A Paris enforcement judge has just drawn a sharp line between an international arbitral award and the assets that can actually be reached to satisfy it. In a judgment dated 17 July 2026, the Execution Judge of the Paris Judicial Court withdrew an ex parte order that had allowed Cardno Middle East Limited to attach funds held by the Banque de France for the Central Bank of Iraq. The public case record identifies the dispute as Cardno v. Central Bank of Iraq, linked to an ICC award of 26 February 2023 and a principal award of more than US$10 million. The result is not a ruling that every Iraqi asset, or every state-owned asset, is untouchable. It is a warning that foreign award creditors face a distinct evidential barrier when the target is a foreign central bank or monetary authority. This analysis explains why French law treats central-bank reserves differently, how the Paris court applied the burden of proof, and what an award creditor should do before attempting another seizure. The French perspective matters beyond Iraq: the same statutory architecture will shape disputes involving frozen reserves, sovereign funds, public banks and central-bank accounts held in France.
I. Can a Paris court block seizure of Iraqi central-bank reserves?
A. What did Cardno v. Central Bank of Iraq decide on 17 July 2026?
The starting point is the procedural posture. The public case record consulted for this analysis describes a judgment of the Paris Execution Judge on 17 July 2026. The Central Bank of Iraq asked the court to retract an order made without an initial adversarial hearing on 6 May 2026. That earlier order had authorised Cardno ME Limited to pursue a saisie-attribution against funds held by the Banque de France. The Banque de France intervened voluntarily in support of the retraction. The court admitted that intervention, rejected Cardno’s request to wait for a discovery process in the United States, withdrew the May order and ordered the attachment to be released.
The attachment was the enforcement phase of a much older commercial dispute. Cardno, a UAE-based engineering and consultancy company, had provided services connected with the Central Bank of Iraq’s new headquarters in Baghdad. The ICC arbitration was seated in Paris. The tribunal rendered its final award on 26 February 2023. The case record describes unpaid invoices, damages for the remaining value of the contract, interest, costs and an award of approximately US$10.19 million in principal damages, together with further relief concerning a performance bond. Cardno then pursued recognition and enforcement in several jurisdictions. The Paris Court of Appeal rejected the Iraqi bank’s application to set aside the award on 21 January 2025, according to the same public record.
That sequence is important because it separates three questions that are often compressed into one headline. First, did an arbitral tribunal issue a valid award? Second, has the award obtained the recognition or exequatur needed in the forum where enforcement is sought? Third, is the particular asset identified by the creditor legally available for execution? Cardno had made progress on the first two questions. The 17 July 2026 ruling concerned the third. Recognition of an award creates an enforceable claim; it does not automatically convert a central-bank reserve account into an ordinary commercial bank account.
Cardno’s position, as summarised in the public record, was that the attached funds could be linked to private commercial activity and that a United States discovery process might produce evidence about their allocation. The creditor also challenged the allocation of the burden of proof. The Paris court refused to postpone the French enforcement decision on that basis. It treated the statutory question as one that the creditor seeking execution had to prove in France, on the evidence available for the measure under review.
The court’s reasoning was reported in clear terms: to overcome the protection for foreign central-bank assets, the creditor had to establish both that the assets were held or managed by the central bank for its own account and that they formed part of a patrimony allocated to a principal activity governed by private law. The public summary further states that the court did not treat the production of yield on foreign-exchange reserves, when consistent with International Monetary Fund guidance, as enough to turn those reserves into commercial funds.
That is the practical lesson for an award creditor. A bank account is not classified by the fact that it earns interest, sits in a financial centre or is held by a commercial bank. A reserve manager may place public reserves with a private custodian, buy securities, receive returns and rebalance its portfolio without changing the public purpose of the assets. The court looks through the custody arrangement and asks what the assets are, for whose account they are held, and what principal activity they serve.
The ruling also illustrates the risk of relying on a broad narrative about a sovereign’s commercial conduct. Iraq may have entered a consultancy agreement governed by an arbitral clause. That fact supports enforcement of the award against assets that satisfy French rules. It does not prove that a particular balance held by the Central Bank of Iraq at the Banque de France is part of the bank’s private-law business patrimony. The legal identity of the debtor, the legal identity of the custodian and the legal purpose of the funds remain separate questions.
