Iraq, and whether decades of alleged non-payment can still be claimed.

The heirs’ route is legally credible as a jurisdictional strategy, but it is not a guaranteed recovery. The civil court must distinguish domestic access to justice from execution against diplomatic assets, and must distinguish a forum in Paris from the application of French law. The decisive evidence will likely be the original lease, later Iraqi arrangements, the legal effect of the 1951, 1967 and 1968 measures, the succession chain, the payment records and a period-by-period damages schedule. Prescription and causation may reduce the case before the court ever reaches the full moral and financial claim.

The wider significance extends beyond this building. Historic state leases often sit at the intersection of private contract, public service, diplomatic protection and forced property change. French courts are likely to examine the act in dispute with care: a rent obligation may be treated differently from a diplomatic decision, and a judgment may be easier to obtain than to execute against protected state property. The next jurisdictional ruling will therefore matter to heirs, landlords, diplomats and governments managing foreign missions far beyond Baghdad.

Official legal materials consulted: the Tribunal administratif de Paris judgment no. 2412294/4-2; Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 17 January 1973, no. 71-11.793; and Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 19 November 2008, no. 07-10.570.

📄 Circulaire officielle