Readers who need the wider French framework can also consult our broader analysis of sovereign-asset execution and the Sapin II rules. This article takes a narrower, news-led route: the Cardno ruling, central-bank reserves and the evidence required to distinguish a reserve account from a commercial asset.
The distinction has international significance. A creditor may have a final award, a French recognition decision and a powerful political argument that a state should pay. The execution judge still has to protect the monetary infrastructure that French law places outside ordinary execution. The court’s role is therefore not to reopen the merits of the Iraqi construction dispute. It is to determine whether a narrowly identified asset falls within a statutory protection and, if not, whether the procedural requirements for a seizure have been met.
For foreign counsel, the case also carries a timing message. An ex parte order can create the appearance of a successful seizure before the central bank or the custodian has been heard. If the order rests on inferences rather than financial evidence, the measure may be withdrawn at the adversarial stage. The creditor should treat the first order as the beginning of the evidential contest, not as proof that the target asset is ultimately available.
The decision does not mean that a central bank can defeat every enforcement attempt by simply using the words “foreign exchange reserves.” The creditor retains the ability to challenge the legal character of the asset. But the challenge must be specific. It must identify the asset, establish the bank’s capacity in relation to it, and show why the asset is linked to a principal private-law activity. General evidence about a state’s borrowing, contracts, investments or failure to pay will usually be weaker than account-level evidence tied to the precise funds named in the proposed seizure.
B. Why does Article L. 153-1 make proof of commercial use decisive?
The central provision is Article L. 153-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. Its first paragraph begins with a categorical formulation:
« Ne peuvent être saisis les biens de toute nature, notamment les avoirs de réserves de change, que les banques centrales ou les autorités monétaires étrangères détiennent ou gèrent pour leur compte ou celui de l’Etat ou des Etats étrangers dont elles relèvent. »
The statutory protection covers “assets of any kind” and expressly mentions foreign-exchange reserves. It is not limited to an account formally registered in the name of the foreign state. It also covers assets held or managed by the central bank for its own account or for the account of the state or states to which it belongs. That wording explains why the Banque de France could intervene even though the funds were held in the French monetary system and the proposed attachment was directed at a debt allegedly owed by the custodian.
The second paragraph creates the narrow route that Cardno attempted to use. It provides:
« Par exception aux dispositions du premier alinéa, le créancier muni d’un titre exécutoire constatant une créance liquide et exigible peut solliciter du juge de l’exécution l’autorisation de poursuivre l’exécution forcée dans les conditions prévues par la partie législative du code des procédures civiles d’exécution s’il établit que les biens détenus ou gérés pour son propre compte par la banque centrale ou l’autorité monétaire étrangère font partie d’un patrimoine qu’elle affecte à une activité principale relevant du droit privé. »
Each element matters. The creditor needs an enforceable title. The claim must be liquid and due. The request must go to the Execution Judge. The property must be held or managed for the central bank’s own account, rather than for the state or another public entity. Finally, the property must be part of a patrimony allocated by that central bank to a principal activity governed by private law. The exception is not satisfied by showing only one of those elements.
The phrase “for its own account” is especially important in a state-reserve case. A central bank can be the legal custodian or manager of assets that belong economically or legally to the state. Article L. 153-1 protects both configurations in its first paragraph. The exception is drafted more narrowly. It focuses on assets held or managed for the central bank’s own account and connected with the central bank’s own principal private-law activity. An award creditor therefore has to map the ownership and mandate chain before arguing about commercial purpose.
Article 1353 of the Civil Code supplies a general evidential starting point: “Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver.” Article L. 153-1 adds a more targeted allocation. The creditor asking to displace the protection bears the burden of establishing the statutory exception. The Paris ruling’s rejection of a stay for foreign discovery shows how seriously that allocation is treated. A creditor cannot replace proof of the French statutory test with an expectation that another jurisdiction may later reveal useful material.
The 12 May 2021 decision of the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, no. 19-13.853, is a key authority. In its official text, the court explained that Article L. 153-1 creates “une insaisissabilité” attached to the assets themselves, distinct from personal immunity. It held that the rule protects assets held by a central bank for the account of the states to which it belongs, and it accepted the legitimacy of preventing a blockage of reserves placed in France. The official Légifrance decision records the holding and the dismissal of Commisimpex’s appeal.
The same decision matters for the custodian. The court stated that a third party subject to a seizure may rely on the asset’s legal unseizability when defending itself against a claim based on an allegedly inaccurate declaration. The creditor cannot avoid Article L. 153-1 by shifting the procedural target from the central bank to the French public body or financial intermediary that holds the account. The law follows the asset’s legal character.
French case law also distinguishes a sovereign act from a private-law transaction. In the First Civil Chamber decision of 19 November 2008, no. 07-10.570, the Court of Cassation stated that foreign states benefit from jurisdictional immunity only when the act at issue participates, by its nature or purpose, in the exercise of sovereignty and is not an act of management. On execution, it added that a foreign state benefits in principle from execution immunity, but that the position differs where the property is connected to an economic, commercial or civil operation under private law giving rise to the claim.
« Les Etats étrangers bénéficient, par principe, de l’immunité d’exécution ; il en est autrement lorsque le bien concerné se rattache, non à l’exercice d’une activité de souveraineté, mais à une opération économique, commerciale ou civile relevant du droit privé qui donne lieu à la demande en justice. »
That principle does not erase the special protection for central-bank reserves. It helps identify what “private law” means, but Article L. 153-1 applies its own text and its own threshold. A private-law contract may show that a state entered a commercial relationship. It does not automatically show that reserve assets are part of a central bank’s principal private-law patrimony. The legal connection must be made at the asset level.
The older First Civil Chamber decision of 17 January 1973, no. 71-11.793, illustrates the same functional method. The court rejected immunity where a foreign state had entered a commercial lease under private-law rules and had not acted as a public authority. The decision concerned jurisdictional immunity and a commercial lease, not a reserve account, but its method remains useful: the court examines the nature and purpose of the concrete act rather than accepting a state label as decisive.
The central-bank line is stricter. In the First Civil Chamber decision of 6 November 2013, nos. 12-15.552 and 12-20.709, the Court of Cassation required the lower court to address the BEAC’s execution immunity under the France–BEAC agreement before treating funds in a Paris account as available. In the First Civil Chamber decision of 25 May 2016, no. 15-18.646, the court ordered the release of a seizure against BEAC funds and held that the inability to seize those funds in France was not, in the circumstances, a disproportionate restriction on the creditor’s rights.
« le seul fait de ne pouvoir saisir les fonds de la BEAC, en France, ne constituait pas, au préjudice de M. X…, une restriction disproportionnée »
The 2016 decision is a reminder that the right to an effective remedy does not necessarily produce a right to seize protected monetary assets. The court accepted that other forms of redress may exist, including a claim engaging state responsibility in the particular legal context. That does not make recovery easy, but it prevents Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights from being used as a substitute for the statutory proof required by Article L. 153-1.
The 17 July 2026 Cardno ruling therefore fits a settled direction rather than creating an isolated immunity doctrine. Its new value is its application to a fresh ICC enforcement dispute involving the Banque de France, a foreign central bank and an award creditor seeking account-level attachment. The court’s rejection of reserve yield as enough to establish private use makes the evidential boundary visible to international businesses considering French enforcement.
II. What can foreign award creditors do after the Paris ruling?
A. How do sovereign immunity, diplomatic assets and enforcement procedure interact?
Article L. 153-1 is not the only French rule in play. The general principle appears in Article L. 111-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures. The official text states: « L’exécution forcée et les mesures conservatoires ne sont pas applicables aux personnes qui bénéficient d’une immunité d’exécution. » The provision addresses the protected person. Article L. 153-1 addresses the special status of central-bank assets. In a case such as Cardno, both ideas may be argued, but they should not be conflated.
For property belonging to a foreign state, Article L. 111-1-1 imposes a procedural gate:
« Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger que sur autorisation préalable du juge par ordonnance rendue sur requête. »
The link to the official Article L. 111-1-1 text should be in every enforcement file. A creditor should not begin with a standard seizure form and attempt to repair the immunity problem later. The request to the Execution Judge must identify the asset, the debtor, the enforceable title and the condition that makes the asset available under French law.
Article L. 111-1-2 then lists the conditions under which the judge may authorise a measure:
« Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée visant un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger ne peuvent être autorisées par le juge que si l’une des conditions suivantes est remplie : »
The conditions include express consent by the state, a reservation or allocation of the property to satisfy the claim, or a judgment or arbitral award combined with a property that is specifically used, or intended to be used, otherwise than for non-commercial public service and that has a link with the entity against which the proceedings were brought. The same article identifies diplomatic accounts, military property, cultural property, archives and tax or social claims as examples of property used for non-commercial public service. The full rule is available in the official Légifrance text.
This architecture creates two different routes. For ordinary state property, a creditor may try to prove commercial or private use under Article L. 111-1-2. For central-bank property, Article L. 153-1 adds a specific statutory reserve protection and a more focused private-law exception. The fact that an asset is used in a commercial-looking transaction may be relevant under the general state rule but still insufficient under the central-bank rule.
Diplomatic assets illustrate why the distinction matters. The First Civil Chamber decision of 24 January 2018, no. 16-16.511, concerned seizures of accounts of the Embassy of the Republic of the Congo. The court treated diplomatic property as requiring an express and special waiver for the relevant execution measure under the post-Sapin II framework, even though the historical dispute involved a broader contractual waiver. An award creditor should therefore never assume that a general waiver in an arbitration clause reaches embassy accounts, mission property or central-bank reserves in the same way.
The First Civil Chamber decision of 13 March 2024, no. 21-17.599, provides a useful modern formulation. The court said that an express waiver can in principle permit execution against state property without an additional special waiver, but it preserved the stricter treatment of property used for diplomatic functions. Its exact statement is:
« la renonciation expresse à l’immunité d’exécution suffit pour que les biens d’un Etat, quels qu’ils soient, puissent faire l’objet d’une mesure d’exécution, sans que soit en outre requise une renonciation spéciale. »
The quotation must be read with the next paragraph of the decision, which refers to Article 22(3) of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations and the special protection for mission premises, furnishings, objects and means of transport. The lesson is not that a creditor can seize any state asset after locating a general waiver. It is that the waiver analysis is asset-specific, and diplomatic property remains subject to an additional safeguard.
A further procedural distinction concerns the bank or public body holding the asset. Article R. 211-5 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures provides that a third party that fails without legitimate reason to supply required information may be ordered to pay the sums due, and may face damages for negligent, inaccurate or false declarations. The official text states: « Il peut être condamné à des dommages et intérêts en cas de négligence fautive ou de déclaration inexacte ou mensongère. » That rule explains why a custodian such as the Banque de France has a strong reason to contest an attachment that targets legally unseizable reserves. It also explains why a creditor should not allege a false declaration without first proving that the seized balance was legally available.
The 12 May 2021 decision, no. 19-13.853, is again central because it treats the Article L. 153-1 protection as attached to the assets and available to the third party. The result is a layered defence: the central bank may invoke its status, the state may invoke its immunity, and the custodian may rely on the asset’s statutory unseizability. A creditor must address each layer in the request for authorisation.
French courts also protect the procedural fairness of a foreign state. In the Second Civil Chamber decision of 24 March 2022, no. 20-17.394, the Court of Cassation examined an attempt to obtain authorisation to seize funds belonging to Lebanon after a French exequatur judgment. The court held that the transmission of the act to the public prosecutor for diplomatic service did not itself prove that the foreign state had received the decision. The official text describes the procedural effect as follows: « la remise à parquet de l’acte de signification du jugement … n’ayant aucun effet procédural, si ce n’est de permettre l’acheminement de l’acte au ministère de la justice aux fins de remise par la voie diplomatique ». Service and proof of service may therefore decide whether an enforcement request is premature.
Finally, Article L. 153-1 cannot be bypassed by changing the label of the measure. A provisional attachment, an attribution seizure, an attachment of a debt owed by a custodian or another form of conservatory measure all raise the same question when the property is a protected reserve. The creditor must identify a legally available asset before choosing the procedural instrument.
B. What evidence, timing and French remedies remain available?
The first step after an award is a French asset map, not a seizure application. The file should separate the debtor’s legal entities, the central bank’s role, the custodian’s role and the precise asset. A creditor should collect the award, the arbitration agreement, the decision recognising or declaring the award enforceable in France, the current calculation of principal and interest, and evidence that the claim is liquid and due. The creditor should then identify whether the proposed target is a reserve account, a government account, a commercial receivable, rental income, securities held for a private activity or property used by a diplomatic mission.
The contractual record still matters. Article 1103 of the Civil Code provides: « Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits. » That rule may help establish the debt and the scope of an arbitration or waiver clause. But the contract is only one part of the enforcement analysis. The award confirms liability; it does not define the legal use of every asset held by a central bank.
Article 1217 of the Civil Code lists the remedies available for non-performance, including forced performance, price reduction, termination and compensation. It also says that « des dommages et intérêts peuvent toujours s’y ajouter ». The official article helps explain why the award may be large and final, while the French execution judge still focuses on the availability of the specific property. Merits and execution are connected but not interchangeable.
For a proposed central-bank seizure, the evidence should answer five questions in a documented order. First, who owns the funds? Second, for whose account does the central bank hold or manage them? Third, what is the mandate governing the account? Fourth, what is the account’s actual and principal purpose? Fifth, what evidence shows that the assets form part of a patrimony allocated to a principal private-law activity rather than to monetary policy, reserve management or another public function?
Account statements alone may not answer those questions. They show balances and transactions, but not necessarily the legal mandate or the patrimonial classification. Stronger evidence may include the central bank’s published statutes, reserve-management rules, audited financial statements, account-opening documents, custody agreements, board resolutions, segregation records, payment instructions and documents showing the destination of the funds. Evidence from the central bank or custodian should be tested against the exact wording of Article L. 153-1 rather than presented as a general dispute about sovereign conduct.
The private-law argument must also be framed narrowly. The creditor should identify the activity said to be private, explain why it is a principal activity of the central bank, and connect the targeted assets to that activity. A single commercial contract, a yield payment or an investment transaction may show an economic operation without proving that the central bank’s principal activity is governed by private law. Cardno’s treatment of reserve yield makes this distinction particularly important.
The Court of Cassation’s decisions provide useful contrasts. The 2008 German-property decision, no. 07-10.570, accepted that acquiring and maintaining an ordinary building could be private management. The 2016 BEAC decision, no. 15-18.646, protected funds linked to an international central bank and its monetary mission. The 2021 BEAC decision, no. 19-13.853, confirmed that Article L. 153-1 protects reserves held for member states. An application should explain which line the proposed asset belongs to, instead of citing the phrase “commercial activity” without a factual bridge.
The creditor should also test alternative targets. Commercial property owned by a state, rent from premises not used for a diplomatic mission, receivables arising from a private-law transaction, shares in a separate commercial entity and other assets may present a better route than a reserve account. Each alternative still requires the authorisation process and the conditions in Articles L. 111-1-1 and L. 111-1-2. The objective is not to seek a broad order against “all assets in France”; it is to present an asset-specific request that the judge can assess.
Jurisdiction and service should be planned at the same time. Article L. 211-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation states that the judicial court knows of civil and commercial matters unless jurisdiction is assigned elsewhere. The official text is a useful starting point, but the Execution Judge’s specific jurisdiction and the statutory authorisation procedure govern the application. A creditor should identify the competent Paris court, the correct procedural vehicle, the necessary exhibits and the service route before any bailiff is instructed.
The 2022 Lebanon decision, no. 20-17.394, shows why diplomatic transmission cannot be treated as administrative detail. If the foreign state has not received the exequatur decision through the legally required channel, the application to seize may fail even where the creditor has located assets that appear commercially connected. The evidence file should therefore preserve proof of transmission, diplomatic service, translations and the dates on which each step occurred.
Waivers require the same discipline. A clause in a commercial agreement may waive jurisdictional immunity, execution immunity or both. It may apply to a defined dispute, a defined category of assets or all assets legally capable of being reached. A central bank may also be protected by a separate statute, treaty or constitutive instrument. The 6 November 2013 decision, nos. 12-15.552 and 12-20.709, shows the danger of ignoring an agreement governing a central bank’s privileges and immunities. The waiver should be analysed against the exact property and the law in force when the seizure is attempted.
Appeal and settlement planning should start as soon as the Execution Judge releases the attachment. The creditor should obtain the complete French judgment, verify the procedural deadline applicable to the order, and assess whether the defect is evidential, jurisdictional or legal. Repeating the same reserve argument with more urgency will not cure the problem identified in Cardno. A better appeal or renewed application would need new evidence that answers the statutory test or a different asset that falls outside the protected category.
A claim against the French state may also be considered in an exceptional case where immunity prevents execution and the legal conditions for state responsibility are met. The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal decision of 4 March 2024, no. 23PA03134, concerned compensation connected with the impossibility of enforcing a judgment against Sri Lanka and illustrates that this is a separate public-law route, not an automatic substitute for seizure. Its result cannot be transplanted mechanically to a central-bank dispute, but it shows why the enforcement strategy should include more than one legal path.
Time limits must be checked claim by claim. Article 2224 of the Civil Code provides that personal and movable actions generally prescribe after five years from the date when the right-holder knew, or should have known, the facts enabling the action. The official text should be read with the award, the recognition decision, the applicable arbitration law, any treaty and the procedural rules governing execution. The five-year rule is not a universal answer for every enforcement step, but it is a warning against leaving an award dormant while assets change location or legal character.
For international businesses, the practical checklist is concise. Preserve the complete award and the French recognition record. Confirm the amount and due date. Identify the exact custodian and account. Obtain evidence of ownership and mandate. Test the asset against Article L. 153-1 before relying on the general state-immunity exception. Prepare the Article L. 111-1-1 authorisation request and the Article L. 111-1-2 analysis. Confirm diplomatic service where required. Anticipate the custodian’s Article R. 211-5 response. Then compare the reserve-account route with commercial state assets and any available public-law remedy.
The Cardno judgment also has a broader policy consequence. France remains an attractive seat for arbitration and a major financial centre, but it does not promise that an award can be converted into a seizure of monetary reserves. The statutory protection reduces the risk that a private enforcement campaign will block the functioning of a central bank or disrupt reserve management. At the same time, the private-law exception prevents the protection from becoming an absolute licence for a central bank to shield every asset, whatever its use. The balance is demanding because it requires evidence, not slogans.
That balance will matter in future disputes over sovereign reserves, frozen assets, public-bank balances and enforcement of awards arising from infrastructure projects. A creditor who wins the arbitration but loses the asset classification question has not lost because French courts deny the award’s existence. The creditor has lost because enforcement is a separate legal inquiry. Cardno makes that inquiry visible at the moment when an attachment first appears to have succeeded.
Conclusion
The Paris Execution Judge’s 17 July 2026 decision in Cardno v. Central Bank of Iraq confirms the high evidential threshold for reaching foreign central-bank assets in France. An ICC award, recognition in France and a liquid debt are necessary foundations, but they do not overcome Article L. 153-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code. The creditor must prove that the targeted assets are held for the central bank’s own account and belong to a patrimony allocated to a principal private-law activity. Reserve yield, financial custody and the debtor’s commercial conduct are not enough by themselves.
The next enforcement decision should therefore begin with classification, ownership, mandate and account-level evidence. If the target is protected, the strategy should move toward a genuinely different asset, a properly framed authorisation request, a valid waiver or a separate remedy. In France, the fastest route to recovery is often the one that respects the execution judge’s narrow question: what exact asset is available, under what exact rule, and what exact proof establishes it?